Charli Scott: A Disappearance in Maui

On a quiet Maui night in February 2014, 27-year-old Charli Scott left her family’s home. She was five months pregnant and expected to return.

She never did.

What began as a frantic search for a missing young woman quickly became something much darker. Her burned vehicle was discovered near one of Maui’s most remote areas, followed by clothing and other evidence scattered along the rugged coastline. Within weeks, police reclassified Charli’s disappearance as a homicide investigation.

But what happened to Charli that night?

And why did the investigation eventually focus on the man who was not only her former boyfriend, but the father of her unborn child?

In this episode of Til TRUTH Do Us Part, Shawna and David dig into the disappearance, the evidence, the competing stories surrounding that final night, and the investigation that ultimately led to a murder conviction.

This isn't just a story about what happened to Charli.

It's about the questions left behind when someone disappears—and how a family refuses to stop searching for the truth.

Where love, lies, and murder collide.

The Forgotten Files — Episode Two: Two Murders, Two Secrets

Two women. Two murders. Two courtroom dramas that captivated Virginia more than a century ago.

In this episode of The Forgotten Files, Shawna and David open two forgotten murder cases from nineteenth-century Virginia. First, we travel back to Richmond in 1885, where the death of 23-year-old Fanny Lillian Madison leads investigators to a young attorney, a shocking secret, and a trial that captured national attention.

Then we head west to Salem, Virginia, in 1891, where the murder of Susan Watkins in the mountains of Roanoke County sparks a fugitive manhunt, tangled relationships, questions of race and justice, and a courtroom battle that would end with a man facing the ultimate punishment.

No DNA. No surveillance cameras. No modern forensic technology.

Just witnesses, letters, physical evidence, newspaper headlines—and twelve people deciding whether the accused were guilty.

Were the right men convicted?

Or did the truth disappear somewhere inside the evidence?

The files are old. The questions aren't.

So grab your flashlight, open the case file, and join Shawna and David as they blow the dust off the files and begin.

The Fisher

What happens when the people you should be able to trust become the ones you fear most?

In this episode of Til TRUTH Do Us Part, Shawna and David dive into the disturbing story of the Fisher family murders—a case filled with betrayal, violence, unanswered questions, and a family tragedy that would leave an entire community shaken.

Join your delightfully diabolical storytelling duo as we separate the facts from the rumors, follow the investigation, and take a closer look at what happened behind closed doors.

Because sometimes the darkest secrets aren't hiding in the shadows… they're sitting right at the dinner table.

Listen closely, Truth Seekers. This one gets dark.

Tacky Tuesdays — Episode 2

Welcome back to Tacky Tuesdays, where the crimes are real, the choices are questionable, and sometimes you just have to ask… WHAT were they thinking?!

In Episode 2, Shawna and David dive into two bizarre true-crime stories that prove reality can be a whole lot stranger than fiction. First up, we’re talking about the Great Canadian Maple Syrup Heist—because apparently, even maple syrup can become the center of a multimillion-dollar crime.

Then things take a seriously strange turn with a repeat “butt” case that has us questioning how someone could possibly find themselves in the same kind of trouble more than once.

It’s weird. It’s wild. It’s tacky.

And, of course, Shawna and David are here to break it all down—with their usual mix of true crime, sarcasm, disbelief, and plenty of “you cannot make this stuff up” moments.

This is Tacky Tuesdays. You’ve been warned. 😈

Til TRUTH Do Us Part — Episode 5: The Harvey Family Murders

What if someone came into your home on New Year’s Day… while your family was there… and turned a place filled with music, laughter, and love into a crime scene?

In Episode 5 of Til TRUTH Do Us Part, Shawna and David take a heartbreaking look at the 2006 murders of Bryan and Kathryn Harvey and their daughters, Stella and Ruby, a Richmond, Virginia family whose lives were violently taken inside their own home. Bryan was a beloved Richmond musician, Kathryn was known for her vibrant personality and her Carytown business, World of Mirth, and together they were raising their two young daughters.

We walk through what happened, the investigation that followed, the men responsible, and the courtroom proceedings that ultimately led to Ricky Gray’s convictions and death sentence for the murders of Stella and Ruby.

But this episode isn't only about how the Harvey family died.

It's about who they were before the headlines.

Because Bryan, Kathryn, Stella, and Ruby were more than victims in a case file. They were a family with personalities, dreams, traditions, friends, and a life together that should have continued.

Join Shawna and David as they remember the Harvey family—and ask the questions that still linger long after the courtroom doors closed.

This is Til TRUTH Do Us Part.

The truth matters. The victims matter. And their stories deserve to be remembered.

The Forgotten Files — Episode One: The Murder of Louise Beattie

Step into the first file of The Forgotten Files, a historical true-crime mini-series built within Til TRUTH Do Us Part.

In our first case, we travel back to Virginia in 1911, where a wealthy young man, a troubled marriage, a forbidden relationship, and a deadly plan collide.

Henry Clay Beattie Jr. claimed a masked stranger stopped his automobile and shot his wife, Louise Owen Beattie, along a lonely Virginia road. But investigators quickly began looking beyond Henry's story—and what they uncovered would expose a tangled relationship with Beulah Binford, a young woman Henry had been seeing.

As the investigation unfolds, questions about motive, money, betrayal, and murder begin to surface. What really happened on that Virginia road? And how much of Henry Beattie's story was a lie?

Shawna and David open the first Forgotten File and take you inside a case that shocked Virginia more than a century ago.

The Forgotten Files is a biweekly Saturday mini-series within Til TRUTH Do Us Part, exploring historical true-crime cases—solved and unsolved—that deserve to be remembered.

Some files were never truly closed.

They were simply forgotten.

In just a second, we're opening our first file.

Tammy Thorpe: When Love Turns Deadly

In this episode of Til TRUTH Do Us Part, Shawna and David dive into the tragic and disturbing case of Tammy Thorpe—a story of relationships, betrayal, and a devastating loss that left more questions than answers.

Join our Delightfully Diabolical Duo as we take a closer look at what happened, the people involved, and the circumstances surrounding Tammy’s case. As always, we’ll separate the facts from the theories and ask the questions that still deserve answers.

Because sometimes the truth is darker than fiction—and sometimes, the motive is hiding in plain sight.

Listen closely, Truth Seekers… and decide for yourself.

Til TRUTH Do Us Part — An All Things Murky, Muderous and Mysterious Podcast

Tacky Tuesdays: Episode 1

Welcome to the very first episode of Tacky Tuesdays, a new segment from Til TRUTH Do Us Part: A True Crime Podcast, where we prove that sometimes true crime gets downright… tacky.

In this episode, Shawna and David dive into a strange, outrageous, and unforgettable true-crime case that reminds us that criminals don’t always think things through—and sometimes their bad decisions make for one hell of a story.

So grab your coffee, your favorite true-crime snack, and join the husband-and-wife team behind Til TRUTH Do Us Part as they explore the weird, the wild, and the downright tacky side of crime.

Because let's be honest… true crime—even tacky, weird crime—is cheaper than marriage therapy.

New Tacky Tuesdays episodes drop every other Tuesday.

Kara Robinson Chamberlain:

The Girl Who Outsmarted Her Abductor

In this episode of Til TRUTH Do Us Part, Shawna takes David through the terrifying true story of Kara Robinson Chamberlain, a teenager whose ordinary day turned into a nightmare when she was abducted by a dangerous predator.

But Kara was not about to become another forgotten victim.

Trapped, terrified, and thinking several steps ahead, Kara paid close attention to her surroundings, her captor, and every detail that could eventually help her escape. What happened next would become a remarkable story of courage, survival, and a young woman who ultimately outsmarted her own abductor.

Shawna and David break down Kara’s abduction, her incredible escape, the investigation that followed, and the shocking details that helped authorities track down the man responsible.

And yes… David has a few things to say about how badly this predator underestimated the wrong girl.

This is a story about fear—but even more importantly, it’s a story about survival, intelligence, courage, and refusing to give up.

🎙️ Til TRUTH Do Us Part

Every relationship has a story. And every story has a truth waiting to be uncovered.

Thank You for hanging in there with us as we navigated our real life experience with True Crime