True Terror on Tap

True Terror on Tap

By Joseph Behill, Gabriel Behill, Michael BehillTrue Crime
Download on the App Store

True Terror on Tap episodes

  • Inside the Life of Israel Keyes Part 2

    Send us a text

    Israel Keyes was unlike any serial killer we’ve ever seen—methodical, patient, and terrifyingly precise. In Part 2 of our deep dive, we pick up where we left off: Vermont, June 2011. Keyes had just arrived, retrieving a kill kit he had buried a year earlier, and searching for his next victims. What followed was an execution of a double murder that would later become the key to understanding his nationwide crimes.

    But the Curriers weren’t his only victims.

    We take you step by step through Keyes’ terrifying admissions, his confession tapes, and the twisted games he played with the FBI. He revealed just enough to haunt investigators—but never enough to solve the full mystery. He talked about murders in Washington, New York, Texas, and the Midwest, but refused to name names. He hinted at bodies that would never be found. He told law enforcement, 

    ‘You’ll never catch me the way you want to.’

    “nd in the end, he was right.

    Before he could be executed by the state, Keyes made sure to execute himself. But even in death, he left one last message—an eerie suicide note and 11 blood-drawn skulls found under his prison bed, possibly a tally of his true number of victims. How many did he really kill? What secrets did he take to the grave? And how close could he have come to getting away with it forever?

    Join us as we unravel the final chapter of one of America’s most terrifying predators. This is True Terror on Tap.

    https://www.instagram.com/trueterrorontap/

    49 min
  • Inside the Life of Israel Keyes Part 2

    Send us a text

    Israel Keyes was unlike any serial killer we’ve ever seen—methodical, patient, and terrifyingly precise. In Part 2 of our deep dive, we pick up where we left off: Vermont, June 2011. Keyes had just arrived, retrieving a kill kit he had buried a year earlier, and searching for his next victims. What followed was an execution of a double murder that would later become the key to understanding his nationwide crimes.

    But the Curriers weren’t his only victims.

    We take you step by step through Keyes’ terrifying admissions, his confession tapes, and the twisted games he played with the FBI. He revealed just enough to haunt investigators—but never enough to solve the full mystery. He talked about murders in Washington, New York, Texas, and the Midwest, but refused to name names. He hinted at bodies that would never be found. He told law enforcement, 

    ‘You’ll never catch me the way you want to.’

    “nd in the end, he was right.

    Before he could be executed by the state, Keyes made sure to execute himself. But even in death, he left one last message—an eerie suicide note and 11 blood-drawn skulls found under his prison bed, possibly a tally of his true number of victims. How many did he really kill? What secrets did he take to the grave? And how close could he have come to getting away with it forever?

    Join us as we unravel the final chapter of one of America’s most terrifying predators. This is True Terror on Tap.

    https://www.instagram.com/trueterrorontap/

    49 min
  • Listener Tales 7

    Send us a text

    History isn’t just something we read about—it lingers. It listens. And sometimes… it reminds us it’s still here. In this episode of Nightmares of the Americas: Indigenous Tales, we dive into listener-submitted stories that bring us face-to-face with the unexplained.

    From Mission San Luis de Apalachee in Florida, where voices from the past still echo in locked rooms and empty churches, to the shadowed roads of the Navajo Nation, where something unnatural watches and waits, these stories reveal the thin line between history and hauntings.

    We thought we were just telling stories. But halfway through a story on a Navajo reservation, Joseph’s equipment completely shut down—no warning, no explanation. Maybe it was just a technical glitch. Or maybe, we were talking about something we weren’t supposed to.”

    Some places don’t want to be forgotten. Some stories don’t want to be told.

    Please remember to subscribe, thanks for listening! 

    🎧 Listen now—just be careful who’s listening with you.

    Merch store- https://indigenoustales.threadless.com/
    Email us at [email protected]
    Also check out our Instagram -https://www.instagram.com/indigenous_tales/
    And our TikTok -https://www.tiktok.com/@indigenous_tales
    Amanda Bland Dallas area Bakery
    instagram - https://www.instagram.com/cupidsweetsbakes/
    Cupid Sweets- https://www.facebook.com/cupidsweets

    37 min
  • Inside the Life of Israel Keyes Part 1

    Send us a text

    In the first episode of our deep dive into the life and crimes of Israel Keyes, we trace his journey from an isolated childhood in rural Washington to his time in the U.S. Army, uncovering the early signs of a predator in the making. Raised in a strict and extremist household, Keyes developed a fascination with violence, control, and meticulous planning—skills that would later define his reign of terror. We explore his early criminal activity, his obsession with evading law enforcement, and the disturbing tactics he honed long before his first known murders. As he begins traveling the country, burying "kill kits" and perfecting his methods, Keyes moves closer to the crime that would bring him national attention. This is the origin story of one of the most calculated serial killers in modern history.

    🎧 Subscribe now and follow along as we unravel the chilling story of Israel Keyes.

    https://www.instagram.com/trueterrorontap/

    1 hr 2 min
  • Battle Royale

    Send us a text

    In this special edition of Nightmares of the Americas: Indigenous Tales, we are on a mission to determine the most feared Indigenous creature of Latin America!

    Six legendary nightmares, each with centuries of terror behind them, will face off in a single-elimination battle royale, where we decide who truly reigns as the most terrifying being of them all.

    Will it be Camazotz, the bloodthirsty Mayan bat god who ruled the underworld? Or La Lechuza, the cursed owl-witch whose cries lure the unsuspecting to their doom? Can El Tío, the demonic overlord of the mines, crush the competition with his terrifying domain?

    In each round, we analyze their origins, abilities, and encounters, and tell a story or two, then choose who is the most feared, based on their legendary status,, and the sheer terror they inspire.

    But this is just the beginning! We’ll be running future battle royales for North America, and beyond to find the greatest nightmare of the Americas.

    Who will rise as the most feared Indigenous entity of Latin America? Let’s find out. 

    Merch store- https://indigenoustales.threadless.com/
    Email us at [email protected]
    Also check out our Instagram -https://www.instagram.com/indigenous_tales/
    And our TikTok -https://www.tiktok.com/@indigenous_tales
    Amanda Bland Dallas area Bakery
    instagram - https://www.instagram.com/cupidsweetsbakes/
    Cupid Sweets- https://www.facebook.com/cupidsweets

    39 min
  • Listener Tales – Encounters with the Unknown

    Send us a text

    Real stories. Real terror. No urban legends—just firsthand accounts from True Terror on Tap listeners who experienced the unexplained.

    In this chilling episode, we dive into encounters that defy logic:

    • The Padre Hotel Haunting – A guest knowingly checks into one of Bakersfield’s most haunted hotels, only to experience the infamous shadow figure firsthand.

    • The Vanishing Hitchhiker – A truck driver picks up a stranded woman on a desolate highway… and watches her disappear before his eyes.

    • The Whispering Woods – A solo hiker ventures deep into the Pacific Northwest wilderness, only to hear voices circling her—voices that shouldn’t exist.

    • The Man in the Window – A childhood memory resurfaces as one listener recalls a figure watching from outside his home. But was he ever outside at all?

    We don’t just tell these stories—we break them down, exploring the haunted history behind these locations and the eerie patterns that emerge from different encounters. Is there a logical explanation? Or do some places—and some things—refuse to be ignored?

    Pull up a chair, pour yourself a drink, and get ready for a night of True Terror on Tap.

    https://www.instagram.com/trueterrorontap/

    56 min
  • Turtle Island Talk 11

    Send us a text

    Welcome to Turtle Island Talk 11, where we go into real stories impacting Indigenous communities across North America. From government surveillance and historical injustices to Indigenous resilience, activism, and culture—nothing is off the table.

    In this episode, we explore the case of Jason Kennedy, a First Nations man who underwent surgery at Grace Hospital in Winnipeg—only to wake up and discover that doctors had amputated the wrong leg. Was this a tragic mistake, or part of the ongoing medical negligence Indigenous people face? We break down the long history of medical racism and what needs to change.

    We also discuss Denise Shafer, the owner of La Indita, a beloved Mexican and Indigenous restaurant in Tucson, Arizona, that was recently targeted by ICE. Was this just a “routine” inspection, or a case of racial profiling? And why do Indigenous and Mexican-owned businesses seem to face this kind of scrutiny more than others?

    Alongside these heavy-hitting stories, we also have much more so sit back and enjoy this episode of Turtle Island Talk. 


    Check out La Indita in Tucson AZ- https://lainditaaz.com/

    Merch store- https://indigenoustales.threadless.com/
    Email us at [email protected]
    Also check out our Instagram -https://www.instagram.com/indigenous_tales/
    And our TikTok -https://www.tiktok.com/@indigenous_tales
    Amanda Bland Dallas area Bakery
    instagram - https://www.instagram.com/cupidsweetsbakes/
    Cupid Sweets- https://www.facebook.com/cupidsweets

    38 min
  • Escaping the Highway

    Send us a text

    "On a cold February night in 2004, Maura Murray crashed her car on a dark New Hampshire road. She was seen standing beside it, refusing help. Just seven minutes later, she was gone—without a trace."

    "Nearly a decade later, in 2013, Bryce Laspisa was driving home to his parents in California. But something wasn’t right. His behavior became erratic, his route made no sense, and after sitting in his car for hours, he suddenly vanished—his wrecked vehicle found at the bottom of a ravine, but Bryce was nowhere to be found."

    "Two roads. Two stories with missing endings. What really happened to Maura and Bryce? Were they running? Were they taken? Or did the highway itself claim them? Tonight, we dive into the haunting mysteries of those who vanished without a trace."

    "Buckle up. This is True Terror on Tap."

    https://www.instagram.com/trueterrorontap/

    1 hr 1 min
  • Escaping the Highway

    Send us a text

    "On a cold February night in 2004, Maura Murray crashed her car on a dark New Hampshire road. She was seen standing beside it, refusing help. Just seven minutes later, she was gone—without a trace."

    "Nearly a decade later, in 2013, Bryce Laspisa was driving home to his parents in California. But something wasn’t right. His behavior became erratic, his route made no sense, and after sitting in his car for hours, he suddenly vanished—his wrecked vehicle found at the bottom of a ravine, but Bryce was nowhere to be found."

    "Two roads. Two stories with missing endings. What really happened to Maura and Bryce? Were they running? Were they taken? Or did the highway itself claim them? Tonight, we dive into the haunting mysteries of those who vanished without a trace."

    "Buckle up. This is True Terror on Tap."

    https://www.instagram.com/trueterrorontap/

    1 hr 1 min
  • Interview with: Vincent Neil Emerson

    Send us a text

    In this episode of Nightmares of the Americas: Indigenous Tales, we sit down with one of the most compelling voices in country and folk music today—Vincent Neil Emerson. His music is raw, real, and deeply personal, weaving in stories of his Choctaw-Apache heritage, the displacement of his ancestors, and the struggles and triumphs that shape his sound.

    From growing up in East Texas to touring with legends like Colter Wall, Charley Crockett, and Rodney Crowell, Vincent shares his journey as a songwriter, the pressures of representing Indigenous voices in country music, and how storytelling remains at the heart of his craft.

    We’ll dive into the history behind his song The Ballad of the Choctaw-Apache, discuss his latest album The Golden Crystal Kingdom, and even explore some eerie folklore from his childhood.

    Find him at https://www.vincentneilemerson.com/

    Merch store- https://indigenoustales.threadless.com/
    Email us at [email protected]
    Also check out our Instagram -https://www.instagram.com/indigenous_tales/
    And our TikTok -https://www.tiktok.com/@indigenous_tales
    Amanda Bland Dallas area Bakery
    instagram - https://www.instagram.com/cupidsweetsbakes/
    Cupid Sweets- https://www.facebook.com/cupidsweets

    41 min

About True Terror on Tap

From the publisher's feed

Welcome to True Terror on Tap, the ultimate podcast for fans of the eerie and the macabre. Join us as we delve into the chilling realms of true crime, horror, creepypasta, lore, myth, and the…

More shows like True Terror on Tap

Lore by Aaron Mahnke

Lore

45,251 Listeners

Unexplained by iHeartPodcasts

Unexplained

7,725 Listeners

The Paranormal Podcast by Jim Harold

The Paranormal Podcast

4,761 Listeners

Unexplained Encounters by Eeriecast Network

Unexplained Encounters

5,145 Listeners

Let's Not Meet: A True Horror Podcast by Cryptic County

Let's Not Meet: A True Horror Podcast

8,972 Listeners

Morbid by Ash Kelley & Alaina Urquhart

Morbid

102,182 Listeners

The Night Owl: True Ghost Stories by The Night Owl: True Ghost Stories

The Night Owl: True Ghost Stories

3,052 Listeners

Ghosted! by Roz Hernandez by Exactly Right and iHeartPodcasts

Ghosted! by Roz Hernandez

3,332 Listeners

Scared To Death by Dan Cummins, Lynze Cummins

Scared To Death

14,041 Listeners

Radio Rental by Tenderfoot TV & Audacy

Radio Rental

32,927 Listeners

Strange and Unexplained with Daisy Eagan by Strange and Unexplained with Daisy Eagan

Strange and Unexplained with Daisy Eagan

10,078 Listeners

Odd Trails: True Paranormal Stories by Brandon Lanier

Odd Trails: True Paranormal Stories

1,601 Listeners

MrBallen Podcast: Strange, Dark & Mysterious Stories by Ballen Studios

MrBallen Podcast: Strange, Dark & Mysterious Stories

29,006 Listeners

Heart Starts Pounding: Horrors, Hauntings and Mysteries by Heart Starts Pounding

Heart Starts Pounding: Horrors, Hauntings and Mysteries

5,024 Listeners

Rattled & Shook by Tenderfoot TV & Audacy

Rattled & Shook

1,404 Listeners