True Crime Central

The Dog That Ate the Carpet: The Disappearance and Death of Marcus Rutledge

A locked bathroom, a starving Rottweiler, and a phone wiped clean before investigators could read it — and that was just the first night Marcus Rutledge was missing. His car turned up three weeks later, more than twenty miles away, with an unregistered handgun under the seat and fingerprints that didn't belong to anyone who knew him. Someone knew exactly where he went. They just haven't said a word in twenty-six years.

In this episode, we explore the thirteen-day gap between Marcus's last confirmed phone call and the moment his car was found at a complex he had no connection to, a skull discovered by a hunter in 2010 that sat unidentified for fourteen years, and the murder of Marcus's best friend Ethan Gibbs Jr. just eight months after Marcus vanished — a case that also collapsed before trial. Was Marcus's death connected to a drug-world home invasion that happened the very next day, or did someone closer to him decide what his secret life was worth? The forensic science points to a name. The legal record refuses to say it.

Case Details

Victim: Marcus Rutledge, 23, Tennessee State University student (unofficial — had secretly dropped out in 1997).

Date: June 8, 1998 (last confirmed contact); remains identified January 31, 2025.

Location: Nashville, Tennessee, USA.

Case Status: Active homicide investigation. Metro Nashville Police Department officially reclassified the case from missing persons to homicide on January 31, 2025, after DNA from a skull found in 2010 was matched through CODIS. No arrests have been made.

Episode Key Points

- Marcus's landline phone was unplugged and removed from his apartment the night he vanished, triggering a factory reset that permanently erased all stored contact numbers before investigators could examine it.

- His red Plymouth Neon was found abandoned at an apartment complex twenty miles from his home, with an unregistered handgun under the driver's seat and one unidentified fingerprint on the inside of the driver's-side window.

- The day after Marcus disappeared, three to four masked gunmen invaded the apartment of Charles D. Brown Jr. — a man connected to Marcus's circle — and fled in vehicles that included a red car visually consistent with Marcus's Plymouth Neon.

- Ethan Gibbs Jr., Marcus's best friend, was shot multiple times in his apartment eight months later; the only named suspect walked free after charges were dropped, and that case also remains officially unsolved.

Marcus Rutledge, Nashville Tennessee homicide, Tennessee State University cold case, cold case 1998, Nashville missing persons, true detective, homicide, murder, investigation, forensic science, criminal minds, unsolved mysteries, true crime English.

She Bought a New Purse That Afternoon: The Murder of Jane Newman

Jane Newman stopped at a store on her way home from work to exchange a purse. That purse was found next to her body less than two hours later. The official investigation closed inside of three months — but the man who burned the only suicide note and threw the shotgun off a highway bridge was never charged with murder.

In this episode, we explore a fishing line threaded through a hole in a laundry room wall, a one-hundred-thousand-dollar life insurance policy whose suicide exclusion expired exactly four days before Jane died, and a computerized phone system her husband programmed himself that may have built his alibi call by call. Was this a woman who planned her own death with military precision — or a crime scene staged by someone who knew exactly which evidence would never be tested?

Case Details

Victim: Jane Newman, 30, mortgage company employee.

Date: November 22, 1993.

Location: St. Croix County, Wisconsin, USA.

Case Status: The case is an open homicide. A 1997 civil jury found James Newman responsible for Jane's murder and ordered over four hundred thousand dollars in damages, upheld on appeal in 2001. No criminal homicide charges have ever been filed.

Episode Key Points

- The suicide exclusion on Jane's one-hundred-thousand-dollar life insurance policy expired exactly four days before her death — a fact her husband claimed not to know.

- Jim Newman burned the alleged suicide note, flushed the ashes, wrapped the shotgun in garbage bags, drove three miles, and threw it from a bridge — all before calling 911.

- Bubble wrap fragments found inside Jane's gunshot wound matched computer packaging material from Jim's employer, where he had direct daily access.

- Jim's employer testified that Jim had personally programmed the company's computerized telemarketing system and could have used it to generate the home calls that formed his alibi.

Jane Newman, St. Croix County Wisconsin homicide, murder 1993, open homicide Wisconsin, civil trial wrongful death, true crime, homicide, investigation, forensic science, murder, criminal minds, unsolved mysteries, true crime English.

The Caller Who Said "You're Talking to Him Right Now": The Murder of Reese Pocan

A man called a sheriff's dispatch at 2:30 in the morning, described exactly how Reese Pocan was killed, named the person responsible — and then paused when the dispatcher asked if he was the killer. The investigation traced the call to a phone number within hours. Then it stopped. Thirty-four years later, no one has been charged in this homicide, and the man who answered his door when detectives played that recording back to him did not deny knowing exactly what it was.

In this episode, we explore how Reese's headless, handless body was found eighty miles from where her hands were recovered — and why it took nine years to confirm they belonged to the same woman, why a boyfriend sold his truck within weeks of her disappearance and admitted to hunting in the exact marsh where her skull turned up, and how at least seven people were approached for polygraphs in 2022 and 2023, with four refusing and one showing deception. Was Reese killed by someone she trusted, someone she met that night, or someone who has been hiding six houses from where she was last seen alive?

Case Details

Victim: Reese Pocan, 35, administrative assistant at the Bradley Center and mother of four daughters.

Date: On or after August 10, 1989.

Location: Milwaukee, Wisconsin, USA — body recovered in Sheboygan County, Wisconsin.

Case Status: Officially open homicide. No arrests have been made as of 2024. Detective Nathan Hatch of the Sheboygan County Sheriff's Office and Special Agent Michael Potter of the Bureau of Indian Affairs are actively investigating.

Episode Key Points

- Reese's body was found in September 1989 without a head or hands; the medical examiner originally theorized animal predation removed them — then later admitted that was not possible and he would now classify the death as homicide.

- Her hands were found eighty miles away in Waukesha County in October 1989, but were not definitively linked to her body until 2018 — nearly thirty years after her death.

- Her boyfriend at the time of her disappearance gave two contradictory accounts of the last time he saw her, sold his truck weeks after she vanished, and admitted to hunting in the Vernon Marsh area where her skull was later recovered.

- A man who called dispatch in 1990 described the killing in specific detail, identified a suspect by name and address, and when asked directly if he was the killer, said "you're talking to him right now" — the call was traced, a name was identified, and the investigation stopped.

Reese Pocan, Sheboygan County Wisconsin homicide, Milwaukee missing persons 1989, indigenous women missing Wisconsin, MMIW cold case, true crime, murder, investigation, homicide, forensic science, criminal minds, unsolved mysteries, true crime English.

The Children Who Vanished in Plain Sight: The Disappearance of Jane, Arna, and Grant Beaumont

Three children boarded a bus to the beach on a public holiday with eight shillings and six pence in coins. By noon, they were buying lunch with a one-pound note that nobody gave them. The man who handed them that note has never been named by police — but investigators believe they know exactly who he was.

In this episode, we explore the one-pound note that appeared from nowhere and reframes every witness account, a small white purse spotted decades later in the basement of a key suspect's widow, and a recorded testimony from the suspect's own son placing three children inside that house on the day they vanished. Was this a calculated abduction by a man who used money to manufacture trust, or did three children simply walk into the water and never come back? The forensic timeline and the witness record cannot both be right.

Case Details

Victim: Jane Beaumont, 9, eldest sibling and designated caretaker; Arna Beaumont, 7; Grant Beaumont, 4.

Date: January 26, 1966.

Location: Glenelg Beach, Adelaide, South Australia, Australia.

Case Status: Unsolved and officially active. No charges have ever been filed. Police named Harry Phipps as a person of interest in 2018, but he died in 2004. A third excavation of his former factory grounds was conducted in February 2025 without conclusive findings.

Episode Key Points

- Jane was given exactly eight shillings and six pence in coins for the day, yet bakery staff confirmed the children paid for lunch with a single one-pound note — a denomination that could not have come from that allowance.

- Harry Phipps's own son Hayden recorded a statement placing three children — two of similar height, one significantly shorter — at the family home on the afternoon of January 26, 1966, the exact day of the disappearance.

- A small white purse consistent with Jane Beaumont's described purse was observed by investigator Stuart Mullins in the basement of Harry Phipps's widow. By the time police arrived at the property, the purse was gone. She stated she had thrown it away.

- Harry Phipps regularly gave children one-pound notes to send them away from his house on Saturdays — a pattern his own grandson later confirmed continued into the next generation.

Jane Beaumont, Glenelg Beach Adelaide disappearance, Beaumont children 1966, South Australia cold case, Harry Phipps investigation, true crime, homicide, unsolved mysteries, forensic science, investigation, criminal minds, murder, true crime English.

The Button Snap That Caught a Ghost: The Quadruple Murder of Kaylee Goncalves, Madison Mogen, Xana Kernodle, and Ethan Chapin.

A figure clad in black walked past a frozen witness at 4:17 AM, leaving four students dead in their beds while the house fell into a terrifying silence. The man behind the mask was a PhD student in criminology who had spent his academic life studying how to commit the perfect crime. Yet, in his arrogance, he left the most damning piece of forensic science on the bed next to his first victim.

In this episode, we explore the chilling eighteen-minute window where a white sedan circled the house four times, the Ka-Bar knife sheath found with a single microscopic DNA source, and the confusing eight-hour delay before 911 was finally dialed. How did a man obsessed with the mechanics of murder make such a fundamental error? The digital timeline and the physical evidence tell a story of a hunter who became the hunted.

• Victim: Kaylee Goncalves, 21, student; Madison Mogen, 21, student; Xana Kernodle, 20, student; Ethan Chapin, 20, student.
• Date: November 13, 2022.
• Location: Moscow, Idaho, USA.
• Case Status: Bryan Kohberger accepted a plea deal in July 2024, pleading guilty to four counts of first-degree murder to avoid the death penalty.

• - A survivor saw the killer's bushy eyebrows and mask inside the hallway but froze in shock and did not call police until noon.
• - The killer's white Hyundai Elantra was recorded circling the dead-end street three times before finally parking at 4:04 AM.
• - A tan leather knife sheath was left on the third-floor bed, containing a single touch DNA sample on the button snap.
• - The suspect's phone pinged the cell tower near the victims' house at 9:12 AM the next morning, suggesting he returned to the scene.

Kaylee Goncalves, Moscow Idaho murders, University of Idaho homicide, King Road killings 2022, forensic science, criminal minds, investigation, murder, true crime English.

Authorities insisted for forty years she was alive in California, showing her mother blurry photos of a stranger to close the case. Meanwhile, the real Kimberly likely never made it out of Iowa, leaving her winter coat behind in a car with a predator. The system spent decades proving she was safe instead of looking for her body.

In this episode, we explore the green two-door car where she was last seen, the jurisdictional ping-pong between two cities that refused to search for her, and the dental records that were falsified to match a Jane Doe in Texas. Where is the fourteen-year-old girl who called home begging for a bus ticket? The official narrative and the physical evidence are strangers to each other.

• Victim: Kimberly Doss, 14, student.
• Date: March 23, 1980.
• Location: Davenport, Iowa, USA.
• Case Status: Active missing persons investigation after DNA cleared a false identification in 2021.

• - Kimberly's winter coat was found in the suspect's car, yet he claimed she walked away into the freezing snow.
• - Police closed the case based on a photo of a woman in California who was four inches taller than Kimberly.
• - Official records listed her age as sixteen, hindering the search for a fourteen-year-old child.
• - A sympathy card was sent to the mother regarding a body found in Texas that police never officially notified her about.

Kimberly Doss, Davenport Iowa kidnapping, cold case 1980, missing children, unsolved mysteries, homicide, investigation, true crime, forensic science, true crime English.

The Freeze Plug Pulled by Hand: The Disappearance of Sarah Boyd, Kimberly Boyd, and Linda McCord.

A blue Lincoln stalled on a dark highway because a freeze plug popped out of the engine, yet the temperature was nowhere near freezing. The car was found twenty minutes in the wrong direction, and a husband arrived home at dawn with mud-caked boots before reporting anyone missing. How does a reliable mother vanish along with her toddler and best friend without a single scream?

In this episode, we explore a credit card used to buy luggage three years after the disappearance, a witness who saw a beat-up blue vehicle stalking the women, and a police lieutenant who helped move the crime scene before it could be processed. Why did a confession years later mention "two birds" when three people were taken? The mechanical evidence suggests this breakdown was no accident.

• Victim: Sarah Boyd, 32, seamstress; Kimberly Boyd, 2, toddler; Linda McCord, 32, factory worker.
• Date: April 3, 1987.
• Location: Dorchester and Orangeburg Counties, South Carolina, USA.
• Case Status: Active cold case with no convictions; the primary suspect died in 2018 without being charged.

• - The Lincoln’s freeze plug was manually removed to disable the engine, despite temperatures remaining above freezing.
• - John McCord returned home at 6:30 AM covered in wet mud but claimed he had been driving around looking for his wife.
• - Sarah Boyd’s credit card was used three years later to purchase luggage, yet the signature was illegible.
• - Police allowed the abandoned vehicle to be towed and repaired before processing it for forensic evidence.

Sarah Boyd, South Carolina disappearance, cold case 1987, unsolved mysteries, homicide, investigation, true crime, kidnapping, forensic science, true crime English.

The Script That Predicted a Disappearance: The Disappearance of Jennifer Farber-Doulos

A Vineyard Vines shirt with the slogan "Every day should feel this good" was found soaked in blood inside a city trash can, miles from the victim's wealthy estate. Her husband was recorded making thirty separate stops along a single avenue to discard heavy black bags, yet his defense team argued she staged the scene herself.

In this episode, we explore the handwritten "alibi scripts" designed to rewrite a Friday morning, a garage scrubbed so clean only microscopic evidence remained, and a manuscript written years earlier that became the blueprint for a legal defense. How does a mother of five vanish without a trace while her car is driven away by someone else?

Case Details

Victim: Jennifer Farber-Doulos, 50, writer and mother.

Date: May 24, 2019.

Location: New Canaan, Connecticut, USA.

Case Status: Fotis Dulos died by suicide before trial; Michelle Troconis was convicted of conspiracy to commit murder in 2024.

Episode Key Points

- A shirt found in the trash bore the ironic slogan "Every day should feel this good" while covered in the victim's blood.

- Surveillance cameras captured a Ford Raptor making thirty distinct stops to dump evidence along a four-mile stretch of road.

- Handwritten notes known as "alibi scripts" were discovered detailing false timelines for the exact hours of the disappearance.

- Ten rolls of paper towels were missing from the garage supply shelf the morning the victim vanished.

Jennifer Farber-Doulos, New Canaan disappearance, missing person 2019, homicide, forensic science, criminal minds, true detective, investigation, murder, true crime English.

Jennifer Lancaster told her mother she was going to the dry cleaners at eight o'clock at night, carrying a laundry basket and two infant daughters. She never came back. Two weeks later, her Jeep was found in a stranger's parking lot, scrubbed chemically clean of all fingerprints.

In this episode, we explore why a mother with a washing machine at home would leave for a dry cleaner that was already closed, the mystery of the missing car seats that vanished while the car remained, and the silence of three social security numbers that have not pinged a single tower in twenty-five years. Was this a desperate flight from a turbulent life, or a trap set by someone waiting in the shadows of a Kansas parking lot? The condition of the vehicle suggests a cleanup that no panicked mother would have time to perform.

• Victim: Jennifer Lancaster, 25, dancer; Sydney Smith, 14 months; Monique Smith, 5 weeks.
• Date: May 2000.
• Location: Topeka, Kansas, USA.
• Case Status: Active cold case investigation with no arrests made in twenty-five years.

• - Jennifer left at 8:00 PM for a dry cleaner that closed hours earlier, an errand that defied her normal routine.
• - Her Jeep Cherokee was found two weeks later with the interior scrubbed so thoroughly that not a single latent fingerprint could be recovered.
• - Both infant car seats were removed from the vehicle and have never been located, despite the car being abandoned.
• - A private DNA test in 2025 disproved a woman's claim to be one of the missing daughters, resetting the investigation to zero.

Jennifer Lancaster, Topeka Kansas missing persons, cold case investigation, family disappearance, forensic science, unsolved mysteries, true crime English.

John Markley was hours away from burying his twin sister when he and his wife vanished from their locked home. Their coffee pot was boiled dry on the stove and Shelly’s cigarettes lay on the table, yet they were seen minutes later at a bank drive-thru with a mystery man. How do two parents abandon five children on the most tragic day of the year?

In this episode, we explore the mud-caked truck found miles away, a ransom note demanding money the family didn't have, and the stranger in the passenger seat who has never been identified. We analyze why a meticulous man left his gun cabinet open and his funeral suit on the bed. Who was really in control of the red Chevy Silverado that morning?

• Victim: John Markley, 36, trucking company owner; Shelly Markley, 31, homemaker.
• Date: December 15, 1995.
• Location: Bristolville, Ohio, USA.
• Case Status: Unsolved; John and Shelly were declared legally dead in 1999 with no murder charges ever filed.

• Shelly’s cigarettes and lighter were found on the kitchen table, despite her being a pack-a-day smoker who never left home without them.
• John and Shelly were recorded at a bank drive-thru at 10:36 AM with an unidentified slim, dark-haired man in their passenger seat.
• The couple’s red Chevy Silverado was found the next morning covered in thick mud, with "Hi Uncle John" written in the grime by a niece who thought they were shopping.
• Two shotguns were missing from the open gun cabinet, while the funeral clothes remained laid out on the bed.
• 
  

John and Shelly Markley, Bristolville cold case, Ohio missing persons, 1995 crime, homicide, investigation, kidnapping, extortion, forensic science, unsolved mysteries, true crime English