
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


Why do people leave Protestant churches even when Protestantism supposedly contains everything they are looking for?
Rachel DeVore Fogarty joins me to discuss her series, “We Are All Non-Denominational Now,” and the gap between historic Protestant theology and the churches ordinary people actually experience.
We talk about worship, music, denominational identity, the Young, Restless, and Reformed movement, Tim Keller, Philip Schaff, John Williamson Nevin, Gavin Ortlund, Glen Scrivener, revivalism, pragmatism, sacramental formation, and why so many Protestants are searching for greater depth, reverence, history, and embodied practice.
At the center of the conversation is a simple question: What happens when a church’s confession says one thing, but its worship, leadership, architecture, and institutional habits say another?
Rachel also shares from her own history as a worship leader and musician, including the church conflicts and personal crises that eventually led her to begin writing publicly.
Read Rachel’s series on Substack:
https://substack.com/@rfogue/p-202759674
Rachel's music:
https://www.racheldevorefogarty.com/
Support the Yours Truly Podcast by liking, subscribing, sharing the episode, or becoming a channel member: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCU5SNBfTo4umhjYz6M0Jsmg/join
#Protestantism #Evangelicalism #Worship #Liturgy #ChurchHistory #RachelDeVoreFogarty #YoursTrulyPodcast
In this episode of the Yours Truly Podcast, Christian Baxter sits down in the actual studio with longtime friend Seth Gschwandegger for one of the most personal and spiritually charged conversations the channel has hosted so far.
What begins as a conversation between old friends slowly unfolds into a meditation on exile, grace, sacrament, suffering, music, memory, embodiment, and the strange spiritual hunger underneath modern life.
Seth shares stories from a childhood marked by constant movement, fractured identity, and the search for belonging — from the hard rock and grunge scenes of the late 80s and 90s, to a spiritual collapse in Los Angeles, to a long pilgrimage through evangelicalism, Catholicism, art, addiction, shame, grace, and ultimately a deeply sacramental vision of reality.
Together, Christian and Seth explore:
* Growing up displaced and searching for identity
* Guns N’ Roses, grunge, emo, and spiritual longing
* The hidden spiritual hunger inside alternative culture
* The tension between sincerity and “corporate Christianity”
* Shame vs guilt and the long process of healing
* Why Gen Z seems drawn toward liturgy and sacrament
* Communion, embodiment, and the recovery of sacred space
* Symbolism, thresholds, bridges, candles, altars, and holy places
* The Eucharist, real presence, and sacramental imagination
* Why modern people feel spiritually homeless
* Friendship, betrayal, reconciliation, and grace
This conversation sits directly inside many of the themes this channel has been circling for the last two years:
the collapse of disembodied religion,
the search for the Real,
and the attempt to recover a Christianity that is not merely conceptual — but participatory, embodied, beautiful, and alive.
If you've followed the channel for a while, you've already heard Christian reference Seth many times. This is the first time many of those foundational conversations are finally happening publicly.
Don’t forget to like, subscribe, and become a channel member if you want to support the ongoing work of the Yours Truly Podcast.
#YoursTrulyPodcast #ConversationCraft #SacramentalOntology #ChristianBaxter #SymbolicTheology #FaithAndMeaning #GenZ #Liturgy #Eucharist #Catholicism #Evangelicalism #Orthodoxy #JordanPeterson #JonathanPageau #MeaningCrisis #SpiritualJourney #Embodiment #ChristianPodcast
Timestamps:
00:00 – Intro
03:12 – Growing up moving constantly
09:48 – Music, rebellion, and the search for identity
18:30 – Grunge, authenticity, and the collapse of corporate religion
28:45 – Shame, guilt, and learning self-respect
38:22 – Los Angeles, collapse, and crying out to God
48:11 – The long walk to the bridge
58:09 – Grace, suffering, and spiritual formation
1:09:14 – Evangelical sincerity and sacramental imagination
1:21:32 – Catholicism, Eucharist, and real presence
1:38:41 – Gen Z, liturgy, and the hunger for the tangible
1:48:55 – Final reflections
Referenced voices and influences:
Jordan Peterson
Jonathan Pageau
Billy Graham
Jimmy Swaggart
Kurt Cobain
Pearl Jam
Alice in Chains
Creed
Michael Knott
This is a channel update, but it is also a way of naming what this whole project has been becoming.
For the last two and a half years, this channel has mostly lived inside a particular corner of the internet — downstream from Jordan Peterson, Jonathan Pageau, John Vervaeke, Paul VanderKlay, Martin Shaw, Paul Kingsnorth, and the wider conversation around meaning, symbolism, Christianity, and the search for reality.
That conversation still matters to me. I am not done with it.
But lately, more pieces have started showing up here: motorcycle rides, Arkansas backroads, Batesville stories, local conversations, video craft, music, church, place, and the attempt to bring my actual life into the same frame.
So what’s next?
Not a new channel. Not a clean niche. Not a total pivot.
More like integration.
Yours Truly is becoming a place where the digital pilgrimage, the local landscape, the podcast, the motorcycle, the studio, the church, and the people around me can start to belong together.
If you have been here for the long conversations, thank you.
If you have enjoyed the motorcycle films, thank you.
If you are curious where this is going, stick around.
We are going to see what is around the corner.
Become a channel member to support the work:
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCU5SNBfTo4umhjYz6M0Jsmg/join
Morning Light Music:
https://morninglightmusic.io/
Speakeasy Rock Band:
https://www.youtube.com/@UCMSrJD3kthH8RxbJw_N3XjQ
#YoursTruly #ChristianBaxter #ChannelUpdate #MotoCraft #Batesville #SymbolicWorld #JordanPeterson #JonathanPageau #PaulVanderKlay #JohnVervaeke
Style ≠ Order.
Modern worship may be confusing the two.
In this conversation with Dr. Matthew Wilkinson — organist, Director of Music, and host of The Pursuit of Beauty — we explore why modern worship often confuses aesthetic preference with spiritual depth.
What happens when worship becomes a stage?
When transcendence is traded for emotional immediacy?
When beauty is reduced to branding?
Matthew’s journey from Pentecostal roots to Anglican liturgy opens a deeper question: Is beauty optional in Christian worship — or is it essential?
We discuss:
• The difference between style and order
• Why liturgy shapes the soul
• The limits of seeker-sensitive worship
• Beauty as one of the names of God
• Bach, chant, and the architecture of transcendence
• Why most contemporary worship music feels thin
• The role of confession, humility, and form
• How churches might recover depth without abandoning creativity
This is not an attack on contemporary worship.
It is a call to aim higher.
If the Church has inherited two thousand years of music, architecture, and liturgical wisdom — why are we so quick to flatten it?
—
About Dr. Matthew Wilkinson
Matthew is Director of Music at St. Michael’s Anglican Church and host of The Pursuit of Beauty, a podcast exploring liturgy, aesthetics, and Christian formation.
His album The Pursuit of Beauty is available wherever music is streamed.
Website: https://matthewwilkinson.net/
Podcast: The Pursuit of Beauty @matthewwilkinsonmusic
—
If you find these conversations meaningful:
• Subscribe to the channel
• Leave a review on your podcast platform
• Follow Yours Truly on Substack
• Consider becoming a YouTube Channel Member
All links below.
—
Yours Truly is a place we go to think out loud
Join this channel to get access to perks:
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCU5SNBfTo4umhjYz6M0Jsmg/join
follow me on X: https://twitter.com/chrbaxter_yt
https://substack.com/@christianbaxteryt
What happens when Christian language collapses but the experiences don’t stop?
In this conversation with @treyhuntley we explore the fault line between the cross, the psyche, and the return of the sacred—where Jung, prayer, discernment, and lived experience refuse to stay in separate categories.
Many people today aren’t losing faith—they’re losing language.
This conversation with Trey Huntley sits at the intersection of Christianity, Jung, psychology, and the symbolic world, asking how the sacred returns through the psyche without collapsing into chaos or control.
Can Christianity and Jung Speak Honestly to Each Other?
This is a conversation for those who’ve had encounters they can’t unsee, but don’t want to lose their minds—or their faith—trying to understand them
This conversation unfolds within a broader ecosystem shaped by thinkers and creators wrestling with meaning, symbolism, and faith in the modern world. @johnvervaeke ’s work on the meaning crisis, relevance realization, and the recovery of the sacred provides a conceptual backdrop for many of the questions explored here.
@JonathanPageau ’s symbolic theology and attention to image, pattern, and tradition inform the way symbols, Scripture, and lived experience are approached—not as abstractions, but as participatory realities.
@JordanBPeterson reintroduction of Jung, biblical symbolism, and archetypal reading into public discourse has helped reopen conversations many people were never given language for.
And @PaulVanderKlay ’s long-form, patient conversational style—especially within “this little corner of the internet”—has modeled a way of thinking out loud that resists both ideological capture and premature certainty.
This episode moves through questions many people are quietly carrying:
• How do we speak honestly about prayer, visions, dreams, and the inner world without collapsing into chaos or control?
• What does Carl Jung offer—and where does he fall short—when held alongside Christian faith?
• Why do so many modern Christians feel haunted by experiences they were never given language for?
• What does resurrection mean when it shows up inside a human life, not just a doctrine?
This is not a debate about belief.
It’s an attempt to recover language that can hold lived experience without losing truth, humility, or sanity.
⸻
🧭 Topics explored in this conversation:
• Carl Jung and the Christian imagination
• Prayer, discernment, and symbolic experience
• Psychology, therapy, and confession
• The dangers of flattening spiritual experience
• Resurrection as lived reality
• Why the sacred keeps returning through the psyche
• Finding sane language in a fractured age
⸻
👤 About the guest:
@treyhuntley works at the intersection of psychology, spirituality, and symbolic meaning. His work engages Jungian thought, the imaginal, discernment, and the lived realities many people experience outside tidy religious or secular categories.
⸻
🕯 About Yours Truly:
Yours Truly is a long-form conversation space for thinking out loud about faith, meaning, psychology, culture, and the slow work of truth-telling in a disenchanted world.
Podcast link: I published my new episode The Yours Truly Podcast, please check it out. https://www.podbean.com/pi/pbblog-y77sn-117e7a0
⸻
🔔 Support the work:
If you find value in these conversations:
• Like & subscribe — it genuinely helps the reach
• Consider becoming a channel member to support the project
• Share with someone who’s asking similar questions
Links below.
Join this channel
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCU5SNBfTo4umhjYz6M0Jsmg/join
Substack: https://open.substack.com/pub/christianbaxteryt/p/midwest-estuary-the-homecoming?r=433pnb&utm_medium=ios&shareImageVariant=overlay
X: https://x.com/chrbaxter_yt?s=21
Trey on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/treyhuntley?igsh=MWxneXB6bHg2eXp5bA==
⸻
📍 Chapters:
(Coming soon)
⸻
🔍 TAGS
@treyhuntley conversation with @PaulVanderKlay
https://youtu.be/KDViTqb-zXQ?si=47bpVxbX8NOIFH0w
• Carl Jung
• Jungian psychology
• Christianity and psychology
• Symbolic theology
• Discernment
• Prayer and therapy
• Christian imagination
• Meaning crisis
• Sacred and secular
• Resurrection
• Depth psychology
Jordan Peterson
In this conversation, I’m joined again by Bob the Baptist to talk about Christianity in the digital age—and the growing gap between discourse and formation.
Online Christian conversations can generate urgency, clarity, and conviction. But they also move faster than people can be formed, stabilized, or responsibly led. Throughout this discussion, we return to a central tension: some people need immediate pastoral triage, while others need long-term structural and liturgical formation—and the internet is optimized for neither.
Bob presses on questions of responsibility, containment, and landing people somewhere real. I press on the limits of online systems, the dangers of premature closure, and the need for slow, embodied reconstruction. We’re not arguing past each other so much as operating on different time horizons.
This episode isn’t a debate. It’s an attempt to name the limits of Christian discourse, the burden placed on leaders in digital spaces, and why one conversation, platform, or “update” can’t do both jobs at once.
Topics include:
– Triage vs formation
– Online discourse and pastoral responsibility
– Why systems shape belief before theology does
– The limits of scale, speed, and visibility
– Why stability can’t be demanded from unstable systems
If you’re trying to think seriously about faith, leadership, and formation after the internet, this conversation is for you.
In this conversation, Christian Baxter sits down with Daniel of @O.G.Rose.Michelle.and.Daniel to explore what happens when Christianity is reduced to ideas, arguments, or online content—and why belief alone is no longer enough to sustain faith in a fragmented, post-institutional age.
The discussion moves through art, beauty, political economy, apologetics, and local community, tracing how modern life has hollowed out shared practices while multiplying opinions. Together, they ask a quietly unsettling question: if Christianity becomes something you mainly consume or debate, what is actually left to participate in?
Rather than offering a program or a culture-war posture, this episode circles a deeper claim: Christianity survives as a lived reality—formed through beauty, ritual, time, and embodied community—not as a set of propositions optimized for the internet. Beauty draws before arguments persuade. Formation precedes explanation. Church is not an information service, but a place you enter and are shaped by.
This conversation will resonate with anyone wrestling with the limits of online discourse, the exhaustion of ideological Christianity, or the longing for something real enough to inhabit. It’s an exploration of why faith must eventually move from the screen into shared life, shared time, and shared ground.
00:00 Introduction & framing the conversation
04:30 Art, faith, and incarnational thinking
11:45 Culture after the “end of history”
19:30 Institutional breakdown and loss of trust
28:10 Politics, economics, and spiritual vacuum
37:20 Christianity reduced to ideas and arguments
46:40 Why apologetics isn’t enough anymore
56:15 Formation vs belief in modern Christianity
1:06:30 The internet, abstraction, and disembodied faith
1:17:00 Beauty as attraction, not decoration
1:28:10 Liturgy, ritual, and lived participation
1:39:30 Why people ask “why bother with church?”
1:50:00 Local community, place, and imagination
2:01:45 Small towns, scale, and human formation
2:13:30 Christianity as a way of life, not content
2:26:00 Closing reflections on reality and participation
Join this channel to get access to perks:
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCU5SNBfTo4umhjYz6M0Jsmg/join
follow me on X: https://twitter.com/chrbaxter_yt
My Substack related: https://open.substack.com/pub/christianbaxteryt/p/what-is-real-christianity?r=433pnb&utm_medium=ios&shareImageVariant=overlay
In this episode, I sit down with a fellow seeker who has been navigating Christianity, coherence, and personal responsibility in the midst of the modern “meaning crisis.” Our conversation explores the difference between understanding ideas conceptually and learning how truth is embodied over time—between having a map and actually walking the territory.
We talk about evangelical Christianity, propositional belief, the role of church and tradition, and the challenges of forming a stable life while participating in online conversations about faith and meaning. Rather than aiming for conclusions or quick resolutions, this episode stays with the tension: how coherence is shaped slowly through practice, discipline, community, and lived participation—not just insight or explanation.
This conversation will resonate with anyone wrestling honestly with belief, belonging, formation, and the question of what it means to live faithfully without rushing arrival
Join this channel
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCU5SNBfTo4umhjYz6M0Jsmg/join
Sign up for the podcast: I published my new episode The Yours Truly Podcast, please check it out. https://www.podbean.com/pi/pbblog-y77sn-117e7a0
Follow Christian on X & Substack
https://x.com/chrbaxter_yt?s=21
https://substack.com/@christianbaxteryt?r=433pnb&utm_medium=ios&utm_source=profile
Ian’s podcast - @insight.incorporated
In this conversation, I’m joined again by Brendan Graham Dempsey to explore one of the deepest questions beneath Christianity, deconstruction, and the meaning crisis:
What does it mean for Christianity to be real?
We talk about why reducing Christianity to either literal historical propositions or “just a story” misses the point—and how story, ritual, participation, and embodiment function as carriers of truth across time. This conversation moves through historical criticism, archetypal meaning, sacramental imagination, developmental faith, and the difference between belief and participation.
Rather than defending Christianity through certainty or abandoning it through reduction, we ask what it looks like to inhabit a tradition honestly after modern skepticism and postmodern critique.
Topics include:
• Why Christianity can’t be reduced to facts alone—or dismissed as mere metaphor
• The difference between belief and participation
• Archetype, story, and reality after deconstruction
• Ritual, sacrament, and transjective meaning
• Developmental faith, doubt, and second naïveté
• Why “saving souls” may not be the same as cultivating a faithful life
This is a conversation for those who still feel the weight of Christianity—but refuse to lie to themselves about history, psychology, or experience.
0:00 Intro & Re-Entering the Conversation
3:30 What’s Changed in the Last Year (Culture & Metamodernism)
11:45 Digital Liminal Spaces & Institutional Drift
22:10 Turning Toward Metamodern Christianity
33:40 Parenting, Formation, and Developmental Faith
50:15 Symbol, Archetype, and What “Real” Means
1:06:20 Liturgy, Sacraments, and Transjectivity
1:22:30 Final Reflections & Mutual Recognition
1:28:54 Closing
⸻
Become a channel member to support finacially - https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCU5SNBfTo4umhjYz6M0Jsmg/join
Related conversations:
• Previous episodes with Brendan Graham Dempsey
• Conversations on symbolic theology, liturgy, and the meaning crisis
• Episodes exploring faith after deconstruction
If this conversation resonates, consider subscribing, sharing, or leaving a comment.
This channel exists for slow thinking, honest dialogue, and meaning worth inhabiting.
Symbol, Tradition, and the Fracturing West — and the Limits of Modern Dialogue
In this episode of the Yours Truly Podcast, I’m joined by Yosef, a Jewish participant in This Little Corner of the Internet, for a careful conversation on Judaism, Christianity, and the crisis of trust shaping the modern West.
We explore how symbol, tradition, and religious memory function in an age of fragmentation—where dialogue is demanded, yet trust is increasingly fragile. Drawing from Jewish thought, Christian theology, cognitive science, and lived digital experience, Yosef offers a perspective rarely heard in contemporary religious and cultural debate.
Our conversation touches on:
• how modernity fractures shared symbolic worlds
• why trust—not just belief—has become the central cultural problem
• the limits of liberal dialogue and “view-from-nowhere” neutrality
• Judaism’s encounter with modernity and its parallels with Christian crises
• why Jewish voices are often spoken about rather than with
We also reflect on the broader cultural moment—where figures like Benjamin Boyce and Nick Fuentes have surfaced difficult questions about identity, power, and influence—often without sustained engagement across traditions.
This is not a debate or a polemic. It’s an attempt to think carefully in public, to hold difference without dissolving it, and to ask whether meaningful dialogue is still possible when our symbolic foundations no longer align.
If you’re interested in religion beyond slogans, culture beyond outrage, and conversation beyond tribes, this episode is for you.
00:00 – Opening: Trust as the Real Crisis
Why belief isn’t the core problem anymore
04:50 – Finding “This Little Corner of the Internet”
Cognitive science, meaning crisis, and unexpected dialogue
11:30 – The Four Ways of Knowing
Participatory, propositional, perspectival—and the poetic
18:40 – Jewish Thought and Symbolic Continuity
Why Judaism never fully abandoned symbol
26:30 – Reform, Conservative, and Orthodox Judaism
How Judaism encountered modernity before Christianity
38:40 – The Protestant Reformation’s Echo in Judaism
Parallel crises of abstraction and disenchantment
47:30 – Symbol vs Rationalization
What breaks when religion becomes purely conceptual
55:40 – Midrash and the New Testament
Why Christians often miss Jewish interpretive worlds
1:05:10 – Trust, Liberal Neutrality, and Power
The limits of “view-from-nowhere” dialogue
1:14:40 – Identity, Ethnicity, and the Fracturing West
Why categories are collapsing—and re-forming
1:24:10 – Nick Fuentes, Benjamin Boyce, and Dialogue at the Edge
Black-pilling, boundaries, and whether conversation can survive
1:33:10 – The Limits of Dialogue
Zones of trust and where conversation breaks down
1:36:40 – Final Reflections
Why trust—not consensus—is the future task
From the publisher's feed