Watch on Philo! - Philo.tv/DTH

The episode kicks off with Alice asking Colton what he was doing. He’s like, “I wasn’t thinking straight. I ran off after the funeral.” She’s like, “And you jumped in a pond?” He’s like, “Who can say?” They go to check in on Vic, and he yells at Colton, telling him it should’ve been him who died.

Elliot and Vic get into an argument. Vic says he refuses to let that ring go to a Landry, claiming, “The Landrys have always used us.” Elliot tells him, “It’s my ring now, and it’s my house now. Get lost.”

Back in ’74, Alice goes with Colton to Coyle’s to join a group of folks remembering Rick. They see the hearse drive by, and Alice locks eyes with Vic.

Kat and Elliot are making out in the shack when they discover some jazz music playing and a bottle of Pinot. Kat jokes, “She’s a cab girl? What gives?!”

That night at dinner, Del tells them all about Sam. Kat responds, “Well, while we’re sharing big news, I’m moving in with Elliot.” Del is shocked and says, “You’re doing what? You need to be here for your daughter.” They begin to argue, and everyone scurries off.

Kat and Alice figure out that there’s another book they should pour wine on. It reveals the rest of the message—a note from Colton to Evalyn that makes it sound like they were both time travelers.

At the market, Alice talks to cute boy Noah. She helps him out in the food truck, and they flirt.

Kat goes to the pond to try traveling back to ’74 herself. When she gets out of the pond, she is greeted by a scary old woman. Apparently, it’s Colton’s grandma, Fern, and she’s acting wild.

Jacob and his childhood friend Danny finally catch up. Danny admits he’s always blamed himself. Jacob reassures him, saying he didn’t push him into the water and that nothing is his fault.

Alice shows Del the books, and Del says she’s not surprised to see this but insists that if Colton had traveled through the pond, he would have told her.

Fern tells Kat, “It’s nice to see someone using the pond again.” When Kat asks if Colton used it, Fern cryptically responds, “If you want the right answers, you need to ask the right questions.”

As Kat heads back to the pond, she sees Colton talking to Evalyn and overhears them discussing the pond. He’s about to tell her something big when they hear a noise.

Kat returns to the present, where Del warns her to leave the past alone. Kat scoffs, “As if.”

She then gets a call and has to rescue Jacob, who is too drunk to get home.

Meanwhile, Elliot discovers that his dad did indeed steal the ring back, even though he had just promised Elliot he wouldn’t.

Alice and cute boy Noah share a kiss.

Finally, Kat and Alice go to the archives to search for answers. They discover a flyer from 1965 about voting to fill in the Landry pond.