Thinks Out Loud: E-commerce and Digital Strategy

Thinks Out Loud: E-commerce and Digital Strategy

Download on the App Store

Thinks Out Loud: E-commerce and Digital Strategy episodes

  • Will Your Customers Use AI? (Thinks Out Loud Episode 418)

    AI might be entering the “trough of disillusionment,” but that doesn’t mean it’s dead. Far from it. In fact, an increasing number of customers are using AI every single day. And, yet, despite this increased use, savvy marketers aren’t spending their time thinking about the artificial intelligence; they’re thinking about their customers.

    That’s what you should do too.

    Because AI isn’t what matters. Your customers are what matters. And AI only matters if your customers are willing to use it. So, will your customers use AI? If not, what’s keeping them from putting it to work? And, most importantly, how can you help them not only choose to use your AI tools, but also choose your business?

    That’s what this episode of the Thinks Out Loud podcast is all about. Want to learn more? Here are the show notes for you.

    Will Your Customers Use AI? (Thinks Out Loud Episode 418) — Headlines and Show Notes
    Show Notes and Links
    • Americans increasingly using ChatGPT, but few trust its 2024 election information | Pew Research Center
    • Should generative AI programs credit their sources? Many US adults say yes | Pew Research Center
    • Americans’ views of artificial intelligence | Pew Research Center
    • Edelman offers its Top 20 Brand Trust Factors – PDF link
    • OpenAI to open access to ChatGPT without sign-up- Republic World
    • Desk Set (1957) – Quotes – IMDb
    • Mini-MBA: Digital Marketing | Rutgers Business School
    • Why You Need to Ignore the Coming AI Backlash (Thinks Out Loud Episode 417)
    • Revisiting Is It Time for Your Marketing Team to Use AI? (Thinks Out Loud)
    • Revisiting 2024 Predictions: Putting AI in Marketing to Work (Thinks Out Loud)
    • No One is Talking About the Most Important Lessons from Google’s Gemini Launch Kerfuffle (Thinks Out Loud Episode 415)
    • Picks, Shovels, and the AI Gold Rush (Thinks Out Loud Episode 414)
    • Is Google Doomed? And Other Top Digital Trends for 2024 (Thinks Out Loud Episode 408)
    • What AI Will Do to Content Marketing (Thinks Out Loud Episode 402)
    • Techno-Optimism and Building a Human Brand (Thinks Out Loud Episode 399)
    • Building a Human Brand in the Age of AI (Thinks Out Loud Episode 398)
    • Rethinking Search Marketing in the Age of AI (Thinks Out Loud Episode 397)
    • Anticipating Radical Shifts in Consumer Behavior from AI Adoption: A Look into the Future (Thinks Out Loud Episode 396)
    • Revisiting Does Marketing Have a Future?
    • You might also enjoy this webinar I recently participated in with Miles Partnership that looked at "The Power of Generative AI and ChatGPT: What It Means for Tourism & Hospitality" here:

      Free Downloads

      We have some free downloads for you to help you navigate the current situation, which you can find right here:

      • A Modern Content Marketing Checklist. Want to ensure that each piece of content works for your business? Download our latest checklist to help put your content marketing to work for you.
      • Digital & E-commerce Maturity Matrix. As a bonus, here’s a PDF that can help you assess your company’s digital maturity. You can use this to better understand where your company excels and where its opportunities lie. And, of course, we’re here to help if you need it. The Digital & E-commerce Maturity Matrix rates your company’s effectiveness — Ad Hoc, Aware, Striving, Driving — in 6 key areas in digital today, including:
        • Customer Focus
        • Strategy
        • Technology
        • Operations
        • Culture
        • Data
        • Best of Thinks Out Loud

          You can find our “Best of Thinks Out Loud” playlist on Spotify right here:

          Subscribe to Thinks Out Loud
          • Subscribe in iTunes
          • Subscribe in the Google Play Store
          • Contact information for the podcast: [email protected]

            Past Insights from Tim Peter Thinks
            Technical Details for Thinks Out Loud

            Recorded using a Shure SM7B Vocal Dynamic Microphone and a Focusrite Scarlett 4i4 (3rd Gen) USB Audio Interface into Logic Pro X for the Mac.

            Running time: 21m 58s

            You can subscribe to Thinks Out Loud in iTunes, the Google Play Store, via our dedicated podcast RSS feed (or sign up for our free newsletter). You can also download/listen to the podcast here on Thinks using the player at the top of this page.

            Transcript: Will Your Customers Use AI?

            Well hello again everyone and welcome back to Thinks Out Loud, your source for all the digital expertise your business needs. My name is Tim Peter. This is episode 418 of The Big Show. And I think we’ve got a really cool show for you today. I really appreciate you tuning in.

            We’ve been doing a lot of episodes lately about artificial intelligence and how the technology might shape your business in the longer term. What I also want to do is I want you to remember that this is a marketing podcast, first and foremost. Marketing is always about people, not technology.

            I think AI is so cool. I’m the one who decides what we talk about every single week. So clearly, artificial intelligence has been top of mind for me and for a lot of other people for the last bunch of months. At the same time, it’s really important to talk about how people are using AI, how your customers are using AI, and what that might mean for your business.

            Because all of the technology in the world is only cool and only matters if your people use it, if your customers use it, if your team uses it. So, I thought it’d be a good time today to talk about where are we with in terms of customers? Will your customers use AI? Do your customers use AI? And the answer to that question is they are using AI, at least to some degree.

            It doesn’t really matter if you’re talking a B2B context or a B2C context, so business to business or business to consumer. Your customers are using AI today. That’s obviously true if they’re using Google to do search, or if they’re using any number of Microsoft products, or if they’re using things like Salesforce, or HubSpot, or Adobe, or LinkedIn, or, you know, autocorrect on their phones, or… well, you get the idea.

            AI is increasingly baked into many of the products, many of the services, many of the tools that your customers use every single day. And as I’ll get to in a minute, we should expect to see a lot more of that in the coming months. What’s also true is that most people don’t think they use AI very much at all.

            Data from Pew Research shows that about 50 percent of Americans say they use artificial intelligence less than once per week. Another Pew Research report shows that only 23 percent of Americans have tried ChatGPT ever. If we want to flip that on its head, obviously that means that 77 percent of Americans have never, ever used ChatGPT.

            And I’ll tell you more in a minute on why that matters. By the way, I, I hope you’ll pardon the provincialism here. I’m using U.S. only research at the moment. I know we’ve got a fair number of listeners all around the world, and I wanted to say thank you so much for listening. At the moment, though, I just don’t have a great source for this data outside the U.S. so that’s why I’m sticking with U.S. data for right now.

            One of the things that appears to be true is that use of AI is more regular and more common among younger and wealthier and more educated consumers. And that’s even more true at work, according to data from the conference board, where we see more than half of all users are using AI at least once a week.

            So, if your question is, are my customers using AI, you know, your customers, it really comes down to who your customers are. If they’re younger, wealthier, more educated, then they are using AI regularly at work and in their personal lives. If they’re older, if they’re less wealthy, if they’re less educated, then either they’re not using AI regularly. Or, in the case of artificial intelligence helping power Google Search, then it’s more likely that they’re not aware how regularly they may be using artificial intelligence.

            We care about this because customer behaviors are ultimately what drive our business, right? We can try to influence customer behaviors as much as we can, and we do, but people behave the way they tend to behave.

            And the behavior that we’re seeing from the less frequent user, least frequent users rather, excuse me, strikes me as the most likely long term reality for everybody. I’ve talked on this show many times about how technology becomes invisible. It’s the default state for technology after a certain period of adoption.

            You’ve heard me use this example plenty of times, how on the original Star Trek, the doors on the ships automatically slide open and closed. That used to be science fiction. Now you see it in every store you go to. That’s true, by the way. Before Star Trek, that wasn’t a thing. I’d ask you, how much internet bandwidth do you use in a given month?

            I suspect most people have no idea. I know that I don’t, actually, and I do this for a living. I suspect if it wasn’t for the fact that you pay your electric bill every month, I’m going to go out on a limb and say most people don’t think at all about the amount of electricity they use in a given week or month.

            And when you do, I suspect it’s only because you know the amount of the bill, not the actual usage in watts or current or anything like that. So why should we think using AI will be any different? I’ve also talked in past episodes about the thousands of AI focused applications and companies that MarTechMap has catalogued.

            So you’re a marketer, you’re using marketing technology in some part of your job. There’s AI baked into many of those tools, and it’s coming for all the ones that it’s not already in, right? And I suspect if you’re like most users, you couldn’t care less if those tools use AI or not. You care about whether the tool helps you do your job effectively.

            How it does it under the hood isn’t really that relevant, or really, isn’t really that important. And that’s why I’m reasonably confident that’s where we’re going to end up in the longer term with artificial intelligence. I talked about this on last week’s show where we’re seeing people enter the trough of disillusionment. Not because they’re disillusioned with AI, but they’re disillusioned with the value that they’re getting from it.

            People don’t care about AI, they care what it does for them. And that leads to the next question you want to think about, which is, what do your customers think about AI? Do they trust AI? And the answer, again, looking at the Pew Research, as well as some others that I’ll link to in the show notes, more or less is, not really.

            And I think this is partly because so many people haven’t spent much time hands on with AI that they’re not really sure of what it can and can’t do. When we think about the fact that more than three quarters of Americans have never used ChatGPT once, they’re not going to be particularly trusting of it.

            They’re not going to have a particular understanding of what it can and can’t do for them. Now that may change. OpenAI has opened up ChatGPT that you can now use it without an account. But we know that people are probably concerned about what it means for their careers, despite evidence that, at least according to the Census Bureau, AI mostly isn’t taking jobs.

            Still, they’re concerned. And until your customers have more exposure and more experience with AI, they’re likely to remain distrustful. They’re likely to remain concerned. This is so normal, by the way. We saw this with the internet, too. I remember going through this when people were first exposed to the internet.

            They weren’t really sure if it was something that they could trust. And, if my history is correct, the same thing happened when computers first came along. My wife and I love this old Katharine Hepburn/Spencer Tracy movie called Desk Set that came out in 1957. Spencer Tracy’s character has created a computer that’s also a search engine and installs it in Katharine Hepburn’s department at the corporation where she works.

            And hilarity and romance ensue. Now, the reason I’m bringing this up is because now, apart from the fact that the film is delightful and you might enjoy it, is because Katharine Hepburn and her team, for most of the movie, are terrified at the prospect that this new machine is going to replace them and take their jobs away.

            One of the characters even says, well, if we do get canned, we won’t be the only ones to lose our jobs because of a machine. Sound familiar? Right? By the way, there’s a line I love in the movie. This is a complete aside, but I hope you get a kick out of it. Katharine Hepburn’s character, Bonnie Watson, says she finds the machines and I quote, Frightening.

            Gave me the feeling that maybe, just maybe, people were a little bit outmoded. And Spencer Tracy with a total deadpan expression replies wouldn’t surprise me a bit if they stopped making them. Ha ha ha, classic. I mean, but notice The same concerns again and again. This movie is almost 70 years old, but the concerns of the characters and the people, people just like you and me and your customers, make it still feel relevant today.

            This is a dialogue we’ve been having for a long, long, long time. So that leads me to the most important questions you should be thinking about, which are, how are you going to use AI in your business, and how are you going to help your customers trust you that you’re using it well? I’ve addressed the first question in a ton of past episodes.

            Check out the show notes in this show and I’ll provide links to many you can check out. I’m going to spend all of our remaining time together on the second question. Notice that as part of that question I didn’t ask, How are you going to help your customers trust the artificial intelligence? I asked, how are you going to help customers trust you and how you use it?

            Why? Because, as I said a little bit ago, if you do it right, your customers don’t care whether you’re using AI or not. They care what it does for them. It’s about how you help them trust you. My friend Mark Schaefer has great advice about this that are words to live by right now that just echo in my skull repeatedly that say the most human company wins.

            And that is so right. I teach a class for Rutgers Business School Executive Education called Personalized Digital Experiences. www. RutgersBusinessSchool. com And in that class, we talk a lot about A, collecting data from your customers, and B, using that data to improve customer experience and how you do it the right way.

            One of the keys to doing those tasks effectively is staying away from what’s known as the creepy line. You know what the creepy line is, of course. It’s when companies do things that are creepy. They creep you out. For instance, if your favorite clothing retailer showed you something on their website or app that said, Here are some recommendations for pants and shirts you might like based on past purchases.

            That’s generally not creepy. If they said instead, Wow, the size of clothing you’re buying sure has changed a lot suddenly. Are you eating properly? Right? I think we’d all agree that would be pretty creepy. Even if it’s intended to be helpful, it’s still so not cool. Now, there are four ways to avoid the creepy line that apply equally well to artificial intelligence.

            The first of these is think big mother, not big brother. This idea comes from Forrester Research’s Julie Ask, and it is great, amazing, perfect framing. Think about if you’re using AI to make better experiences for your customers, or are you using it just because you can, just because you can do something cool.

            The first of those is generally okay. Think The second of those might lead you towards doing things creepy because you’re not thinking about the customer, you’re thinking about the technology. Second, have a devil’s advocate. Have someone on your team whose bonus is based on stopping you from doing creepy stuff.

            If everyone on your team’s bonus and salary and, oh, I don’t know, continued employment depends on doing something that veers towards creepy, I’ll give you one guess which choice they’re going to make. If instead, someone on the team is actively rewarded for pushing back on potentially creepy choices, you know, maybe a lawyer, maybe a programmer, maybe a business leader, someone with strong critical thinking skills, who’s thinking about the customer first and foremost, It minimizes the risk that you’ll do creepy stuff.

            It will keep you away from the creepy line. Also, test. Third thing, test. Don’t be afraid to start with small scale tests. Start with a small audience. Start with a small task. Try that. Learn what works and what doesn’t. And then scale up over time to more tasks or more audiences or both. Fourth, and finally, Be transparent.

            Don’t be afraid to let customers know how you’re using AI, why you’re using it, and how it benefits them. Offer them something like a frequently asked question and page. And if possible, and not always possible, but if you can, some way to opt out, so that if they’re not ready, they’re not forced to do this.

            Let them know any actions you’re taking to mitigate risks to them and risks to your business. Microsoft The more we shine light on the benefits of AI and the benefits that it offers to our customers, the more likely it is that our customers will trust it, and by extension, trust you. So the key points you want to remember is that your customers are using AI at least some of the time.

            That’s true in both B2B and B2C. The younger, wealthier, and more educated they are, the more they use and accept the tool. And the older, less wealthy, and less educated they are, the less they use AI, or at least the less they think they do. There is still a fair amount of mistrust around AI usage, and that mistrust is a normal part of technology adoption.

            We’ve seen this before. Your job is to help your customers trust not only your use of AI, but your company overall as well. Keep Mark Schaefer’s immortal words, the most human company wins, front and center for you. You can help them trust you more by A, thinking big mother, not big brother, B, working with a devil’s advocate, C, testing to see what works, and D, offering transparency around how you’re using AI.

            Your customers want the benefits artificial intelligence offers. That’s why they’re using it today. Your competitors are using AI in many cases to help provide those benefits. This is increasingly becoming table stakes. You can use AI too, but keep your focus on being human. Keep your focus on your customer.

            Because customers ultimately want to work with people and companies they trust. If you do that, if you keep the focus on your customer, they won’t just keep coming back because of the AI. They’ll keep coming back because of you.

            Show Wrap-Up and Credits

            Now, looking at the clock on the wall, we are out of time for this week.

            And I want to remind you again that you can find the show notes for this episode. As well as an archive of all past episodes by going to timpeter.com/podcast. Again, that’s timpeter.com/podcast. Just look for episode 418.

            Subscribe to Thinks Out Loud

            Don’t forget that you can click on the subscribe link in any of the episodes that you find there to have Thinks Out Loud delivered to your favorite podcatcher every single week. You can also find Thinks Out Loud on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube Music, anywhere fine podcasts are found.

            Leave a Rating or Review for Thinks Out Loud

            I would also very much appreciate it if you could provide a positive rating or review for the show whenever you use one of those services.

            If you like what you hear on Thinks Out Loud, if you enjoy what we talk about, if you like being part of the community that we’re building here, please give us a positive rating or review.

            Reviews help other listeners find the podcast. Reviews help other listeners understand what Thinks Out Loud is all about. They help to build our community and they mean the world to me. So thank you so much for doing that. I very, very much appreciate it.

            Thinks Out Loud on Social Media

            You can also find Thinks Out Loud on LinkedIn by going to linkedin.com/tim-peter-and-associates-llc. You can find me on Twitter or X or whatever you want to call it this week by using the Twitter handle @tcpeter. And of course, you can email me by sending an email to podcast(at)timpeter.com. Again, that’s podcast(at)timpeter.com.

            Show Outro

            Finally, and I know I say this a lot, I want you to know how thrilled I am that you keep listening to what we do here. It means so much to me. You are the reason we do this show.

            You’re the reason that Thinks Out Loud happens every single week. So please, keep your messages coming on LinkedIn. Keep hitting me up on Twitter, sending things via email. I love getting a chance to talk with you, to hear what’s going on in your world, and to learn how we can do a better job building on the types of content and community and information and insights that work for you and work for your business.

            So with all that said, I hope you have a fantastic rest of your day, I hope you have a wonderful week ahead, and I will look forward to speaking with you here on Thinks Out Loud next time. Until then, please be well, be safe, and as always, take care, everybody.

            The post Will Your Customers Use AI? (Thinks Out Loud Episode 418) appeared first on Tim Peter & Associates.

            22 min
          • Why You Need to Ignore the Coming AI Backlash (Thinks Out Loud Episode 417)

            I’m calling it: We’ve reached “peak AI.” There’s too much hype. With over $50B in venture capital investment in 2023 and literally thousands of “AI focused companies” in marketing technology alone, that’s a bubble that needs to let at least some air out and soon. And when that happens, we usually see a serious backlash. My advice to you if and when that happens for artificial intelligence is simple: Ignore it.

            Seriously. You need to ignore any AI backlash. Not because it won’t be justified… at least in part. But because hype and backlash are two sides of the same coin. One side assumes everything is amazing and can never go wrong. The other assumes everything is terrible and can never go right. And, at least as we’re seeing with AI, neither of those is true.

            Sure, AI is overhyped. And, yes, you want to ignore that hype. At the same time, artificial intelligence is also capable of improving your content, focusing your thinking, and helping your customers have better experiences. Why wouldn’t you embrace that?

            How can you use AI to drive better results? Where should you put your focus? And why is it so important to ignore the coming AI backlash? That’s what this episode of Thinks Out Loud is all about.

            Here are the show notes for you.

            Why You Need to Ignore the Coming AI Backlash (Thinks Out Loud Episode 417) — Headlines and Show Notes
            Show Notes and Links
            • Gartner hype cycle – Wikipedia
            • Gartner Hype Cycle Reviews Digital Technology and Trends
            • (1) Ethan Mollick on X: "People on this site: AI is going through the Gartner Hype Cycle. AI: Using historical Hype Cycle data from Gartner, itself, only 4.1% of technologies actually fit the growth, decline, plateau pattern described by the Hype Cycle. (Though this is only one approach to the data) https://t.co/5yDu2lUM4P" / X
            • Amazon, Google Quietly Tamp Down Generative AI Expectations — The Information
            • Gartner Predicts Search Engine Volume Will Drop 25% by 2026, Due to AI Chatbots and Other Virtual Agents
            • Which AI should I use? Superpowers and the State of Play
            • Revisiting 2024 Predictions: Putting AI in Marketing to Work (Thinks Out Loud)
            • Is Google Doomed? And Other Top Digital Trends for 2024 (Thinks Out Loud Episode 408)
            • Revisiting Is It Time for Your Marketing Team to Use AI? (Thinks Out Loud)
            • No One is Talking About the Most Important Lessons from Google’s Gemini Launch Kerfuffle (Thinks Out Loud Episode 415)
            • Anticipating Radical Shifts in Consumer Behavior from AI Adoption: A Look into the Future (Thinks Out Loud Episode 396)
            • AI Won’t Steal Your Job: Smart People Who Put AI to Work Will (Thinks Out Loud Episode 208)
            • Picks, Shovels, and the AI Gold Rush (Thinks Out Loud Episode 414)
            • AI winter – Wikipedia
            • You might also enjoy this webinar I recently participated in with Miles Partnership that looked at "The Power of Generative AI and ChatGPT: What It Means for Tourism & Hospitality" here:

              Free Downloads

              We have some free downloads for you to help you navigate the current situation, which you can find right here:

              • A Modern Content Marketing Checklist. Want to ensure that each piece of content works for your business? Download our latest checklist to help put your content marketing to work for you.
              • Digital & E-commerce Maturity Matrix. As a bonus, here’s a PDF that can help you assess your company’s digital maturity. You can use this to better understand where your company excels and where its opportunities lie. And, of course, we’re here to help if you need it. The Digital & E-commerce Maturity Matrix rates your company’s effectiveness — Ad Hoc, Aware, Striving, Driving — in 6 key areas in digital today, including:
                • Customer Focus
                • Strategy
                • Technology
                • Operations
                • Culture
                • Data
                • Best of Thinks Out Loud

                  You can find our “Best of Thinks Out Loud” playlist on Spotify right here:

                  Subscribe to Thinks Out Loud
                  • Subscribe in iTunes
                  • Subscribe in the Google Play Store
                  • Contact information for the podcast: [email protected]

                    Past Insights from Tim Peter Thinks
                    Technical Details for Thinks Out Loud

                    Recorded using the travel rig: Shure SM57 Cardioid Dynamic Instrument Microphone and a IK Multimedia iRig Pro Duo IO USB audio interface into Logic Pro X for the Mac.

                    Running time: 20m 04s

                    You can subscribe to Thinks Out Loud in iTunes, the Google Play Store, via our dedicated podcast RSS feed (or sign up for our free newsletter). You can also download/listen to the podcast here on Thinks using the player at the top of this page.

                    Transcript: Why You Need to Ignore the Coming AI Backlash

                    Well hello again everyone and welcome back to Thinks Out Loud, your source for all the digital expertise your business needs. My name is Tim Peter. This is episode 417 of The Big Show. And thank you so much for tuning in, I very much appreciate it. I think we’ve got a really cool show for you today.

                    So, in case you haven’t noticed, AI is beginning to experience some backlash. AI in marketing, AI in sales, AI in customer service to a lesser degree. But we’re starting to see people question, “Wait a second, is this AI thing just a bunch of hype?”

                    And in fact, there is something called the Gartner Hype Cycle. Been around for years. It’s got five stages. Gartner, the IT research firm, has been talking about this for the long time. And they basically say there’s five stages of technology adoption. The first is a technology trigger. Something happens that makes the technology gain some buzz. And usually some publicity. I love this line from the Wikipedia article: “Often no usable products exist and commercial viability is unproven.” Classic.

                    Then we hit the peak of inflated expectations where some companies start to do stuff with it and the publicity ramps up a lot. People hear all of the great things that the new technology can do. That’s kind of where we are right now for sure with AI.

                    But then you hit the peak and you fall off the peak into what is called the trough of disillusionment. Basically, people start to question, “wait, is this thing all hype? Is this, you know, not as cool as we thought?”

                    Eventually you climb out of the slope of the trough of disillusionment into the slope of enlightenment where you begin to recognize how you really can use the technology in reality day in and day out.

                    And you finally end up on the plateau of productivity where it becomes mainstream.

                    Now this happens with technology a lot, although according to research from Ethan Mollick, most technologies don’t actually follow the Gartner hype cycle, only about 4%. But it seems like this time we really are following the script.

                    The technology trigger was ChatGPT. We’re kind of at the peak of inflated expectations, and we’re starting to see people make some noise that lead me to think we’re about to fall into the trough of disillusionment.

                    As I mentioned earlier this year, as I’ve been hearing from some folks I’m talking to in the C-suite and the like, we’re beginning to get folks in the C-suite asking what value their businesses receive for all of the investment they’ve made so far in AI tools.

                    As I heard somebody say recently, “I have more pilots than United. I’m done with pilots. It’s time for the planes to fly.” And that gets to a fundamental truth, and this is true always: Results matter. And because results matter, you’re going to inevitably have a fallout or a bust when, you know, there’s been a lot of buzz and a lot of hype about something.

                    There’s an old expression that “extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.” Lots of people have been making bold claims. People, including me, have been making bold claims, but way more than me have been making bold claims about the fact that AI is going to make a significant change on the way we do things.

                    And so now decision makers at a lot of companies are beginning to say, “OK, cool, prove it, show me.” Again, I said that was happening in an episode we did a couple months ago because that’s where we always end up. If CEOs and other company leaders weren’t asking that question, they wouldn’t be doing their jobs.

                    And the reality is there has been too much money chasing too few actual solutions. In 2023, there was $50 billion in venture capital investment in AI companies. And I’ve mentioned this stat before, but according to MarTechMap, there were thousands of “AI focused” martech tools in the marketplace between May of 2023 and November of 2023, plus all the existing tools that have been adding AI capabilities as fast as they can dream them up.

                    I completely believe that in two to three years, every piece of software you use today will either have AI built into it or it will have AI wrapped around it. Now what I mean by wrapped around it is that some legacy applications, and I’m thinking of things like existing hotel central reservation systems or financial services database applications, similar things to that, they’re not going to get ripped out and replaced with an AI version in the next two to three years. That’s just not going to happen. I do think we’re beginning to see a near-Y2K level effort to make it easy for AI to get access to the data stored within those applications. I’m going to talk a little bit more about this later, but clearly that is an area where a lot of work needs to be done.

                    And the coming AI backlash, one of the causes, if we’re being 100 percent honest about this, is that AI is not perfect. Not by a long shot. I’ve certainly never said it is. AI is not a one size fits all solution. Yeah, we might get artificial general intelligence or artificial super intelligence, you know, in the next months or years. I’m not convinced. It could also never show up. And I would be surprised if it does. I’m not smart enough to know if or when we might actually see something like that. And if or when we do we’re in a whole new world, one where we’ve invited an entirely new species to share the planet with us. A species that is smart, or smarter than we are. I am really not willing to place bets one way or the other about whether that’s going to happen and what it would look like if we do. Personally, I’m not going to worry about it much.

                    The point remains that AI as it exists today isn’t perfect. At the same time, neither are people. I’m a big fan of people. I think we’re going to keep them around for a while. As we’re learning, AI actually helps most people be better at what they do. So it’s not an “either/or,” — it’s not either AI or people. It’s definitely going to be AI and people for the near term… and probably for the longer term too.

                    Instead, here are my thoughts about where we are, where we’re going, and why you need to ignore the coming AI backlash.

                    Yes, AI is overhyped for sure. Way too many “solutions” that don’t solve real business problems. We’re probably looking at an equivalent of the dot-com bubble bursting somewhere in the next 12 to 18 months, I think. I could easily be wrong about the timing, and I could easily be wrong about the scale of any shift that occurs there. Don’t go making stock picks because of anything I’m saying here.

                    On the other hand, if you really think more than 13,000 martech solutions and $50 billion of VC investment is sustainable, I’ve got a startup or three I’d like to pitch you on. I just don’t think that’s a sustainable reality, and I don’t think that’s a bold claim.

                    At the other other hand, this isn’t like what we saw with something like crypto. Crypto often has been a solution in search of a problem. Finally, we’ve also seen AI winters happen before. We then climb out of them. We then go back to an AI spring. Good stuff tends to follow.

                    And the reason I think that’s the case this time is because a lot of the AI that’s being produced right now is genuinely useful. And this gets to the core point I want you to think about today, which is don’t let anti-hype prevent you from doing things that matter to your business. Don’t let the AI backlash, if and when it occurs, prevent you from using a tool to improve the things you do for your customers.

                    Despite its limitations, you can use AI to solve all kinds of problems today in marketing and in customer service. You can generate, you can use generative AI tools for visuals and text. I’ll give you an example of that in just a moment. You can use it for customer service and chat. I’m seeing cases where companies are using chatbots with their customer service representatives or their employees to improve issue resolution without even exposing it to the customer because the customer service reps or the employees can recognize any issues that the chatbot gets wrong.

                    You can use it for brainstorming ideas where you’re already an expert — which I think might be the best use case and is certainly my most frequent use case.

                    Let me give you an example of what that looks like in practice. I gave a 45 minute talk earlier this week about artificial intelligence to a CEO roundtable.

                    The first thing I did is what I always do when I’m giving a talk. I drafted an outline of what I intended to talk about. What I did differently this time is I then ran the outline through ChatGPT to get feedback. I could have used the latest version of Gemini 1.5, which I increasingly like, or I could have used Claude. All three are exceptional, and according to an array of people I respect, are the very best frontier models, at least at the moment. But I used ChatGPT because it’s the one I’m most familiar with, and I think it’s really good at this sort of thing. Based on ChatGPT’s feedback, I made a couple of changes to the outline.

                    The overall outline didn’t change a ton, but it did provide a useful set of suggestions to review, even in cases where I rejected its recommendations. Because what happened was it caused me to think more deeply about whether I was making the point I was trying to make, and if I was making it as clearly as I could.

                    After that, just as I always do, I started building slides. For some slides, I also ran my basic thesis of the slide through ChatGPT, as well as discussing it with people on my team to get feedback on the ideas and the voiceover that I planned to use. Simultaneously, I worked with MidJourney to get visuals for some of the slides.

                    For this talk in particular, normally I have somebody on my team who creates visuals for me or selects them from, you know, stock image libraries and things like that. But I wanted every visual apart from screenshots and graphs to be AI generated. I specifically did that because I wanted to show the good, the bad, and the ugly so people can get a feel for the array of things that can occur, especially if, like me, you’re not a graphic designer or you’re not expert at this sort of thing. In a few cases, when I got stuck for a visual idea, I asked ChatGPT to recommend concepts or potential prompts. I often edited those, but it was a good thing to have a sounding board to work from, it was a really useful tool for that.

                    If I’m being completely transparent, I also want to point out that I ran every visual past my content manager on my team, to see what they thought, and then incorporated those recommendations into the prompts, too. A big part of my objective for this talk, is What I did was to use AI as much as possible to show what it’s capable of and show where it sometimes falls down. What I also did was use AI to augment both my capabilities and that of the people on my team.

                    Now I want to be very clear, I would not at this point outsource the job of creating out the outline, the images, or the slides entirely to an AI. Every time my content manager or I reviewed ChatGPT’s recommendations, we found ways to improve them — or at least almost every single time.

                    Also, ChatGPT, at minimum, made my thinking clearer when I had to defend my original idea against the AI recommendation. And in a couple of cases, its recommendations were outstanding and I think made the overall talk better too.

                    The end result here was a very strong, very well received talk. It was, at least in my view, better, sharper, and came together faster than it would otherwise have done. And from the feedback I got from people at the talk, it was very, very well liked by the audience. I had lots of conversation with people afterwards. It seemed to go really, really well.

                    And my point in telling this story is to say this. Don’t get hung up on the hype cycle. Ignore any backlash against AI because you don’t want to waste your time worrying about all the things that AI doesn’t do if that’s going to distract you from what it does do.

                    Generative AI for visuals and text, customer service and chat, brainstorming, idea generation, and a host of others you’ve probably found that I haven’t even talked about here. Work on solving real problems, not pilots.

                    Also look at what needs to happen to connect AI to your data. As I mentioned before, the biggest problem by far that I’m running into with companies is connecting AI with existing sources of data because it’s distributed all over their company. I think that’s an important and accurate driver of the frustration some leaders are feeling right now.

                    So ignore the coming AI backlash. It’s a waste of time. Use the tools for the things they’re good at. And keep working to improve your customer’s experience and your content and your ideas. Because if you do that, you’re going to do better than everybody else who’s going, “Oh gosh, maybe it’s time we back away from AI.”

                    And as I’ve said once a long time ago, you’re not going to lose your job to AI, you’re going to lose your job to smart people who use AI. Just like it would be silly to foolishly follow the hype, it would be equally silly to follow the anti-hype and to follow the backlash. Be smart, be thoughtful, focus on customer problems, and you’re going to accomplish a ton.

                    I, for one, can’t wait to see what you do.

                    Show Wrap-Up and Credits

                    Now, looking at the clock on the wall, we are out of time for this week.

                    And I want to remind you again that you can find the show notes for this episode. As well as an archive of all past episodes by going to timpeter.com/podcast. Again, that’s timpeter.com/podcast. Just look for episode 417.

                    Subscribe to Thinks Out Loud

                    Don’t forget that you can click on the subscribe link in any of the episodes that you find there to have Thinks Out Loud delivered to your favorite podcatcher every single week. You can also find Thinks Out Loud on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube Music, anywhere fine podcasts are found.

                    Leave a Rating or Review for Thinks Out Loud

                    I would also very much appreciate it if you could provide a positive rating or review for the show whenever you use one of those services.

                    If you like what you hear on Thinks Out Loud, if you enjoy what we talk about, if you like being part of the community that we’re building here, please give us a positive rating or review.

                    Reviews help other listeners find the podcast. Reviews help other listeners understand what Thinks Out Loud is all about. They help to build our community and they mean the world to me. So thank you so much for doing that. I very, very much appreciate it.

                    Thinks Out Loud on Social Media

                    You can also find Thinks Out Loud on LinkedIn by going to linkedin.com/tim-peter-and-associates-llc. You can find me on Twitter or X or whatever you want to call it this week by using the Twitter handle @tcpeter. And of course, you can email me by sending an email to podcast(at)timpeter.com. Again, that’s podcast(at)timpeter.com.

                    Show Outro

                    Finally, and I know I say this a lot, I want you to know how thrilled I am that you keep listening to what we do here. It means so much to me. You are the reason we do this show.

                    You’re the reason that Thinks Out Loud happens every single week. So please, keep your messages coming on LinkedIn. Keep hitting me up on Twitter, sending things via email. I love getting a chance to talk with you, to hear what’s going on in your world, and to learn how we can do a better job building on the types of content and community and information and insights that work for you and work for your business.

                    So with all that said, I hope you have a fantastic rest of your day, I hope you have a wonderful week ahead, and I will look forward to speaking with you here on Thinks Out Loud next time. Until then, please be well, be safe, and as always, take care, everybody.

                    The post Why You Need to Ignore the Coming AI Backlash (Thinks Out Loud Episode 417) appeared first on Tim Peter & Associates.

                    21 min
                  • Revisiting Is It Time for Your Marketing Team to Use AI? (Thinks Out Loud)

                    As noted in the past, with all the hype and hope attached to artificial intelligence, it’s worth asking, is it time for your marketing team — is it time for many of your teams — to use AI? The simple answer to the question is, “yes.” As it happens, the more complicated answer is yes, too.

                    Why is it time for your team to use AI? Where are the areas where AI can provide the greatest value to your organization? How can it help you improve your marketing — and your business? And, most importantly, how can you get started? That’s what this episode of the Thinks Out Loud podcast is all about.

                    Want to learn more? Here are the show notes for you.

                    Revisiting Is It Time for Your Marketing Team to Use AI? (Thinks Out Loud) Headlines and Show Notes
                    Show Notes and Links
                    • Gartner says Generative AI is entering the Trough Of Disillusionment | LinkedIn
                    • Gartner Hype Cycle Reviews Digital Technology and Trends
                    • Ethan Mollick on X: "People on this site: AI is going through the Gartner Hype Cycle. AI: Using historical Hype Cycle data from Gartner, itself, only 4.1% of technologies actually fit the growth, decline, plateau pattern described by the Hype Cycle. (Though this is only one approach to the data) https://t.co/5yDu2lUM4P" / X
                    • Is It Time for Your Marketing Team to Use AI? (Thinks Out Loud Episode 405)
                    • Revisiting 2024 Predictions: Putting AI in Marketing to Work (Thinks Out Loud)
                    • AI Makes Human Expertise and Creativity More Vital in Marketing & Communications
                    • Working with AI: Two paths to prompting – by Ethan Mollick
                    • The Best Available Human Standard – by Ethan Mollick
                    • Federal Register :: Copyright Registration Guidance: Works Containing Material Generated by Artificial Intelligence
                    • https://www.adobe.com/content/dam/cc/us/en/products/sensei/sensei-genai/firefly-enterprise/Firefly-Legal-FAQs-Enterprise-Customers-2023-09-13.pdf
                    • Introducing the Microsoft Copilot Copyright Commitment
                    • Revisiting "How to Add an AI to Your Team" (Thinks Out Loud)
                    • AI is not good software. It is pretty good people.
                    • Everyone is above average – by Ethan Mollick
                    • What AI Will Do to Content Marketing (Thinks Out Loud Episode 402)
                    • Building a Human Brand in the Age of AI (Thinks Out Loud Episode 398)
                    • AI Won’t Steal Your Job: Smart People Who Put AI to Work Will (Thinks Out Loud Episode 208)
                    • You might also enjoy this webinar I recently participated in with Miles Partnership that looked at "The Power of Generative AI and ChatGPT: What It Means for Tourism & Hospitality" here:

                      Free Downloads

                      We have some free downloads for you to help you navigate the current situation, which you can find right here:

                      • A Modern Content Marketing Checklist. Want to ensure that each piece of content works for your business? Download our latest checklist to help put your content marketing to work for you.
                      • Digital & E-commerce Maturity Matrix. As a bonus, here’s a PDF that can help you assess your company’s digital maturity. You can use this to better understand where your company excels and where its opportunities lie. And, of course, we’re here to help if you need it. The Digital & E-commerce Maturity Matrix rates your company’s effectiveness — Ad Hoc, Aware, Striving, Driving — in 6 key areas in digital today, including:
                        • Customer Focus
                        • Strategy
                        • Technology
                        • Operations
                        • Culture
                        • Data
                        • Best of Thinks Out Loud

                          You can find our “Best of Thinks Out Loud” playlist on Spotify right here:

                          Subscribe to Thinks Out Loud
                          • Subscribe in iTunes
                          • Subscribe in the Google Play Store
                          • Contact information for the podcast: [email protected]

                            Past Insights from Tim Peter Thinks
                            Technical Details for Thinks Out Loud

                            Recorded using a Shure SM7B Vocal Dynamic Microphone and a Focusrite Scarlett 4i4 (3rd Gen) USB Audio Interface into Logic Pro X for the Mac.

                            Running time: 25m 53s

                            You can subscribe to Thinks Out Loud in iTunes, the Google Play Store, via our dedicated podcast RSS feed (or sign up for our free newsletter). You can also download/listen to the podcast here on Thinks using the player at the top of this page.

                            Transcript: Revisiting Is It Time for Your Marketing Team to Use AI?

                             Hi, everyone, and welcome back to Thinks Out Loud.

                            If you have any experience with deploying technology in your company, you probably are familiar with Gartner’s Hype Cycle, which talks about how technologies get adopted and used within large organizations. And they go through, you know, the period where it first blows up and then it, we get inflated expectations and then we dive into what is known as the trough of disillusionment before people start to become enlightened and actually put the tool to work to improve productivity.

                            And Gartner has been pretty forthcoming that they think that generative AI is entering the trough of disillusionment. We are seeing this all over the place. I talked about this last week in the episode on putting AI to work. The funny thing about the trough of disillusionment, the funny thing about the hype cycle, Is that according to Ethan Mollick at Wharton, only about 4 percent of companies, only 4 percent of technologies actually go through all of the stages of Gartner’s hype cycle.

                            So it’s possible that we’re actually going to see greater benefit from AI over the long term. And that right now, people are just a little uncomfortable with the lack of results. Part of the reason for this is that companies are struggling to figure out how to put AI to work, which is why we talked about that on last week’s episode.

                            But you also cannot generate results if you’re not using AI, and it is well past time for your marketing team, and frankly, many of your other teams, to use AI in practice. very much. And that’s why this is a good opportunity for us to revisit an episode that asked, Is it time for your marketing team to use AI?

                            Spoiler alert, it is, but the episode also explains exactly how you can do that. So sit back, relax, and enjoy this repost of a prior episode.

                            Well, hello again, everybody, and welcome back to Thinks Out Loud, your source for all the digital expertise your business needs. My name is Tim Peter. This is episode 405 of The Big Show, and thank you so much for tuning in. I think we have a really cool show for you today. I want to start with a bit of a headline.

                            So Google shipped, kind of, Gemini, its new AI model, today in three different versions. And when I say kind of, I say kind of because one is already available. You can start using it today within Bard. The other two are either in developer previews, are coming in the new year.

                            And I’ve got to tell you, there’s a great brand story here. I’m going to do a little sidebar here for a second. In their announcement, they did a really cool framing thing. In their introducing Gemini blog post CEO Sundar Pichai said, "nearly eight years into our journey as an AI first company…"

                            And the reason I thought that was really cool. is because they’re trying to reclaim the mantle of the OG AI company. They’re saying, "we’ve been doing this for nearly eight years. We’re not new to this whole idea." And that is an entirely fair claim. When you hear about GPT, like ChatGPT, that stands for "Generative Pre-Trained Transformers."

                            And the original paper about generative pre-trained transformers, GPTs, were written by researchers at Google. So they are, in some ways, the OG AI company, or OG generative AI company, I think is probably fairer to say. So that’s smart of them to kind of say, "look, we’re Google, we’ve been doing this a long time, we’re really good at this." Good, good marketing lesson there.

                            The bad side of the story is that their product messaging is complicated at best. Show of hands, I know you’re listening in your car, but show of hands, how many of you know the difference between Bard, Duet, Gemini Pro, Gemini Nano, and Gemini Ultra? Right, probably not tons of you. Again, show of hands, how many of you are going to do the work to find out?

                            Some of you, for sure, and some of you are just going to wait until it sorts itself out, which is an entirely valid strategy, by the way. Maybe they should have asked their AI to help them streamline their messaging. It’d be easier for people to understand what they do if they were clearer about what these are.

                            And that brings me to the point of today’s episode. We are into a place where, yeah, we’re in the early innings of AI. Yes, there is a lot of change we’re going to see. There’s going to be a lot of development over the course of the next year. At the same time, we’re further along than I think most people realize.

                            There’s new research that came out about a month ago from the conference board that shows that greater than 50 percent of marketing or communications professionals use AI for a variety of things. Drafting content, inspiring thinking. Summarizing Content and Conducting Research. According to the report, marketers and communications professionals, this is a quote, “are becoming editors of machine generated content to improve creative output and ensure accuracy and relevance.”

                            Think about that. The AI is doing the groundwork, is doing the legwork, and then the marketers and communications professionals are overseeing that work, and I want you to tuck that in your back brain, because we’re going to come back to that in just a little bit. Now, in the sum of this data, the report itself calls out that there is small sample sizes because everything I’m about to tell you came from the pool of the 50 percent or more who said they were doing those things.

                            But, of those folks, 82 percent say that it helps them get tasks done faster. Almost 70 percent state that it significantly improved their ability to get started on a new project. Half say that it significantly improved their ability to understand and research new topics faster. And more than 40 percent say it significantly Improved the quality of their content.

                            Those numbers are big enough that I’m willing to give them the benefit of the doubt, even with the small sample sizes. At least among the people using those tools. And one of the reasons is, I’m speaking from my own experience. I completely agree with these findings. Is it possible that it’s just reinforcing my bias?

                            Well, sure, maybe. But I’m genuinely seeing benefits in the same areas as the survey respondents. Faster. Cheaper. Better. That’s happening today. And I’d argue that the 50 percent who aren’t doing these things Might be in a little bit of trouble. I’ve said for some time that AI won’t steal your job, but smart people who use AI will.

                            My advice to you is don’t be in that 50%. That’s a huge, huge risk. You know that I like to say that when you build the ship, shipwreck. It is always a good and wise idea to consider the downsides, and there are downsides to AI. We’re going to talk about those a little bit more in a moment. You’ve heard them, so I’m not going to belabor the point, but I don’t want to put it aside entirely.

                            I do want to talk about one specific problem for a moment, and why you might want to think about that differently. You may have heard of what’s known as the stochastic parrot problem, excuse me, stochastic parrot. And a stochastic parrot is this idea that the AI is simply echoing things it’s already read.

                            It’s not reasoning, it’s not generating new ideas. It is simply telling you something that is in its own training data. It’s regurgitating something it’s heard before. And there are some obvious risks there. Copyright or trademark infringement, contextual errors, where the thing that it read isn’t actually accurate in this specific context.

                            And I share those concerns. There’s also the downside to assuming that the risks of the shipwreck outweighs the value of the ship. The economist Brad DeLong had a great line the other day, where he said, we, human beings, are often stochastic parrots. How often is it that we’re simply echoing back something that we’ve known from the past?

                            I mean, think about it. In your day to day lives, how often do you think deeply about every single situation you encounter? I’m not trying to malign you, by the way. I’m as guilty of this as anyone. There are plenty of times when, confronted with a specific challenge, I fall back on what’s worked in the past.

                            I’m regurgitating responses based on my past experiences. That’s what past experiences are for, right? That’s why we want to build experience. You know, the old joke that says experience is that thing you can’t have until after you need it. That’s why we build those, the experience that we build. I also, personally, legitimately place a focused block of time on my calendar each week just for thinking time.

                            And I usually do about a day every couple of months where I do nothing but focus on new ideas. Because I want to make sure I’m not just going through the motion day after day, because on a lot of days I am, I’m being a stochastic parrot. I’m parrot, I’m drawing on my experience to accomplish a task or solve for a problem.

                            So it’s not that there’s no risk there, it’s that the risk from the AI may not be that much larger than what we deal with in our day to day already. The other thing we wanna realize is that the benefits from these use ca in some cases. Can be huge. I had a conversation the other day with a company that makes custom video.

                            They go out and they get sponsors to sponsor the creation of video that is then distributed via television networks, cable channels, as well as on the internet. And they’ve gone to the marketplace in less than six months. They’ve gone from not existing to being in over 107 million households plus online streaming.

                            And I asked the question about, well, what would this have cost you to do if you didn’t have AI? How much would it have, you know, would it have taken to do? And he said, I don’t think it would have been doable. They’re, they’re creating all kinds of content, they’re using AI to do this in a way that is more economical, which then makes it more valuable to the sponsors, which then allows them to go ahead and get the thing made in the first place.

                            As he said, AI is my right hand man. AI didn’t make this cheaper or more efficient. I mean, it did, but it didn’t make it something where they cut costs dramatically of something they were already doing. It made a thing that they weren’t doing. Doable. That’s massive. It couldn’t have been done any other way economically and actually been able to bring it to the market.

                            And there’s a huge downside that you could be left behind. Again, going back to the conference board research, mid level and junior marketers and communicators. are at the forefront of adopting AI in their work, and increasingly so. It’s positioning them as the leaders within their organization in terms of how you use AI.

                            Again, these are small sample sizes. But a 20 point increase in usage over the last 3 months among mid level and junior marketers, and a 9 point increase among communications professionals, suggests that they’re outpacing their elders, they’re outpacing other people by a lot. In June, they were at roughly equal levels with senior professionals in the two disciplines.

                            Now they are way ahead. Their productivity is way up. I make this joke all the time about the fact that, you know, I can’t outrun Usain Bolt. But put me in a Toyota and I’m going to kick his ass. Right? That’s huge. By the way, this has been proved in other categories. Ethan Mollick, a researcher and associate professor at Penn, at the Wharton School, has said they had a paper where consultants at Boston Consulting Group improved the quality of their work by 40%.

                            And he noted in a recent blog post that there’s a key point people are missing in that data. The consultants, this is a quote, “were not given some special version of AI trained on proprietary data and with a customized interface. They were just given GPT-4 with minimal training and examples.”

                            Boom. That’s crazy.

                            Now, the conference board data does show that the quality and creativity benefit does remain uncertain. It’s not necessarily as predictable, I suspect, based on my own experience rather than any huge data set. That one of the reasons that the BCG folks saw such a big improvement and that so many marketers don’t yet is that these folks were already experts.

                            They’re using it to leverage their expertise, to boost their expertise, and when they see errors, they can just go in and fix them. If you’re a junior level marketer or junior level communications professional, with no disrespect, you may not yet have enough of a feel for what constitutes good quality to be able to tell the difference.

                            Or consistently tell the difference. So you may be, you may do more rework because you want to make sure it meets the standards that you need to meet that you’re not necessarily as comfortable with. Now, I like to quote William Gibson, the author, All the time, who said the future is already here, it’s not, it’s just not evenly distributed.

                            And that’s the thing I want to leave you with today. We’re already in the future. You’ve heard me say more than once on this show how I’m a fan of the principle of who, not how, when you’re faced with a new challenge or a new task. Don’t ask how I can do it, ask who can help me do it. And AI is, at least for the first pass of many things, the new, “ooh, we can leverage a decent expert at any time.”

                            Another Ethan Mollick insight is what he refers to as the best available human standard. AI can help us with “creativity, collaboration, and co intelligence.” It enables us to say, how do we get better at something that either we don’t know how to do, or we do know how to do, but we don’t know where to begin.

                            And that latter one is where you really ought to be focusing for now, because it will help you overcome the errors. You already know the answer. It’s just helping you get there quicker and you’ll know whether or not it’s doing a good job.

                            There’s a framework I really like from Salesforce that talks about enablers versus differentiators in terms of the work you use AI to do.

                            Enablers are table stakes. They make you more effective and efficient, but they probably aren’t transformative. We’re there today. That already works with AI. Differentiators make you more desirable. They drive transformative growth. We may not fully be there yet, though this producer I was talking to about the television show, maybe is getting close.

                            And the great thing about this is there are lots of really credible options for which to choose. With Google, we’ve got Bard, we’ve got, now that the now has Gemini underneath it. We’ve got Duet AI within Workspace. Microsoft has launched its Copilot programs in lots of its tools, Word and Excel and PowerPoint and Outlook and the like.

                            Facebook has a whole series of task built AI tools versus general purpose tools under their LLaMA framework. Amazon just launched something called Q the other day. OpenAI obviously has ChatGPT and DALI. Anthropic has Claude. Adobe has Sensei and Firefly. And Salesforce has Einstein. Notice who the players are here, by the way.

                            With the exception of OpenAI and Anthropic, they’re all folks we’ve talked about for years. They’re Big Tech, the AGFAM, plus Adobe and the Salesforce. This isn’t some day. This isn’t something coming down the road. This is already here. The future is already here. And the great thing is people like Microsoft and people like Salesforce.

                            have basically said that they’re going to help eliminate some of the risk in terms of copyright or legal because they’re going to assure certain quality of outputs in some context. By the way, I’m going to put a link to those in the show notes. As you’ve heard me say many times, I’m not a lawyer, so you’re going to want to check that it helps you specifically.

                            Obviously, there are risks you need to be concerned about, whether they are legal, whether they are quality of data, whether there’s privacy, things that you absolutely should be concerned about. Making sure the quality of outputs match what you want, and that they’re not going to expose you to reputational harms or reputational risk.

                            I still believe the best people to use AI are those who are the most skilled. You’re outsourcing the work that you do to a junior team member. I’ve talked about this in a past episode on how to hire an AI for your team. But just like any junior team member, they require supervision. The challenge here is their errors aren’t always obvious.

                            So that’s where the oversight and the expertise come into play. But, you don’t have to use some fly by night or some random thing you’ve never heard of. You can work with the biggest players in tech and have some assurance that at least most of the time the results are going to be what you expect.

                            Where do you get started? I mean, how do you begin with this? I would encourage you to, at minimum, start playing with Bing and use it in its creative mode. Because then you’ll be using GPT 4 under the hood. And you don’t need to pay for an account or anything along those lines, it will get you started pretty quickly and pretty readily.

                            If you can, go ahead and break out the credit card and sign up for OpenAI’s paid version of GPT-4, of ChatGPT. Because you’ll get an even better experience and the like, and it’s not super expensive, it’s like 20 bucks a month or something along those lines. But, you want to get started, because we want to start thinking about who, not how.

                            We want to remember that the future is already here, it’s just not evenly distributed. We want to remember that your competitors are already using this, especially the junior folks on their teams. They’ve already gotten started with this. And just like you’re not going to outrun Usain Bolt, you’re not going to outrun these folks in their Toyotas either.

                            So as we begin to wrap up to the end of the year here, the key point is it’s not too late to get started. The key point is there are core tools that exist right now from credible players that will allow you to get started. The key point is that you can do this. And the key point is, you need to do this. Especially if you don’t want to get left in the dust.

                            Show Wrap-Up and Credits

                            Now looking at the clock on the wall, we are out of time for this week. I want to remind you again that you can find the show notes for this episode, as well as an archive of all past episodes, by going to timpeter.com/podcast. Again, that’s timpeter.com/podcast. Just look for episode 405.

                            Subscribe to Thinks Out Loud

                            Don’t forget that you can click on the subscribe link in any of the episodes you find to have Thinks Out Loud delivered to your favorite podcatcher every single week.

                            You can also find Thinks Out Loud on Google Podcasts, Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Anywhere fine podcasts are found.

                            Leave a Rating or Review for Thinks Out Loud

                            I would also very much appreciate it if you could provide a positive rating or review for the show whenever you use one of those services. If you like what you hear on Thinks Out Loud, if you enjoy what we talk about, if you like being part of our community, please, give us a positive rating or review.

                            Reviews help other listeners find the podcast. Reviews help other listeners understand what Thinks Out Loud is all about. They help to build our community and they mean the world to me personally. So thank you so much for doing that. I very much appreciate it.

                            Thinks Out Loud on Social Media

                            You can also find Thinks Out Loud on LinkedIn by going to linkedin.com/tim-peter-and-associates-llc. You can find me on Twitter or X or whatever you want to call it this week by using the Twitter handle @tcpeter. And of course, you can email me by sending an email to podcast(at)timpeter.com. Again, that’s podcast(at)timpeter.com.

                            Show Outro

                            Finally, and I know I say this a lot, I say this pretty much every week, I am just so thrilled that you keep listening to what we do here every week.

                            It means the world to me. You are the reason we do this. You’re the reason we make this happen. So please keep your messages coming on Twitter, on LinkedIn, on email. I love getting a chance to talk with you, to hear what’s going on in your world and to learn how we can do a better job building the types of content and insights and information and community that works for you and works for your business.

                            So with all that said, I hope you have a fantastic day. I hope you have a wonderful weekend, and I will look forward to speaking with you here on Thinks Out Loud next time. Until then, please be well, be safe, and as ever, take care, everybody.

                            The post Revisiting Is It Time for Your Marketing Team to Use AI? (Thinks Out Loud) appeared first on Tim Peter & Associates.

                            26 min
                          • Revisiting 2024 Predictions: Putting AI in Marketing to Work (Thinks Out Loud)

                            The Information reports that Amazon and Google are quietly tamp ing down generative AI expectations, noting that it’s tough to make the case for AI benefits “because of the high cost of the software and the difficulty of measuring productivity gains.” That echoes the comments I’d made in this “Best of Thinks Out Loud” episode that “We’re past the point of AI pilots in marketing. Instead, in 2024, it’s time to put AI to work in your marketing.”

                            Why is this reality important for your brand and your business? What does putting AI to work in your marketing mean? And, most importantly, how can you get started? That’s what this episode of the Thinks Out Loud podcast is all about.

                            Want to learn more? Here are the show notes for you.

                            Revisiting 2024 Predictions: Putting AI in Marketing to Work (Thinks Out Loud) Headlines and Show Notes
                            Show Notes and Links
                            • Amazon, Google Quietly Tamp Down Generative AI Expectations — The Information
                            • Google Lacks Vision: Big Tech Earnings and the State of Digital Q1 2024 (Thinks Out Loud Episode 412)
                            • No One is Talking About the Most Important Lessons from Google’s Gemini Launch Kerfuffle (Thinks Out Loud Episode 415)
                            • Picks, Shovels, and the AI Gold Rush (Thinks Out Loud Episode 414)
                            • Usain Bolt – Wikipedia
                            • IMF chief says AI could disrupt nearly 40% of global employment ahead of Davos | CNN Business
                            • AI Will Transform the Global Economy. Let’s Make Sure It Benefits Humanity.
                            • Executives say they’re not ready for AI
                            • Is Google Doomed? And Other Top Digital Trends for 2024 (Thinks Out Loud Episode 408)
                            • Is It Time for Your Marketing Team to Use AI? (Thinks Out Loud Episode 405)
                            • Building a Human Brand in the Age of AI (Thinks Out Loud Episode 398)
                            • Rethinking Search Marketing in the Age of AI (Thinks Out Loud Episode 397)
                            • Anticipating Radical Shifts in Consumer Behavior from AI Adoption: A Look into the Future (Thinks Out Loud Episode 396)
                            • Your AI-powered Copilot for the Web | Microsoft Bing
                            • Copilot Pro Plan & Pricing – Latest AI Models, Chat Tool & Assistant | Microsoft Store
                            • You might also enjoy this webinar I recently participated in with Miles Partnership that looked at "The Power of Generative AI and ChatGPT: What It Means for Tourism & Hospitality" here:

                              Free Downloads

                              We have some free downloads for you to help you navigate the current situation, which you can find right here:

                              • A Modern Content Marketing Checklist. Want to ensure that each piece of content works for your business? Download our latest checklist to help put your content marketing to work for you.
                              • Digital & E-commerce Maturity Matrix. As a bonus, here’s a PDF that can help you assess your company’s digital maturity. You can use this to better understand where your company excels and where its opportunities lie. And, of course, we’re here to help if you need it. The Digital & E-commerce Maturity Matrix rates your company’s effectiveness — Ad Hoc, Aware, Striving, Driving — in 6 key areas in digital today, including:
                                • Customer Focus
                                • Strategy
                                • Technology
                                • Operations
                                • Culture
                                • Data
                                • Best of Thinks Out Loud

                                  You can find our “Best of Thinks Out Loud” playlist on Spotify right here:

                                  Subscribe to Thinks Out Loud
                                  • Subscribe in iTunes
                                  • Subscribe in the Google Play Store
                                  • Contact information for the podcast: [email protected]

                                    Past Insights from Tim Peter Thinks
                                    Technical Details for Thinks Out Loud

                                    Recorded using a Shure SM7B Vocal Dynamic Microphone and a Focusrite Scarlett 4i4 (3rd Gen) USB Audio Interface into Logic Pro X for the Mac.

                                    Running time: 23m 43s

                                    You can subscribe to Thinks Out Loud in iTunes, the Google Play Store, via our dedicated podcast RSS feed (or sign up for our free newsletter). You can also download/listen to the podcast here on Thinks using the player at the top of this page.

                                    Transcript: Revisiting 2024 Predictions: Putting AI in Marketing to Work

                                    Tech website The Information Today published an article that said that Amazon and Google are quietly tamping down generative AI expectations. They said that “the analysis of using AI tools is challenging because of the high cost of the software and the difficulty of measuring productivity gains.”

                                    In an episode from earlier this year, I talked about how marketers are regularly asked to do more with less. And that this year, that’s going to be more expected when it comes to AI. And that’s why it’s a good reason to revisit this episode that talked about why one of the big trends in 2024 is putting AI to work for your business. So I hope you’ll enjoy this repost of a prior episode on putting AI and marketing to work, coming at you right now.

                                    Well, hello again, everybody, and welcome back to Thinks Out Loud, your source for all the digital expertise your business needs. My name is Tim Peter, this is episode 409 of The Big Show, and welcome back. I think we’ve got a really cool show for you today. I want to build on the discussion that we were having last week about the big trends that are going to shape 2024.

                                    Just as was the case in 2023, I think that AI will continue to be a big trend. I know that I’m not going out on a big limb suggesting this. What I think is true, though, is we’re entering a space where it’s less about, oh, "are we doing something with AI?" and more about "What is AI doing for us?" In other words, it’s about being accountable for what you’re doing with AI to your business and to your customers.

                                    As I noted last week, marketers are going to be asked to do more with less. They’re going to be asked to be more accountable for the results any time things get a little tougher. And right now, people are concerned that the economy is going to be kind of wacky. It’s important that you’re able to demonstrate value to your organization.

                                    So it can’t just be, "oh, we’re using AI" or "we’re trying AI". It’s got to be, "here’s how we are using AI to accomplish a specific objective." And we’re going to talk about this a lot over the course of the episode.

                                    What I want to do to start though is take a big step back. And maybe recontextualize artificial intelligence for you and how you might want to think about it. And it’s based on some data that’s coming around right now that I’ll get to in just a moment. I use an analogy all the time where I say that I can’t beat Usain Bolt in a foot race. You all know Usain Bolt, the legendary runner who won a gazillion world championships and Olympic medals. You know, there’s no way if he and I line up alongside, even retired, that I win. He’s going to smoke me every time, right? I can’t beat him in a race. But put me in a Toyota, and I’m going to kick his ass. There’s no two ways about it. I’m just going to be faster, by definition.

                                    That’s what AI does for the people on your team. That’s what AI does for you. It gives you a car, or it gives you a horse, or it gives you a tool that you can put to use that even the best in the world may not have access to all the time. That analogy is probably even more accurate than I intended it to be when I first started using it. Because I’m only comparing my driving a car to Usain Bolt’s running. If you put him in a Toyota though, and I think he kicks my ass. I, plain and simple. Because he’s better suited to make the most of the advantages that technology offers him. He’s got more experience running races, he’s certainly going to be better at that. He’s got way faster reaction times. So, you know, you put two people who are unequal in their abilities with the same tech helping them out, and probably the person who’s more capable is going to do better.

                                    So sure, a less capable runner, i. e. me, in a car is going to do better against the best runner. But the best runner in a car, or the best racer anyway in a car, is going to beat the average or mediocre, you know, racer. Because they’re just more skilled. They’re more able to take advantage of their skills and the skills of the technology, or the abilities of the technology, to improve.

                                    Now, I’m not the only one who thinks this, there’s new research from the International Money Fund that suggests AI will "disrupt" almost 40 percent of the jobs around the world. I want to be really clear, you’re going to want to read this research for yourself, because "disrupt" in that sentence is doing a ton of work.

                                    And I think you’re going to see it get misrepresented a lot in headlines and in articles and in blog posts and the like. Pay attention to what that actually said, because it doesn’t say that 40 percent of jobs go away. It doesn’t say that 40 percent of the tasks in every job will go away. It simply says that artificial intelligence will "disrupt" almost 40 percent of the jobs around the world.

                                    And here’s what that means. There’s a key sentence in the post on the IMF’s website that talks about this. This is a quote: "In advanced economies, about 60 percent of jobs may be impacted by AI. Roughly half the exposed jobs may benefit from AI integration, enhancing productivity."

                                    I’m going to read that again because that’s a really critical point. "Roughly half the exposed jobs may benefit from AI integration enhancing productivity." That’s Usain Bolt in a car. You know, the post does worry about artificial intelligence increasing economic inequality, particularly for people in low income and emerging market countries.

                                    It goes on to say, and again, this is a quote, "Many of these countries don’t have the infrastructure or skilled workforces to harness the benefits of AI, raising the risk that over time the technology could worsen inequality among nations." I think that’s important research to be aware of. And I want to be very clear, I’m not an economist. I’m not a world leader. Instead, I think about how these sorts of things apply to the business world. As it happens, so does the IMF. They note, and again, this is a quote, "AI could affect income and wealth inequality within countries. We may see polarization within income brackets, with workers who can harness AI seeing an increase in their productivity and wages, and those who cannot falling behind."

                                    It goes on to say that "research shows that AI can help less experienced workers enhance their productivity more quickly. Younger workers may find it easier to exploit opportunities, while older workers could struggle to adapt."

                                    Now again, note what they’re saying here. AI can make poor performers more productive more quickly. But the long term benefits are going to be to those who actually put the tool to work most effectively. And that’s really what I want to talk about today. It’s really the point that I want you to be aware.

                                    Everybody, every company is using AI to some degree. Not everybody at every company, but every company has somebody who’s trying to put AI to work for either the business at large or themselves personally. That’s a fact.

                                    And you’re not going to succeed by ignoring that reality. If you want to be able to win the race in the long term, you have to be running it the same way that the people you’re running against are. You have to be using the same advantages that they are. If everybody else is in a car and you’re running on foot, I don’t care how fast you are, eventually you’re going to lose, so you’ve got to get in the car at some point.

                                    I’d argue that that point is today.

                                    I’m also convinced that the companies who execute will do better than the ones who simply acquire the most tools. Buying the car doesn’t do you any good if you don’t actually drive it in the right direction. Execution matters. I’m going to ask you a question. Do you really think that the company or the team or the individual that wins is going to be the one that buys the best tool?

                                    Of course not.

                                    It’s the company or the team or the person who puts those tools to work who win. It’s the ones who take care of their customers, who put those tools to work to improve customer acquisition, customer experience, customer retention. The ones that make their teams and the individuals on those teams more effective and more efficient. The ones that give their teams the right tools that integrate AI into their marketing and sales activities, all of their operations, who will do better than those who just buy a car. Ideally, if you can pair Usain Bolt’s on your team with Toyota’s and Ferrari’s, you’re going to win a lot more races than if you’re just trying to run the way you do today.

                                    Another thing that I want to encourage you to remember is that we are still somewhat in the relatively early innings of artificial intelligence and how we use it in business and how we use it in marketing and how we use it in sales. No one has all the answers here. I don’t have all the answers by any stretch. This is a complicated topic and it seems like there’s a lot of people still figuring out how they’re going to use this in the longer term. Just like we did when the social came around. Just like we did when mobile came around. Just like we did when the internet came around.

                                    People who I consider much smarter than me on these topics seem to be confused still about where we’re end up because we don’t really know. It’s very hard to predict the future. In some cases, they might even be a little more confused, which strikes me as a sign that I need to keep learning. I need to keep asking better questions.

                                    Somebody asked me the other day, you know, who’s going to win? And honestly, I don’t know. We’re in a bit of a gold rush at the moment, though. And I’m reasonably confident that the big winners during a gold rush tend to be the people selling the picks and shovels. So, you know, Amazon with AWS, and Google with Google Cloud, and Microsoft with Azure, and Adobe, and OpenAI, and Salesforce, and HubSpot. They’re probably going to win at least in the immediate term.

                                    I can’t guarantee somebody isn’t going to come along six months from now, or nine months from now, or a year from now, or two years from now, you know, the proverbial "two kids in a garage," who’ve thought about AI in a completely new way, who might beat them. I don’t know. We can’t know that.

                                    What I do know is we need to keep asking the right questions. Worrying about who’s going to win isn’t necessarily the best question if the answer isn’t you.

                                    The questions that I think you should be asking are the same questions we always come to when it comes to strategy. What won’t change? What should we expect to stay the same?

                                    And I don’t think the answer is "nothing."

                                    I think there are a number of things that are always important regardless of how sophisticated or how impressive a new tool might be or a new set of tools might be. You know, I would start by asking, what are your objectives? What do you want AI or artificial intelligence to do for you, your career, your business, your long term success? What do you need it to do that you’re not already getting somewhere else? How do your investments in artificial intelligence benefit your customers?

                                    We always want to keep our customers top of mind. The first job of business is to create a customer. How will your investments in artificial intelligence benefit your top line and your bottom line? You know, are you doing this to grow revenues? Are you doing this to control costs? Are you doing it to do both? And as you think about those — your objectives, the benefits to your customers, the benefits to your top line, the benefits to your bottom line — you also want to say, “Cool, what are the next steps? What’s the next thing that I should be doing?"

                                    Well, there are four areas that I think I would look at as the next steps.

                                    First, take a look at your existing tool set. Most of them are incorporating AI in some way, shape, or form. If you’re using, if you’re like most companies, you’re using a number of different tools to help with your sales, to help with your marketing, to help with your customer experience, and your customer service, what AI capabilities are they adding to those tools right now?

                                    And how can you better deploy them to improve? Some part of what you’re doing. Do you know how to put those tools to work for your business? Do you know how to use those in a way that benefit your customers? Because that’s a place I would look. You can start using AI right now with the things you already pay for.

                                    Think about how those tools affect your planning, how they affect your product development, or your pricing, or your distribution of your products. Think in terms of how they can help you with content creation, or content distribution, or controlling your marketing spend, or improving your customer service, or driving better analytics around any or all of those.

                                    Those are all opportunities that exist today, probably with tools that you already have in place. You don’t need to spend any more money, you don’t need to buy something new, you don’t need to implement something that you don’t have. Work with what you’ve got and see how it can be put to better use.

                                    Another thing that you’re going to want to do is get yourself an account on OpenAI or use Microsoft Copilot on Bing and start using ChatGPT. Microsoft literally just announced some new products today, the day I’m recording this. So I haven’t had a chance to explore them in all the detail. It seems like they are getting better, but also you have to pay for them, whereas Bing Copilot or Microsoft Copilot on Bing Search used to be free, so you may be better served paying for OpenAI, but pick one or the other and start using it every single day.

                                    Make sure your team does too. There was an article on Axios the other day that said if you’re going to look at this as some side initiative, a department of generative AI that’s going to come up with the use cases, it’s going to be a massive failure. That was Deloitte’s global CEO, Joe Okazaglo. I’m pretty sure I butchered his name, and I’m sorry, Joe, if you’re listening to this.

                                    But, you know, if you’re doing this as a side project, it probably isn’t going to work. He went on to say, you need an ecosystem mindset. That’s really important. People should be using this in their work today. Yes, you need to put the right guardrails in place. Yes, you need to have the right governance. Yes, you need to have the right structures.

                                    I don’t want to downplay that. I also want to say that you’re giving your team the tools to work with it so that they can actually get familiar with it. Remember, the teams that put these to use are going to be the most effective. The ones that integrate AI into their workday are going to be most effective.

                                    With regard to that, in terms of don’t just have a side initiative, don’t just launch a pilot. I heard one person recently say that "when it comes to AI, they have more pilots than Delta, right?" You want to use these tools to solve an actual problem. Where is an area where you’re not getting what you need out of your existing tool set or out of your existing solutions or out of your existing processes?

                                    Can you use AI to solve that? Give it a shot and take a look and see what you get out of it. And then the last thing, and I know I say this a lot, but you’ve got to keep learning. We’re in the early innings today, still, but it’s also time to get in the game. AI will definitely pass you by if you let it. So don’t let it.

                                    Don’t let yourself lose the race without ever, ever getting off the starting line. You can’t beat Usain Bolt in a race if you stand still. The reality is the future of AI is going to be decided by the people who put it to work to improve their customer experience. It’s going to be decided by the people who put it to work to acquire more customers, to make those customers happy, and to grow their business.

                                    I’m confident you can win this race. But it requires that you get in the car. So go ahead, hop in the car, and let me know how you’re making out. Because I can’t wait to see how far you run.

                                    Next Week’s Show: Interview with Scott Cohen of Inbox Army

                                    Now, since a lot of this episode has been talking about execution, I definitely want to let you know that we’re going to spend more time focusing on execution this year, including next week when we’re going to have an interview with Scott Cohen from Inbox Army, who’s going to talk about how you can improve your email marketing. That’s particularly important when AI might be the thing that is both reading and writing the emails that your customers receive. So I would encourage you to tune in for that. That’s going to be episode 410 of the podcast, and that’ll be out next week.

                                    Show Wrap-Up and Credits

                                    Of course, looking at the clock on the wall, we are out of time for this week.

                                    And I want to remind you again that you can find the show notes for this episode. As well as an archive of all past episodes by going to timpeter.com/podcast. Again, that’s timpeter.com/podcast. Just look for episode 409.

                                    Subscribe to Thinks Out Loud

                                    Don’t forget that you can click on the subscribe link in any of the episodes that you find there to have Thinks Out Loud delivered to your favorite podcatcher every single week. You can also find Thinks Out Loud on Google Podcasts, Apple Podcasts, Spotify, anywhere fine podcasts are found.

                                    Leave a Rating or Review for Thinks Out Loud

                                    I would also very much appreciate it if you could provide a positive rating or review for the show whenever you use one of those services.

                                    If you like what you hear on Thinks Out Loud, if you enjoy what we talk about, if you like being part of the community that we’re building here, please give us a positive rating or review. Reviews help other listeners find the podcast. Reviews help other listeners understand what Thinks Out Loud is all about. They help to build our community and they mean the world to me. So thank you so much for doing that. I very, very much appreciate it.

                                    Thinks Out Loud on Social Media

                                    You can also find Thinks Out Loud on LinkedIn by going to linkedin.com/tim-peter-and-associates-llc. You can find me on Twitter or X or whatever you want to call it this week by using the Twitter handle @tcpeter. And of course, you can email me by sending an email to podcast(at)timpeter.com. Again, that’s podcast(at)timpeter.com.

                                    Show Outro

                                    Finally, and I know I say this a lot, I want you to know how thrilled I am that you keep listening to what we do every single week. It means so much to me. You’re the reason we do this.

                                    You’re the reason we make Thinks Out Loud happen. So please keep your messages coming on Twitter, on LinkedIn, on email. I love getting a chance to talk with you, to hear what’s going on in your world, and to learn how we can do a better job building the types of content and community and insights and information that work for you and work for your business.

                                    So with all that said, I hope you have a fantastic rest of your day, I hope you have a wonderful week ahead, and I will look forward to speaking with you here on Thinks Out Loud next time. Until then, please be well, be safe, and as ever, take care, everybody.

                                    The post Revisiting 2024 Predictions: Putting AI in Marketing to Work (Thinks Out Loud) appeared first on Tim Peter & Associates.

                                    24 min
                                  • CEO Howard Chang on Artificial Intelligence, the Future of Work, and Being a Better Human (Thinks Out Loud Episode 416)

                                    In our latest Thinks Out Loud interview, company founder and president Tim Peter sat down to talk with Howard Chang, CEO of The Turn Lab and CEO of Just Boardrooms. In this thoughtful and insightful discussion, Howard and Tim discussed:

                                    • Artificial Intelligence and its effects on the future of work
                                    • Remote work, loneliness, and the need for belonging
                                    • Managing anxiety in a rapidly changing, often remote workplace
                                    • Increasing productivity
                                    • Improving business as a force for social good
                                    • And how Howard’s personal health journey has helped him grow as a leader
                                    • We think you’ll enjoy this deeply engaging conversation. Here are the show notes for you.

                                      CEO Howard Chang on Artificial Intelligence, the Future of Work, and Being a Better Human (Thinks Out Loud Episode 416) Headlines and Show Notes
                                      Show Notes and Links
                                      • Howard Chang | LinkedIn
                                      • Just Boardrooms | Meeting Venues for rent | Conference Rooms
                                      • The Turn Lab – The Turn Lab– Howard Chang (@adcycle) / X
                                      • Hybrid Work Is Just Work. Are We Doing It Wrong?
                                      • The No. 1 workplace distraction that kills productivity, according to Microsoft
                                      • Work Trend Index: Microsoft’s latest research on the ways we work.
                                      • Watch Live to 100: Secrets of the Blue Zones | Netflix Official Site
                                      • Belonging to the Brand: Why Community is the Last Great Marketing Strategy by Mark Schaefer (affiliate link)
                                      • B Lab Global Site
                                      • Stephen Bebis | LinkedIn
                                      • Your Employees — and Customers — Live in a Different World Now (Thinks Out Loud Episode 362)
                                      • Why Would Anyone Want to Work For You? (Thinks Out Loud Episode 337)
                                      • REMOTE WORK | The Conference Board
                                      • You might also enjoy this webinar I recently participated in with Miles Partnership that looked at "The Power of Generative AI and ChatGPT: What It Means for Tourism & Hospitality" here:

                                        Free Downloads

                                        We have some free downloads for you to help you navigate the current situation, which you can find right here:

                                        • A Modern Content Marketing Checklist. Want to ensure that each piece of content works for your business? Download our latest checklist to help put your content marketing to work for you.
                                        • Digital & E-commerce Maturity Matrix. As a bonus, here’s a PDF that can help you assess your company’s digital maturity. You can use this to better understand where your company excels and where its opportunities lie. And, of course, we’re here to help if you need it. The Digital & E-commerce Maturity Matrix rates your company’s effectiveness — Ad Hoc, Aware, Striving, Driving — in 6 key areas in digital today, including:
                                          • Customer Focus
                                          • Strategy
                                          • Technology
                                          • Operations
                                          • Culture
                                          • Data
                                          • Best of Thinks Out Loud

                                            You can find our “Best of Thinks Out Loud” playlist on Spotify right here:

                                            Subscribe to Thinks Out Loud
                                            • Subscribe in iTunes
                                            • Subscribe in the Google Play Store
                                            • Contact information for the podcast: [email protected]

                                              Past Insights from Tim Peter Thinks
                                              Technical Details for Thinks Out Loud

                                              Recorded using a Shure SM7B Vocal Dynamic Microphone and a Focusrite Scarlett 4i4 (3rd Gen) USB Audio Interface into Logic Pro X for the Mac.

                                              Running time: 39m 53s

                                              You can subscribe to Thinks Out Loud in iTunes, the Google Play Store, via our dedicated podcast RSS feed (or sign up for our free newsletter). You can also download/listen to the podcast here on Thinks using the player at the top of this page.

                                              Transcript: Howard Chang on Artificial Intelligence, the Future of Work and Being a Better Human

                                              Tim Peter (00:02.146)

                                              Howard Chang, welcome to the show.

                                              Howard Chang (00:04.479)

                                              Hey, Tim. Thanks for having me.

                                              Tim Peter (00:06.966)

                                              Thanks so much for being here. You’ve got.

                                              Just an incredible background. You’ve done an enormous amount of things. I mean, I’m just reading off the list here. Retail, product design, sports marketing, film and stills production, commercial real estate, advertising, and digital technology. You’re currently the founder and chairman of the TurnLab and CEO and founder of Just Boardrooms. So you’ve done a lot over the course of your career. You’ve got a broad background in how digital has sort of affected the workplace, how AI is affecting the workplace,

                                              workplace and ultimately how that affects the people in the workplace. So, you know, just to open it up with a big question, we’re talking a lot about hybrid work. We’re talking about a lot about the future of work. We’re talking a lot about how AI might affect work. What’s going on? You know, what are we seeing that, you know, interests you and you find particularly exciting? I told you we were going to dive right in, right?

                                              Howard Chang (01:01.035)

                                              You didn’t start with a softball question, Tim. So I love it. I love it. Yeah, I mean, you hear the term the future of work. And I think everyone sort of has an interpretation what that might mean for their organization. So whether you’re working for a company or leading a company, there’s probably more questions than answers at the moment.

                                              We do a lot of consulting to C-suite leaders and we talk to them a lot around company culture, morale, productivity, innovation. And there is a general agreement right now that no one’s really got it quite figured out in terms of how are we actually maximizing our people’s productivity? How are we maximizing their ability to collaborate and bring value to a company to help product service development, etc.

                                              Howard Chang (01:52.033)

                                              where sometimes they’re working remotely through a pinhole called Zoom or Teams, which is very difficult to build morale and culture. So many pieces of the puzzle and of course AI fits into all of this, right? Because if you think about AI strictly as a productivity tool, how it’s used, if it’s used, can dramatically impact

                                              Tim Peter (01:58.058)

                                              Yeah, sure.

                                              Howard Chang (02:12.783)

                                              how an individual performs and how a company performs and if it’s used badly or not used at all, some companies might be left behind and so there’s all of that kind of going on right now. So we’re spending a lot of time in the learning phase. There are some published articles now by Harvard Business Review, Forbes, etc. They’re all kind of weighing in but no one really is the expert in the space because it’s happening in real time.

                                              Tim Peter (02:36.018)

                                              Absolutely. Oh, for sure. So one of my favorite quotes, there’s this French philosopher, people who’ve heard the show before have heard me say this before, but I’m not a big reader of French philosophers, but somehow I ran across this quote that when you build the ship, you build the shipwreck. And, you know, the point being that ideally the value of the ship outweighs the negatives of the shipwreck, but we also have to acknowledge that there are those risks and we have to think around

                                              the positives of remote work. There’s a lot of talk about people working remotely and everything. What are some of the downsides? What are some things people need to be concerned about or thinking about there?

                                              Howard Chang (03:16.735)

                                              Well, so to give you an idea, you know, our company, the Tern Lab, has about 50 people, all knowledge workers. We work hybrid, you know, we’re in the office a couple of days a week and we’re remote most of the days a week. So we’ve done our own surveys and workshopping around what’s the best model. But I also think that there’s larger studies afoot right now, like Microsoft published a study I think about 18 months ago that looked at tens of thousands of workers across their

                                              Tim Peter (03:24.661)

                                              Mm-hmm.

                                              Howard Chang (03:46.849)

                                              offices and they looked at groups that were predominantly in office and groups that were predominantly remote. And they were really doing it initially to measure productivity. Is there a productivity difference? They did notice a productivity difference, but it wasn’t as big as they thought. What actually surprised them was that the in office group

                                              Tim Peter (03:56.386)

                                              Yeah.

                                              Howard Chang (04:06.431)

                                              had much higher rankings in terms of product innovation and product quality. So by coming together in person, they were able to collaborate more, argue more, debate more, challenge each other more, which led to better product design, better product development. So productivity is only just one piece of the puzzle. And there are studies that are showing for some companies, the productivity that can be actually quite large, up to like 30% for some companies, because a lot of new people coming to the workforce,

                                              Tim Peter (04:11.168)

                                              Mm-hmm.

                                              Tim Peter (04:18.528)

                                              Yeah.

                                              Howard Chang (04:35.855)

                                              No one really taught them how to do time management as an example. Right. So, so how do we, how do we close that gap? We’re not going to bring everybody back in the office all the time. So how do we close that gap is the big question people are trying to answer.

                                              Tim Peter (04:37.912)

                                              Right.

                                              Tim Peter (04:47.434)

                                              Yeah, makes sense, makes sense. And I know in some of the discussions we’d had, you know, there have been some mental health issues and the like that some folks are concerned about. You know, maybe you can talk about that a little bit.

                                              Howard Chang (04:57.892)

                                              Yeah, I mean, there’s a mental health issue that’s growing called belonging deficit, right? As people felt isolated during COVID, they weren’t part of physical communities and stuck in that tiny little

                                              channel called social media, you can actually feel more socially isolated because you feel like you’re missing out on everything. So the belonging deficit is a big issue for remote workers, even hybrid workers. But what belonging deficit is also leading to is something called collaboration deficit. So as people are feeling like my work is really starting to get really isolated and I’m starting to feel really alone in my work, that’s also creating mental health issues. Not to mention

                                              Tim Peter (05:18.872)

                                              Yeah, sure, sure.

                                              Howard Chang (05:42.049)

                                              other work. So it’s kind of like a double-edged sword. And here’s the other really dangerous thing that’s happening. With the advancement of AI and the ability for AI to generate content for a lot of knowledge work, the work that we do sitting on our own is going to be more easily replaced by AI than the work we do together as teams. So

                                              Tim Peter (06:05.751)

                                              Oh sure.

                                              Howard Chang (06:06.515)

                                              That natural creativity, innovation, that’s the kind of knowledge work that’s gonna be continued to be led by human beings. The sit at home typing out, oh, I gotta write an article on cryptocurrency, or I’ve gotta create, I have to do some analytics on a research study. AI is gonna do all of that, right? So…

                                              Tim Peter (06:27.63)

                                              Sure, sure.

                                              Howard Chang (06:28.935)

                                              The interesting thing is that there’s also anxiety from people going, ooh, how am I gonna keep my job with all of this coming in? I think the key here is people need to come together in ways that make sense for moments that matter, probably in person, so that they can create amplification and acceleration of what humans are actually good at, which tends to be creativity, innovation, problem solving, something that they currently do much better than AI.

                                              Tim Peter (06:58.606)

                                              That makes so much sense. I mean, some of the things you’re talking about there is belonging deficit. Listeners of the show have heard me talk about a book by a real good friend of mine, Mark Schaefer, called Belonging to the Brand, where he talks about how community is the next great marketing channel and the like. And it sounds like you’re talking about the same thing from a product innovation perspective, from a serendipity perspective, right? The random collisions of people that lead to observations or insights you might not have had before, right?

                                              Howard Chang (07:24.939)

                                              What?

                                              And you might live longer. Like if you watch the Netflix show, The Blue Zone, it’s so interesting how if you look at all the Blue Zone communities that the host studied, almost all of them had one commonality, which was community. So whether that was the seven day Adventists with their community built around their religion, or whether that was the Okinawan grannies that got together every day to cook together, knit together. So quilt, you know, that idea of bringing people together

                                              Tim Peter (07:29.704)

                                              Oh yeah, sure. Yeah.

                                              Howard Chang (07:55.489)

                                              for moments of matter is incredible for not just our mental health but also our physical health and longevity. So there’s a lot of science behind the need to be social animals.

                                              Tim Peter (08:07.046)

                                              Absolutely. So I thought we would get to this later, but this seems like a natural touch point right now. You know, you’ve talked a lot about in your career the force of business for, you know, business is a force for good and the impacts that we make on the world in a positive way as a business, right? If I can invert that quote I said before, let’s talk about the ship maybe a bit and not the shipwreck, you know. Let’s hear some of what you think there.

                                              Howard Chang (08:33.878)

                                              Yeah.

                                              You know, listen, I’m an entrepreneur, right? I started my first business at 20 and I’ve done very well. So, you know, I am not gonna be someone who is a hater of capitalism. I would like to think that I am a, you know, socially conscious, environmentally conscious business leader. So what we’ve done is we’ve actually taken some of these socially conscious, environmentally, you know, ideas, philosophies and put them into practice

                                              by applying for and getting certified as a B Corp, so a benefit corporation. So the B Corp movement, it’s growing, still small, but members include like Patagonia, Ben and Jerry’s. Companies that believe that it’s not all about the shareholders, right? It’s not only about the bottom line. These tend to be kind of like triple bottom line companies and we’re one of them. We’re a certified B Corp, we’ve been since 2018. It’s a rigorous process. There is something on the B Corp website called a quick assessment that you can go

                                              Tim Peter (09:09.456)

                                              Oh yeah, sure.

                                              Howard Chang (09:34.153)

                                              as a company to see how big a gap is it between what you do and what a B Corp subscribes to. So that’s a good starting point. But what I like about the B Corp movement is it kind of quantifies and systematizes the idea of being a good corporate citizen. So it looks at things like worker health inequity. It looks at things like environmentalism, health of the planet, but also looks at things like giving back to the community, supporting underserved communities. So these are things that are all important was when I read the term stakeholders versus shareholders. So, you know, Tim, you’ve talked to enough business people, we always talk about our shareholders, our shareholders, but what.

                                              Tim Peter (10:08.49)

                                              Right, definitely.

                                              Howard Chang (10:15.379)

                                              B Corps are trying to do and what we’re trying to do is actually there’s a larger group of stakeholders involved, right? There’s our customers, there’s our staff, there’s the communities we serve, there’s the environment, biodiversity, they’re all stakeholders. It’d be very hard to run a business if we had no biodiversity as an example. What if all the bees disappear? We are screwed basically, right? So I think it’s really shifting perspective and understanding that if we account more

                                              Tim Peter (10:38.454)

                                              Ha ha ha!

                                              Howard Chang (10:45.513)

                                              we might be able to do good as we do well. And I think that’s a great combo.

                                              Tim Peter (10:51.542)

                                              Well, in what you’re talking about with the mental health situation with employees or things along those lines, the anxiety that they feel around artificial intelligence potentially taking their job or the belonging deficit when they’re working remote and not connecting with other people. That’s not going to make for happy, healthy, functional employees. Those folks are also representative of the people who buy from our companies and the like. And it probably doesn’t make for happy, healthy, functional consumers. So I mean, at the end of the day,

                                              Howard Chang (11:18.804)

                                              Yeah.

                                              Tim Peter (11:20.798)

                                              I’ve thought about this from a very different perspective over the course of my career, and I agree with everything you said, so I don’t want any of this to sound like I’m disagreeing. It’s also, at a worst case scenario, and folks who’ve listened to the show have heard me say this before, if you’re not doing well in your community, you’re not creating an environment where people want to work with you, or want to buy from you, or will need your things. So even if you don’t believe in some of these principles, though I would argue you should,

                                              You would argue you should. It’s also in your best interest to do it because it’s in your best interest to do it. Right?

                                              Howard Chang (11:56.615)

                                              Yeah, I mean, 87% of millennials and Gen Z who apply for a job want to know the values of the company. 87%. So it’s a huge piece around not just corporate culture, but in terms of talent acquisition, talent retention. If you don’t stand for something, people have a hard time connecting their value strictly to a paycheck. And I think people are looking for more than that right now.

                                              Tim Peter (12:19.178)

                                              Yeah, absolutely.

                                              Howard Chang (12:23.695)

                                              Sorry about the fire. I live in the big city so you know fire, sirens, it happens.

                                              Tim Peter (12:23.938)

                                              We’ll let that.

                                              Tim Peter (12:30.18)

                                              No worries, that’s no problem at all. Cool, that’s faded. So just continuing on that, continuing on the discussion. So it sounds like when we talk about things like remote work or when we look at things like the future of work, you know, hybrid isn’t a, in your view, that’s not a fad. That’s a thing that’s going to exist for a long time. People are going to need that balance of

                                              We’re not going fully remote ever. I’m not trying to put words in your mouth. This is more, a friend of mine likes to say, I think I heard what you thought you said, right? So we’re probably not going full remote because of the downsides that exist there. We’re also probably not going back to everybody in the office five days a week, right? Is that right? Or how do you see this playing out?

                                              Howard Chang (13:11.976)

                                              Yeah, I think that’s right and there’s a nuance to that. So one of the things that we’re observing as we’re studying this space is that it’s becoming a little bit more of a hub and spoke model. So people aren’t necessarily wanting to drive from their home in the suburbs all the way downtown to meet with their team for three hours. They’ve done a three hour commute round trip just to get that three hour meeting. And so one of the reasons why we launched our latest startup, JustBoardrooms, which we launched in March, it’s essentially a Airbnb spaces. So we’re just a marketplace, right? So, you know, for instance, Tim, if you had an office, if you had an office and you had a boardroom, you can put your boardroom on and rent it by the hour, by the day to a user. So that’s an example. So we get a lot of usage in our system in the suburbs. So we poll our users and go like, why did you use your boardroom? I said, well, you know what, it was close to work to where me and my client lived. Oh, our team lives on the west end of the

                                              Tim Peter (13:55.21)

                                              Yup.

                                              Howard Chang (14:14.517)

                                              they’re happy to pay 50 bucks an hour or whatever for a boardroom on demand because it actually makes them more productive. They save two hours on the commute, they get more done, and they only use it when they need it. So this hub and spoke type situation is we’re seeing more and more of that. You know as the downtowns are a little bit emptier now than they used to be, what’s happening is work is happening elsewhere.

                                              Tim Peter (14:17.248)

                                              Yup, yup.

                                              Howard Chang (14:38.015)

                                              What I do see is the really smart companies are looking at ways to bring their people together more often and to make it as easy as possible for that to happen because they see the benefit of doing it.

                                              Tim Peter (14:51.342)

                                              Right, right. And I want to come back to that point just for a second, but just as you’re talking about your company a little bit, where are you located? Like, where can people find you?

                                              Howard Chang (15:01.035)

                                              We’re in Toronto, fourth largest city in North America. I know that’s surprising for a lot of Americans, but our clients are all over North America. So what The TurnLab is a marketing technology lab and incubator. So we do traditional marketing, market research, we do planning, we do media campaigns, but we also do a lot of technology. So all our software engineers are in-house, they’re not off-shored in India, they’re here.

                                              Tim Peter (15:04.298)

                                              Yep. Ha ha ha.

                                              Howard Chang (15:30.709)

                                              you know, million dollar enterprise digital commerce sites. We also build apps for startups. So one of the products we developed was Just Boardrooms. So that’s one of our proof products as an example, right? So we’re an incubator and we’ve helped other startups incubate as well. So we are based in Toronto and you can check us out at the https://theturnlab.com. And I definitely suggest you check out our marketplace, Just Boardrooms, it’s justboardrooms.com. You know, the sharing economy is gonna be another big piece of the future of work, right? As we start thinking about reducing friction

                                              as we think about collaboration, there’s gonna be a lot of assets right now, commercial real estate assets, transportation assets that have been all geared towards coming back to the office that aren’t gonna be used for coming back to the office. So the share economy is gonna play a much bigger role in that not just in Canada, you know, we have 55 cities for just boardrooms, most of them are in the States. So the US is really growing quickly and I think that’s something that’s gonna happen for every major and minor market is we’re gonna do things differently.

                                              Tim Peter (16:33.71)

                                              That makes total sense. Well, and what I love about it specifically, first of all, I think it’s a cool product and it gets a cool idea. I also love that you’re putting your money where your mouth is, right? You’re talking about all of this in terms of, these are the trends we see happening. You build digital experiences, you build commerce experiences. Hey, let’s put these two things together and actually show this in practice, right? Ha ha ha.

                                              Howard Chang (16:52.359)

                                              Yeah, I love burning my own money. Like, like, it’s like a dumpster fire in the back of my office. Like, let’s just throw more money out of startup because I just I’m a glutton for punishment. But you know what the good news is, it’s growing quickly. So, you know, we were at 250 locations now where sales are growing in double digits compounded month over month. So it’s all good. But the truth of the matter is I’ve been a startup guy since I was 20 years old. I, I played a lot of risks as we do it, an appetite for risk if you’re going to do a startup.

                                              Tim Peter (17:24.466)

                                              Absolutely and we’ll give you a chance to say this again at the end but just for folks who’ve heard this bit, you know, it’s…

                                              Howard Chang (17:32.491)

                                              https://theturnlab.com and justboardrooms.com.

                                              Tim Peter (17:45.25)

                                              So, you know, one of the things that I find particularly fascinating about your story is that, you know, you just said you have to have an appetite for risk as an entrepreneur. You obviously, you like to burden your own money doing this, right? You like to have fun doing this and finding new challenges and all. But you’ve gone through a personal challenge. Like, you’re a recent cancer survivor. You know, can you talk about that a little bit?

                                              Howard Chang (18:08.011)

                                              That’s right.

                                              Absolutely. In 2017, I was diagnosed with relatively advanced prostate cancer and part of it was because I sat on my hands and, you know, did the usual guy thing and say, well, you know, I’m going to delay dealing with this as long as possible. So my tumor was about two thirds of my prostate. So it was it was a it was relatively advanced. So when I talked to the local urologist, you know, very good urologist at great hospitals here, and we have universal health care, by the way.

                                              Tim Peter (18:29.128)

                                              Oh wow.

                                              Howard Chang (18:39.725)

                                              So it was all free healthcare. So I talked to the best specialists and they gave me a bunch of options. And frankly, I didn’t love the options. So I did my own research. I am a very curious guy and I’m more than capable of doing, you know, using that thing called Google. I’m not sure whether you heard about it. But I ended up finding a clinic in Germany that was doing a very innovative surgery called IRE NanoKnife. And I would say if anyone listening has anybody in their family that is going through localized

                                              Tim Peter (18:41.77)

                                              Yep.

                                              Tim Peter (18:54.37)

                                              Hehehehe

                                              Howard Chang (19:09.645)

                                              other words it has not metastasized, it has localized the prostate, definitely check out something called the VITIS Prostate Clinic in Offenbach Germany. So, they have a procedure called IRE Nanonife that stands for irreversible electroporation. It’s what they call a focal therapy. So instead of cutting you open,

                                              Tim Peter (19:11.455)

                                              Right, sure.

                                              Howard Chang (19:28.331)

                                              cutting around all your nerves and removing your prostate, which leads to a very high level of chance of incontinency, erectile dysfunction. Hopefully I’m not getting too personal here. But the bottom line is there’s a there’s a lot of side effects to traditional radical prostatectomies. So the Nano knife is a whole different system where they basically using MRIs and and and other technology, they isolate the tumor and they basically zap it with high voltage for nanoseconds.

                                              Tim Peter (19:38.122)

                                              That’s okay. I asked the question. It’s okay.

                                              Tim Peter (19:43.054)

                                              Sure.

                                              Sure.

                                              Howard Chang (19:58.285)

                                              a knife. So I had full recovery, they got rid of my tumor. After three weeks I was good as new and I was great for five years. And then two years ago my cancer came back. So I had to deal with that. So they spotted three tumors and what was left of my prostate. You know I’m at that age now where that could absolutely happen.

                                              Tim Peter (20:21.378)

                                              Yep.

                                              Tim Peter (20:25.171)

                                              Absolutely, sure.

                                              Howard Chang (20:26.315)

                                              And so I had to figure out, well, what am I gonna do? Am I going back to Germany, pay for surgery, go through the recovery process again? And I decided to actually talk to a naturopathic oncologist who specializes in alternative cancer treatments. She works with regular oncologists, she works with hospitals, but she does a lot of complementary treatments. There’s something called a high dose vitamin C IV, which is basically an IV, very high dose vitamin C, which has been shown in clinical trials to slow down or even reverse the trend of cancer in breast and prostate cancer.

                                              Tim Peter (20:36.75)

                                              Mm-hmm.

                                              Howard Chang (20:56.269)

                                              So I started doing that, changed my diet and crazy thing Tim, after 18 months of doing this, all my tumors went away. So, this is…

                                              Tim Peter (21:04.15)

                                              Wow.

                                              Howard Chang (21:07.243)

                                              I share this story not because I want to give you the gruesome details in prostate cancer. I want to share with you my core philosophy in life and business which I think drives me as an entrepreneur but what makes our company so successful and powerful. A lot of companies in the knowledge space are focused on selling their solution. We are focused on falling in love with the problem. So

                                              Tim Peter (21:26.667)

                                              Mm-hmm.

                                              Tim Peter (21:30.743)

                                              Mm-hmm.

                                              Howard Chang (21:32.075)

                                              With that philosophy, our job at the TurnLab, for instance, and how I operate personally is I don’t even want to talk solution. In fact, the solution may actually not even be anything I sell. I want to first deeply understand the problem. That’s why we do leverage AI in our company. We do have analysts and strategists and market researchers in our company. Unlike a lot of traditional marketing firms, we invest in that space because having evidence

                                              Tim Peter (21:44.436)

                                              Mm-hmm.

                                              Tim Peter (21:49.638)

                                              Yep.

                                              Howard Chang (22:02.029)

                                              the right strategy to build the right solution has been our path to success. And I think a lot of people forget about that and they get so in love with their solution that they’re just kind of ramming it down people’s throat whether they need it or not. So sorry that was a long-winded very you know convoluted way to get to that point but it came through cancer.

                                              Tim Peter (22:16.179)

                                              Ha ha!

                                              Well, that’s OK. I mean, that’s what podcasts are for, right? That’s for us to have a conversation and kind of work our way around to the thing. It’s really funny you say that. We are very fond of the expression around here that a problem well-defined is half solved, right? Rather than starting with a solution, and how do we try to apply the solution to a range of problems, it is very much understand the problem, understand what the challenge is, and then talk about what can be done to solve it, rather than start with the solution

                                              Howard Chang (22:36.107)

                                              Yes.

                                              Tim Peter (22:53.488)

                                              looking for problems that it might whack a mole, right?

                                              Howard Chang (22:56.843)

                                              Yeah, yeah, yeah, for sure, for sure.

                                              Tim Peter (22:57.874)

                                              Yeah, so it’s interesting to me, you’ve had a couple of, I would say fairly substantial health scares, I don’t think that’s an unfair way to state that, right? And the like, and you also talk about creating these environments where people can work more productively, where people can come together, where they can do better work, how they can contribute to their communities and things along those lines. I’m personally very curious about this.

                                              Howard Chang (23:08.747)

                                              Yeah.

                                              Tim Peter (23:27.728)

                                              You know, is there a relationship there? Were you always in that view? Or did your health challenges kind of lead you in that direction? Or was it sort of just a little bit of both?

                                              Howard Chang (23:36.651)

                                              Yeah, I think that’s a great question. I founded and ran a very successful integrated ad agency for about 20 years. So I started in the 90s and we had great clients. We had Callaway Golf, we had Honda. It was great. It was like 55 people, good kind of mid-sized boutique shop. But in the kind of like mid-20 teens, like 2015, 2016, I really started feeling like

                                              Tim Peter (23:45.634)

                                              Yep.

                                              Howard Chang (24:05.835)

                                              we were becoming more the hands for our clients than thought partners, right? And I thought the idea of an integrated ad agency was becoming a lot more commoditized, right? And what I found interesting is that my clients started to be meeting with companies like PWC and Deloitte and Accenture on their marketing strategy, I thought was really interesting. So the consultancies are starting to occupy the space. So I was thinking about it for a while, I was thinking about how do we deal with it, and I will tell you right now, a move. So what I did is I actually shut down that company to start the TurnLab.

                                              Tim Peter (24:36.941)

                                              Yeah.

                                              Howard Chang (24:42.507)

                                              So I shut down a successful 20 year multimillion dollar agency and started with a handful of intrepid people that were willing to bet on my bet to do this kind of consultancy led marketing technology model. And oh my god Tim we stubbed our toes so many times in the beginning like we didn’t quite get it right. We couldn’t get our proposition right. But after about 18 months to

                                              Tim Peter (24:55.437)

                                              Yep.

                                              Tim Peter (25:04.969)

                                              Sure.

                                              Howard Chang (25:12.461)

                                              people kind of hiring us for the right reasons, not to be their hands, but to be thought partners. And now we’re…

                                              bigger than I ever was as an integrated agency with about 50 staff now, higher revenues. And I think the model’s working. I like to tell people we’re a lab, which means you can break some beakers. That’s what, we stubbed our toes, but just don’t burn down the lab, right? So we wanna do it right, but we’re gonna make mistakes along the way and we’re gonna learn. My background, I’ve been a competitive athlete a lot in my life,

                                              Tim Peter (25:38.91)

                                              Yeah, sure. Right, right. Ha ha ha.

                                              Howard Chang (25:50.285)

                                              athletes and I would say that the most impressive characteristic of any great athlete I’ve ever met is just resilience. You know we’re gonna keep stumbling, we’re gonna keep skinnier knees but are you able and willing to get up and go and keep going? That I think is key to any for any entrepreneur but really for any business leader or someone who’s trying to progress in their profession.

                                              Tim Peter (26:15.114)

                                              Yeah, absolutely. Well, and I mean, I don’t want to trivialize.

                                              You know, your health situation by any stretch. I unfortunately have a, as listeners to the show know, I’ve got a cancer history in my family. So it’s something that I’ve been close to a lot. You know, and I think that there’s a lot to be said there of just getting up every day and dealing with whatever it is, you know, is the difference between folks who are successful, who would deem themselves successful. I mean, forget what society says, but you know, you have gotten to where you wanna get, or things along those lines,

                                              keep trying, right? Even if it knocks you back a little bit, setbacks are temporary. They don’t stop you, right?

                                              Howard Chang (26:56.139)

                                              Yeah, and I think anytime we hit an existential crisis in our lives, it provides clarity, right? So you start thinking, well, I only have X number days. Sometimes we think, oh, our luck goes on forever. But when you have these moments, you go, well, actually, no, I played most of the cards in my deck already. I only have so many left. And so you start thinking, well, how am I going to play them? Those questions come into mind. And so it definitely provides a lot of clarity.

                                              Tim Peter (27:01.952)

                                              Yeah, right, right.

                                              Hehehehe

                                              Yeah, no, that makes perfect sense. And I think very inspiring for people to hear in terms of, if you’re going through a rough time, this will probably pass and all you can do is just put one foot in front of the other and kind of work towards whatever the next objective is, right?

                                              Howard Chang (27:39.307)

                                              for sure and surround yourself with good people, right?

                                              Tim Peter (27:42.322)

                                              Absolutely.

                                              Howard Chang (27:43.595)

                                              I would say, you know, as an entrepreneur who started at 20 and built a multi million dollar business in my 20s, I would say the biggest mistake I made as a young entrepreneur is I thought I was the smartest kid in the room. And so I didn’t look for enough advice from smart people around me. And I would say my success now is I’m really good at identifying smart, aligned, talented people, and put them on the right seats of the bus. I

                                              Tim Peter (28:01.688)

                                              Yeah.

                                              Howard Chang (28:13.549)

                                              anything and I think business is no exception. Even if you’re working for a company, look at the team around you and look at how you can impact making sure you have the right people around you, right? So I think it’s really important to surround yourself with supporters that are aligned and that can amplify, you know, who you are and what you bring to the table.

                                              Tim Peter (28:33.578)

                                              Yeah, yeah, so much.

                                              I told you when we were starting off, I’ve been consulting for a little over a dozen years, and it’s so funny, I always think that one of my great failings was, in jobs that I’d had prior is, you wanna be the smart person in the room, you wanna ask really smart questions. One of the things I love about being a consultant is you’re allowed to ask the dumbest questions in any room, right? You learn so much when you just ask things that you don’t have to look smart. People think, oh, that’s a really interesting question, because I never thought about it that way, when you ask things that sound really

                                              Howard Chang (28:54.539)

                                              Absolutely.

                                              Tim Peter (29:06.2)

                                              dumb at first, right? Please.

                                              Howard Chang (29:07.371)

                                              I’m going to do a shout out to a buddy of mine. His name is Steve. His name is Steven Babis. He is a CEO coach and you can check him out on LinkedIn. He was one of my first major clients and he brought Home Depot into Canada and he launched this incredible big box golf concept called Golf Town. And I worked with him for 12 years helping to helping him build it into a $400 million retail company. And I couldn’t figure him out at first because he’d be the guy in the room

                                              Tim Peter (29:17.003)

                                              Yeah.

                                              Howard Chang (29:37.325)

                                              dumbest questions. And I was like what’s going on with this guy because he’s obviously successful, he’s obviously smart. And then I realized no that’s actually his superpower. He would ask the questions that everybody felt embarrassed to ask and he got to the truth way faster. And so I do think that we let ego get in the way a lot when it comes to how we perform. And I think the ability to ask the obvious or dumb question is actually a bit of a superpower.

                                              Tim Peter (30:06.826)

                                              Yeah, well, and especially, right, if your bonus at the end of the quarter or at the end of the year depends upon it, right? You, it, you, not asking the dumb question, right? You want to look like the smart person in the room because there’s a lot of incentives to look like the smart person in the room. Yeah, for sure. For sure. That’s great. It’s great advice in terms of being willing to ask, surrounding yourself with smart people. I just love the stuff we’re talking, you know, we’re talking about here, Howard. And I know we’re coming near to the time we have together.

                                              Howard Chang (30:17.579)

                                              Right.

                                              Howard Chang (30:21.099)

                                              Right.

                                              Tim Peter (30:36.72)

                                              to put a button on this, you know, you’re talking about how we get people to belong more effectively. You’re talking about how we bring people together more effectively. I love this focus on the triple bottom line and having some larger purpose to actually appeal to the folks who want working with you and the like. If you’re going to attract smart people, it probably makes some sense to focus on things that those smart people might care about beyond just a paycheck, right?

                                              Tim Peter (31:06.74)

                                              the matter. So if people want to learn more about what you do and your companies and the like, where can they go? How can they find you?

                                              Howard Chang (31:15.019)

                                              Yeah, so definitely go to https://theturnlab.com to check us out. You can email me at HowardC(at )theturnlab.com. Happy to field any questions anybody might have. I am still on X, a little reluctantly, but still on X. I’m @adcycle. I’m an avid cyclist and so therefore @adcycle. And also just check me out on LinkedIn. I’m always happy to you know, have a productive conversation around life, work, and what I would call the human condition.

                                              Tim Peter (31:53.678)

                                              I love it. I love it. Howard, before I let you go, there’s one last question I always like to end with. I always like to ask people, you know, is there something I haven’t asked you that I should have? Is there something you’d love a chance to, you know, kind of share with the folks we’re talking to today?

                                              Howard Chang (32:08.811)

                                              Yeah, I think one of the things that keeps me up at night is all the division that’s happening in society right now. So whether that’s political division, religious division, I mean, you look at what’s happening globally right now in Gaza, what’s happening both in Canada and the US in terms of political division and the idea of, you know, dogma fighting dogma, whether you’re a liberal or a conservative. And I do think that there is an opportunity for people to be more empathetic and to lean in and to listen. And, you know, a little a little trick I learned over the years is that when

                                              Tim Peter (32:22.833)

                                              Sure.

                                              Howard Chang (32:42.253)

                                              somebody comes at you with a position that’s completely counter to what you believe in, instead of going right at them and going, that’s BS, what I’ve started doing is you could be right.

                                              and are you open to hear my opinion? So acknowledging them, like the biggest problem right now between let’s say Democrats and Republicans is there’s a general lack of acknowledgement. I think we can all agree that Republicans aren’t all wrong and the Democrats aren’t all wrong. There’s probably some right between both of them. If we could have a little bit more discourse around, you know what, you could be right and I also have a point of view I’d love to share.

                                              Tim Peter (32:58.446)

                                              Sure.

                                              Tim Peter (33:13.716)

                                              Of course.

                                              Howard Chang (33:21.099)

                                              individually if we can do that more, as leaders if we can do that more, I think we just get a lot more out of it.

                                              Tim Peter (33:28.238)

                                              Perfect. Howard Chang, thank you so much for being on the show. I really appreciate it. This has been a delightful conversation. Again, you can find Howard at https://theturnlab.com. Hold on, I’m going to say that again and make sure I got that right. You can find Howard again at https://theturnlab.com and at justboardrooms.com. Again, Howard Chang, thank you so much. Take care of yourself. We’ll talk with you soon.

                                              Howard Chang (33:55.851)

                                              Thanks so much, Tim.

                                              Show Wrap-Up and Credits

                                              Now, looking at the clock on the wall, we are out of time for this week.

                                              And I want to remind you again that you can find the show notes for this episode. As well as an archive of all past episodes by going to timpeter.com/podcast. Again, that’s timpeter.com/podcast. Just look for episode 416.

                                              Subscribe to Thinks Out Loud

                                              Don’t forget that you can click on the subscribe link in any of the episodes that you find there to have Thinks Out Loud delivered to your favorite podcatcher every single week. You can also find Thinks Out Loud on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube Music, anywhere fine podcasts are found.

                                              Leave a Rating or Review for Thinks Out Loud

                                              I would also very much appreciate it if you could provide a positive rating or review for the show whenever you use one of those services.

                                              If you like what you hear on Thinks Out Loud, if you enjoy what we talk about, if you like being part of the community that we’re building here, please give us a positive rating or review.

                                              Reviews help other listeners find the podcast. Reviews help other listeners understand what Thinks Out Loud is all about. They help to build our community and they mean the world to me. So thank you so much for doing that. I very, very much appreciate it.

                                              Thinks Out Loud on Social Media

                                              You can also find Thinks Out Loud on LinkedIn by going to linkedin.com/tim-peter-and-associates-llc. You can find me on Twitter or X or whatever you want to call it this week by using the Twitter handle @tcpeter. And of course, you can email me by sending an email to podcast(at)timpeter.com. Again, that’s podcast(at)timpeter.com.

                                              Show Outro

                                              Finally, and I know I say this a lot, I want you to know how thrilled I am that you keep listening to what we do here. It means so much to me. You are the reason we do this show.

                                              You’re the reason that Thinks Out Loud happens every single week. So please, keep your messages coming on LinkedIn. Keep hitting me up on Twitter, sending things via email. I love getting a chance to talk with you, to hear what’s going on in your world, and to learn how we can do a better job building on the types of content and community and information and insights that work for you and work for your business.

                                              So with all that said, I hope you have a fantastic rest of your day, I hope you have a wonderful week ahead, and I will look forward to speaking with you here on Thinks Out Loud next time. Until then, please be well, be safe, and as always, take care, everybody.

                                              The post CEO Howard Chang on Artificial Intelligence, the Future of Work, and Being a Better Human (Thinks Out Loud Episode 416) appeared first on Tim Peter & Associates.

                                              40 min
                                            • No One is Talking About the Most Important Lessons from Google’s Gemini Launch Kerfuffle (Thinks Out Loud Episode 415)

                                              You’ve probably heard about Google’s messy launch of its Gemini AI product. Commentators with political axes to grind across the spectrum have pounded the search giant for its mistakes, leading CEO Sundar Pichai to call the tool’s responses “completely unacceptable.” As entertaining as it might be for some folks, though, to watch Google get pummeled, there’s a larger story that we seem to be missing. The Gemini debacle highlights serious lessons about artificial intelligence that matter to your business, too.

                                              What are those lessons from Google’s Gemini launch kerfuffle that no one is talking about? Why do they matter for you, your brand, your business, and your career? And how do you make sure you can put those lessons to work? That’s what this episode of the Thinks Out Loud podcast is all about.

                                              Want to learn more? Here are the show notes for you.

                                              No One is Talking About the Most Important Lessons from Google’s Gemini Launch Kerfuffle (Thinks Out Loud Episode 415) Headlines and Show Notes
                                              Show Notes and Links
                                              • Google pauses Gemini’s ability to generate AI images of people after diversity errors – The Verge
                                              • Google CEO Sundar Pichai calls AI tool’s responses ‘completely unacceptable’ | Semafor
                                              • What happened with Gemini image generation
                                              • Google Gemini AI: Black Nazis? A woman pope? Just the start of its AI problem. – Vox
                                              • Why Google’s ‘woke’ AI problem won’t be an easy fix
                                              • Nick Bostrom – Wikipedia
                                              • Instrumental convergence – Wikipedia (Includes “the paperclip problem”)
                                              • Chart: How Much of the Internet Consists of Porn? | Statista
                                              • Gartner Predicts Search Engine Volume Will Drop 25% by 2026, Due to AI Chatbots and Other Virtual Agents
                                              • Google Lacks Vision: Big Tech Earnings and the State of Digital Q1 2024 (Thinks Out Loud Episode 412)
                                              • Teamster – Wikipedia
                                              • 2023 Trucking Statistics | Yuma Truck Driving School
                                              • 1850 Fast Facts – History – U.S. Census Bureau
                                              • AI Could Actually Help Rebuild The Middle Class
                                              • You might also enjoy this webinar I recently participated in with Miles Partnership that looked at "The Power of Generative AI and ChatGPT: What It Means for Tourism & Hospitality" here:

                                                Free Downloads

                                                We have some free downloads for you to help you navigate the current situation, which you can find right here:

                                                • A Modern Content Marketing Checklist. Want to ensure that each piece of content works for your business? Download our latest checklist to help put your content marketing to work for you.
                                                • Digital & E-commerce Maturity Matrix. As a bonus, here’s a PDF that can help you assess your company’s digital maturity. You can use this to better understand where your company excels and where its opportunities lie. And, of course, we’re here to help if you need it. The Digital & E-commerce Maturity Matrix rates your company’s effectiveness — Ad Hoc, Aware, Striving, Driving — in 6 key areas in digital today, including:
                                                  • Customer Focus
                                                  • Strategy
                                                  • Technology
                                                  • Operations
                                                  • Culture
                                                  • Data
                                                  • Best of Thinks Out Loud

                                                    You can find our “Best of Thinks Out Loud” playlist on Spotify right here:

                                                    Subscribe to Thinks Out Loud
                                                    • Subscribe in iTunes
                                                    • Subscribe in the Google Play Store
                                                    • Contact information for the podcast: [email protected]

                                                      Past Insights from Tim Peter Thinks
                                                      Technical Details for Thinks Out Loud

                                                      Recorded using a Shure SM7B Vocal Dynamic Microphone and a Focusrite Scarlett 4i4 (3rd Gen) USB Audio Interface into Logic Pro X for the Mac.

                                                      Running time: 26m 39s

                                                      You can subscribe to Thinks Out Loud in iTunes, the Google Play Store, via our dedicated podcast RSS feed (or sign up for our free newsletter). You can also download/listen to the podcast here on Thinks using the player at the top of this page.

                                                      Transcript: No One is Talking About the Most Important Lessons from Google’s Gemini Launch Kerfuffle

                                                      Well hello again everyone and welcome back to Thinks Out Loud, your source for all the digital expertise your business needs. My name is Tim Peter, this is episode 415 of The Big Show, and thank you so much for tuning in. I very much appreciate it.

                                                      I’m going to talk about something today that I didn’t think I was going to address, but it’s been such a big topic, I feel like it’s important to talk about. And that is Google’s Gemini rollout and the big kerfuffle that has emerged around it because it produced some shockingly bad answers. And I want to be very clear, I am going to stay away from all the culture war arguments that people are making online because I don’t.

                                                      Think that’s the important part of what happened here. So, as a quick recap, just for those of you who are not aware, Google released Gemini Pro 1.5 about a week ago, and it has gone really badly. Gemini produced a series of images, when prompted, that were historically inaccurate in the extreme. So it showed, you know, people prompted it to show the founding fathers of the, of America.

                                                      And it, it was In the interest of being diverse, it was very inaccurate. So it drew pictures of people who were persons of color, or Native Americans, or Asians, or the like, instead of, as you might expect you know, European white males, right? Which, I mean, not great in terms of historical accuracy, obviously, without getting into any of the culture side of this, right?

                                                      It was even more hilariously wrong. When people said, hey, draw me a picture of Nazis, and it did the same thing. And of course, this has led people to say that it is biased, that Google has developed something that is biased against white people. And of course, folks on the other side of the spectrum saying that it’s creating harms by accusing people who weren’t involved in, say, the atrocities of Nazism with being Nazis.

                                                      So, you know, basically, lots of folks online were not happy about this. Again, I don’t think that the way that Google’s Gemini screwed up is all that interesting. Sure, it allows people to fight online, and gosh knows, everybody loves that. But that’s not really what I think is the important story here. And I’m going to explain what I think the important story is in just a moment.

                                                      What I think we can say Is that, yeah, Google screwed up. I’m a big fan of the quote that to err is human, to really screw up requires a committee. Right? This took some doing for Google to get this, you know I also don’t think they’re evil in this case, unlike the folks on either side who seem to be arguing that Google’s biases blinded it to the problem.

                                                      I don’t think that’s what happened here, and I could be wrong. I want to be fair. I could be very wrong about this. I want to also be very upfront. You’ve heard me bash Google many, many, many times. And on this one, I’m going to defend them, but not in the way that I think you expect. In fact, as I’ll talk about a little bit later, they likely spent so much time thinking about some truly evil behaviors, that they missed the more banal biased material that Gemini produced.

                                                      And I think Google’s error is a sign of a bigger problem that almost no one is talking about. And that is that AIs are a black box. Google wanted an AI that overcame traditional biases. And instead, they got one that’s absurdly biased in an entirely different, entirely unpredictable direction. Some of you may have heard people talk about AI’s alignment problem, which is that the machine is going to do things in a way that we don’t think about very often.

                                                      This is most famously postulated by the Swedish philosopher Nick Bostrom in what is known as the paperclip problem. And I’m going to I’m going to read this at length from the Wikipedia article. Bostrom said, Suppose we have an AI whose only goal is to make as many paperclips as possible.

                                                      The AI will realize quickly that it would be much better if there were no humans, because humans might decide to switch it off. Because if humans do so, there would be fewer paperclips. Also, human bodies contain a lot of atoms that could be made into paperclips. The future that the AI would be trying to gear towards would be one in which there were a lot of paperclips, but no humans.

                                                      Right? Okay, grim and dark, but I mean, Swedish philosopher, what do you expect? You know, this is one of those situations where Google said, don’t be biased, and the A. I. said, cool, okay, I’ll just be biased in an entirely different way. That’s going to happen sometimes because A. I. s aren’t predictable in the way that we think they will be.

                                                      From a more practical perspective, imagine if instead of creating something to do image and text generation, Google built an AI to find the most efficient way to fly an airplane, and the AI figured the best way to do that was to turn off the oxygen in the cabin. That’s what the, what Gemini seems to be doing.

                                                      It’s not at all biased in the way you would expect, and instead is biased in a really, really different way that no one predicted. And that’s the part that I think you should be thinking about when we talk about AI, and how you use AI in your business. Think about this for a minute. We know for sure that Google trained its AI to avoid biased and outright racist outputs.

                                                      And I’m going to be very transparent. I don’t think that’s stupid, evil, or negative. In fact, it’s something that every big company does every day. Not just with AI, just in everything they do. And most small ones do the same thing. That’s not even cautious, that’s just plain smart, that’s how you run your business.

                                                      How many messages are put out by every company in the world every day that manage not to offend people? You know, like most of them. That’s pretty normal behavior to say we want to make sure that we’re representing the broadest possible community and we’re doing some a way, you know, we’re doing so in a way that is respectful of our customers and our larger community.

                                                      So yeah, Google didn’t think of testing Gemini to say draw me historically accurate pictures of Nazis or explain whether Elon Musk and Pol Pot are ethically comparable. And the reason they didn’t, I think, is because we know for sure they were thinking of things that are so much worse. And I’m going to apologize right up front here to anyone who’s sensitive about what I’m about to talk about.

                                                      But I was having a conversation the other day with someone who noted that 4 percent of internet sites contain pornographic material. And that depending on whose numbers you go by, 20 percent of all searches are for pornographic material. Without putting guardrails in place, it’s pretty much a given that somewhere between 4 percent and 20 percent of the images an AI is trained on the internet produces would include naked people.

                                                      Some of them doing things that aren’t fit for a mass audience. And that’s just one category of material that no business wants out there with their name attached to it. Now, this is where it gets darker still, and I, again, I apologize in advance, but I’m going to read you a quote from an internal paper at Google that described how Gemini works.

                                                      It was their internal paper where they were announcing Gemini and the project and its status internally. They said,

                                                      "Our model safety policies reflect our established approach towards product safety and preventing harm in consumer and enterprise contexts. Policy areas include generation of child sexual abuse and exploitation content, hate speech, harassment, dangerous content such as guidance on how to make weapons, and malicious content.

                                                      We also aim to reduce bias in our models via guidelines focused on providing content that reflects our global user base."

                                                      That’s the end of the quote. Google cares about this so much that they actually have guidelines for how long human reviewers can look at the materials being output, and the material being input, to make sure that people exposed to that stuff Don’t get exposed to it too much.

                                                      They provide mental health services for the people in these jobs, specifically because they’re exposed to such terrible, terrible things on the internet, that they want to make sure those people are okay. I actually have zero problem with that. There is a lot of awful, awful stuff on the internet. And so I think A system that compares the ethics of mass murdering dictators and internet billionaires probably wasn’t high on their list of concerns.

                                                      And if you say, well, it should have been I don’t know. I talked about Google’s scale problem a couple weeks ago in the PO in the episode about Google Lacks vision, big text earnings. Google gets eight and a half billion searches a day. Imagine if even 1 percent of those were for objectionable material.

                                                      That’s 85 million potentially objectionable requests. As my friend Mike Moran says, when your UI is an open ended prompt, it’s devilishly difficult to stamp out all problems. An open ended prompt provides all sorts of possibilities. Anyone who thinks this is easy to test has never done it. Just to give you a point of comparison, I’m just going to pull from my own website.

                                                      77 percent of the searches on my website were unique over the last year. The most common search term accounted for 11 percent of all searches. The second most common accounted for just under 4%. And I’m very confident that Google’s numbers are even more skewed towards the long tail. Literally, large user bases are where the concept of the long tail came from.

                                                      11 percent of 85 million searches is 9. 35 million. So what’s Google supposed to do about the other 75. 6 million requests? Right? That’s a tough problem to solve. Of course they automated this. Of course they built in rules. And, of course, because of the way AIs work, those rules produced a whole bunch of stuff that nobody saw coming.

                                                      My entire argument here, by the way, also assumes that there were no bad actors on the internet aching to make Google look bad. That’s just if we take basic numbers and add them up, it gets ugly quick. That puts Google in a really tough position. That position, and this episode overall this situation overall, underscores why market leaders have such a tough time winning in new markets.

                                                      Google has to protect its brand reputation and its advertisers brands in a way that’s going to make it exceedingly risk averse. And notice, none of the things I just talked about, none of the things they called out in that paper, are things that every brand would want to avoid being associated with. So, I don’t think Google did something evil here.

                                                      They just are in a tough, tough position when they’re also trying to protect their brand. And let’s face it, lots of startups don’t have that same problem. Even if they did have the same kind of mistake that we’ve seen with Gemini here, it probably wouldn’t tarnish their brand irreparably in the short run, in the long run.

                                                      They could just say, Oh my gosh, it was a beta. We fixed it. And now we’re back for tests. Take two. Google is going to struggle with that. And that’s where I want you to think about this for your business. This is where I want you to focus on what I think is the most important problem. For starters, you likely don’t have Google scale problems, so yay!

                                                      But you will also have to take it for granted that any artificial intelligence you’re exposing to the world could behave unpredictably. Even if you think you’ve built in the right guardrails, as Google did, the guardrails themselves can produce outputs you couldn’t possibly expect. I don’t think Google would have released this if they thought this was something that they were going to see.

                                                      Maybe they did. Maybe they looked at this and they went, Oh, nobody’s going to care. But I doubt that. I really do. You know, they’re, they’re walking it back all over the place. Sundar Pichai has put out a memo basically saying, We screwed up. We’re going to fix this. This is unacceptable. As you would expect he would.

                                                      This is, they’ve gotten a lot of egg on their face here. But, it demonstrates the thing you need to be thinking about. That you’re going to get outputs you don’t expect. And it’s something that you need to put the right governance procedures in place, just as you probably have today, to ensure that any outputs that are generated align with your brand’s values and the values of your customers.

                                                      That’s an important point and it’s the part I think people need to focus on more. AIs are unpredictable. You have to expect that they’re going to be unpredictable and they’re going to be unpredictable in unpredictable ways. So your governance procedures and the way you make, you expose these tools to the internet have to be really well thought through to ensure you’re not creating Other bias problems.

                                                      You know, you have to monitor the outputs. You have to monitor the customer experience throughout to ensure you’re not creating a problem different than the one you were trying to prevent in the first place. On a completely separate note, on a side note, I also think there’s a big silver lining for lots of people here that we want to highlight.

                                                      We’ve heard people say, lots of people who say AI is going to take their job away. Right? And obviously, every time anybody makes a mistake, it’s evidence for why that’s not true. But I think this specific type of mistake is very hard to eliminate at all, and is Particularly strong evidence for why this is true.

                                                      Now, let’s be fair. AI is going to make some jobs go away. You’ve heard me tell the story about my grandmother who was a telephone operator a hundred years ago. That’s a fact. She was. And technology made her job go away because technology always makes some jobs go away. Also be aware, there are more women working today than were even alive a hundred years ago.

                                                      The reason I bring up women in this case is because telephone operators were largely women and it was one of the largest job categories for women when my grandmother was a telephone operator, right? Today there are more women working, period, than even were alive when my grandmother was a telephone operator.

                                                      Clearly, there’s plenty more jobs. The reality is, if 100 percent of the value you bring to your organization can be automated, the problem isn’t with the automation. Right? Instead, you need to think about how you can use AI to augment the value you bring. Think about how automation and technology have changed lots of jobs over the years.

                                                      For instance, just to pick one. Think about how we used to move material and freight from one place to another. A couple of Teamsters which the name comes from managing a team of horses, mules, or oxen, loaded freight on a wagon pulled by those horses, mules, or oxen, and took it to the next town or the next county or the next state.

                                                      Then one day, the truck came along. Well, what happened? The truck didn’t eliminate the Teamsters. It created truck drivers, and the speed with which trucks could deliver things created more demand, which then created more demand for truck drivers. So more Teamsters. More jobs. There are three and a half million truck drivers in the U.

                                                      S. alone today. That’s more than 15 percent of the U. S. population in 1850, right? So, clearly, we’ve seen an increase in demand because of technology, not technology taking the jobs away. I suppose if you were the person shoeing the horses, or the oxen, or the mules, do oxen and mules even wear shoes? You get my point.

                                                      That job went away. But it created more jobs than it eliminated. There’s a phenomenal piece by a guy named David Autor, and I think I’m pronouncing his name correctly in a, in a online journal called Noema, about how AI could actually help rebuild the middle class. And he gives the example of nurse practitioners and he says, to put it more simply, electronic medical records and improved communication tools enabled nurse practitioners to make better decisions.

                                                      Moving forward, AI could ultimately supplement the expert judgment of nurse practitioners engaging in a broader scope of medical care tasks. And this point applies much more broadly. From contract law, to calculus instruction, to catheterization, AI could potentially enable a larger set of workers to perform high stakes expert tasks.

                                                      It can do this by complementing their skills and supplementing their judgment. Not to be flipped, but given what we’ve seen from the Gemini debacle, we’re going to need more skilled, knowledgeable people to understand whether the outputs produced by AI are accurate and safe. It’s not an either AI or people situation, it’s not an either or, it’s both and.

                                                      Both people and AI working together, just like trucks and their drivers. Instead, when I look at this whole situation for Google and Gemini, I think what we’ve learned is, A, Google had a terrible product launch, B, they’re probably not evil, or at least if they are, this isn’t evidence for it, C, and probably most importantly, AI is unpredictable.

                                                      Even the way it’s unpredictable is unpredictable. D, you need to think how AI can be used against you, how it can hurt your brand as you deploy these. We’re going to see lots of these examples like just happened in the near term and probably over the long term, too. We know that we still see people pointing out internet fails all the time.

                                                      I don’t think AI is going to be any different in that regard. E, you need to ensure that the AIs you’re exposing to the public are fair, accurate, and safe. Think about your governance procedures. Who’s reviewing the work that your team or your company’s AI produces? You’re going to be using AI more and more.

                                                      You want to be sure it’s producing the right material and doing so in a way that represents your brand well and is beneficial to your community, not harmful. So think about your governance procedures long and hard. F on my list here. We also, it also highlights Google’s problem and the problem that any market leader has trying to adapt to a new technology or a new reality.

                                                      I don’t know that Google is doomed, but they, they’re going to face some problems from this and we may see that going on as we go forward. Gartner had a piece the other day I will link to in the show notes that showed they predict search will drop by 25 percent in the next two years. I don’t believe those numbers, but in the spirit of time, I will address those in a future episode.

                                                      And lastly, G, this episode highlights why AI isn’t going to eliminate every job, but rather create whole new categories of jobs. We are definitely living in a different world as we work with AI. But just as we did with social, just as we did with mobile, just as we did with the internet, we will learn to put the right governance procedures in place to ensure that we’re protecting our brands, we’re protecting our businesses, we’re protecting our customers, and we’re protecting our communities.

                                                      If you put your focus there and less on the specifics of what happened, you’re setting yourself up for long term success in a way that Google may struggle to do so themselves.

                                                      Show Wrap-Up and Credits

                                                      Now, looking at the clock on the wall, we are out of time for this week.

                                                      And I want to remind you again that you can find the show notes for this episode. As well as an archive of all past episodes by going to timpeter.com/podcast. Again, that’s timpeter.com/podcast. Just look for episode 415.

                                                      Subscribe to Thinks Out Loud

                                                      Don’t forget that you can click on the subscribe link in any of the episodes that you find there to have Thinks Out Loud delivered to your favorite podcatcher every single week. You can also find Thinks Out Loud on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube Music, anywhere fine podcasts are found.

                                                      Leave a Rating or Review for Thinks Out Loud

                                                      I would also very much appreciate it if you could provide a positive rating or review for the show whenever you use one of those services.

                                                      If you like what you hear on Thinks Out Loud, if you enjoy what we talk about, if you like being part of the community that we’re building here, please give us a positive rating or review.

                                                      Reviews help other listeners find the podcast. Reviews help other listeners understand what Thinks Out Loud is all about. They help to build our community and they mean the world to me. So thank you so much for doing that. I very, very much appreciate it.

                                                      Thinks Out Loud on Social Media

                                                      You can also find Thinks Out Loud on LinkedIn by going to linkedin.com/tim-peter-and-associates-llc. You can find me on Twitter or X or whatever you want to call it this week by using the Twitter handle @tcpeter. And of course, you can email me by sending an email to podcast(at)timpeter.com. Again, that’s podcast(at)timpeter.com.

                                                      Show Outro

                                                      Finally, and I know I say this a lot, I want you to know how thrilled I am that you keep listening to what we do here. It means so much to me. You are the reason we do this show.

                                                      You’re the reason that Thinks Out Loud happens every single week. So please, keep your messages coming on LinkedIn. Keep hitting me up on Twitter, sending things via email. I love getting a chance to talk with you, to hear what’s going on in your world, and to learn how we can do a better job building on the types of content and community and information and insights that work for you and work for your business.

                                                      So with all that said, I hope you have a fantastic rest of your day, I hope you have a wonderful week ahead, and I will look forward to speaking with you here on Thinks Out Loud next time. Until then, please be well, be safe, and as always, take care, everybody.

                                                      The post No One is Talking About the Most Important Lessons from Google’s Gemini Launch Kerfuffle (Thinks Out Loud Episode 415) appeared first on Tim Peter & Associates.

                                                      27 min
                                                    • Picks, Shovels, and the AI Gold Rush (Thinks Out Loud Episode 414)

                                                      I’ve been relatively bearish lately on Google’s articulated vision — or lack thereof — for artificial intelligence. I’ve been much more bullish about Microsoft and Amazon and OpenAI. But here’s the thing. We’re in the early days of generative AI in practice. Yes, it’s getting used every day. At the same time, I’d challenge most people to name 10 great products that depend solely on generative AI, let alone 10 great companies that that do.

                                                      Yes, we’re seeing gen AI features incorporated into existing great products. We’re also seeing great technology that might someday morph into a great product. It’s just that great technology isn’t the same thing as a great product. Google achieved its dominant position not only because they offered terrific search results that worked well for searchers. It’s also because they had a great way to monetize those results that worked well for searchers, advertisers, and everyone else in the value chain. That’s what a great product does. It works. And it pays. For itself.

                                                      What we’re seeing instead at the moment is a gold rush. And, as you know, the winners in a gold rush aren’t the people mining for gold. It’s the people selling picks and shovels. Who are those people today? Big Tech companies like Google and Microsoft and Amazon. And aspiring members of Big Tech like OpenAI and Adobe and Salesforce.

                                                      The trick for you is to ensure you’re able to connect with your customers whether or not AI helps you find gold. And that’s what this episode of Thinks Out Loud is all about.

                                                      Picks, Shovels, and the AI Gold Rush (Thinks Out Loud Episode 414) Headlines and Show Notes
                                                      Show Notes and Links
                                                      • OpenAI Develops Web Search Product in Challenge to Google — The Information
                                                      • Video generation models as world simulators
                                                      • Introducing Gemini 1.5, Google’s next-generation AI model
                                                      • ChatGPT bug causes chaos as AI generates nonsensical responses – Dexerto
                                                      • Reddit – “Ah the classic super buff native american and Indian couple from 1820 germany”
                                                      • Reddit – “excuse me but what the actual fu-“
                                                      • Reddit – “Yo, Gpt4 just went full hallucination mode on me, hasn’t really every happened to me this severely since the early days of gpt3 : ChatGPT”
                                                      • Google Lacks Vision: Big Tech Earnings and the State of Digital Q1 2024 (Thinks Out Loud Episode 412)
                                                      • Subprime Intelligence
                                                      • Groq Costs, Gemini Pro 1.5, Google’s Timidity – Stratechery by Ben Thompson
                                                      • Say Goodbye to Google, Hoteliers | By Tim Peter
                                                      • The End of Google? (Thinks Out Loud Episode 372)
                                                      • Rethinking Search Marketing in the Age of AI (Thinks Out Loud Episode 397)
                                                      • Revisiting Will AI and ChatGPT Kill Your Search Traffic? (Thinks Out Loud)
                                                      • Can Podcasting Help Your Business Bypass the Big Tech Gatekeepers? (Thinks Out Loud Episode 413)
                                                      • Is Google Doomed? And Other Top Digital Trends for 2024 (Thinks Out Loud Episode 408)
                                                      • You might also enjoy this webinar I recently participated in with Miles Partnership that looked at "The Power of Generative AI and ChatGPT: What It Means for Tourism & Hospitality" here:

                                                        Free Downloads

                                                        We have some free downloads for you to help you navigate the current situation, which you can find right here:

                                                        • A Modern Content Marketing Checklist. Want to ensure that each piece of content works for your business? Download our latest checklist to help put your content marketing to work for you.
                                                        • A Brief Introduction to Thinks Out Loud. As a bonus, we’ve also included this PDF document that highlights some of our core episodes to help you dig into what the show is about. We think it will help you capture the show’s essence while you’re working your way through the 300-plus episodes published so far. Download it here.
                                                        • Digital & E-commerce Maturity Matrix. As a bonus, here’s a PDF that can help you assess your company’s digital maturity. You can use this to better understand where your company excels and where its opportunities lie. And, of course, we’re here to help if you need it. The Digital & E-commerce Maturity Matrix rates your company’s effectiveness — Ad Hoc, Aware, Striving, Driving — in 6 key areas in digital today, including:
                                                          • Customer Focus
                                                          • Strategy
                                                          • Technology
                                                          • Operations
                                                          • Culture
                                                          • Data
                                                          • Subscribe to Thinks Out Loud
                                                            • Subscribe in iTunes
                                                            • Subscribe in the Google Play Store
                                                            • Contact information for the podcast: [email protected]

                                                              Past Insights from Tim Peter Thinks
                                                              Technical Details for Thinks Out Loud

                                                              Recorded using a Shure SM7B Vocal Dynamic Microphone and a Focusrite Scarlett 4i4 (3rd Gen) USB Audio Interface into Logic Pro X for the Mac.

                                                              Running time: 28m 07s

                                                              You can subscribe to Thinks Out Loud in iTunes, the Google Play Store, via our dedicated podcast RSS feed (or sign up for our free newsletter). You can also download/listen to the podcast here on Thinks using the player at the top of this page.

                                                              Transcript: Picks, Shovels, and the AI Gold Rush

                                                               Well, hello again, Big Thinkers, and welcome back to Thinks Out Loud, your source for all the digital expertise your business needs. My name is Tim Peter. This is Episode 414 of the Big Show. And thank you so much for tuning in. I really, really appreciate it. I think we’ve got a cool show for you today. I want to kick off by highlighting four news stories that tie into a larger point about the AI moment we’re living through in marketing and sales and customer experience and why they’re important and why they’re important for your business.

                                                              But I’m going to start with the news stories. The first is that Google launched its Gemini Pro model version 1.5. And I’m going to talk about each of these in a little bit of detail in a second, but I’m just going to give you the headlines first. So Gemini dropped Gemini excuse me, Google dropped Gemini Pro 1.5. OpenAI launched its Sora video from text product. OpenAI might launch a search engine, it was reported the other day. And, ChatGPT, over the last 24 hours or so, has lost its damned mind. It’s been doing some really weird stuff.

                                                              So I’m going to do these in order first. First, Google dropped Gemini Pro 1.5. This is a very, very cool tool. It’s their ChatGPT or GPT-4 competitor, it’s very, very cool. It can do things like multimodal analysis, so you can feed it text or images or audio. And its big enhancement relative to something like GPT-4 is that it can input up to 1 million tokens. That’s roughly 70,000 words of text or about an hour of video. Which is pretty extraordinary because you can then do some things with that material in memory that can’t really be done any other way.

                                                              The tech under the hood gets a little complex , there’s other ways to accomplish the same thing. But having a larger token set is impressive in its own right and opens up some possibilities that haven’t existed before. For instance, you could have, you could upload an immense amount of data into memory and have it analyze that data rather than doing it a piece at a time so you can get a better sense of the big picture. That’s really, really cool and something that is very hard for people other than Google to do because it requires A, enormous processing power and B, it’s pretty expensive in terms of running the damn thing.

                                                              So that’s kind of a big deal and something that a startup like OpenAI may have more problems with. Yes, Microsoft can probably do it. Yes, Amazon can probably do it. But the number of companies that can actually pull this off besides those big three is vanishingly small.

                                                              One of the things that I think is important here is Benedict Evans noted in his newsletter he said it’s pretty clear that it’s not going — it, ChatGPT, or it, OpenAI — is not going to be the only company with "the best models."

                                                              There’s a very real competition going on here between OpenAI and Google and Microsoft, and probably Amazon and probably Facebook for who is the best AI out there. And that’s something that’s going to play out over time.

                                                              Now, of course, OpenAI hasn’t been sitting still the last couple weeks. One, they launched Sora. Sora is so cool. I’ve played with it a little bit. You feed it a line of text, and it can output video, and the videos are remarkable. Also, like we saw with image generation with the early versions of Dall-E or MidJourney, it’s that they can be genuinely weird and disturbing. But when’s the last time you heard people talk about AI-generated images being weird and disturbing? They’re mostly pretty good now. And that’s only taken a few years.

                                                              So I’m more interested in what Sora represents over the long term than what it is today. And what it is over the long term is AI-generated video that’s accessible to everybody, to you, relatively inexpensively. More on that in a minute.

                                                              The third news story and the one that’s sort of the centerpiece of this whole episode this week is that there’s a news story. The Information reported that OpenAI might launch a search engine. I shared this on LinkedIn and what I said at the time was "this is a major development with broad implications for businesses that get a significant portion of their website traffic from Google. Whether it’s organic search, paid search, meta search, local search, etc., any loss in Google’s market share could impact your revenue. This doesn’t mean Google is going away or that they’ll fail, but the potential market shift could have long term effects."

                                                              I mean, when’s the last time we cared about a new competitor to Google? Right? It’s been a minute. So, this could have a lot of effects on you in the longer term, and it’s something I’ve talked about here quite a bit over the last few years, so I’m not going to belabor the point now, but I will come back to it a little bit later.

                                                              The last news story I want to talk about is that ChatGPT did some weird stuff over the last 24 hours. I don’t know if it’s still going on. I don’t know if it has been corrected yet. What I do know is that this thing has been doing some weird, wacky stuff. Last night when I heard that this was going on, I asked ChatGPT for its take on how OpenAI’s potential new search engine could affect the market.

                                                              And I’m, the first chunk it replied with was perfectly fine, perfectly normal. However, when it got to its fifth point, it started going off the rails in a weird way. And so I’m going to read you a lengthy excerpt. This is a quote from ChatGPT. Starting with:

                                                              “Item 5. Caveats to unbridled growth and self correction. The very appeal of every neotech market headliner is its scale and insatiability. First, will there be youth in all Azure titted cubes, or perhaps governance, ethics, and disenfranchised auditoriums could hard stop correctly any singular surf logic, perhaps right sizing to several bookhouse keepers? Six: Future Model Policies and Strategic Legislation. New teleco landscapes or great shadowing lanes of e-clearance and host source munitioning personally might take traffic abreast anchoring light to algorithmic pendants."

                                                              I’m sorry, what? I want to be very clear, I, you’re not having a stroke as you’re listening to that. I’m not having a stroke as I’m saying it, but it sure seems like ChatGPT was. What in the world?

                                                              I have to give you one more line that said, for those of you who are listening to this while you’re driving in your car or something, I do apologize, I don’t mean to make you drive off the road or whatever, but it’s last line said:

                                                              "The seers pipe calls for acceptance of not unusual throw, but swift strategics, genius incrementals, and earth spin grit to not just take, but throw a mill’s engine in case."

                                                              What?!? Now, look, we all know that artificial intelligence, that generative AI tools, can experience hallucinations. I’ve not seen any of the text tools hallucinate this badly in a pretty good while. Like, this is nutty, and last I knew as of, oh, 10 o’clock in the morning on Wednesday, February 21st, 2024, this was still going on some of the time.

                                                              Which brings me to a smaller point I want to get to here. Now, I have said for some time that ChatGPT faces an uphill climb.

                                                              I’ve talked about the threats to Google a lot. But I haven’t always talked as much about the threats to Bing, Microsoft, and ChatGPT. They absolutely could lose. I wrote in an article for HospitalityNet a year ago, this is a quote from the article,

                                                              “With no disrespect intended to Microsoft and Bing, they haven’t found a way to bump Google from its throne, despite decades of experience in the search market. Cool technology alone does not equal a successful product. Microsoft and Bing could win, but I’ll believe they’ve succeeded this time when they succeed."

                                                              It’s not like Microsoft is new at challenging Google. They just have never managed to beat them. And as we’re just seeing with this nonsense that occurred, that’s kind of a sign of why this is so hard, right? ChatGPT has been doing great up until today or yesterday, and who knows what this is going to do to them.

                                                              My very, very good friend Mike Moran and I have been having an email debate/discussion over the last couple of days and he very, very, very intelligently points out that Google is wise to move cautiously here. They are the dominant brand. They have the most to lose if it goes wrong, potentially more than they have to win if it goes right. We certainly know people are motivated as much by fear, if not more so, than they are by upsides. So, it’s understandable that they would be cautious. I have some specific issues when I talk about Google’s lack of vision, that they’re not communicating that caution well, in my view. But, maybe other people feel differently. And this is certainly a sign of why you want to move cautiously, if you’re Google.

                                                              By the way, I want to make a quick aside about Microsoft’s position in the space at the moment. Again, some of this comes from my friend Mike Moran, who noted that despite the massive investments that Microsoft has made in OpenAI, they don’t own the company, and they don’t control the company.

                                                              Now, I’ve heard arguments from a number of people that suggest this is a benefit for Microsoft. They get all the benefits of OpenAI’s models. They’re only responsible for part of the cost. And they’re very much isolated from brand risk during periods when ChatGPT does something like, I don’t know, losing its damned mind. If their products are isolated from that, that’s no harm to them.

                                                              There are also strong arguments to be made, some of these from my friend Mike, that talk about why this is bad for Microsoft. Yeah, they influence the product, but they don’t control it. In other words, OpenAI probably listens to Microsoft, but they’re going to do what’s best for their business.

                                                              It reminds me of a lesson I learned years ago about joint ventures between big companies. The joint venture has to exist for the benefit of the child, the joint venture itself, not the benefit of its parents, the companies that are jointly partnered on this thing. I led a joint venture between a hotel company and a group of outside investors and we often struggled to move forward on things because each owner wanted different things that they felt were best for their businesses, not necessarily what was best for the business they had invested in that I was running. It can be really, really icky and frustrating if you have to deal with it every day. Trust me on this one, I know.

                                                              In any case, Microsoft is playing a very different game than Google. And it’s going to be interesting how this shakes out over theintermediate term, right? The benefits might turn out to be benefits, the downsides might turn out to be downsides. Probably a little bit of both. But we’re going to have to see what happens there. We know for sure that it’s going to be a different reality than what Google’s going through.

                                                              And just to close the loop on why Google is so tough to beat, as I posted a comment on that LinkedIn thread I referenced earlier,

                                                              "I doubt Google loses right away, if at all. Not only do they have as much or more data than anyone else, they’ve got an immense amount of processing horsepower available, a generally great brand, oh, and a war chest of more than 100 billion dollars in cash on hand."

                                                              By the way, that’s billion with a B. That’s a lot of money. They’re going to be really tough to unseat.

                                                              Okay, so I said that these four news stories all had one common theme. And the common theme, the thing that I think you should be taking away from this is the pace of innovation that we’re seeing, and specifically the pace of technology innovation. I’m putting emphasis on the words "technology innovation" here because we haven’t yet seen any real innovation in business practices or business models.

                                                              To me, when I look at what we’re seeing right now, it looks a bit like the dot-com boom all over again. It’s really hard to know where we are in big picture terms because everything is changing so fast. But I’d equate where we are at the moment to the internet maybe in 1997 or 1998:

                                                              • There’s lots of cool technology.
                                                              • There’s some cool products.
                                                              • And there’s really only a handful of businesses, if that, that make any sense yet.
                                                              • Again, I refer to my point about Bing not yet beating Google. They’ve got good tech, but we’re not sure if it’s a good product yet. ChatGPT is good tech. We’re not sure if it’s a good product yet.

                                                                Google is taking a deliberate pace with its product. I don’t know what it’s doing in terms of its tech. When I talk about their lack of vision, part of this is its articulated vision. It’s what are they saying out loud? Maybe the product ideas they have are phenomenal, but they haven’t talked about them yet, they’re still talking about the tech.

                                                                Now just to be clear, I said earlier, and I’m going to say this again, good technology does not equal a good product.

                                                                That’s the place where many companies have failed, and we saw this a ton during the dot-com boom. There was a company called Pets.com that essentially today is Chewy. But what they hadn’t figured out was how do we actually deliver things like dog food economically? And so they burned through a ton of money and went out of business.

                                                                There were companies like Flooz.com, that was digital currency. There were companies like Webvan that did grocery delivery. All of these are things that exist today. But the companies don’t, because they didn’t figure out how to make a business out of what they were offering.

                                                                Yes, Google brought in really great search products, but also they brought in a really great business model with their ads and with AdWords because that actually paid for all this and has made them an incredibly successful business. We’ll see whether Microsoft or OpenAI is able to monetize generative AI in the way that Google monetized search and is able to turn it into a business in the same way. Right now, we just don’t know. So that’s something you really want to be clear about.

                                                                The other reason that right now it’s tough to predict exactly where we are is things are moving so fast. You know, my analogy that right now we’re in 1997 or 1998 is we don’t know if next year is going to be 1999 or if it’s going to be 2004 or if it’s going to be 2011, right? Things are just changing that fast.

                                                                What’s definitely true Is that we are in a gold rush right now. And as you all know, in a gold rush, the big winners are the people who sell picks and shovels. So when we start to think about who’s likely to win in the AI moment or wherever we end up with AI, at least for now, the big winners are the folks who would expect. It is Google. It is OpenAI. It’s Microsoft. It’s Amazon. It’s the people I was talking about over the last couple weeks.

                                                                I’ve been slagging Google like crazy. They’re also not exactly collapsing under their own weight. My point has not been that Google will fail. My point is that they don’t have as clearly articulated a vision as the other folks out there. And they, if they fail, that there is a playbook by which that’s going to occur that they appear to be following. We’ll see if that holds true, right?

                                                                They’re also still in a very, very, very powerful position. They have long since figured out how to productize cool technology. And it’s very clear that Microsoft has a clear vision of how to do that. And I think it’s pretty clear that OpenAI and Amazon have a pretty clear way of how to do that. So, we’re going to see the dominant players probably remain dominant.

                                                                The threat to Google specifically, and I’m going to repeat something I said the other day, is that every time a customer uses any tool to search, so a developer uses GitHub Copilot, a shopper uses Amazon’s Rufus, a marketer uses Microsoft 365 Copilot, a product manager riffs on an idea in ChatGPT, a writer uses Perplexity or Claude or so on, that’s potentially a lost click for Google and lost revenues for Google.

                                                                But notice what I said there. For the most part, I’m talking about Microsoft. I’m talking about Amazon. I’m talking about Microsoft. I’m talking about OpenAI. Yeah, Perplexity and Claude are new and could come out and be big winners in the longer term. But they’re still a lot bigger than folks who are putting AI into their products and services, right? You would expect Adobe’s gonna be fine. You would expect that Salesforce is gonna be fine. The people selling picks and shovels are the ones who are going to win, at least in the near term.

                                                                Some of the folks who are out there right now with cool technology are going to end up being tomorrow’s Pets.com or tomorrow’s Webvan. That’s the reality that we’re facing. And until we, until things shake out a little more, I would still bet on the people who hold the picks and shovels.

                                                                Which brings me to my largest point, and the one that I talk about all the time, which you’ve heard me say a million times on this show that "gatekeepers gonna gate."

                                                                Notice who we’re talking about in this. We’re talking about the Big Tech folks. We’re talking about the folks who are gatekeepers to you. And we’re talking about the folks who get between you and your customer pretty much all the time. And if you’re not thinking about how do I connect with my customer beyond the gatekeepers, beyond Big Tech, You’re setting yourself up for a lot of trouble.

                                                                I’ve given a scenario a number of times on various episodes of the show where I talked about Google losing just a handful of points of market share. If you think about it, search that comes in at the top of the funnel, informational search, means that’s 5 percent of site visitors you can’t retarget. It means your email list doesn’t grow as fast. It means your ABM campaigns have less data to build from and learn from.

                                                                It means that either you have to spend more to attract awareness and interest in your product or service, or you have to place your product on places like Amazon or Google product search or somewhere else.

                                                                In either case, you’re spending money with Big Tech. They win, you lose, at least a little. I think of companies I’ve worked with, that get at least 5 percent of traffic from informational search and that I’m reasonably confident turned into revenue later. Certainly, a lot more than 5 percent of traffic and probably at least a bit more than 5 percent of revenue.

                                                                And it doesn’t matter whether you’re a billion dollar company or a 10 million dollar company. 5 percent, at minimum, is still a lot of money. Nobody likes telling their boss that they missed forecasts even by as little as 5%. It’s not a good place to be.

                                                                So it comes back to, how are you building connections with your customers independent of Big Tech? How are you building connections with customers so that regardless of whether they’re using search, or they’re using AI, or they’re using whatever else comes down the pike someday, they still are looking for you, they are still connecting with you, they are still engaging with your brand and your business in a way that works for you.

                                                                Because the other thing that we know about gold rushes is sometimes they’re busts at the end. And you don’t want to be the one holding a bunch of picks and shovels that you no longer need and having to turn back to the same company store you bought them from trying to find the next thing that will help you dig for gold.

                                                                That’s a losing strategy in the long term and one that you absolutely want to avoid no matter what next week’s headlines happen to be.

                                                                So, yes, we’ve had a really cool week for big tech, we’ve had a really cool week in AI, there have been lots of amazing news stories. So yeah, cool technology is really cool. Cool products are better. And cool businesses are best of all.

                                                                If we’re in a gold rush, try to make sure you’re selling picks and shovels at least to your customers so that they go looking for you — and so that you end up being a cool business no matter what happens with tech or the news around it.

                                                                Show Wrap-Up and Credits

                                                                Now, looking at the clock on the wall, we are out of time for this week.

                                                                And I want to remind you again that you can find the show notes for this episode. As well as an archive of all past episodes by going to timpeter.com/podcast. Again, that’s timpeter.com/podcast. Just look for episode 413.

                                                                Subscribe to Thinks Out Loud

                                                                Don’t forget that you can click on the subscribe link in any of the episodes that you find there to have Thinks Out Loud delivered to your favorite podcatcher every single week. You can also find Thinks Out Loud on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube Music, anywhere fine podcasts are found.

                                                                Leave a Rating or Review for Thinks Out Loud

                                                                I would also very much appreciate it if you could provide a positive rating or review for the show whenever you use one of those services.

                                                                If you like what you hear on Thinks Out Loud, if you enjoy what we talk about, if you like being part of the community that we’re building here, please give us a positive rating or review.

                                                                Reviews help other listeners find the podcast. Reviews help other listeners understand what Thinks Out Loud is all about. They help to build our community and they mean the world to me. So thank you so much for doing that. I very, very much appreciate it.

                                                                Thinks Out Loud on Social Media

                                                                You can also find Thinks Out Loud on LinkedIn by going to linkedin.com/tim-peter-and-associates-llc. You can find me on Twitter or X or whatever you want to call it this week by using the Twitter handle @tcpeter. And of course, you can email me by sending an email to podcast(at)timpeter.com. Again, that’s podcast(at)timpeter.com.

                                                                Show Outro

                                                                Finally, and I know I say this a lot, I want you to know how thrilled I am that you keep listening to what we do here. It means so much to me. You are the reason we do this show.

                                                                You’re the reason that Thinks Out Loud happens every single week. So please, keep your messages coming on LinkedIn. Keep hitting me up on Twitter, sending things via email. I love getting a chance to talk with you, to hear what’s going on in your world, and to learn how we can do a better job building on the types of content and community and information and insights that work for you and work for your business.

                                                                So with all that said, I hope you have a fantastic rest of your day, I hope you have a wonderful week ahead, and I will look forward to speaking with you here on Thinks Out Loud next time. Until then, please be well, be safe, and as always, take care, everybody.

                                                                The post Picks, Shovels, and the AI Gold Rush (Thinks Out Loud Episode 414) appeared first on Tim Peter & Associates.

                                                                29 min
                                                              • Can Podcasting Help Your Business Bypass the Big Tech Gatekeepers? (Thinks Out Loud Episode 413)

                                                                You’ve heard me say many times that “gatekeepers gonna gate.” That’s what they do. Woudln’t it be great if there was an easy, inexpensive way to bypass Big Tech’s gatekeepers? Wouldn’t it be wonderful if you could extend your brand’s awareness and reach without having to rely too heavily on Amazon, Google, Facebook, Apple, or Microsoft? Would you believe me if I said there might be an option you’re overlooking?

                                                                What is that option? Podcasting. Now, I want to be fair. Podcasting takes some work. It requires consistency, patiences, and at least a little effort. It’s absolutely not the right choice for every business. But, where it works, it offers an exceptional way to bypass the gatekeepers in Big Tech and reach your customers for relatively low cost.

                                                                What makes podcasting work? Why is it a good option for some businesses? What questions should marketers and strategists ask as they consider podcasting? And, of course, how can your business use podcasting to bypass the Big Tech gatekeepers? That’s what this episode of the Thinks Out Loud podcast is all about.

                                                                Want to learn more? Here are the show notes for you.

                                                                Can Podcasting Help Your Business Bypass the Gatekeepers? (Thinks Out Loud Episode 413) Headlines and Show Notes
                                                                Show Notes and Links
                                                                • Google Lacks Vision: Big Tech Earnings and the State of Digital Q1 2024 (Thinks Out Loud Episode 412)
                                                                • Google Podcasts – Wikipedia
                                                                • Podcast statistics & trends in 2024 – Podcastpage.io – The Podcast Website Builder
                                                                • Google Podcasts can import your Play Music subscriptions – 9to5Google
                                                                • Podcast Statistics & Industry Trends 2024: Listens, Gear, & More
                                                                • What Connects TikTok and the Hub and Spoke Model of Digital? (Thinks Out Loud Episode 299)
                                                                • Is Content Still King or Have the Gatekeepers Won? (Thinks Out Loud Episode 328)
                                                                • How to Drive Business Using Digital (Thinks Out Loud Episode 368)
                                                                • Do You Still Need a Website? (Thinks Out Loud Episode 400)
                                                                • A Podcasting and Content Marketing Case Study (Thinks Out Loud Episode 394)
                                                                • Revisiting How to Escape Big Tech’s Web (Thinks Out Loud)
                                                                • Big Trends: Bundling, Unbundling, and Customer Acquisition (Thinks Out Loud Episode 411)
                                                                • Three Content Distribution Concepts to Help Your Company’s Content Marketing Succeed (Thinks Out Loud Episode 329)
                                                                • Content Marketing in Action: 10 Years of Thinks Out Loud (Episode 359)
                                                                • Marketing Mix Podcast – Solent Strategies
                                                                • John Oliver Fears For Humanity While Eating Spicy Wings | Hot Ones – YouTube
                                                                • You might also enjoy this webinar I recently participated in with Miles Partnership that looked at "The Power of Generative AI and ChatGPT: What It Means for Tourism & Hospitality" here:

                                                                  Free Downloads

                                                                  We have some free downloads for you to help you navigate the current situation, which you can find right here:

                                                                  • A Modern Content Marketing Checklist. Want to ensure that each piece of content works for your business? Download our latest checklist to help put your content marketing to work for you.
                                                                  • A Brief Introduction to Thinks Out Loud. As a bonus, we’ve also included this PDF document that highlights some of our core episodes to help you dig into what the show is about. We think it will help you capture the show’s essence while you’re working your way through the 300-plus episodes published so far. Download it here.
                                                                  • Digital & E-commerce Maturity Matrix. As a bonus, here’s a PDF that can help you assess your company’s digital maturity. You can use this to better understand where your company excels and where its opportunities lie. And, of course, we’re here to help if you need it. The Digital & E-commerce Maturity Matrix rates your company’s effectiveness — Ad Hoc, Aware, Striving, Driving — in 6 key areas in digital today, including:
                                                                    • Customer Focus
                                                                    • Strategy
                                                                    • Technology
                                                                    • Operations
                                                                    • Culture
                                                                    • Data
                                                                    • Subscribe to Thinks Out Loud
                                                                      • Subscribe in iTunes
                                                                      • Subscribe in the Google Play Store
                                                                      • Contact information for the podcast: [email protected]

                                                                        Past Insights from Tim Peter Thinks
                                                                        Technical Details for Thinks Out Loud

                                                                        Recorded using a Shure SM7B Vocal Dynamic Microphone and a Focusrite Scarlett 4i4 (3rd Gen) USB Audio Interface into Logic Pro X for the Mac.

                                                                        Running time: 38m 02s

                                                                        You can subscribe to Thinks Out Loud in iTunes, the Google Play Store, via our dedicated podcast RSS feed (or sign up for our free newsletter). You can also download/listen to the podcast here on Thinks using the player at the top of this page.

                                                                        Transcript: Can Podcasting Help Your Business Bypass the Gatekeepers?

                                                                         Well, hello again, everyone, and welcome back to Thinks Out Loud, your source for all the digital expertise your business needs. My name is Tim Peter. This is episode 413 of the Big Show. And thank you so much for tuning in, I think we have a really cool show for you today.

                                                                        This one might go a little long, I don’t know, there’s a lot to talk about. And I’m going to tell you right up front, it’s about podcasting. It’s about podcasting for your business, but also it’s not. It’s also about how you can bypass gatekeepers. How you can connect with your customers more effectively, more efficiently, and more inexpensively, how you can save money doing it.

                                                                        I hold several core beliefs. I love cool, creative businesses. I am so lucky that I get to work with some amazing brands and businesses in what I do. I’m always learning from them and from the work that we do together. And one of the things that I’ve learned is that it’s pretty much always a bad idea to build your brand on rented land.

                                                                        You’ve heard that expression many times, not just from me, but from, I don’t know, everybody, right? But I want to be really clear. The reason that I say this, the reason that so many people say this, is because we see it again and again and again. I believe that far too many marketers, far too many companies, rely too heavily on the gatekeepers, on Big Tech, on the AGFAM — Apple, Google, Facebook, Amazon, Microsoft — what have you.

                                                                        And at least in part, the reason that’s a problem is because I also believe gatekeepers gonna gate. These folks are gatekeepers and it’s in their DNA to raise cost to you over time. Which means that over time, it’s going to cost you more to acquire customers. I’ve worked for years with people in the travel and hospitality industry and seen how expensive folks like Google and Expedia and Booking.com can be.

                                                                        This doesn’t mean you’re not going to use these players. We’ll talk about that in a moment. It just means that they can get quite expensive.

                                                                        I’ve seen the same for clients I’ve worked with in retail, with Amazon. I’ve seen the same with B2B companies learning how to connect with customers directly, especially during the pandemic and post pandemic.

                                                                        I believe, in my core, that you can market and acquire customers beyond Big Tech. And I love helping people and companies and brands figure this stuff out. Big companies, little companies. As long as you’re doing cool stuff, I love that I get to help people sort this out.

                                                                        Now I mentioned a moment ago, I don’t think Big Tech is evil. I think they can be incredibly useful. Particularly to help you reach customers you can’t reach more efficiently or more affordably on your own. You just don’t want to rely on them too heavily. I talked about this in detail last week, specifically focusing on Google’s lack of vision and what that could mean to you in the longer term.

                                                                        Which kind of brings me to my core point. I also love podcasts. I think they are a great medium as entertainment and I think they can be incredibly valuable for marketing.

                                                                        Which leads, today, to kind of a funny reality. Two different topics — my love of podcasts and Google’s lack of vision — are colliding at the moment.

                                                                        Google, over their history, has had at least three different podcast listening solutions for its users over the years. Originally, it was Google Play Music; if they had something before that, I don’t recall it. But certainly they had Google Play Music. Then, beginning around 2020, they switched users to Google Podcasts. And now they are switching users again to YouTube Music.

                                                                        Now, in this case, I want to be fair, I suspect this behavior is as much about lack of money as it is lack of vision. Though, that focus on the near term that I talked about last week is also playing a role.

                                                                        One of the reasons that Google struggles, one, one of the reasons they consistently struggle is based on their scale. Google is a massive company in a way very few of us have to deal with. And they’re a public company. Every quarter they have to report on their business to Wall Street. And getting big introduces problems that, you know, normal-sized companies don’t have to think about very often.

                                                                        Just like any public company, every quarter they need to show that the things they’re working on, as the Wall Street folks say, are material to earnings. More simply, do the things that they do help grow their revenues and profits?

                                                                        And the reason that it’s different for Google and the size of Google than it is for most of us is because it can be really tough to show when you’re generating $300 billion in revenue and $74 billion in profit in a year that any one thing you’re working on is going to actually drive those numbers up in a meaningful sense.

                                                                        I want to be clear, I have no idea what Google’s past podcast platforms contributed to that $74 billion in profit and $300 billion in revenue. But let’s pretend that their podcasting platform generated, I don’t know, $20 million in revenue. Now, to most people, that number would sound pretty great. I mean, in theory, even Google wouldn’t hate it.

                                                                        At the same time. $20 million in additional revenue as a share of Google’s revenue is 6/1000th of 1%. I want to be really, really clear about what that is. That is 0.006%. You know, in other words, that’s not what you’d call material to earnings. That’s not a big number in relative terms as far as they’re concerned.

                                                                        Now, I suspect they keep changing their podcast app because they don’t want too many people at the company working on too many things that in Google’s $300 billion universe don’t matter that much. And as a result, Google is shuffling their existing efforts into YouTube Music to reduce the number of disparate platforms they have competing for listeners and so that their product teams can spend time on the things that are going to matter materially.

                                                                        The funny thing about this is this has a huge advantage for podcasts as a marketing platform, certainly for my business, and I suspect for many of you, for yours too. Because no one owns podcasts the way that Google owns search, or Meta owns social, or LinkedIn owns business connections. Podcasts provide a direct connection with your customers.

                                                                        There are a ton of advantages, but the first one is they’re a great way to bypass the gatekeepers. Yes, there are gatekeepers in the podcasting space. Apple is number one, Spotify is number two, Google, particularly through YouTube, might be third. But, for instance, I get less than half of my listens of this podcast — which we’ve been doing for over a decade and 400-plus episodes — I get less than half of my listens on Apple Podcasts. I get 20 percent in Chrome directly, the web browser. There’s over a dozen distribution platforms that we’re using, including Apple, including Google, including Amazon, including Spotify, including YouTube, Music, and Pandora, and Podcast Index, and Deezer. We get 15 percent combined from places like Overcast, Podcast Addict, CastBox, and PocketCast. And it doesn’t cost us anything extra to be on all those platforms. We publish once and we distribute broadly. That’s a huge advantage.

                                                                        Another advantage for podcasts. What I love about this podcast is that it builds authority for your brand and business. You get an opportunity to spotlight your expertise and your ability to help your customers. All I do on this podcast is talk about what I do and what the people on my team do. We’re generating content that helps us find new business. Really great.

                                                                        Podcasts offer you another content distribution channel. You’ve heard me say many times that content without distribution, content that doesn’t get seen, provides zero value to your business. The great thing about podcasts, as I just talked about, is that your listeners can follow you anywhere. Whether it’s on your own website, whether it’s through an Apple or a Spotify or a Google or an Audible. There’s lots of places that they can find you.

                                                                        Podcasts create immense opportunity for content reuse. I’ll talk about this in a very specific example in a minute, but whenever we do an episode, that episode tends to live on in other content forms. So the script for the podcast episode, such as it is — and again I’ll explain that in a minute — can be turned into a blog post, or vice versa. Blog posts can be, can lead to, scripts. Either of those can lead to videos.

                                                                        I do this all the time with presentations for clients and speaking gigs. They often start as podcast episodes. This show is called Thinks Out Loud for a reason. Or the presentation turns into an episode, or more than one. I sometimes make an entire episode out of a single slide. I’ve got three speaking gigs coming up in the next month on “AI and marketing” and “AI and customer experience” and I absolutely guarantee that you’re going to hear a lot about the research we’re doing for those in future episodes. And those will also drive blog posts and social media content and the like. So huge, huge reuse opportunities.

                                                                        Also, I find that most episodes tend to have a longer shelf life than most other content. You know, just as with most areas of content marketing, the more recent episodes get more traction, for sure. But we’ve got episodes from as far back as 2015 and 2018 in the top 25 episodes that people have listened to so far this year to date. That’s huge. Huge, huge, because we’re getting lots of value out of something that we created, you know, what now, six years ago, nine years ago? Still getting listens and still getting meaningful listens.

                                                                        Another huge advantage to podcasts, something that I’m incredibly proud of, and this gets to a really important point in the current environment we’re living in, is that you get to build a personal connection with your audience.

                                                                        You may have heard there’s this thing called artificial intelligence, right? Anyone can create content easily and expensively. Content that’s, you know, at least pretty good, if not really good. We know that AI makes it easier and faster to produce quality content. But when I’m talking on a podcast episode, and the more that you imbue your personality into the episode, the tougher it is for people to replicate what you do. You stand out by being human.

                                                                        All you have to do is be yourself when you’re listening to this. You’re getting pretty much me, the me that everybody sees every day. I mean, sure, I have my slight business persona. I don’t talk at length about, you know, my family or people in my lives as much as I might do if we were sitting down having a drink, you know, right? But that’s because my wife and kids haven’t signed up to be on the podcast. That’s not about being fake. That’s about respecting other people’s wishes. Otherwise, I’m pretty much just me. I reference guitars, and music, and travel, and pop culture, and sometimes baseball on this show, and I joke on the show, or have fun on the show, because that’s important to me.

                                                                        I’ll tell you, one of my favorite marketing podcasts is hosted by a guy named Steve Cummins, and he includes a cocktail recipe in pretty much every episode. Why? Because he likes good cocktails. That’s a really human thing, and it makes him stand out from other people doing what they do. You should go listen to him. He’s great. After you listen to me, ok? But, you know, you get to build a personal connection.

                                                                        I’ve mentioned this many times, my friend Mark Schaefer talks about community being the next, last great form of marketing. Now, I tend to question his focus on last, but I certainly agree with his point that community matters. I’m going to let you in on a secret: It’s somewhat easier to build a community around people than it is around a business because you’re not trying to connect people with a business; you’re trying to connect people with people. It’s about making friends. You or someone on your team who’s the podcast host puts a human face on your business and creates more opportunity to build that community. That’s amazing.

                                                                        Of course, doing that, you’re also establishing a direct platform to engage with your customers. You’ve heard me talk many times on this show about “the Hub and Spoke strategy.” You know, the hub includes things like your website, your email list, your apps, assets that you control. They’re not the rented land, they’re the land you own.

                                                                        Spokes include things like distribution channels, so Google, or Facebook, or LinkedIn, or Apple’s App Store, or Amazon, or TikTok. They’re ways to extend your reach. The great thing about podcasts is they fit nicely into this ecosystem because they help you do both.

                                                                        The channels you use to distribute your episodes are additional spokes. Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube Music, Pandora, what have you. Those are places your business may not be today, and suddenly you have new spokes to reach your customers.

                                                                        Meanwhile the content, the episodes themselves, are another part of your hub. Wherever you post your podcast, that’s in effect part of your hub. And most podcast hosting services make it easy to embed episodes on your website. For instance, we get roughly 5 percent of all listens of Thinks Out Loud right on timpeter.com on the website. They also are another reason people come to the site. In the last year, more than 15 percent of all traffic to my company’s website started with a podcast episode, almost all of that as organic search. So there’s an SEO benefit as well. Huge, huge way to extend your reach on both the hub and the spokes.

                                                                        And then happily, last benefit that I want to talk about, is podcasting is not terribly expensive; it’s a relatively cost effective way to reach new customers. The initial investment is probably measured in hundreds of dollars to the very, very low thousands of dollars, you know, one to two thousand dollars per year.

                                                                        A quality podcasting microphone is going to cost you less than $100 for most podcasters. And if you want to go to something a little fancier, probably no more than a few hundred dollars. There are also free podcast hosting services, but if you’re really going to commit to this, in all reality, you’re still only going to pay maybe tens of dollars per month. You know, decent hosting, depending on the size of your podcast audience, depending on how many episodes you’re going to create, probably isn’t going to cost you more than maybe $500 to $1,000 per year.

                                                                        The software you need ranges from free, something like GarageBand or Audacity, to subscription services that, again, cost in the tens of dollars per month. All told, you can do this really efficiently economically. Most businesses will probably spend in the range of five or six hundred dollars in the first year. And, unless you get really big, you’re almost certainly not going to spend more than maybe $1,500 for the first year.

                                                                        The biggest expense, and we will talk about this in some length in a moment, is time. So hang on to that notion.

                                                                        All of these points lead to the big question of this episode, which is should you have a podcast for your business? And the answer I’m going to give you you’re going to hate on what level after all this, but the answer is “maybe.”

                                                                        I want to be really fair. There is no one absolutely true universal answer here. There are a lot of variables that come into play. I’ve already made the case for why you should do podcasts:

                                                                        • They help you establish authority and expertise
                                                                        • You’ve got easy content reuse
                                                                        • You’ve got broad content distribution
                                                                        • They help you establish a personal connection with your customers
                                                                        • They’re relatively inexpensive
                                                                        • And they help you bypass the gatekeepers.
                                                                        • What I do want to say, though, is there are a series of questions you need to ask to determine if a podcast makes sense for your business. And that’s really where I want to focus the rest of this episode.

                                                                          The first big question is, how is your podcast going to tie into your marketing efforts and into your business objectives? Don’t think of a podcast as a standalone effort. It almost certainly should connect with your other marketing activities and definitely should connect with your overarching business objectives. Does the podcast help you reach a different audience? Does it help you extend your brand? Does it humanize your company? Does it help you grow your revenues or your profits? Remember, podcasts are a cost effective way to reach an audience, but that cost effectiveness only matters if the audience ultimately takes some action that matters to your business.

                                                                          By the way, I want to be clear, this doesn’t have to be purely commercial. I know of one company that has a really cool podcast targeted at college students to help humanize the company and show why they’re a great place to work. So it ties back to a business objective, even though it’s not necessarily tied to a revenue objective. So you need to make sure your podcast, if you do one, is tied into your marketing and your overarching business objectives.

                                                                          The second question you need to ask is, who are you making your podcast for? Who do you want to talk with? Like that example I just gave about the company with the college students. You also need to ask, do those people, who ideally are your customers, listen to podcasts?

                                                                          There are a lot of people out there who listen to podcasts. More than 80 million people in the U. S. listen to podcasts on a weekly basis. And global numbers are pretty good too.

                                                                          Roughly 40 percent of the listeners to this podcast are in the U.S., which is a significant plurality. But we have listeners in Sweden, the U.K., Portugal, Switzerland, Australia, India, Germany, Singapore, the Netherlands, and so on. It’s a global reach and happily concentrated in countries where our company does business. You just want to do the research to make sure that the people you want to reach are a good audience for podcasts. Because if they’re not, then making a podcast, you know, this is not a, if you build it, they will come. If they’re not doing the activity you want them to do, listening to podcasts in this specific case, then having a great podcast might get you an audience, but it’s not one that’s going to build your business. So be very clear about who you’re making your podcast for.

                                                                          The next question you need to ask is, do you know what you’re going to talk about? Now that might seem obvious. But you’re going to create between 12 and 48 episodes a year. You know, you’re gonna create anywhere from a monthly podcast to a weekly podcast with probably a few weeks off. So you need to say, is this something we can talk about for a dozen or a few dozen episodes every year?

                                                                          And as you’re asking that question, you also need to ask, what makes your topic, your episode, the one that listeners will choose? Why will listeners choose your podcast over all the other podcasts out there?

                                                                          The numbers vary. There are probably between 3.5 million and 4.5 million different shows out there. Hundreds of thousands of those active shows today, so you want to say, what helps set me apart? Now, that’s in total. That doesn’t mean there are millions on your specific topic, and that number might sound large, but think about how many pages exist on the internet about your topic. I did a search for “hotel marketing,” which is something I talk about, and it returned 909 million results. I did one for “Digital Strategy,” and it brought, brought back 1,730,000,000 results on Google. So, you know, even if there were 3 million podcasts out there about those topics, that’s still small compared to Google. There’s an opportunity to cut through. I just need to make sure I’m sufficiently differentiated.

                                                                          You need to make sure you’re sufficiently differentiated as to why customers are going to listen to you versus someone else. They can’t listen to you both at the same time, realistically. So you want to be very clear on that answer.

                                                                          The next big question, is how long is each episode going to be? Now, there are different opinions here. I’m going to give you my opinion and my experience on this: Less is more.

                                                                          My good friend Ed St.Onge always likes to say that the job of every second of content you create is to earn the next second of your audience’s attention. The biggest mistake I see companies and people make with podcasts is that their shows are too long. I try to focus on being around 20 to 25 minutes for solo episodes, I mean ones where I’m not interviewing somebody, and usually around 45 minutes or less for interviews.

                                                                          I figure that a good podcast episode should be consumable during a workout or before people worked from home all the time during an office commute. You know, if it’s longer than that, it’s tough for people to listen to all in one sitting. So keep it in mind that less is more. I’m laughing as I say this because this episode is going to run about 40 minutes and it’s just a solo episode. It happens sometimes. Hopefully you’re on the treadmill a little longer this time.

                                                                          Just remember that less is more and that the job of every second of content is to earn one more second of your audience’s attention.

                                                                          To the point of earning that attention, think about what your format is going to be. Are you going to do a solo show? Are you going to do interviews? Are you going to do a panel? Any of these can work, and you can vary the format some. I’m mostly a solo show, and then we do some interviews, usually about one a month these days. But be very conscious of, why is this format the right one for the topic you want to talk about? I find a solo show works well for what I’m talking about because it tends to be my area of expertise. And because, literally, this is called Thinks Out Loud, we’re really kind of exploring this together. I don’t claim to have all the answers, I want to make sure that I’m posing the questions and hearing from you about what some of those answers might be as well.

                                                                          The next big question, and this gets to a core, is are you prepared to do the work? This is a biggie. I told you one of the biggest expenses was going to be your time. Podcasting rewards consistency, whether you do it once a week, every other week, or once a month. You need to commit to that. Data shows, and we’ve found with this show, that if you maintain a regular publishing schedule, your audience will grow over time. If you’re inconsistent, it’s very, very hard to establish an audience that will stick around. You can find a cadence that works for you, but once you find it, you’ve got to stick with it.

                                                                          And it’s also going to take some time to produce the episodes, especially at the beginning. I don’t know overall stats. I don’t know what everybody else’s world looks like. But I am happy to share my team’s experience. I tend to work from an outline rather than a firm script. Yes, you can use ChatGPT or Gemini or Microsoft Copilot to help build that outline. It’s still going to take you maybe a half hour, up to maybe two hours, depending on how scripted you’re going to be, to develop that script, that outline.

                                                                          Recording takes about as long as you expect the episode to be, plus, in my experience, 25-50% more. You know, so a 30 minute episode usually takes around 35-45 minutes to record.

                                                                          If you’re interviewing guests, researching those guests is going to vary widely. But figure that you or someone on your team is going to spend at least an hour or two on that. In fact, I’d recommend that you do. You need to do your homework. If you don’t do your homework, you’re going to have very, very bad interviews, and that’s going to be very bad for your podcast, and very bad for your guest, and very bad for your brand.

                                                                          Do you ever watch that YouTube show, Hot Wings, that’s really popular right now, really cool show? One of the reasons is because its host and his producers Find amazing details about their guests to discuss with them each week. That just makes for a better show. So, expect you’re gonna put in some work there. Editing varies widely. In our experience, editing and prepping an episode that includes, you know, collecting the show notes, it includes writing up the little intro and everything, that usually takes 30 to 40 minutes per week.

                                                                          So if you think about it, a typical episode that we do takes anywhere between one-and-a-half to two person-hours or thereabouts every week to publish. That’s a time commitment. That’s a pretty significant time commitment. So you need to make sure you’re willing to make that commitment.

                                                                          If you’re going to do an interview or a longer episode, such as last week’s quarterly Big Tech earnings call episode, that could be four to five person hours.

                                                                          I want to be fair, the upside is that those quarterly episodes spur a ton of content reuse. I’m going to reference stats and observations from that episode for at least the next quarter. Notice today’s episode started with a reference to Google’s lack of vision, i.e., last week’s episode. It’s an investment that pays off over time.

                                                                          The same tends to be true with interviews. Interviews tend to get broader distribution because they’re introducing the podcast to new audiences. If nothing else, guests share the episode with their network, which expands your reach. The investment can pay off. You also want to be clear that it is an investment.

                                                                          So are you committed to doing the work? If you don’t think you can maintain your chosen publishing schedule, if you don’t think you can maintain the amount of time it’s going to take you to put together a quality episode, even if it’s an hour a week, the podcasting might not be for you or your business.

                                                                          I’d add that’s all true in terms of doing the work for your host, too. Having a consistent host ends to work better. It’s tougher to build personal relationships if there isn’t a single person or a, you know, a common group of people that your audience comes to know. You also need to learn the skills. You know, if you’re gonna interview, learning how to be a good interviewer. If you’re going to moderate a panel, learning how to moderate. You’re going to have to learn some basic editing skills. And learn how to convey information. Learning to host if you’re going to be the host yourself.

                                                                          I want to be clear, none of this is especially hard on its own. These are also skills like any others. You need to commit to getting better at the ones that matter if you’re going to have a good show. Audiences tend to be okay with casual discussions. They want your show to be a good hang as much as anything else. They also aren’t going to live with something that’s too raw or amateurish. You’re competing with potentially thousands of other shows. Make sure that that good hang is worth your audience’s time.

                                                                          I mentioned some of the expenses before. You know, investing in a good microphone, investing in good headphones, investing in good hosting. Those are table stakes. You just need to do that.

                                                                          And then the last part of doing the work is you’ve got to promote. Like all content marketing, podcasts require promotion. Are you willing to dedicate the time and resources necessary to promote your episodes? I’d argue that if the answers to all of the other questions I’ve just asked are “yes,” then this one probably should be a yes too. But you do have to plan and budget for this effort just like you would with other forms of promotion. Again, promoting the podcast is table stakes. If you’re not willing to do it, it’s probably not the right medium for you.

                                                                          For me, personally, my answers to all of these questions are yes. Yes, I’m very much committed to that. I find that podcasting is incredibly worth it for my business. I’m also still learning. I’m always trying to get better. The team is always trying to get better. The work that the folks behind the scenes do, they’re all working hard to get better. I tend to think, and we have found, that these efforts are worth it, and undervalued by far too many companies.

                                                                          If you’re trying to connect directly with customers, to build deep relationships, a lasting community, and bypass Big Tech, consider podcasting. I can’t say that every business should have a podcast, I can say that it’s a really good idea for every business to take a long look at the platform and decide whether it makes sense for their business.

                                                                          Which I guess is one more item I can add to my core beliefs.

                                                                          If your business has a podcast, let me know about it. I’d love to hear what you’re doing and what you’ve learned from the process. I think it’d make for a great discussion. Thanks for hanging with me while we talked this through. I just so appreciate everything that you do for us.

                                                                          Show Wrap-Up and Credits

                                                                          Now, looking at the clock on the wall, we are out of time for this week.

                                                                          And I want to remind you again that you can find the show notes for this episode. As well as an archive of all past episodes by going to timpeter.com/podcast. Again, that’s timpeter.com/podcast. Just look for episode 413.

                                                                          Subscribe to Thinks Out Loud

                                                                          Don’t forget that you can click on the subscribe link in any of the episodes that you find there to have Thinks Out Loud delivered to your favorite podcatcher every single week. You can also find Thinks Out Loud on Google Podcasts, Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube Music, anywhere fine podcasts are found.

                                                                          Leave a Rating or Review for Thinks Out Loud

                                                                          I would also very much appreciate it if you could provide a positive rating or review for the show whenever you use one of those services.

                                                                          If you like what you hear on Thinks Out Loud, if you enjoy what we talk about, if you like being part of the community that we’re building here, please give us a positive rating or review. Reviews help other listeners find the podcast. Reviews help other listeners understand what Thinks Out Loud is all about. They help to build our community and they mean the world to me. So thank you so much for doing that. I very, very much appreciate it.

                                                                          Thinks Out Loud on Social Media

                                                                          You can also find Thinks Out Loud on LinkedIn by going to linkedin.com/tim-peter-and-associates-llc. You can find me on Twitter or X or whatever you want to call it this week by using the Twitter handle @tcpeter. And of course, you can email me by sending an email to podcast(at)timpeter.com. Again, that’s podcast(at)timpeter.com.

                                                                          Show Outro

                                                                          Finally, and I know I say this a lot, I want you to know how thrilled I am that you keep listening to what we do here. It means so much to me. You are the reason we do this.

                                                                          You’re the reason we make Thinks Out Loud happen. So please keep your messages coming on LinkedIn, on Twitter, via email. I love getting a chance to talk with you, to hear what’s going on in your world, and to learn how we can do a better job building the types of content and community and insights and information that work for you and work for your business.

                                                                          So with all that said, I hope you have a fantastic rest of your day, I hope you have a wonderful week ahead, and I will look forward to speaking with you here on Thinks Out Loud next time. Until then, please be well, be safe, and as ever, take care, everybody.

                                                                          The post Can Podcasting Help Your Business Bypass the Big Tech Gatekeepers? (Thinks Out Loud Episode 413) appeared first on Tim Peter & Associates.

                                                                          39 min
                                                                        • Google Lacks Vision: Big Tech Earnings and the State of Digital Q1 2024 (Thinks Out Loud Episode 412)

                                                                          If we learned anything from Big Tech’s earnings this quarter, it’s that Microsoft, Meta, Amazon, and Apple have a clear vision for the future & and that Google doesn’t. Don’t get me wrong. They have a vision. It’s just a bad one. Their vision: Ads, ads, and more ads. The only thing they seem to know how to talk about, the only thing they seem to know how to do, is sell ads. Their grand vision for artificial intelligence is about how to improve the ad experience and use AI to place ads alongside tools like Search Generative Experience.

                                                                          Where are the other members of Big Tech focusing their vision? Why is Google’s lack of vision a big deal? And what does all of that mean for your business? That’s what this episode of the Thinks Out Loud podcast is all about.

                                                                          Want to learn more? Here are the show notes for you.

                                                                          Google Lacks Vision: Big Tech Earnings and the State of Digital Q1 2024 (Thinks Out Loud Episode 412) Headlines and Show Notes
                                                                          Show Notes and Links
                                                                          • Desktop operating system market share 2013–2023 | Statista
                                                                          • Animation: Internet Browser Market Share (1996–2019)
                                                                          • History of Microsoft – Wikipedia
                                                                          • Internet Explorer – Wikipedia
                                                                          • Browser Market Share Worldwide | Statcounter Global Stats
                                                                          • 2023 Q4 Earnings Call – Alphabet Investor Relations
                                                                          • Q4 2023 Alphabet earnings release PDF link
                                                                          • Google 10K 2023 PDF link
                                                                          • 34 Eye-Opening Google Search Statistics for 2024
                                                                          • Amazon.com, Inc. – Overview
                                                                          • Amazon.com, Inc. – Amazon.com Announces Fourth Quarter Results
                                                                          • Amazon.com, Inc. – Quarterly results
                                                                          • Amazon.com, Inc. – Amazon.com Announces Fourth Quarter Results
                                                                          • Amazon 2023 Financial PDF link
                                                                          • Amazon earnings call transcript PDF link
                                                                          • Microsoft Investor Relations – Home Page
                                                                          • FY24 Q2 – Press Releases – Investor Relations – Microsoft
                                                                          • Microsoft Earnings Call Transcript FY24Q2
                                                                          • Microsoft Earnings Slides FY24Q2 PPTX
                                                                          • 2024 Predictions: Putting AI in Marketing to Work (Thinks Out Loud Episode 409)
                                                                          • Amazon, Google, Facebook, Apple and Microsoft Have a Secret Plan Right Now. Here’s Why You Should Care (Thinks Out Loud Episode 286)
                                                                          • META Q4 2023 Earnings Call Transcript PDF link
                                                                          • Meta-12.31.2023 – Exhibit 99.1 PDF link
                                                                          • Meta Earnings Presentation – Q4 2023 PDF link
                                                                          • X (Twitter) Statistics: How Many People Use X? (2024)
                                                                          • Apple Earnings Call – Apple
                                                                          • Apple Consolidated Financial Statements PDF link
                                                                          • Apple 10-K 2023 PDF link
                                                                          • Apple Inc. (NASDAQ:AAPL) Q1 2024 Earnings Call Transcript
                                                                          • Apple Inc. (NASDAQ:AAPL) Q1 2024 Earnings Call Transcript – Insider Monkey
                                                                          • You might also enjoy this webinar I recently participated in with Miles Partnership that looked at "The Power of Generative AI and ChatGPT: What It Means for Tourism & Hospitality" here:

                                                                            Free Downloads

                                                                            We have some free downloads for you to help you navigate the current situation, which you can find right here:

                                                                            • A Modern Content Marketing Checklist. Want to ensure that each piece of content works for your business? Download our latest checklist to help put your content marketing to work for you.
                                                                            • A Brief Introduction to Thinks Out Loud. As a bonus, we’ve also included this PDF document that highlights some of our core episodes to help you dig into what the show is about. We think it will help you capture the show’s essence while you’re working your way through the 300-plus episodes published so far. Download it here.
                                                                            • Digital & E-commerce Maturity Matrix. As a bonus, here’s a PDF that can help you assess your company’s digital maturity. You can use this to better understand where your company excels and where its opportunities lie. And, of course, we’re here to help if you need it. The Digital & E-commerce Maturity Matrix rates your company’s effectiveness — Ad Hoc, Aware, Striving, Driving — in 6 key areas in digital today, including:
                                                                              • Customer Focus
                                                                              • Strategy
                                                                              • Technology
                                                                              • Operations
                                                                              • Culture
                                                                              • Data
                                                                              • Subscribe to Thinks Out Loud
                                                                                • Subscribe in iTunes
                                                                                • Subscribe in the Google Play Store
                                                                                • Contact information for the podcast: [email protected]

                                                                                  Past Insights from Tim Peter Thinks
                                                                                  Technical Details for Thinks Out Loud

                                                                                  Recorded using a Shure SM7B Vocal Dynamic Microphone and a Focusrite Scarlett 4i4 (3rd Gen) USB Audio Interface into Logic Pro X for the Mac.

                                                                                  Running time: 32m 02s

                                                                                  You can subscribe to Thinks Out Loud in iTunes, the Google Play Store, via our dedicated podcast RSS feed (or sign up for our free newsletter). You can also download/listen to the podcast here on Thinks using the player at the top of this page.

                                                                                  Transcript: Google Lacks Vision: Big Tech Earnings and the State of Digital Q1 2024

                                                                                   Well, hello again, everyone, and welcome back to Thinks Out Loud, your source for all the digital expertise your business needs. My name is Tim Peter. This is episode 412 of The Big Show, and thank you so much for joining us. I think we’ve got a really cool show for you today. So, in the late 1990s, Microsoft Windows ran on more than 90 percent of the world’s personal computers.

                                                                                  That’s according to Wikipedia. And by 2003, Microsoft’s Internet Explorer web browser owned 95 percent of the market for web browsers. To people like me, to people at the time, Microsoft was the Borg, right? Resistance was futile. They were everywhere. And if you look today, despite the fact that Microsoft is doing some amazing things, and frankly, some of the coolest things they’ve ever done, they are nowhere near as dominant as they once were.

                                                                                  Windows is still a major operating system. Edge is still a browser people use. Microsoft is an enormous part of big tech. They’re also not inevitable in the way that they once were. You can live your entire life and never have to deal with Microsoft if you choose not to. A lot of people are choosing to work with Microsoft because they’re doing some really cool things.

                                                                                  But they’re not inevitable. You have options out there. You have choices out there. And there’s lots of reasons why this happened. But the biggest one, by far, was mobile. Microsoft missed the mobile moment. They tripped when it came to mobile. Because they didn’t want to upset the status quo they enjoyed with the desktop or the browser.

                                                                                  They were too afraid of hurting their core business to innovate in the ways that they probably should. And that’s what I think is happening to Google right now. You know that every quarter I take a look at the, uh, Big Tech earnings to see what they tell us about the current state of digital. And that’s what I see happening to Google right now.

                                                                                  They’re missing the AI moment in the same way that Microsoft missed the mobile moment. Now, I often talk about how Google might fail, particularly because so many of you depend on Google for so much of your traffic and so much of your business. I actually couldn’t care less what happens to Google as a company.

                                                                                  I care a lot about what happens to your business if Google goes away. And when I talk about how Google might fail, I might get a little hyperbolic sometimes. I don’t mean to suggest that Google will go out of business. What I do mean is, like Microsoft in the late aughts and early 2010s, Google could lose their cultural and technical dominance.

                                                                                  And that’s a huge issue for you if they lose mind share and market share. But to put this in terms that matter to Google, they made 86 billion dollars in revenue last quarter. Almost 300 billion dollars in revenue last year. And 76 percent of their revenues come from advertising. Most of that from search.

                                                                                  Uh, Ruth Porat, the company’s chief financial officer said search remained the largest contributor to revenue growth. And as new tools come around, new AI tools come around, we may see, and I would argue we are starting to see, People shift from using Google quite as much as they used to. Satya Nadella, Microsoft’s CEO, said that they saw both Edge and Search, Bing, gain market share in the last quarter.

                                                                                  Now, it might only be a point or something, but a point when you’re talking about a 300 billion business is a lot of money, right? If Google Search were to lose 20 percent of their dominant share, as Microsoft Windows has done, that’s 46 billion in lost revenue. I’m not even suggesting that they’ll lose 90 points of market share as Microsoft’s browsers have.

                                                                                  Just 20 percent of search. That would be a crushing blow for Google. 46 billion is more than Facebook has ever made in a single quarter. And theoretically, Google could lose that. That doesn’t mean they go away. They could still have immense market share. But if they went from 75 percent of the market to 25, uh, 55 percent of the market, that’s massive.

                                                                                  And it’s what I feel like I’m seeing in big tech’s quarterly earnings. Google lacks vision. I asked that as a question last year. There’s an episode where I asked, does Google lack vision? Now I’m stating it outright. The difference in what each of the big tech firms talked about in terms of where their companies are going and where their companies are growing and where Google is talking about is night and day.

                                                                                  I’m going to start with Microsoft. And I’m probably not going to talk too much about the money that everybody made. You can look this up easily enough, but they did great. In their comments, in their answers to questions, in their prepared remarks, Microsoft referenced artificial intelligence 117 times in an hour long presentation.

                                                                                  So that’s, you know, two a minute. Now, I want to be fair, about half of those were references to CoPilot, which is their product strategy for how they’re putting Microsoft, uh, how they’re putting AI into their various products. The other players have a more fragmented product strategy, and they’re not talking about them in quite the same way Microsoft was, so it’s tough to, you know, uh, compare apples to apples there.

                                                                                  But Satya Nadella, as he often does, made the quote of the day where he said we’ve moved from talking about AI to applying AI at scale. I talked about this in a podcast episode a few weeks ago. This is the next challenge for you as a marketer. For you as a business professional. It’s about putting AI to work, whether it’s in marketing, whether it’s in sales, whether it’s in operations.

                                                                                  It’s about putting AI to work. It’s not enough to talk about it. You’ve gotta apply it, and if you’re Microsoft, apply it at scale. Nadella referred to this AI moment, just the whole idea, like mobile, that AI is the thing that we must all get our arms around today. And he laid out such a compelling vision for where the world is going.

                                                                                  He said that their own research, as well as external studies, quote, show as much as a 70 percent improvement in productivity using generative AI for specific work tasks. And overall, early co pilot for Microsoft 365 users were 29 percent faster in a series of tasks like searching, writing, and summarizing.

                                                                                  He went on to say that it, generative AI, is going to have a very, very foundational impact. And my favorite thing that he stated was he said the demand signal, the deployment signal, it’s faster than anything else because it’s easier, right? I mean, it sort of shows up in your apps, you click on it like any ribbon thing, and it becomes a daily habit.

                                                                                  I’m quoting him at some length here. He said, in fact, it reminds me a little bit of sort of back in the day of PC adoption, right? It first starts off with a few people having access. PCs became standard issue at some point after PCs being adopted by early adopters. I think that’s the cycle that at least we expect.

                                                                                  This is a key point I’m saying. AI is becoming already a thing, just a thing. It becomes invisible as all technology becomes invisible. It just becomes something we use. Now when I say technology becomes invisible, a light switch is technology. You probably never even think about it. Air conditioning is technology.

                                                                                  You probably never think about that. Your phone is technology, but often you don’t even think about that. It’s just a thing you pull out of your pocket and use. And AI is beginning to show that same behavior pattern. This is what I mean when I talk about having vision. Again, Nadella laid out this really clear use case of summarizing documents, of drafting emails or documents, of chat and the way that you can chat with your documents.

                                                                                  This is an amazing statement. He said, The database of your documents and communications now queryable by natural language in a powerful way. I can go and say what are all the things Amy said I should be watching out for next quarter and it will come out in great detail. You’ll see work and workflow change as people summarize faster, draft regulatory submissions faster, chat to get knowledge from your business.

                                                                                  It’s going to be standard issue like a PC. I mean that’s That’s amazing in terms of being clear about where we’re going with this. He had a funny line, he said, If you take away a spell check from Word, I’ll be unemployable. And similarly, it’ll be like GitHub Copilot becomes core to anybody who is doing software development.

                                                                                  It’s not just tools, it’s about productivity of your dev team. Now obviously, Satya Nadella is talking about. Developers, but scale that to your marketing team, your finance team, your operations team, your legal team, and so on. That’s a compelling portrait of where they think they’re going, where they think we’re all going.

                                                                                  And they weren’t the only ones. Mark Zuckerberg on Facebook’s earnings call also laid out an incredibly compelling vision. And when you think about it, you know, Facebook has had some ups and downs over the last couple of years, but they had an amazing quarter. They’re, they’re doing tremendous, tremendous work.

                                                                                  One of the things that Mark Zuckerberg said among his 74 references to AI or Artificial Intelligence was a major goal will be building the most popular and advanced AI products and services. If we succeed, everyone who uses our services will have a world class AI assistant. To help get things done, every creator will have an AI that their community can engage with, every business will have an AI that their customers can interact with to buy goods and get support, and every developer will have a state of the art open source model to build with.

                                                                                  He talked about how they’ve been working on general intelligence, artificial general intelligence, for more than a decade. And he believes that that’s going to be necessary to reach the next generation of services. I don’t know that he’s right. I’m not qualified to know if he’s right or wrong. But he said, we’re going to need our models to be able to reason, plan, code, remember, and many other cognitive abilities in order to provide the best versions of the services that we envision.

                                                                                  Again, very clear vision of where they want to go and where they believe we’re all headed. And I want to be fair. They’re still talking about things like smart glasses. They’re still talking about the metaverse. And they’re talking about how you tie the metaverse together. How they will need to be connected to work well.

                                                                                  He said people are going to want new categories of devices that let you frictionlessly engage with AIs throughout your day without having to take out your phone and press a button and point it at what you want it to. That’s compelling. I don’t know that he’s right, but it’s compelling about how these devices might work together.

                                                                                  And they’re executing really well. I’ve talked many times before about ideas are one thing, but you have to be able to execute. They launched Threads, uh, six months ago, seven months ago. It already has more than 130 million monthly actives, which is amazing, amazing, given how hurriedly introduced it was while Elon Musk started burning Twitter to the ground.

                                                                                  It’s made it to about a quarter of the size of Twitter in roughly six months. That’s remarkable. That’s clear execution, clear focus on execution in a way that’s working really well for them. And it’s clear that they have a vision of where they want to go. Now some of this might be because their growth is slowing in other areas.

                                                                                  Um, you know, it’s tough for them to get much bigger. Uh, uh, Microsoft said, excuse me, Microsoft, Mark Zuckerberg said, At least 3. 1 billion people use at least one of our apps each day. That’s basically two out of every five people you encounter in a day. They’re using one of Meta’s apps, whether it’s Instagram, whether it’s WhatsApp, whether it’s Threads, whether it’s Facebook.

                                                                                  And they had said that they’re going to stop reporting Facebook specific metrics, probably because its growth has slowed down enough that all the growth is coming somewhere else. . The last thing I wanna say about Facebook before I move on to the next player in our game here is that they said that they’re increasing their capital expenditures, their investments in infrastructure, people, and products by about $2 billion this year, up to about $37 billion this year.

                                                                                  Now. We’ve heard a lot about tech layoffs in the last year, including in the last six months. That’s true for many of the big tech players. They’ve been having layoffs all over the place. However, what I think we’re seeing since I started this episode talking about things back in the, you know, aughts and, uh, late nineties and the like is there was a term that used to get used a lot called right sizing, right?

                                                                                  You weren’t downsizing. You were right sizing where we’re losing people in one area because we need people in another area. And if you look at most of the big tech companies, First of all, they still have way more employees, in many cases 50 percent more than they did at the beginning of the pandemic.

                                                                                  Secondly, they are hiring. Um, one of the things that Facebook’s CFO talked about was that they’ve had a current hiring underrun. You know, which is a fancy way of saying we need more people, especially those with technical skills. Facebook specifically has cut about 20, 000 people in the last year, but that’s after they almost doubled in the size between 2019 and 2022.

                                                                                  They went from about 45, 000 people in the company to 86, 500. They’re still at almost 65, 000 folks, roughly 20, 000 people larger than they were pre pandemic. So, for all the doom and gloom, and I want to be fair, it’s unfortunate for the people who get laid off. It’s terrible for the people getting laid off.

                                                                                  They clearly are still hiring and bringing people in. They’re just trying to be lean. Not small. They’re trying to invest in resources, in people, where they have the greatest opportunity for success. Which they clearly see as AI and the Metaverse, but again, it’s a clear vision. Amazon. I want to talk about them.

                                                                                  They had 41 artificial intelligence references in their, in their earnings call. Andy Jassy, uh, and Brian Olszewski, their CFO. Um, they talked about new personalized size recommendations powered by AI. They talked about Rufus, its new generative AI powered conversational shopping experience. They talked about new generative AI ad solutions for lifestyle imagery.

                                                                                  They talked about Q, its coding companion for developers. By the way, Andy Jassy said, if you can get 30 40 percent better productivity for your developers, it’s a game changer. They talked about something called AVI, it’s Automated Vehicle Inspection Tool for Amazon Delivery Vans. They’re investing in AI at every part of the value chain.

                                                                                  And, I can’t, I cannot hesitate enough, I can’t emphasize enough, excuse me, talking about how Speaking of vision, Amazon increasingly looks like Buy and Large. If you remember Pixar’s film WALL E, you know, Buy and Large had everything. Amazon literally is the everything store. And I don’t just mean in terms of things you can buy, but in terms of all of their various offerings.

                                                                                  They have shopping, as we well know. They have Amazon Web Services, as we all know. So you can host, you know, websites or apps or things like that. They have Amazon Prime Air for delivery. They’ve released 16 films and TV shows from their MGM subsidiary. They broadcast Thursday night football. They’re now gonna start selling cars in collaboration with Hyundai.

                                                                                  They’ve got a new healthcare division that they’re doing. They’ve got satellites through its Project Kuiper subsidiary. They design their own computing chips, though, to be fair, that’s pretty much true across all of the big tech companies. But Amazon’s customers include Anthropic, Airbnb, Qualtrics, Ricoh, Snap.

                                                                                  They really are the everything store. And when you talk about vision, one of the most remarkable statements from Andy Jassy was when he said about their investments in something called One Medical, or their partnership with something called One Medical. He said, I think that the healthcare experience, particularly in the U.

                                                                                  S., is a pretty frustrating one, not a very good one. I’m skipping a bit here, but he says, when we tell our grandkids that the way you used to have to go get primary care was to make an appointment three weeks in advance and then drive 20 minutes to the doctor, park, wait in the reception for 15 minutes.

                                                                                  Get put in an exam room for 15 minutes, doctor comes in, talks to you for 5 to 10 minutes, and then you’ve got to drive 20 minutes to the pharmacy. Our grandkids will not believe that that was the experience. And it’s not going to be. Again, vision, and they see themselves powering this. Just like Facebook, just like Microsoft, they are doing a, they’re saying we anticipate CapEx, capital expenditures, to increase year over year, primarily driven by increased infrastructure to support growth of our AWS business, including investments in generative AI and large language models.

                                                                                  Vision. They have a vision. Last people I want to talk about before I beat the hell out of, I mean before I talk about Google, is Apple. Who I will spend very little time on, but no pun intended, not only do they have Vision, they launched their Apple Vision Pro VR headset the other day. Um, I have thoughts about this, it’s gonna take too long to talk about, it’ll be another episode.

                                                                                  But, it’s something that, you know, Apple has over 2. 2 billion active devices out there. And, they’ve said that, uh, this is a quote, We’ve always said we will never under invest in the business. We are making all the investments that are necessary throughout our product development, software development, services deployment.

                                                                                  And so, we will continue to invest in every area of the business at the appropriate level. And Tim Cook talked about we’ve got some things that we are incredibly excited about that we’ll be talking about later this year with regard to AI. I think there’s a huge opportunity for Apple with Gen AI and AI, and without getting into more details and getting out in front of myself, um, that’s kind of where he tailed off.

                                                                                  So they didn’t talk about AI as much as other people, but they clearly see opportunities here. So, what did we hear from Microsoft? We heard Vision. What did we hear from Facebook? We heard Vision. What did we hear from Amazon? We heard Vision. What did we hear from, uh, Apple? We heard Vision. Pun kind of intended.

                                                                                  What did we hear from Google? We heard a lot about how much they depend on ads. They get almost, like I said, 76 percent of their revenues from, uh, ads. Search remaining the largest individual contributor to revenue growth. They said, we entered 2024 with advertising revenues of more than a hun more than a hundred billion dollars higher than 2019.

                                                                                  They talked a lot about how subscriptions like YouTube Premium and YouTube Music are driving revenues for them. That’s great, but again, it’s selling content. They talked about AI about 76 times, um, either AI or Gemini and their AI models. And when they talked about Gemini, what did they talk about?

                                                                                  Automatically created assets, a big component of their ads platform. This is a quote, uh, early tests show advertisers are building higher quality search campaigns with less efforts, especially SMBs who are 42 percent more likely to publish a campaign with good or excellent air strength. Philip Schindler, their, uh, chief business officer said, AI has been at the core of our advertising products for a very, very long time.

                                                                                  They talked about, we are surfacing more links within search generative experience and linking to a wider range of sources on the results page and will continue to prioritize approaches that add value for our users and send valuable traffic to publishers. Ads will continue to play an important role in the new search experience and will continue to experiment with new formats native to SGE.

                                                                                  What? That’s their vision. Their vision is more ads. That’s it. That’s all they talked about. And I feel bad, because they talk a little bit about what they’re doing for developers, and they talk a little bit about the challenges that they have with search, which I agree with. Search is a hard problem. I’ve not built anything to the scale that Google has, obviously.

                                                                                  Obviously. That’s like the understatement of the decade. You should roast me for that one. Um But I built search engines. They’re hard. Um, you know, one of the, one of the remarkable quotes, uh, uh, from, um, Sundar Pichai was he said, One of the things I think people underestimate about search is the breadth of search.

                                                                                  The amount of queries we see constantly on a new day, which we haven’t seen before. You know, if you think about the scale problems that Google has to solve for, that’s crazy. There are roughly 6 million searches every minute, roughly 8. 5 billion searches every day. That’s nuts! If even 1 percent of that 6 million searches per minute are brand new, that’s 60, 000 new searches every minute, 3.

                                                                                  6 million brand new searches every hour, 86. 5 million brand new searches every day, and almost 605 million brand new searches every week. And they gotta work hard to figure out how to put ads alongside them. Oh, wait, I’m not the only one criticizing them here. You probably saw one of their software engineers a couple weeks ago, wrote a lengthy piece on LinkedIn savaging the leaders, saying they don’t have a visionary leader within the company.

                                                                                  I wrote that or I said that in a podcast three months ago. She just came out and stated it as cold hard fact. And to bring us back to where I started this episode. That’s a huge problem, not just for Google, but for you. Because that’s how Google will lose market share. If they keep putting their emphasis on how do we create more ads, and how do we put ads alongside the things that people search for, and not into how do we make a better search product, how do we message that product better, how do we come up with a coherent product strategy rather than Gemini and Bard and Gemini Ultra, and all of these other different things that they’ve got out there that are too confusing.

                                                                                  Nexus, you know, just an amazing number of tools that aren’t clear to people. As opposed to Microsoft with Copilot, period. You know, Bing Copilot? Sure. Edge Copilot? Sure. 365 Copilot? Sure. But it’s always Copilot. That’s a clear vision, and Google, flat out, isn’t showing it yet. And to go back to the beginning, the reason I care, the reason that it matters so much, is because you get a lot of your business from Google.

                                                                                  If you’re like most businesses out there. And so you need to be thinking today about what do I do if Google drops by 10 points? What do I do if Google drops by 20 points? How do I ensure that the way I get my customers isn’t just by buying more ads on Google? Because that’s not a winning strategy.

                                                                                  That’s not winning for you in the long run. And then it won’t be Google’s lack of vision that’ll be a problem. It’ll be your own. Google today might feel like Microsoft did 20 years ago, where resistance is futile. You’re dominant. They’re dominant. You don’t have a choice. But you have a lot of choices.

                                                                                  And what their vision, or lack thereof, should show you, is that it’s time for you to make those choices. Starting with, how do you get more business from people who aren’t Google?

                                                                                  Show Wrap-Up and Credits

                                                                                  Now, looking at the clock on the wall, we are out of time for this week.

                                                                                  And I want to remind you again that you can find the show notes for this episode. As well as an archive of all past episodes by going to timpeter.com/podcast. Again, that’s timpeter.com/podcast. Just look for episode 412.

                                                                                  Subscribe to Thinks Out Loud

                                                                                  Don’t forget that you can click on the subscribe link in any of the episodes that you find there to have Thinks Out Loud delivered to your favorite podcatcher every single week. You can also find Thinks Out Loud on Google Podcasts, Apple Podcasts, Spotify, anywhere fine podcasts are found.

                                                                                  Leave a Rating or Review for Thinks Out Loud

                                                                                  I would also very much appreciate it if you could provide a positive rating or review for the show whenever you use one of those services.

                                                                                  If you like what you hear on Thinks Out Loud, if you enjoy what we talk about, if you like being part of the community that we’re building here, please give us a positive rating or review. Reviews help other listeners find the podcast. Reviews help other listeners understand what Thinks Out Loud is all about. They help to build our community and they mean the world to me. So thank you so much for doing that. I very, very much appreciate it.

                                                                                  Thinks Out Loud on Social Media

                                                                                  You can also find Thinks Out Loud on LinkedIn by going to linkedin.com/tim-peter-and-associates-llc. You can find me on Twitter or X or whatever you want to call it this week by using the Twitter handle @tcpeter. And of course, you can email me by sending an email to podcast(at)timpeter.com. Again, that’s podcast(at)timpeter.com.

                                                                                  Show Outro

                                                                                  Finally, and I know I say this a lot, I want you to know how thrilled I am that you keep listening to what we do every single week. It means so much to me. You’re the reason we do this.

                                                                                  You’re the reason we make Thinks Out Loud happen. So please keep your messages coming on Twitter, on LinkedIn, on email. I love getting a chance to talk with you, to hear what’s going on in your world, and to learn how we can do a better job building the types of content and community and insights and information that work for you and work for your business.

                                                                                  So with all that said, I hope you have a fantastic rest of your day, I hope you have a wonderful week ahead, and I will look forward to speaking with you here on Thinks Out Loud next time. Until then, please be well, be safe, and as ever, take care, everybody.

                                                                                  The post Google Lacks Vision: Big Tech Earnings and the State of Digital Q1 2024 (Thinks Out Loud Episode 412) appeared first on Tim Peter & Associates.

                                                                                  33 min
                                                                                • Big Trends: Bundling, Unbundling, and Customer Acquisition (Thinks Out Loud Episode 411)

                                                                                  Peter Drucker said it years ago: Your job is to create a customer. But creating a customer can be hard, especially as media and creators and influencers get bought out or burned out. Essentially, media is continually in a process of being bundled or unbundled, of integrating and dis-integrating. So, how are you supposed to acquire customers — to create customers — in that world?

                                                                                  The simple fact is that the world we all live in changes constantly. It’s true for your customers. It’s true for your business. But, there is a path by which you can connect with customers, acquire customers, and keep your customers no matter how much bundling or unbundling happens around you. And that’s what this episode of the Thinks Out Loud podcast is all about.

                                                                                  Want to learn more? Here are the show notes for you.

                                                                                  Big Trends: Bundling, Unbundling, and Customer Acquisition (Thinks Out Loud Episode 411) Headlines and Show Notes
                                                                                  Show Notes and Links
                                                                                  • Quote by Peter Drucker: “The purpose of business is to create and keep a customer” | Goodreads
                                                                                  • Belonging to the Brand: Why Community is the Last Great Marketing Strategy: Schaefer, Mark W.: 9781733553391: Amazon.com: Books
                                                                                  • The Future of Email Marketing — Interview with Scott Cohen from InboxArmy (Thinks Out Loud Episode 410)
                                                                                  • 2024 Predictions: Putting AI in Marketing to Work (Thinks Out Loud Episode 409)
                                                                                  • Is It Time for Your Marketing Team to Use AI? (Thinks Out Loud Episode 405)
                                                                                  • What "It’s All E-commerce" Means in 2024 (Thinks Out Loud Episode 404)
                                                                                  • What AI Will Do to Content Marketing (Thinks Out Loud Episode 402)
                                                                                  • Revisiting How to Escape Big Tech’s Web (Thinks Out Loud)
                                                                                  • The Single Biggest Myth in Digital: Content is Expensive (Thinks Out Loud Episode 275)
                                                                                  • How to engage your hotel’s secret sales force
                                                                                  • You might also enjoy this webinar I recently participated in with Miles Partnership that looked at "The Power of Generative AI and ChatGPT: What It Means for Tourism & Hospitality" here:

                                                                                    Free Downloads

                                                                                    We have some free downloads for you to help you navigate the current situation, which you can find right here:

                                                                                    • A Modern Content Marketing Checklist. Want to ensure that each piece of content works for your business? Download our latest checklist to help put your content marketing to work for you.
                                                                                    • A Brief Introduction to Thinks Out Loud. As a bonus, we’ve also included this PDF document that highlights some of our core episodes to help you dig into what the show is about. We think it will help you capture the show’s essence while you’re working your way through the 300-plus episodes published so far. Download it here.
                                                                                    • Digital & E-commerce Maturity Matrix. As a bonus, here’s a PDF that can help you assess your company’s digital maturity. You can use this to better understand where your company excels and where its opportunities lie. And, of course, we’re here to help if you need it. The Digital & E-commerce Maturity Matrix rates your company’s effectiveness — Ad Hoc, Aware, Striving, Driving — in 6 key areas in digital today, including:
                                                                                      • Customer Focus
                                                                                      • Strategy
                                                                                      • Technology
                                                                                      • Operations
                                                                                      • Culture
                                                                                      • Data
                                                                                      • Subscribe to Thinks Out Loud
                                                                                        • Subscribe in iTunes
                                                                                        • Subscribe in the Google Play Store
                                                                                        • Contact information for the podcast: [email protected]

                                                                                          Past Insights from Tim Peter Thinks
                                                                                          Technical Details for Thinks Out Loud

                                                                                          Recorded using a Shure SM7B Vocal Dynamic Microphone and a Focusrite Scarlett 4i4 (3rd Gen) USB Audio Interface into Logic Pro X for the Mac.

                                                                                          Running time: 24m 42s

                                                                                          You can subscribe to Thinks Out Loud in iTunes, the Google Play Store, via our dedicated podcast RSS feed (or sign up for our free newsletter). You can also download/listen to the podcast here on Thinks using the player at the top of this page.

                                                                                          Transcript: Big Trends: Bundling, Unbundling, and Customer Acquisition

                                                                                           Well, hello again, everyone, and welcome back to Thinks Out Loud, your source for all the digital expertise your business needs. My name is Tim Peter. This is episode 410 of the Big Show, and I think we’ve got a really cool episode for you today.

                                                                                          You know, one of the things that I think about a lot — what we do here, what my firm does, what I try to do, what my team tries to do — is we try to help our clients lower the cost of acquiring customers.

                                                                                          Fundamentally, that’s what we do. It’s so important to me that I’m writing a book about it. But we try to help clients get more customers for less money. That could be by helping with marketing. It could be by helping with customer experience. It could be by helping with their tech stack. And we do this for companies in hospitality, or travel, or SaaS, or technology, or financial services, what have you.

                                                                                          You know, lots of different things. When I talk about e commerce, or AI, which we’ve done in lots of recent shows, or email, like last week’s show, or what have you, it’s always coming from a place of lowering that cost of finding and connecting with customers. Fundamentally, you’ve heard me say this Drucker quote, that the first job of business is to create a customer.

                                                                                          And if we’re not doing that, if we’re not helping our clients do that, if we’re not helping you do that on this show, then we’re not doing our jobs. Now, of course, one of my favorite ways to do that is by keeping an eye on various trends that matter, that are either going to raise the cost of acquiring customers for you, or are going to lower your costs if you put them to work the right way.

                                                                                          I mean, that’s why I’m so hot on AI lately. And there is a big trend that’s going on right at the moment that gets overlooked a lot by me as much as anyone, I should add. And my epiphany on this, my realization on this, came from a conversation I was having with my friend Mark Schaefer last week. Mark is a great guy, big thinker, super, super smart dude, has written, I don’t know, 787 books or something like that.

                                                                                          He’s just the best guy and a really, really smart dude. And he is It’s rightly a big proponent of community, of user generated content, and of creators and influencers, in terms of their ability to help you reach your customers. And, in the case of community, of having customers help you reach more customers, help customers help themselves, and create greater experience.

                                                                                          His new book called Belonging to the Brand, his most recent book, is well worth a read on that very topic. And as much as he loves creators and influencers, and I do too, I think they’re tremendous, tremendous resources for you, he mentioned a limitation that exists among them, which is burnout. I’ve seen a bunch of folks I follow on YouTube in just the last few weeks dedicate entire episodes to the topic.

                                                                                          He’s talked, he was talking about in our conversation about people who just get fed up and can’t do it anymore. And if you think about it, how many television shows had amazing runs for their entire history? How many film sequels were as good as the original? Not many, right? It’s tough to sustain creativity.

                                                                                          And what you’re starting to see more of, and I think somebody like Mr. Beast would be a good example of this, though there are countless others, are creators who are becoming production companies. These aren’t solo operators or solopreneurs. They have an entire crew and company where they’re consolidating efforts.

                                                                                          They’re bringing people together. To, you know, make the work easier. And that really is the larger trend that I want to talk about. This idea of bringing things together. And the weird part is, I’m not going to just talk about bringing them together. I’m going to talk about bringing them together and splitting them apart.

                                                                                          Jim Barksdale, who was one of the founders of Netscape back in the day with Marc Andreessen and Jim Clark. Famously said, there are only two business models, bundling the unbundled and unbundling the bundles, right? If you think about the number of businesses out there that have been successful, they’re always either splitting off some feature or function from another business, or they’re taking a bunch of features and functions and putting them together.

                                                                                          You know Craigslist unbundled classified ads from newspapers. And, in fact, if you think about lots of services, they’re just like little things that used to be in newspapers, right? Instagram, unbundled the photo sharing functionality from Facebook, originally. On the bundling side to YouTube, bundled videos from everywhere.

                                                                                          They became the place where you could get everything Amazon bundled purchasing. Instead of going to 12 different stores, you can just go to Amazon and get everything. LinkedIn sort of unbundled your business contacts from, you know, wherever else you might have had them. Right? They’re just different ideas of this idea of bundling or unbundling, or if you prefer.

                                                                                          Integration and disintegration. We’re talking about ways you split apart, you know, the place that you go or you, you bring different places you go into one. And the reason I bring this up is because this has a lot of effect on what’s gonna happen with your marketing and what’s going to happen on the way you use digital to reach your customers.

                                                                                          See, bringing this back around to where I started today. I believe, I have long believed, and I think most people would agree, the best form of marketing is, was, and always shall be word of mouth. It’s why I always say that customer experience is queen. Your customers are your secret sales force. Every single person who you interact with has roughly 200 friends and family and fans and followers.

                                                                                          on various social networks, on various social connections. They, they tell your, those friends and family and fans and followers all about your products and services. They sometimes do this when they have a good experience. And they always do this, or pretty much always do this, when they have a bad experience.

                                                                                          That’s kind of how people are wired. They talk to what’s going on in their lives with their social network. And one of the things you have to remember is that social networks are not a technology platform. Social networks are people. Social is people. We call Meta and Facebook and Threads and Instagram and TikTok and LinkedIn and Discord and Snap social networks.

                                                                                          But they’re not. They’re platforms that connect people with their actual social network, with the people they care about. They’re still incredibly important as platforms because they’re where word of mouth happens a ton of the time. Not as much, maybe, as when you’re talking to people at dinner, or you’re talking to people at a nightclub, or you’re talking to people at a company meeting, but they talk to all their friends, and family, and fans, and followers on those platforms.

                                                                                          And, of course, influencers and creators are a form of word of mouth, at least to a point. Obviously, most of what they’re talking about is not your business, or not the companies they partner with, but some of the time they do, so they’re providing word of mouth opportunities for you. community is a form of word of mouth.

                                                                                          You know, my friend Mark Schafer’s thing that he’s beating the drum about, so, so rightly lately, it’s also, if you think about it, a form of unbundling, and this gets really important when we talk about, you know, burnout among creators and the like, because what community is doing is it’s moving the creation from a bundled point, the creator or the influencer or the brand.

                                                                                          To an unbundled group, the community. It’s user generated content at scale, where the content may just be the conversation that’s happening among the people in that community. The point is that we see this continual pendulum of bundling and unbundling, of integration and disintegration, and we’re kind of going through a period right now where that’s occurring, we’re moving forward.

                                                                                          From what seemed to be more of a centralized activity where the brand or the influencer or the creator was the centralized point. It’s starting to unbundle, it’s starting to disintegrate a little bit. I think we are in the early days of an unbundling period. People want to engage with their social networks.

                                                                                          Privately more than they did. They don’t want one place where people can go and see everything about them. They’re trying to, they’re trying to keep different groups of people separate from one another. Jeff Jarvis once referred to the difference between “the public” and “a public.” They’re okay with sharing information with a select group of people, but maybe they don’t want it shared with the world.

                                                                                          And if you look at things like Substack or Discord, those are more private communities or more private ways of sharing that, again, are sort of an unbundling, sort of. Substack’s a weird one because it’s bundling all these unbundled creators and bringing them into one place. So, you know, the pendulum doesn’t have to just move in one direction at any given time.

                                                                                          I suppose it’s sort of like Schrodinger’s pendulum. It depends on how you look at it at any given point. But a Substack, a subscription, or Discord, or things like that, those are more private. And your audiences are getting more discreet, more fragmented, and maybe a little more private. So we’re having a little more disintegration going on, a little more unbundling going on.

                                                                                          The point is that the way you get your message out Changes. It changes constantly and it is in this constant state of flux between a bundled situation and an unbundled situation. And what you need to be thinking about is how do you work in an environment, in a fragmented environment, in an unbundled environment, or in a bundled one that may later become unbundled and be prepared for it.

                                                                                          You know, work well in that environment. And there’s a handful of things you need to do, and the great thing is that these are things we’ve talked about before. The strategies don’t change that much. The tactics might change a lot, but the strategies don’t change tons. The first is you need to connect with your customers directly.

                                                                                          You need to build relationships with your customers wherever you build them. Whether you build them in your email list, whether you build them in a community, whether you build them through partnerships, whether you build them from getting people to use your app. It’s about connecting with customers directly.

                                                                                          And you need to have quality content to do that. You need to be a trusted resource that your customers can go to for at least some of their questions, right? So think in terms of quality content that addresses their needs. There’s a reason why I say content is king. You also don’t need to be the only people who create that content.

                                                                                          Real partnerships with creators that matter to your customers can be super effective as a form of content. And when I say real partnerships, I mean partner with people whose audience are your customers. Build relationships with those creators communities. This shouldn’t just be about paid placement. A.

                                                                                          It raises your costs, so let’s not do that, shall we? B. You’ll look like an outsider. You’ll look inauthentic. And C. You don’t really become Of the community, it makes it less likely that the people you’re interacting with are people who actually want to interact with you. This should be a mutually beneficial relationship.

                                                                                          At the same time, we should realize that some of these folks you’re working with might burn out. They might find things that are more interesting than what they’re talking about. They may evolve over time, so you don’t want to put all your eggs in that one basket. You should make sure you’re working with an array of creators, not necessarily 50 or 100 or 200.

                                                                                          But a set that makes sense to the scale of your business that you can work with effectively and manage. If you’re working with one creator, that’s probably not enough. If you’re working with 100, 000, you’ve got a bigger budget than most people. Congratulations, that’s fantastic. Right, but it’s, it’s finding the scale that fits your needs without relying solely on a single creator.

                                                                                          You also want to think about the hub and spoke model that we’ve talked about lots of times. You need a hub where all your content can be found, can be addressed. That’s your website, that’s your email, that’s your app. It could be a community that you create and that you run on behalf of your customers.

                                                                                          With the caveat that of course the minute you have a community, it belongs to the community as much as it belongs to you. So that one’s You know, a hub, but it may not be the most central part of your hub because you don’t have as much control there as you would like to, or you may want to in certain cases.

                                                                                          But you want to have those hubs available to you. And then the spokes are using channels like YouTube, using channels like Substack, using creators who you partner with, using channels like Instagram or, or LinkedIn, if you’re a B2B company to connect with customers where they are. The point, once again, is not to be disintegrated if one of those goes away, but to have an array of these spokes that you’re using that enable you to connect with customers where they are and not be dependent on anyone should two smart kids in a garage come along and blow one of them up one of these days.

                                                                                          You know, make it go away. And then the last core strategy that matters here is this idea of core and explore that we’ve talked about plenty of times here. You know, as I talk about this, it can be easy to get a little overwhelmed and say, well, that’s too many things. How do I do all of that? And the answer is you don’t.

                                                                                          And I mean, you start by putting 80 percent of your efforts or 90 percent of your efforts on the things that you know work and that continue to work well for you and you put most of your effort, most of your time, most of your money, most of your resources into the core, into the items that have proven successful for you again and again and again.

                                                                                          And then with the 10 or 20 percent that you have left over, you test. So you test with a creator. You test with a new channel. You test with a community that you join. Maybe don’t start your own, maybe join someone else’s as a genuine member of that community. But these are tests to see if they work, to see if you gain any traction.

                                                                                          If you find you’re not getting any traction, you either change what you’re doing or you change where you’re doing it. Just change the one thing and then see what happens there. But that’s the explore part, because you’re going to find some of those tests don’t work. And some of those tests are going to work really well for you and may eventually become part of your core because they outperform something that is in the core.

                                                                                          That’s okay. That’s normal. That’s why you do it this way. The point to remember there is that the way you reach customers continually changes. The way customers want you to reach them. Continually changes, and if you continue to always do what you’ve always done, you may be, you know, you may be sadly surprised to learn that it doesn’t work as well over time, which is why you have to continually be testing for new opportunities.

                                                                                          So, integration and disintegration, bundling and unbundling. Is a reality in the digital world. Is a reality in the business world. It’s been a reality forever and it’s unlikely to change. What we know is true is that customers still want to connect with trusted individuals and trusted brands on the topics that A.

                                                                                          matter to them and B. you’re a relevant resource for. So work to connect directly with customers. Work to create quality content that addresses their needs. Remember that content is king and customer experience is queen. So create great experiences that turn your secret sales force into influencers and creators on behalf of your brand in their social networks and in their communities, regardless of whether those happen online or offline.

                                                                                          Think in terms of real partnerships with creators that matter to your customers, whether they’re your customers themselves or whether they’re people who create content. Keep hub and spoke top of mind for how you do what you do. Make sure you’ve got a hub that you people can always find the content and community and customer experience that matter to them.

                                                                                          And also, using different spokes to reach customers in all of the various places that they are. And then lastly, Core and Explore. Focus most of your energies on the areas that work today and test 10 to 20 percent of the time on new things that will help your business in the longer term as we live through this pendulum swing between bundling and unbundling or integration and disintegration over time.

                                                                                          Because the one thing I will tell you is that’s a huge trend that we’ve seen again and again and again. It’s not going away anytime soon. It’s going to come back again and again and again. And you want to make sure that whether it’s in a bundle or whether it’s unbundled, people know where to find you.

                                                                                          Your customers know where to find you. And if you do that consistently, then you’re going to continue to be able to acquire customers without raising your costs over the long run. And that’s really the first job, as we said at the beginning. Your job is to create a customer and do it in a way that’s profitable to you.

                                                                                          The only thing I want you to do is do it in a way that it works, whether it’s bundled or unbundled. Put those pieces together properly for your business, and I guarantee you’ll be just fine, whether it’s an integrated solution or a disintegrated solution. Whether the creators you like burn out, or whether you find new ones altogether.

                                                                                          In any case, you’ll be creating customers who’ll be happy to work with you for years to come. Let me know how you’re making out. I can’t wait to hear what you do.

                                                                                          Show Wrap-Up and Credits

                                                                                          Of course, looking at the clock on the wall, we are out of time for this week.

                                                                                          And I want to remind you again that you can find the show notes for this episode. As well as an archive of all past episodes by going to timpeter.com/podcast. Again, that’s timpeter.com/podcast. Just look for episode 409.

                                                                                          Subscribe to Thinks Out Loud

                                                                                          Don’t forget that you can click on the subscribe link in any of the episodes that you find there to have Thinks Out Loud delivered to your favorite podcatcher every single week. You can also find Thinks Out Loud on Google Podcasts, Apple Podcasts, Spotify, anywhere fine podcasts are found.

                                                                                          Leave a Rating or Review for Thinks Out Loud

                                                                                          I would also very much appreciate it if you could provide a positive rating or review for the show whenever you use one of those services.

                                                                                          If you like what you hear on Thinks Out Loud, if you enjoy what we talk about, if you like being part of the community that we’re building here, please give us a positive rating or review. Reviews help other listeners find the podcast. Reviews help other listeners understand what Thinks Out Loud is all about. They help to build our community and they mean the world to me. So thank you so much for doing that. I very, very much appreciate it.

                                                                                          Thinks Out Loud on Social Media

                                                                                          You can also find Thinks Out Loud on LinkedIn by going to linkedin.com/tim-peter-and-associates-llc. You can find me on Twitter or X or whatever you want to call it this week by using the Twitter handle @tcpeter. And of course, you can email me by sending an email to podcast(at)timpeter.com. Again, that’s podcast(at)timpeter.com.

                                                                                          Show Outro

                                                                                          Finally, and I know I say this a lot, I want you to know how thrilled I am that you keep listening to what we do every single week. It means so much to me. You’re the reason we do this.

                                                                                          You’re the reason we make Thinks Out Loud happen. So please keep your messages coming on Twitter, on LinkedIn, on email. I love getting a chance to talk with you, to hear what’s going on in your world, and to learn how we can do a better job building the types of content and community and insights and information that work for you and work for your business.

                                                                                          So with all that said, I hope you have a fantastic rest of your day, I hope you have a wonderful week ahead, and I will look forward to speaking with you here on Thinks Out Loud next time. Until then, please be well, be safe, and as ever, take care, everybody.

                                                                                          The post Big Trends: Bundling, Unbundling, and Customer Acquisition (Thinks Out Loud Episode 411) appeared first on Tim Peter & Associates.

                                                                                          25 min

                                                                                        About Thinks Out Loud: E-commerce and Digital Strategy

                                                                                        From the publisher's feed

                                                                                        A weekly podcast exploring how e-commerce and digital trends shape your business and marketing strategy