Platypus Psalms
When studying the Bible, scholars often adopt a role akin to field biologists. They endeavor to place the diverse parts of Scripture into their respective Kingdom, Phylum, and Class. This approach is quite helpful. It helps us identify the various types of Scripture. Just as a biologist might ask, 'Is this animal a mammal, bird, or a reptile?' readers of the Bible ponder, 'Is this part meant to be read like history, poetry, or prophecy?' (or something else?) Knowing the literary type of a passage helps us adjust our expectations when we read it.
In the animal kingdom, we have creatures that defy classification, like the duckbilled platypus. It belongs to a class—it is a mammal—but it has attributes that belong to the classes of birds and reptiles. It's mysterious and difficult to fit into the accepted taxonomy.
Thanks for reading The Wheatland Mission ! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.
Platypus (Ornithorhynchus anatinus). First Description 1799 - https://biodiversitylibrary.org/page/40321089
The Psalms are like the platypus. While each Psalm can be assigned to a category, the moment we attempt to confine it within a specific category, it resists. Most Psalms exhibit attributes of others, blurring the lines between categories. There's no clear-cut boundary where one type begins and the other ends.
When creating categories for the Psalms, scholars typically use the psalm's content to distinguish it from others. Does the psalm thank God for his deliverance or admire him for his attributes? It's a psalm of praise. Does the psalm cry to God for deliverance or complain about the wicked? It's a lament. Does the psalm dispense advice on how to live? It's a wisdom psalm. These are three broad categories, but there are many more.
Walter Brueggemann1 categorizes the Psalms differently. Instead of focusing on content, he categorizes them according to use. Brueggemann asks how Israel used these psalms in their worship and prayer life. What was Israel going through, or at least the writer, when the psalm was composed?
Brueggemann's three categories for the Psalms are Orientation, Disorientation, and New Orientation.
These categories describe our modern-day experiences as well as they did Israel's. Here's a brief rundown of each type.
Psalms of OrientationPsalms of Orientation are noted for their confidence. The person who prays this way sees God's faithfulness through their experience of his generosity and predictability. Sometimes life goes really well. In these moments, God may seem nearer than other times. We worship from a place of feeling cared for. Life is not chaotic but ordered and simple. Hope comes naturally.
Psalms of Orientation present the world as predictable. It is predictable because it is God's good creation. Those who do right prosper. Those who do evil are punished. And we see these happen promptly.
Psalm 1 is an example of a Psalm of Orientation. Blessed are the righteous, and cursed are the wicked. It's simple and straightforward. Psalm 162 is another good example, along with 14, 37, 131, and 133.
Psalms of Disorientation
Psalms of Disorientation are notable for their authenticity. When a psalm begins with the phrase, "How long?" or "I cry," or "My God, My God!"3 you are probably reading a Psalm of Disorientation.
God's creation is indeed good, but sometimes, its goodness is obscured by bad behavior, tragic accidents, violence, and the natural despair accompanying it. And sometimes, life is just a grind.
It is from experiences like these that the psalms of disorientation arise. These psalms keep our prayers honest. And, quite frankly, if it weren't for psalms of disorientation we may not know how to pray at all when life is complicated.
These psalms remind us that we don't have to clean up our language, much less ourselves, before we come to God. It may sound weird to put it this way, but Brueggemann likens God to a therapist, and the psalms of disorientation are the therapy.4 Where can we share what we dare not share? To whom can we say things we are afraid to say to ourselves?
Many of the Psalms of Disorientation end with a return to praise. In the last line, you may see a phrase like, "Yet, I will praise you." The psalmist knows that difficult things have to be acknowledged but recognizes God as the good creator.
Psalms of New OrientationJust beyond this, however, is the experience of New Orientation. These psalms are not cynical like some of the psalms of disorientation. Neither are they naive, like psalms of orientation. Psalms of New Orientation originate in the experience of having survived the desert and been found by God on the other side. The faith of New Orientation is hopeful but informed. A grateful confidence that has its eyes open.
In the Psalms of Disorientation, the turn back to praise is abrupt and may feel forced. With the Psalms of New Orientation, the turn to praise is not dutiful but natural. Words of praise roll off the tongue, because the psalmist knows God has delivered and trusts God will deliver again. Psalms of New Orientation provide a proper confidence that is patient, self-aware, and mature.
Psalm 30, 32, 103, and 116 are excellent examples of Psalms of New Orientation.
The Psalms Are UsBrueggemann's three psalm types describe how the Psalms were used in Israel. They represent the people's condition. They also represent our condition. At any given time we will find ourselves in a state of Orientation, Disorientation, or New Orientation. Maybe we notice that we live in one of these states more than the others.
One beautiful thing about the Psalms is their capacity to meet us in whatever depths or joys we find ourselves in. They give us the language we can borrow even as it becomes our own. Taking the three kinds of orientation to heart might help us in our own extemporaneous prayers and when we pray the Psalms.
We should acknowledge that the condition of our hearts is often a mix. One moment we are supremely disoriented by our life and the next we feel incredibly secure. Another moment we feel delivered and another we feel no need for deliverance. There is not one category that can contain or describe all that we are. Like the Psalms, our experiences cannot always be classified, and gratefully, there are psalms for that experience too. Like the platypus, the Psalms, and our own emotional state, defy easy categorization.
Through the Psalms, God may be a good therapist after all.
1
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Walter_Brueggemann
2
Nathan Hansen preached a fine sermon on Psalm 16 recently. “This is my life. I want no other.”
3
Psalm 13, 88, and 22 respectively.
4
This brief video is really good. God as therapist—kinda.