A classic demon in a Vicky suit in a Michael suit dilemma!! Or is it? Join hosts @MarielouMandl, @iambollygirl , and @storyof_samantha as they debate the fate of the soul sqaud in this episode of The Good Place Afterbuzz TV After Show - Season 4 Episode 4 (Chapter 43).

When a tractor-trailer carrying erectile dysfunction products strikes and kills Eleanor Shellstrop, she's surprised to find herself in the "good" area of the afterlife. She quickly realizes she has been mistaken for someone else when her wise, newfound mentor tells her she earned her place by helping get innocent people off death row. She decides that she wants to shed her old foul-mouthed and hard-drinking ways and find a way to embrace the good person within -- at least when she isn't considering finding a way to return to her mundane existence back on Earth.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices