Iggy, Michael, and Ken taste the 2016 version of Thomas H. Handy Rye from the Buffalo Trace Antique Collection.

Do we think this is the pinnacle of rye? Is it worth the hype?

Email us at - [email protected]

#Thomas H. Handy #Buffalo Trace #rye #2016 #bourbon community #secondary market #tasting #whiskey enthusiasts #bourbon #rye spice

Thomas H. Handy Rye (2016)

In a recent gathering of whiskey enthusiasts, we had the pleasure of sampling Thomas H. Handy Rye from 2016. This particular expression is a part of the Buffalo Trace Antique Collection, and it left us with a range of impressions and opinions.

The whiskey boasts a robust 126.2 proof, and with a retail price of $99, it had us wondering what the secondary market value might be. As we discussed, the secondary market can sometimes escalate to incredible heights, making this bottle a highly sought-after treasure, possibly reaching prices of $1,000 to $3,000.

Upon opening the bottle and taking our first whiff, the initial impression was a notable grassy scent with hints of orange. The nose left us intrigued but divided, as rye isn't everyone's preferred choice. Some found it grassy and somewhat challenging, while others detected an unexpected sweetness.

As we delved into tasting this high-proof rye, we found it to be surprisingly smooth. At 63% ABV, it appeared lower than its actual strength would suggest. The initial sips presented grassy notes, which were in line with our first impressions. However, with further exploration, we started to uncover flavors of cherry, reminiscent of George T. Stagg, which was a pleasant surprise.

Upon adding a few drops of water to our glasses, the whiskey's character transformed. The rye spice became more pronounced, accompanied by raisins, honey, and toffee. The finish left a lasting impression, with a powerful heat enveloping the mouth, featuring rye spice, white pepper, and noticeable oak notes. Despite the grassy beginning, the chocolatey finish was an unexpected twist that some of us appreciated.

One taster expressed a strong fondness for this rye, citing its expressive and complex flavors. It was his favorite among the pours we had that evening. Others found it enjoyable but not necessarily their top choice, given their preference for bourbons or other ryes.

In conclusion, the Thomas H. Handy Rye from 2016 is a whiskey worth trying if you can find it at its original retail price of $99. However, the secondary market prices can be astronomical, so it's a matter of personal preference and budget. It's a unique rye with a distinctive character, combining grassy and sweet notes, and it certainly left a memorable impression on our tasting group. Whether or not it's your preferred style of whiskey, it's always a pleasure to explore the diverse world of fine spirits. Cheers!

Henry, Jason, Iggy, Doc, and Ken all taste some of what many consider the Holy Grail of bourbon, Pappy Van Winkle 20 year. We compare it to Elijah Craig 18 and Knob Creek 18. Who do you think wins this head-to-head?

Who will win the best of this head-to-head? Are we wrong? Send us an email to tell us your thoughts.

Music by Adam Whitehead - ⁠⁠⁠⁠https://www.facebook.com/adamwhiteheadmusic⁠⁠⁠⁠

#Pappy, #Pappy Van Winkle, #20-year, - #Elijah Craig 18, #Knob Creek 18, #bottle #barrel #note #taste

Ken, Iggy, Michael, Doc, and the Nurse taste test way too many 12-Year-Old bourbons, so you don't have to. (We will own the headache tomorrow)

In our lineup, we start with Weller 12 and work our way to Boone County 12, that's made by ghosts. It's tough to find a winner when your table is filled with some of the heavy hitters of the industry.

Who will win our best of the night, or did we have way too many samples?

Music by Adam Whitehead - ⁠⁠⁠⁠https://www.facebook.com/adamwhiteheadmusic⁠⁠⁠⁠

#Weller 12 #Knob Creek 12 #1792 #Evan Williams 12 #Jack Daniels 12 #Wild Turkey 12 #Boone County #Ambassador #bottle #barrel #note #taste #nose #whiskey #bourbon #barrels #Buffalo Trace, #Heaven Hill, #Brown Forman, #Campari #MGP #banana #Jack Daniels Twice Barrel #single malt #Dickel #Pepper Jacks

Ken, Iggy, Michael, and Doc travel to Weston, Missouri, and the Holladay Distillery. There we got to sit down with Kyle Merklein, Master Distiller, and Patrick Fee, Vice President of Sales & Marketing with McCormick Distilling Co. Inc. and Holladay Distillery.

To say these folks rolled out the red carpet is an understatement, and they provided amazing access to their story and their facility. Go grab a bottle of Holladay bourbon, and sit back with us for the next hour as we learn more about this historic distillery, which dates back to 1856.

Music by Adam Whitehead - ⁠⁠⁠https://www.facebook.com/adamwhiteheadmusic⁠⁠⁠

Email us at - [email protected]

#Missouri #bottle #barrel #Holladay #small batch #note #taste #McCormick #nose #whiskey #bourbon #barrels

In this episode, Ken, Iggy, Michael, and Doc all sample some of the Ben Holladay products as we pregame before visiting the Holladay Distillery in Weston, Missouri.

The limestone water source was discovered by explorers Lewis and Clark, and Holladay used that water to make his whiskey when he founded the distillery in 1856.

In the episode, we try their standard bottle-in-bond, their rickhouse version, and two single-barrel offerings.

Music by Adam Whitehead - ⁠⁠https://www.facebook.com/adamwhiteheadmusic⁠⁠

Email us at - [email protected]

#Missouri #bottle #barrel #Holladay #small batch #note #taste #McCormick #nose #whiskey #bourbon

Weller Full Proof Private Pick 2019

I had the pleasure of tasting the Weller Full Proof Private Pick Bourbon from 2019, as discussed in the engaging conversation among bourbon enthusiasts. The whiskey was highly recommended by Robert, a member of the Bourbon Real Talk community, and I must say that it did not disappoint.

Initial Impressions:

Tasting Notes:

The finish is where this bourbon truly shines. It's described as fantastic, with a lingering warmth that stays with you for an enjoyable amount of time. The tannins from the barrel aging process are also noticeable, contributing to the complexity of the finish. The woodiness adds a layer of sophistication that bourbon connoisseurs often seek.

Comparison:

Final Thoughts:

In summary, the Weller Full Proof Private Pick Bourbon is a bourbon that's well worth trying, even for those who may not typically favor Buffalo Trace products. Its unique flavor profile, with a cinnamon kick and rich fruit notes, makes it a memorable and enjoyable pour.

In this episode, Ken, Iggy, Michael all sample some of a Wisconsin treasure, J. Henry & Sons Distillery.

They treated one of our own, as they do to most all guests to a splendid tour of the distillery and welcome center.

Music by Adam Whitehead - ⁠⁠⁠https://www.facebook.com/adamwhiteheadmusic⁠⁠⁠

Email us at - [email protected]

J. Henry & Sons Distillery in Wisconsin is a hidden gem in the world of bourbon and whiskey. Nestled in the heart of Dane County, Wisconsin, this family-owned distillery has a unique story and a commitment to producing high-quality spirits. Here's a review of the distillery and its products:

Distillery Experience: Walking into the J. Henry & Sons Distillery feels like stepping into a rustic, welcoming farmhouse with a charming bar set up in what was probably once the living room or kitchen. The staff's warm and inviting demeanor immediately makes you feel at home. The fireplace in the corner and the small field outside give it an authentic rural charm. The fact that you're offered a drink as soon as you walk in sets a fantastic tone for the visit.

Product Range: J. Henry & Sons offers a range of products, with their base offering being a 5-year straight bourbon whiskey. What sets them apart is their commitment to using high-quality grains, including proprietary blue corn, which they are transitioning to for all their whiskey offerings. Their products are known for their well-balanced flavors and an approachable profile.

Specialty Bottles: The distillery also offers specialty bottles that are finished in different barrels. The "Belafonte Reserve" is finished in cognac barrels, and the "Laflopp" is finished in Armagnac barrels. These unique finishes impart delightful flavors and depth to their bourbons. The Belafonte is known for its caramel, vanilla, and butterscotch notes, while the Laflopp offers a fruitier, aromatic experience.

Quality and Craftsmanship: What's truly impressive about J. Henry & Sons is their commitment to quality and craftsmanship. Their whiskey showcases the influence of Wisconsin's extreme weather, with the fluctuations allowing the spirit to soak deeply into the oak staves. This contributes to the unique and delicious flavor profiles of their products. The flavors are rich, well-balanced, and a testament to the dedication of the distillery team.

Availability and Pricing: While their base offering is reasonably priced, specialty bottles like the Belafonte and Laflopp can be a bit harder to find and are often priced higher. The quality justifies the price point, though, making them excellent choices for special occasions or a treat for yourself.

Recommendation: If you're a bourbon enthusiast or just someone looking to explore the world of whiskey, J. Henry & Sons is worth a visit. Their welcoming distillery, flavorful products, and the unique influence of Wisconsin's climate on their whiskey make it an excellent destination for any whiskey lover. The Belafonte Reserve and Laflopp are highly recommended for those seeking a premium sipping experience.

In summary, J. Henry & Sons Distillery is a testament to the passion and craftsmanship that goes into producing high-quality bourbon and whiskey. The distillery's welcoming atmosphere, unique product offerings, and commitment to excellence make it a must-visit destination for whiskey enthusiasts. Their dedication to quality and exploration of flavor profiles set them apart in the world of craft distilleries.

Iggy, Michael, and Ken sample a 2019 version of Blanton's Gold thanks to the generosity of a fellow whiskey lover.

What makes Blanton's Gold different than the normal Blanton's? Is it worth the hunt?

Email us at - [email protected]

#Blanton's Gold #bourbon #review #flavor #aroma #TV Show #yellowstone #tasting notes #long finish #exclusive

Blanton's Gold Bourbon Review

In this lively conversation, the hosts of the Magic Water Show explore the flavors and characteristics of Blanton's Gold Bourbon. As they sip and savor this fine spirit, they provide an engaging review that captures the essence of this exclusive drink.

Blanton's Gold is a special release, primarily available in non-US markets, making it somewhat of a unicorn in the bourbon world. At 103 proof, it packs a punch compared to the regular Blanton's single barrel.

Speaker 3, clearly a fan of Blanton's, starts the discussion with an enthusiastic endorsement, declaring it his favorite so far. He mentions that the aroma is reminiscent of dessert, with a cookie-like quality. The initial scent of vanilla and caramel sets the stage for what's to come.

Speaker 1 chimes in, appreciating the simplicity and tastiness of Blanton's Gold. He likens it to a bourbon you'd be happy with even if it was the first drink of the evening.

Speaker 2 shares that the bourbon has a little more "hyper burn" compared to the regular Blanton's but praises the smoothness of this burn, highlighting its enjoyable finish.

As the conversation progresses, the hosts delve deeper into the flavor profile, identifying rich sweetness, brown sugar, oak, toffee, vanilla, and hints of dark cherry in the nose. The palate is described as sweet, toffee-forward, and featuring notes of chocolate and cream soda. The finish is said to be moderately long, with lingering impressions of chocolate, root beer (or cream soda), and pepper.

The hosts seem to appreciate the bourbon's long finish, making it perfect for relaxed sipping. Speaker 1 likens it to a "campfire bourbon" ideal for slow sipping on a pleasant evening.

The discussion also takes a playful turn when they mention the TV show "Yellowstone" and its connection to Buffalo Trace, alluding to the show's influence on the bourbon's popularity.

In conclusion, Blanton's Gold Bourbon receives high praise from the hosts for its rich, sweet, and dessert-like character, long finish, and overall sipping experience. They appreciate its exclusivity and endorse it as a bourbon that's worth seeking out and savoring.

Overall Rating: 4.5/5

This bourbon's unique qualities, coupled with its impressive flavor profile, make it a true gem for bourbon enthusiasts. If you're lucky enough to come across a bottle of Blanton's Gold, it's worth every sip.

Iggy, Michael, and Ken sample some Weller 12 from 2009. We've had Weller 12 on occasion, but will this older version teach us they don't make it like they used to?

Music by Adam Whitehead - ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠https://www.facebook.com/adamwhiteheadmusic⁠⁠⁠⁠

#Weller 12 #whiskey #bourbon #2009 release #aroma #tasting notes #rarity #Buffalo Trace #secondary market #whiskey enthusiasts

Weller 12 - A Whiskey Enthusiast's Perspective

In the world of bourbon, there are legendary names, and Weller 12-year-old, is undoubtedly one of them. Join us on this exciting journey as we delve into the intricacies of a 2009 release of Weller 12, courtesy of our generous friend, Robert. This bourbon is known for its scarcity, its mesmerizing aroma, and its well-deserved place in the hearts of enthusiasts.

Appearance: The journey begins with the sight of this liquid gold in the glass. Its white coats and fantastic legs already hint at something special. At 45% ABV, it's not overpowering but sets the stage for what's to come.

Nose: The anticipation builds as we bring the glass to our noses. It's an enchanting experience with layers of complexity. A cotton candy sweetness envelops the senses, tantalizing the olfactory receptors. There's an elusive, faint fish oil note that plays peek-a-boo. Some suggest hints of almond and caramel, and our expert from Breaking Bourbon even mentions vanilla. But, it's an aroma that keeps you guessing, inviting you to explore deeper.

Palate: The first sip is like an introduction to an enigmatic story. It's a bit subtle at first, but hang on - it gets better. The palate follows the nose's lead with almond, caramel, and vanilla dancing on the taste buds. There's an undeniable sweetness, but it doesn't cross the line into overwhelming. Just when you think you have it all figured out, there's a gentle arrival of dryness, like a twist in the plot of a good book.

Finish: The journey culminates in the finish, where things take an unexpected turn. A spicy heat, but never too much, starts to sizzle. It's balanced by that enduring wheat sweetness, and it transitions into a well-balanced dryness. The ending might not be what the nose promised, but it's an excellent resolution to the story.

In conclusion, the 2009 release of Weller 12 is a whiskey experience that doesn't come around often. Its rarity and complexity make it a gem in the world of bourbon. It's a testament to the skill of the distillers and the magic of aging. Whether you're a seasoned bourbon drinker or just starting your journey, it's an opportunity you'd cherish.

As for the hype and the skyrocketing secondary market prices, they're facts, but they should remind us of the importance of enjoying whiskey for the sheer pleasure it brings. After all, no price can truly capture the essence of this remarkable bourbon.

A big shoutout to Robert for sharing this treasure with us, allowing us to embark on this unique bourbon adventure. Until the next bottle comes our way, cheers to the Weller 12, a bourbon that lives up to the legend.

Ken, Iggy, and Michael sample of 2017's Elmer T. Lee, a highly sought-after bottle from Buffalo Trace.

What will their impressions be of this nearly impossible-to-find bourbon?

⁠https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/holladay-happy-hour/id1641581320⁠

Music by Adam Whitehead - ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠https://www.facebook.com/adamwhiteheadmusic⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠

#Whiskey Friends #Bourbon Real Talk #Elmer T. Lee #Buffalo Trace #2017 Vintage #Whiskey Tasting

#Secondary Market Prices #whiskey enthusiasts #whiskey review

A Sip of Elmer T. Lee - A Journey with Whiskey Friends

Introduction:

Appearance:

Nose:

Palate:

Finish:

Conclusion:

This bourbon transported us to a place where we could appreciate the craftsmanship and artistry behind the spirit. A big thank you to our generous donor for allowing us to embark on this wonderful journey. Our Whiskey Friends are now eagerly looking forward to the next adventure in the world of whiskey. Cheers!