You have probably felt the pull in both directions. Seeing a queer character on screen for the first time can change what a young person believes is possible for their own life. Watching that same character get written off as a punchline can undo years of careful conversation with a parent who was almost there. So which is it? It's often both. Knowing how to tell the difference is the part nobody hands you. Joe and Rya work through what makes representation land well or poorly. If you have ever sat in a living room watching a scene go sideways and had no idea whether to speak up or let it pass, this is the one to hear.

Send us Fan Mail

Support the show

What does it actually feel like to be so afraid of coming out as LGBTQ+ that dying starts to look like the reasonable option? Rya lived it. These are her real journal entries from 2014, read aloud for the first time, written during the two years she spent bargaining with God over whether she could survive being herself. If you love a gay or transgender person who is still in the closet, you will hear what they cannot tell you. If you are queer and hiding, you will hear your own thoughts in another person's handwriting. This is one person's story of what it cost, and how she made it through to find hope again.

Content warning: this episode contains detailed discussion of suicidal thoughts and one attempt. Please take care of yourself while listening.

If you are struggling, help is available. Call or text 988 for the Suicide and Crisis Lifeline. Trans Lifeline, staffed by and for trans people, is 1-877-565-8860. The Trevor Project, for LGBTQ+ young people under 25, is 1-866-488-7386.

Send us Fan Mail

Support the show

It is possible to get everything wrong in a perfectly calm voice. Is it true that transgender people had the culture on their side until they pushed too far? Father and daughter, Joe and Rya answer the points one at a time, showing why claims that sound objective can be misleading. You are not wrong to have questions. But this is what it sounds like when the evidence presented gets fact-checked.

The video we respond to is Ken LaCorte's "What Killed the Transgender Movement?" (titled "Why Trans People Lost the Culture" at the time of recording): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9mxEmt4obg

Clips are used for purposes of commentary and criticism under fair use. The script for this response episode was generated in part with the help of Claude AI by Anthropic.

Send us Fan Mail

Support the show

Most people know the name Stonewall. Almost nobody knows what happened three years earlier in a San Francisco cafeteria. In 1966 the word transgender did not exist yet. Joe and Rya follow the trail from a church basement to the local diner where queens finally stood up to the bullies. History nearly lost this story, and that is exactly why it is worth reclaiming.

On the thumbnail: Nearly every photograph of Compton's Cafeteria is under copyright, so we could not use one. This thumbnail was made with ChatGPT. We generally steer clear of AI art, but Edward Hopper's Nighthawks restaged with the queens of the Tenderloin District in the window was too good to pass up.

One correction: In the episode, we say that nothing earlier than Compton's was documented. That is inaccurate. The Dewey's lunch counter sit-in in Philadelphia came first in April 1965, and the Black Nite brawl happened in Milwaukee, in 1961. There are also accounts of a riot at Cooper Do-nuts in Los Angeles in 1959, though that one is thinly sourced. Compton's is still among the earliest and by far the largest. We are learning this history right along with you.

Send us Fan Mail

Support the show

Most parents call the school after something has already gone wrong. By then you are negotiating from behind. The teacher who could have been your ally has already built their own explanation for your kid, and nobody handed them the real one. There is another version of this. You go first, before anyone is upset, and you hand the school the things only you know. Joe and Rya walk through what to say and who to say it to, starting long before you need it. The parents who get the best results are not the ones with the loudest voice in the principal's office. They are the ones who never had to raise it.

Thumbnail image "10070032" by moodboardphotography is licensed under CC BY 2.0.

Send us Fan Mail

Support the show

Somebody was probably nervous to send you this link. Nothing here asks you to change your mind. This episode is a conversation between an LGBTQ child and her father, talking about how to stay close to someone you are not going to agree with. Joe and Rya have been doing it for eleven years. If the arguing has cost more than it has won you, that is worth twenty-five minutes.

Send us Fan Mail

Support the show

Content note: This episode includes a personal account of suicidal thoughts and a suicide attempt. If you are struggling, you can reach the 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline by calling or texting 988 in the US, any time.

What do you do when the life you built is wrong? Jess Betts-Nelson chased the marriage, the four kids, the business and the white picket fence for nine years. But you can't marry your way out of who you are. If you are in that same bargain, telling yourself to try a little harder, Jess knows exactly how you're feeling. He has something to say to you from the other side of it. 

Send us Fan Mail

Support the show

When someone you love disagrees with you about LGBTQ issues, faith, or politics, there is a better way through than fighting. It starts with knowing the difference between a person seeking understanding and a person seeking victory. Learn to tell the two apart and stop wasting your heart on conversations that were never going to move. Most of us were never taught how to do this. There is another way, and it just might save a relationship you were starting to give up on.

Send us Fan Mail

Support the show

Have you ever loved someone you could not talk yourself out of, no matter how much simpler life would have been if you could? King David knew that feeling. Joe and Rya look at the famous Bible story with fresh eyes, asking whether David was actually bisexual. LGBTQ+ readers may meet an ancestor right in the pages of the Bible. You will never read this story the same way again.

Thumbnail Image by Otto Semler based on the engravings by Carolsfeld

Send us Fan Mail

Support the show

Maybe you have a question you stopped asking out loud, because the last time you tried you got corrected on your wording or treated like the enemy. So here is something rare. Someone willing to take your hardest objection and build it stronger than you could, then give it an honest answer instead of a script. Rya spent years as a conservative evangelical pastor who held the skeptic's case and preached it from the pulpit. She has not forgotten how it sounds from the inside. She and Joe pick up the questions people are most afraid to ask and give them a fair hearing, no scolding and no spin.

Image by Gerd Altmann

Send us Fan Mail

Support the show