Today, we're diving into one of the most significant and dramatic events in Scottish history—the death of King Duncan I on August 14, 1040. This moment not only changed the course of the Scottish monarchy but also inspired one of the most famous plays in the English language, Shakespeare's Macbeth.
King Duncan I, or Donnchad mac Crínáin in Gaelic, was born around 1001 in Atholl, in what is now modern-day Scotland. He ascended to the throne of Scotland, known as Alba, on November 25, 1034, following the death of his grandfather, King Malcolm II. Duncan's rise to power seemed to have been smooth, as there was no apparent opposition to his rule, which suggests that he may have been Malcolm’s acknowledged successor, or Tánaiste.
Duncan's lineage was prestigious; he was the son of Crínán, the hereditary lay abbot of Dunkeld, and Bethóc, Malcolm II’s daughter. This made Duncan the first monarch of the House of Dunkeld, a line that would continue to shape Scottish history for generations. However, Duncan's reign, which lasted a mere six years, would be marked by a series of military failures and ultimately, his untimely death.
Contrary to Shakespeare's portrayal, the historical Duncan I was not the old, kindly king we see in Macbeth, but rather a young and somewhat inexperienced ruler. His early reign was relatively uneventful, but this calm was not to last. In 1039, Duncan led a large army south to besiege Durham, in what appears to have been an ill-fated attempt to expand his influence into northern England. The campaign was a disaster, and Duncan barely escaped with his life.
Following this defeat, Duncan turned his attention northward, to Moray, a region in Scotland that was semi-autonomous and fiercely independent. Moray was ruled by Macbeth, a powerful nobleman and Duncan’s cousin, who served as his dux, a Latin term meaning "war leader." The relationship between Duncan and Macbeth was complex and fraught with tension, partly because of their competing claims to the throne and partly due to the nature of medieval Scottish politics, which often saw kinship ties and alliances shift rapidly.
In the summer of 1040, Duncan launched a campaign against Macbeth in Moray, likely aiming to assert his dominance over the region. The reasons for this campaign are not entirely clear, but it seems Duncan sought to curb Macbeth's growing power. The two armies met at Bothnagowan, near Elgin, a site now known as Pitgaveny. It was here, on August 14, 1040, that Duncan I was killed in battle by Macbeth and his forces.
Duncan’s death marked a pivotal moment in Scottish history. Macbeth, who had likely viewed Duncan as an ineffective ruler, assumed the throne and ruled Scotland for the next 17 years. Macbeth’s reign, contrary to the villainous depiction in Shakespeare’s play, was relatively stable and prosperous, earning him a place in history as a capable ruler.
As for Duncan, his legacy lived on through his sons. His eldest son, Malcolm III, would eventually overthrow Macbeth in 1057, reclaiming the throne and solidifying the House of Dunkeld's hold on Scotland. Duncan's second son, Donald III, would also become king, though his reign was much shorter and fraught with conflict.
Duncan I’s burial is thought to have taken place at Elgin, though his remains were later moved to the island of Iona, the traditional burial place of Scottish kings. Despite his short and tumultuous reign, Duncan I’s story is a crucial chapter in the history of Scotland, highlighting the brutal and often treacherous nature of medieval Scottish politics.
The events surrounding Duncan's death, particularly his conflict with Macbeth, have been immortalized by Shakespeare, though with significant dramatic license. The real story of Duncan I is one of a young king facing the harsh realities of medieval rule, marked by ambition, betrayal, and the violent struggle for power that characterized the period.
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit bagtown.substack.com