On Halloween night, 1986, Chaim Weiss was found  in his dorm room in a Jewish Orthodox high school on Long Island, New York. His killer had entered his  room during the night and bludgeoned him with a sharp object while he slept. Despite the bizarre nature of the crime  no one was ever charged. For decades, the case has haunted investigators, his classmates, and the Jewish community.

Federal prosecutor Jonathan Luna was found face-down in a shallow creek in rural Pennsylvania; wounds covered his body. His bloodied car was left running…

Was it Murder? A cover-up? The FBI’s official ruling raised more questions than answers  and two decades later, this case still baffles investigators and the public alike.

In this episode, we explore the chilling timeline of Luna’s final hours, the eerie clues left behind, and the theories that continue to haunt this unsolved death.