A predawn emergency call launches police into the heart of a wealthy Washington, North Carolina neighborhood where they discover an unimaginable scene. Leith Von Stein, a prominent local executive, lies murdered in his bed – his body bearing the marks of a savage attack with multiple head wounds and stab wounds to his chest and back. His wife Bonnie, critically injured but alive, whispers about a dark figure with a baseball bat and knife.

The crime scene immediately raises questions. Blood spatters the walls and ceiling of the master bedroom, yet the teenage daughter sleeping just down the hall claims to have heard nothing. A broken window suggests a break-in, but valuable items remain untouched throughout the house. The staged appearance of the scene and the peculiar calm of family members trigger the investigators' instincts that this is no ordinary home invasion.

When Detective Sergeant Melvin Hope interviews the Von Steins' daughter Angela, he's struck by her emotional detachment – a stark contrast to her brother Chris's seemingly performative grief when he arrives from college. "Chris was really trying to appear grief-stricken but he wasn't quite making it. It was almost like he was going for an Emmy," Hope later recalls. As medical teams work to save Bonnie's life, investigators begin piecing together the truth behind this brutal attack, suspecting that the most dangerous threats may have come from within the family's own walls.

Step into the shocking investigation of the Von Stein murder case, where appearances are deceiving and the peaceful facade of an affluent neighborhood masks a chilling reality. Follow detectives as they navigate bloody crime scenes, suspicious behavior, and family secrets to uncover who would want this prominent businessman dead – and why they would strike with such savage intensity.

Send us a text

Support the show