Send us Fan Mail
26‑year‑old Sara Reynolds of New Milford Township, Susquehanna County, PA, has been missing for 32 agonizing days.
In this episode, host and advocate Tiff Kline breaks down the timeline, the last known moments, the surveillance footage, the witnesses who remain silent, and the unbearable reality her family wakes up to every single day.
Sara was last seen on July 2nd, 2026, near Route 492 and Interstate 81 after being dropped off by her ex‑boyfriend’s mother. She had no transportation. She never made it home. She never called. She never showed up again. And for 26 days, the only proof of her existence has been a few seconds of surveillance video.
Her family has lived through 32 days of torture, 32 days of not knowing, 32 days of pure hell.
Her five‑year‑old son cries for his mother.
Her father and loved ones beg for answers.
Witnesses stay in the shadows.
And the silence is killing them.
This episode dives into:
- Who Sara is — a mother, daughter, friend, and human being who deserves to come home.
- Her last known movements and the critical surveillance footage.
- The abuse history that shaped her life and may hold answers.
- The witnesses who have not come forward despite knowing what happened.
- The heartbreaking timeline of missed birthdays, missed milestones, and missed chances for answers.
- The desperate plea for anyone with information to speak up — anonymously if needed.
This is not just a case.
This is a family’s nightmare.
This is a child without his mother.
This is a community that must not go silent.
If you know anything about Sara’s whereabouts, please contact:
Pennsylvania State Police – Gibson Barracks
Trooper Godino: 570‑465‑3154
PSP Tips: 1‑800‑472‑8477
Someone knows something.
And it’s time to do the right thing.
Support the show