The Man Who Shot the Wrong Person and Changed the Law: The Murder of Edward Drummond

A stranger stood outside 10 Downing Street for weeks, watching. Soldiers noticed him. Police questioned him. He told them he was waiting for a gentleman. On January 20, 1843, he finally stopped waiting — and fired a pistol into the back of a man he had never met, a man he was absolutely certain was someone else. The jury heard the evidence, deliberated, and found him not guilty. What happened next rewrote the legal definition of criminal responsibility for two countries.

In this episode, we explore how Daniel McNaughton spent over a year reporting a conspiracy against his life to Scottish police — and was dismissed — how a single case of mistaken identity between two men of identical height and routine created a legal precedent still cited in American courtrooms today, and why Queen Victoria personally intervened after the verdict to demand a stricter standard. Was this a calculated act of political violence, or the endpoint of a documented psychotic collapse that no institution chose to stop? The forensic record and the testimony of nine medical experts point in opposite directions.

Case Details

Victim: Edward Drummond, approximately 43, private secretary to British Prime Minister Sir Robert Peel.

Date: January 20, 1843.

Location: Whitehall, London, England, United Kingdom.

Case Status: Daniel McNaughton was found not guilty by reason of insanity at the Old Bailey in March 1843 and committed to Bethlehem Royal Hospital for 20 years. No criminal conviction was ever entered. The case directly produced the McNaughton Rule, still the dominant legal insanity standard in approximately half of U.S. states.

Episode Key Points

- McNaughton had reported his persecutors to the Glasgow police commissioner 18 months before the shooting — the same officer later testified at trial, confirming the delusions were documented and dismissed by authorities.

- Drummond and Prime Minister Sir Robert Peel were the same height, maintained identical daily routines through Whitehall, and were routinely mistaken for one another by people who knew them.

- McNaughton was carrying a second loaded pistol at the moment of arrest and had additional ammunition in his coat pockets and in his rented room on the same street as the shooting.

- Queen Victoria personally pressured the House of Lords after the not-guilty verdict, directly triggering the parliamentary creation of the two-part insanity standard now known as the McNaughton Rule.

Edward Drummond, Whitehall London homicide, insanity defense 1843, McNaughton Rule legal history, Old Bailey criminal trial, true crime, murder, forensic science, criminal minds, investigation, homicide, true detective, true crime English.

She Called In Late. She Never Made It Out.: The Disappearance of Jodi Huisentruit

At 4:10 in the morning, a young news anchor answered her phone, groggy, and promised her producer she'd be at the station in twenty minutes. She never arrived. Outside her apartment, investigators found her shoes, her hair dryer, and a bent car key on the ground — but no Jodi. In nearly thirty years, no one has been charged, and the investigation file is still being resealed every single year.

In this episode, we explore a disputed timeline that places Jodi in two locations at the same time on her final night, an unidentified hair collected from the crime scene that police mentioned exactly once and never discussed publicly again, and a sealed GPS warrant that investigators have refiled annually since 2017 targeting vehicles connected to one man. Was Jodi the victim of a calculated abductor who had been watching her for weeks, or did someone close to her know exactly when she would walk out that door? The forensic evidence and the witness accounts do not tell the same story.

Case Details

Victim: Jodi Huisentruit, 27, morning news anchor at KIMT-TV, Mason City, Iowa.

Date: June 27, 1995, approximately 4:00 AM.

Location: Key Apartments parking lot, Mason City, Iowa, USA.

Case Status: Jodi Huisentruit is officially listed as missing and presumed dead. The case remains unsolved with no charges ever filed. As of 2023, a sealed GPS warrant connected to a named person of interest continues to be refiled annually by investigators.

Episode Key Points

- Jodi's confirmed phone call from her apartment at 8:24 PM directly conflicts with a person of interest's claim that she visited his home that same evening.

- An unidentified hair was recovered from the crime scene and publicly acknowledged by police in February 1996 — it has never been mentioned in any official statement since.

- Search dogs brought in the day of the disappearance failed to pick up a scent trail, leading investigators to conclude Jodi was placed directly into a vehicle at the scene.

- Beer cans found lined up in the parking lot in the days before Jodi vanished were positioned with a direct sightline into her apartment window — and were never seen again after her disappearance.

Jodi Huisentruit, Mason City Iowa abduction, KIMT-TV anchor missing 1995, unsolved disappearance Iowa, Key Apartments crime scene, true crime, homicide, investigation, unsolved mysteries, forensic science, criminal minds, murder, true crime English.

The Text She Sent Before She Disappeared: The Death of Morgan Patton

At 10:25 PM on November 8, 2019, a 24-year-old woman texted her fiancé something strange — a tip about cocaine being smuggled onto a Marine Corps base through pizza deliveries. Eleven minutes later, she sent her last message. Six minutes after that, she was dead, found on the ground beneath a speeding truck she had no known reason to be inside. The forensic science, the witness statements, and the medical records all point in different directions — and nobody has been charged with her murder.

In this episode, we explore the autopsy's two blood alcohol readings that cannot both be true, a foreign male DNA profile found under Morgan's fingernails that has never been matched to anyone, and a sworn military statement that directly contradicts the physical injuries documented in hospital records. Was Morgan Patton the victim of a tragic accident driven by a drunk Marine, or was something far more deliberate happening inside that truck? The investigation, the homicide, and the evidence tell three different stories.

Case Details

Victim: Morgan Patton, 24, former waitress and only child, traveling to visit her fiancé at Camp Lejeune.

Date: November 8–9, 2019.

Location: Maysville, North Carolina, USA.

Case Status: Hunter O'Neill Wells has been indicted on felony death by vehicle, involuntary manslaughter, and DWI charges; a criminal trial is pending. No foul play charges have been filed. The question of how Morgan came to be in the truck remains officially unanswered.

Episode Key Points

- Morgan's blood BAC measured 0.13 from an aortic sample collected 59 hours after death, while her vitreous fluid — unaffected by decomposition — measured only 0.02, a discrepancy prosecutors addressed by telling the family to "assume somewhere between the two."

- Foreign male DNA from two contributors was recovered from Morgan's fingernail scrapings; the quantity was deemed insufficient for identification and no match has ever been announced.

- The Event Data Recorder confirmed the truck was traveling at 86 miles per hour with zero braking detected before leaving the road — a detail the family says raises questions about who, if anyone, was trying to stop the vehicle.

- Charlie Cornwall gave a sworn military statement claiming he was wearing a seatbelt, then later asked civilian prosecutors whether he had been wearing one, then told a private investigator he remembered nothing about the crash or the months surrounding it.

Morgan Patton, Maysville North Carolina homicide, Camp Lejeune 2019, felony death by vehicle North Carolina, Marine Corps criminal case, true crime, murder, forensic science, investigation, criminal minds, homicide, unsolved mysteries, true crime English.

She Won Six Hundred Dollars. Then Someone Shot Her.: The Murder of Furbia Faye Tinsley

A 51-year-old Army veteran won big at bingo on a Friday night, deposited her winnings at the bank, and was found shot twice in the head inside her own car before sunrise. The engine was still running. Her seatbelt was still on. Her purse was gone, but nothing inside the car had been touched. Homicide investigators have named no one in over a decade — but one man who was in that car walked away without calling 911.

In this episode, we explore a phone call Faye made before 5 a.m. that brought her to a street she had no reason to visit, a convenience store surveillance clip showing a man without shoes who told a clerk something so significant that detectives still refuse to repeat it, and a gun linked to multiple Charlottesville shootings that has never been found. Was Faye driven to that block by someone she trusted, or did she go there to confront the truth about her own relationship? The forensic science and the witness accounts point in two directions that cannot both be right.

Case Details

Victim: Furbia Faye Tinsley, 51, U.S. Army veteran living on disability benefits.

Date: July 14, 2012.

Location: 800 block of Prospect Avenue, Charlottesville, Virginia, USA.

Case Status: The murder of Furbia Faye Tinsley remains officially unsolved. No charges have ever been filed. As of 2023, the case is technically active but has seen no public movement in years.

Episode Key Points

- Two spent handgun casings were found inside Faye's locked car with all windows rolled up, yet no one could definitively establish where the shooter was sitting.

- A man who was present in the car when Faye was shot fled on foot, appeared on surveillance without shoes minutes later, and left Charlottesville that same morning without calling police.

- The gun used to kill Faye was ballistically linked to multiple other Charlottesville shootings, suggesting it was passed between individuals before and after the murder.

- Detectives tried repeatedly to bring charges but prosecutors declined, citing a mystery third-party shooter described by the surviving witness — a man no one has ever identified.

Furbia Faye Tinsley, Charlottesville Virginia homicide, Prospect Avenue murder 2012, unsolved cold case Virginia, bingo night shooting, true crime, murder, investigation, forensic science, homicide, criminal minds, unsolved mysteries, true crime English.

She Said His Name. The Phone Disappeared.: The Murder of Deanna Cook

She called 911 while he was in the room. For nearly seventeen minutes, the operator listened to a woman beg for her life — and heard a man say "I'll kill you" three times. When police finally knocked on her door, they left without going inside. Three days later, her mother found her face down in a bathtub full of water. The phone Deanna used to make that call was never recovered from the scene.

In this episode, we explore a 911 call that captured an active homicide in real time but triggered no immediate response, the fifty-minute gap between dispatch and the moment officers knocked and walked away, and DNA evidence from a sexual assault kit that took two separate laboratory tests to produce a usable profile. Was this a system that failed one woman, or a system that was never built to protect her at all? The forensic science and the recorded audio tell a story the city of Dallas spent years trying to avoid.

Case Details

Victim: Deanna Cook, 32, mother of two, Dallas resident.

Date: August 17, 2012.

Location: Dallas, Texas, USA.

Case Status: Delvecchio was convicted of murder on May 18, 2015, and sentenced to 85 years in prison. A civil lawsuit filed by Deanna's mother against the City of Dallas and others was still in active appeals as of March 2019 with no public resolution confirmed after that date.

Episode Key Points

- The 911 call ran for eleven to seventeen minutes and captured the sound of a struggle and what investigators described as water splashing, yet the call taker did not log an active assault in her records.

- Two responding officers stopped at a 7-Eleven and completed paperwork from a prior call before arriving at Deanna's address — fifty minutes after they were dispatched.

- Deanna's sexual assault kit contained DNA from two unidentified males who have never been traced, a gap the defense used to argue the investigation was never completed.

- Without the 911 recording, the medical examiner stated the death would have been classified as mysterious rather than homicide — there was no visible bruising consistent with a beating.

Deanna Cook, Dallas Texas homicide 2012, domestic violence murder Dallas, 911 call evidence, criminal minds, true detective, homicide, forensic science, investigation, murder, systemic failure, true crime English.

The Confession That Wasn't His to Give: The Murder of Father Patrick Ryan and the Wrongful Conviction of James Harry Rios

A housekeeper opened Room 126 of a Texas motel on December 22, 1981, and found a man beaten beyond recognition, hands bound, lying face-down in a pool of blood. The investigation that followed produced a conviction built entirely on a phone call — no fingerprints, no DNA, no physical evidence placing the accused anywhere near that room. The man who confessed said, repeatedly, that he didn't do it.

In this episode, we explore a speeding ticket that placed the convicted man 200 miles from the crime scene during the murder window, a set of fingerprint templates believed destroyed for nearly three decades that ultimately identified the real killers, and a prosecutor so certain his own case was wrong that he wrote an eight-page letter to the Governor of Texas begging for a pardon. How does a system convict a man with an alibi, zero physical evidence, and a confession he immediately recanted — and then take forty years to admit the mistake?

Case Details

Victim: Father Patrick Ryan, 49, Catholic priest assigned to St. William's Church, Denver City, Texas.

Date: December 21, 1981 (murder); October 4, 2023 (official exoneration of wrongfully convicted James Harry Rios).

Location: Sand and Sage Motel, Odessa, Texas, USA.

Case Status: James Harry Rios was officially exonerated on October 4, 2023, after serving 20 years in prison and nearly 20 additional years on parole. The real perpetrators were identified posthumously via CODIS; no criminal charges can be filed as both individuals are deceased.

Episode Key Points

- Harry's speeding ticket and timestamped receipts placed him in Roswell, New Mexico — 200 miles away — during the murder window, yet the jury convicted him in 7.5 hours with zero physical evidence.

- No fingerprints, hair, saliva, or semen matching Harry were recovered from Room 126 or from Father Ryan's car, despite extensive forensic collection at both scenes.

- The prosecutor who argued against Harry's 1984 appeal later spent an entire night reviewing the trial record, concluded Harry was innocent, and filed an unprecedented 8-page pardon request — which the Texas Board of Pardons and Paroles denied 16 to 0.

- Fingerprint templates believed destroyed by Odessa PD in 1994 were rediscovered in 2022 after two true crime podcast listeners from Odessa prompted a new evidence search — leading directly to the CODIS identification of the real killers.

Father Patrick Ryan, James Harry Rios, Odessa Texas homicide, wrongful conviction 1983, Ector County Texas, true crime, homicide, investigation, forensic science, criminal minds, innocence project, murder, true crime English.

The Officer Who Investigated His Own Crime: The Disappearance of Rachel Good

A 20-year-old mother of three vanished on the night of October 18, 2003, and by the next morning, the officer assigned to find her was the same man investigators now name as their only suspect. He stood at the missing persons desk, pen shaking in his hand, and took the report himself. How does a police department hand a case to the man who may have been the last person to see her alive?

In this episode, we explore the secret relationship between Rachel Good and Officer Adam Williams that nobody at the Elkton Police Department was supposed to know about, the love letters her grandmother found inside a kitchen drawer days after the disappearance, and the phone records showing Adam called Rachel almost every day — then never again after she vanished. Was Rachel's pregnancy the motive, or did something go wrong that night in the national forest? The forensic science and the phone records tell a story the grand jury heard for over a year and still could not finish.

Case Details

Victim: Rachel Good, 20, mother of three children and approximately 10 weeks pregnant at the time of her disappearance.

Date: October 18–19, 2003.

Location: Elkton and Harrisonburg, Virginia, USA.

Case Status: Unsolved homicide. No criminal charges have ever been filed against Adam Williams, the confirmed primary suspect. A civil wrongful death suit remains active and awaiting a trial date as of recording.

Episode Key Points

- Officer Adam Williams took Rachel's missing persons report himself, visibly shaking and barely able to hold the pen, before anyone at the department knew he had been in a secret relationship with her.

- Adam gave Rachel $1,400 in cash to end a pregnancy investigators believe was his — Rachel did not use the money for that purpose and had threatened to expose the affair to his wife.

- Phone records confirmed by Virginia State Police show Adam and Rachel called each other almost daily before her disappearance; Adam never called her number again after she vanished.

- A special grand jury met for over a year after the prosecutor declared indictment was "certain" — and adjourned without returning a single charge.

Rachel Good, Elkton Virginia missing persons, Harrisonburg Virginia homicide, unsolved disappearance 2003, Virginia cold case, true detective, homicide, criminal minds, forensic science, investigation, murder, unsolved mysteries, true crime English.

She Texted Goodbye. He Described the Wrong Death.: The Death of Molly Marie Young

A 21-year-old woman was found on the floor of her boyfriend's bedroom with a gunshot wound above her left eye. When her boyfriend called 911, he described an overdose — never once mentioning the visible wound to her head. The gun that killed her left no residue on her hands. So how did she pull the trigger?

In this episode, we explore the eighteen-minute gap between Molly's final text and the estimated moment of the shooting, a .45 caliber handgun with no identifiable fingerprints on the trigger or magazine, and three unidentified male DNA profiles found under Molly's fingernails that investigators never matched. Was this a young woman in crisis who followed through on a desperate threat, or did someone in that apartment already know what had happened before anyone called for help? The forensic science and the 911 recording pull in two directions that cannot both be true.

Case Details

Victim: Molly Marie Young, 21, college student and aspiring artist.

Date: March 24, 2012.

Location: Carbondale, Illinois, USA.

Case Status: The case remains officially unsolved and active. Jackson County State's Attorney Joe Cervantes, elected in 2020, has stated he would have prosecuted the primary person of interest and has filed a motion to unrecuse Jackson County from further investigation.

Episode Key Points

- Molly's gunshot residue was found only on her right sweatshirt sleeve — not on either of her hands — despite the wound being classified as a contact shot.

- Richie Minton Jr. called 911 and described Molly as having overdosed and bled through her nose, never mentioning the visible gunshot wound above her left eyebrow.

- Three distinct male DNA profiles were recovered from under Molly's fingernails; only Richie's DNA was submitted for comparison, and the other two profiles were never identified.

- Richie's cell phone was in his possession at the police station for approximately thirty minutes before investigators took it, and when forensic tools were applied, the device failed to connect — a system his father, a digital forensics expert, had been specifically trained to operate.

Molly Young, Carbondale Illinois homicide, Jackson County unsolved 2012, Southern Illinois University death, undetermined ruling Illinois, homicide, forensic science, true detective, criminal minds, investigation, murder, unsolved mysteries, true crime English.

She Was Wrapped, Bound, and Nobody Looked: The Murder of Patricia "Tricia" Melody Newsome

A canvas tarp. Copper wire. Two trash bags and a cloth stuffed in her mouth. Someone spent a significant amount of time preparing this body for disposal — and then nearly fifty years passed without a single arrest. The forensic science existed. The tips came in. So why does no one answer for what happened to Tricia Newsome?

In this episode, we explore how the physical evidence points to a killer with military or maritime knot knowledge, why a convicted murderer in Maine refused to speak with investigators for decades despite living five minutes from the dump site in August 1975, and how a flooded evidence room destroyed nearly everything police had collected. Was this a calculated disposal by someone who had done this before, or a crime that was simply allowed to go cold? The investigation and the DNA timeline tell two stories about what justice actually means.

Case Details

Victim: Patricia "Tricia" Melody Newsome, 18, private citizen reported missing by no one.

Date: August 1975 (body discovered); identity confirmed April 10, 2023.

Location: East Haven, Connecticut, USA.

Case Status: Unsolved and actively investigated. No arrests have ever been made. East Haven Police Department continues to pursue tips as of 2023.

Episode Key Points

- Tricia's body was wrapped in a canvas tarp, secured with copper wire, two plastic bags, twine at wrists and ankles, and a cloth stuffed in her mouth — a level of preparation that required time, materials, and more than one pair of hands.

- A convicted murderer named Glenner lived five minutes from the dump site in August 1975 and used an almost identical binding method — plastic bag over the head, mouth stuffed, ankles tied with twine — in a separate murder years later.

- All physical evidence collected in 1975 was destroyed when a toilet malfunction flooded the East Haven Police evidence room, leaving investigators with only a pubic bone and swabs stored at a separate medical examiner's lab — both too contaminated for DNA testing.

- When investigators exhumed Tricia's grave in June 2022, they opened the casket and found the body of an unknown young boy. Tricia's actual remains were located ten feet away in a second exhumation one month later.

The Dog Bones Buried Six Feet Deep: The Disappearance of Reed Jepson

A fifteen-year-old boy stepped into his backyard to feed his dogs on a Sunday afternoon in 1964 and was never seen again. Forty-five years later, a backhoe in the neighboring yard hit something five feet down — two dogs, surgically dismembered, sealed in plastic bags. The man who owned that property in 1964 was a bone surgeon. When police finally questioned him, he didn't say Reed had run away. He said he hoped they'd find out who killed him.

In this episode, we explore why the $60 Reed supposedly took to run away was found untouched in a jar in his closet, how a bone surgeon with an open-secret history of abusing teenage boys lived forty years next door to the family he may have destroyed, and why voice stress tests administered to the primary person of interest produced results investigators called deliberately sabotaged. Was this a crime of opportunity against a boy with two minutes to spare before Sunday lunch, or something far more calculated? The forensic science and a single unguarded sentence point in the same direction.

Case Details

Victim: Reed Jepson, 15, Eagle Scout and high school student.

Date: October 11, 1964.

Location: Salt Lake City, Utah, USA.

Case Status: Unsolved and active. Salt Lake City Police Department reopened the case on May 25, 2010. No charges have ever been filed. The primary person of interest died in 2016.

Episode Key Points

- The $60 Reed allegedly took to fund a runaway was found intact in a jar inside his closet — every belonging he owned remained at home.

- Dog remains discovered in 2009 had been surgically dismembered and buried five to six feet underground in sealed plastic bags — on a property owned in 1964 by an orthopedic surgeon.

- When detectives questioned the property's 1964 owner, he volunteered that he hoped police would find out who "killed" Reed — at a time when the public narrative described Reed as a runaway, not a homicide victim.

- During a voice stress test, the same man deliberately gave false answers to basic control questions, rendering the results inconclusive — then requested and passed a second test.

Reed Jepson, Salt Lake City Utah missing person, cold case homicide 1964, Mill Creek Canyon remains, orthopedic surgeon person of interest, true crime, murder, investigation, forensic science, homicide, criminal minds, unsolved mysteries, true crime English.