
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


🔔 Subscribe for more true crime episodes:
https://www.youtube.com/@BeachHouse34?sub_confirmation=1
In Episode 29 of The Avery Trial, we hear more from Sergeant Colborn and find out how the key to Teresa Halbach's vehicle was discovered - and the timeline that seems a bit fishy.
Colborn claims he was shoving a bookcase back in place in Steve Avery's tiny bedroom when all of a sudden, Lieutenant Lenk pointed out the key. But with Calumet Deputy Kucharski nearby, distracted and writing a report, was anyone actually watching Lenk? And if Colborn didn’t see the key fall, how did it suddenly appear—days into the investigation?
We also get a glimpse into the behind-the-scenes power dynamics: how closely Lenk and Colborn worked, their ties to the Avery lawsuit, and even Colborn’s concern about being named a defendant in Steven Avery's civil lawsuit against Manitowoc County.
It can't help much either with honest testimony while Investigator Wiegert is present in the courtroom every day. We can’t help but ask—how much pressure were these officers under, and how much could they really say?
👀 Watch from the beginning:
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLCJ3mSH5sYXsw6fiiDWTDAL0bYtfSwvKz
Subscribe & join the community:
🔔 YouTube: @BeachHouse34
🎧 Podcast: https://pod.link/1665226558
📸 Instagram: https://Instagram.com/BeachHouse34Podcast
🚪 Patreon: https://patreon.com/BeachHouse34
✨ Website: https://BeachHouse34.com
🌟💰 Tip Jar: https://ko-fi.com/beachhouse34
🎥 Related Viewing
Watch Making a Murderer on Netflix: https://www.netflix.com/title/80000770
(This case was first introduced to many through this documentary. We recommend watching it for broader context—but this podcast dives much deeper into the testimony and timeline.)
00:00 Avery Trial: Episode 29 - Did This Lawsuit Skew Colburn’s Testimony?
01:59 Direct Continues
06:46 Exhibit 114
08:15 Exhibit 158
13:00 Exhibit 208
17:15 Exhibit 209
17:38 Exhibit 210
18:45 Exhibit 208
18:58 Exhibit 210
25:14 Exhibit 169
27:24 Exhibit 211
33:36 Cross Examination
44:10 Jury Not Present
48:11 What Just Happened?
50:08 Re-Direct Resumes
TL;DR - Why does it matter if Colborn was listed as a defendant?
01:16:21 Colborn's Call to Dispatch
01:16:49 Colborn's Call to Dispatch
01:17:06 Colborn's Call to Dispatch
01:19:04 Exhibit 153
01:19:42 Colborn's Call to Dispatch
01:22:10 Summary
LINKS & SOURCES
foulplay.site
StevenAveryCase.org
https://www.youtube.com/@BM-iv9xu
In Episode 28 of the Avery Trial, we dig into Sergeant Andrew Colburn’s testimony—and the moment the investigation shifted from a missing person to something much darker. Why were handcuffs and leg irons taken from Avery’s home before there was any confirmed crime? Why were the guns left behind?
This episode questions the early decisions made by law enforcement—what they took, what they ignored, and whether they followed procedure or jumped straight to guilt. Legally, constitutionally, something doesn’t add up.
👀 Watch from the beginning: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLCJ3mSH5sYXsw6fiiDWTDAL0bYtfSwvKz
Subscribe & join the community:
🔔 YouTube: @BeachHouse34
🎧 Podcast: https://pod.link/1665226558
📸 Instagram: https://Instagram.com/BeachHouse34Podcast
🚪 Patreon: https://patreon.com/BeachHouse34
✨ Website: https://BeachHouse34.com
🌟💰 Tip Jar: https://ko-fi.com/beachhouse34
00:00 The Avery Trial: Episode 28
07:11 Exhibit 86
31:38 Exhibit 103
38:07 Exhibit 102
38:41 Exhibit 163
39:06 Exhibit 175
42:55 Exhibit 38
44:35 Exhibit 119
49:05 Exhibit 38
50:07 Exhibit 52
52:44 Exhibit 55
54:45 Exhibit 164
58:42 Exhibit 165
59:51 Wrap Up
LINKS & SOURCES
foulplay.site
StevenAveryCase.org
🔔 Subscribe for more true crime episodes:
https://www.youtube.com/@BeachHouse34?sub_confirmation=1
The Avery Trial: Episode 28 – Evidence Taken Before a Crime Was Confirmed
Thumbnail Text: Something’s Off Here
In Episode 28 of the Avery Trial, we dig into Sergeant Andrew Colburn’s testimony—and the moment the investigation shifted from a missing person to something much darker. Why were handcuffs and leg irons taken from Avery’s home before there was any confirmed crime? Why were the guns left behind?
This episode questions the early decisions made by law enforcement—what they took, what they ignored, and whether they followed procedure or jumped straight to guilt. Legally, constitutionally, something doesn’t add up.
👀 Watch from the beginning: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLCJ3mSH5sYXsw6fiiDWTDAL0bYtfSwvKz
Subscribe & join the community:
🔔 YouTube: @BeachHouse34
🎧 Podcast: https://pod.link/1665226558
📸 Instagram: https://Instagram.com/BeachHouse34Podcast
🚪 Patreon: https://patreon.com/BeachHouse34
✨ Website: https://BeachHouse34.com
🌟💰 Tip Jar: https://ko-fi.com/beachhouse34
00:00 The Avery Trial: Episode 28
07:11 Exhibit 86
31:38 Exhibit 103
38:07 Exhibit 102
38:41 Exhibit 163
39:06 Exhibit 175
42:55 Exhibit 38
44:35 Exhibit 119
49:05 Exhibit 38
50:07 Exhibit 52
52:44 Exhibit 55
54:45 Exhibit 164
58:42 Exhibit 165
59:51 Wrap Up
LINKS & SOURCES
foulplay.site
StevenAveryCase.org
📺 Subscribe here: https://youtube.com/beachhouse34
In this episode, we wrap up the testimony of Sgt. William Tyson, the officer from Calumet county whose job it was to watch the Manitowoc officers while they searched Steven Avery's home.
The prosecution made a big deal about this bleach bottle in the bathroom but conveniently failed to mention that this is also where Steven's washer and dryer were located. They also made it wound as if Teresa's number in a notebook found in Steven's house was a piece of evidence even though two different colored inks were used. And then there's the hood latch swab which didn't happen until 5 months after the crime lab had the RAV4 in their possession.
Why?
Piece by piece, it feels less like they were uncovering the truth, and more like they were making sure Steven Avery was their guy.
Next time, Sergeant Andrew Colborn takes the stand — and his testimony could change everything.
00:00 The Avery Trial: Episode 27 - Tyson: "To the Best of My Ability"
01:35 Tyson Cross-Examination
20:42 Exhibit 101
20:58 Exhibit 104
29:14 Exhibit 207
30:23 Exhibit 206
32:24 Exhibit 163
46:04 Exhibit 194
50:35 Exhibit 205
59:10 Exhibit 195
01:03:33 Redirect by Kratz
01:06:07 Wrap
Sources: foulplay.site, stevenaverycase.org
Today, we hear more from the Calumet County officer who was the babysitter for Maniwooc Cunty officers as they searched Steven Avery's trailer. For three hours.
The jury learns about notebooks, phone numbers, a for-sale sign, and even a bleach bottle — framing them as incriminating evidence against Steven Avery. But are these items really proof of anything, or just everyday household objects twisted to fit a narrative?
Again, why were Manitowoc County officers involved? Still? And what about the carpet in Steven’s trailer — why didn’t investigators remove it if they believed a cleanup had happened? Why did it sit there, in the trailer, for months? After they had released the "scene"?
The inconsistencies are piling up, and the jury is being shown supposed evidence that in reality, anyone could have had in their home yet the prosecution is frames them as something nefarious. Are we seeing justice at work — or manipulation?
👉 Watch now and decide for yourself.
🔔 Don’t forget to subscribe: @beachhouse34
Subscribe & join the community:
🔔 YouTube: @BeachHouse34
🎧 Podcast: https://pod.link/1665226558
📸 Instagram: Instagram.com/BeachHouse34Podcast
🚪 Patreon: patreon.com/BeachHouse34
✨Website: https://BeachHouse34.com
🌟💰 Tip Jar: https://ko-fi.com/beachhouse34
00:00 The Avery Trial: Episode 26 - Manipulating the Jury
03:12 Direct Examination Continues
06:26 Exhibit 163
09:45 Exhibit 166
10:29 Exhibit 167
11:48 Exhibit 168
15:11 Exhibit 169
16:19 Exhibit 170
16:33 Exhibit 171
17:54 Exhibit 170
19:21 Exhibit 172
23:11 Exhibit 204
23:47 Exhibit 203
24:16 Exhibit 173
24:37 Exhibit 174
27:07 Exhibit 200
32:38 Exhibit 175
33:21 Exhibit 198
33:43 Exhibit 148
34:24 Exhibit 176
34:51 Exhibit 197
34:51 Exhibit 199
35:20 Exhibit 194
35:48 Exhibit 149
36:00 Exhibit 177
36:19 Exhibit 178
36:30 Exhibit 179
36:53 Exhibit 202
37:20 Exhibit 150
37:34 Exhibit 180
37:45 Exhibit 181
38:02 Exhibit 201
38:22 Exhibit 182
38:27 Exhibit 151
39:02 Exhibit 195
39:27 Exhibit 183
39:35 Exhibit 184
40:09 Exhibit 185
40:37 Exhibit 186
40:45 Exhibit 187
41:08 Exhibit 188
41:21 Exhibit 189
42:06 Exhibit 190
45:43 Exhibit 205
46:38 Exhibit 191
46:47 Exhibit 192
53:32 Exhibit 59
01:01:18 Exhibit 193
01:07:01 Summary
Sources: StevenAveryCase.org, FoulPlay.site
Today, we hear from Deputy David Siders, who talks about the burn barrel and the contents that were found inside. Things like you'd imagine, ashes, etc., but also, according to him, melted plastic and what he says were cell phone parts.
Then we hear the beginning of testimony from Sergeant William Tyson, who was "the guy" assigned to Manitowoc County officers as they did searches of items on the Avery property. Why was Manitowoc County still involved?
#truecrime, #truecrimecommunity, #truecrimepodcast, #crime
Subscribe & join the community:
🔔 YouTube: @BeachHouse34
🎧 Podcast: https://pod.link/1665226558
📸 Instagram: Instagram.com/BeachHouse34Podcast
🚪 Patreon: patreon.com/BeachHouse34
✨Website: https://BeachHouse34.com
🌟💰 Tip Jar: https://ko-fi.com/beachhouse34
00:00 The Avery Trial: Episode 25 - What the Burn Barrel Reveals
02:26 Prosecution Questoins David Siders
04:41 Exhibit 85
06:57 Exhibit 37
08:04 Exhibit 51
09:02 Exhibit 59
09:52 Exhibit 156
10:35 Exhibit 154
10:54 Exhibit 155
11:53 Exhibit 157
13:53 Cross Examination of Deputy Siders
14:00 Exhibit 51
14:44 Exhibit 37
17:08 Exhibit 51
22:44 Direct Examination of Sergeant William Tyson
27:37 Exhibit 86
37:49 Summary
Sources: FoulPlay.site, StevenAveryCase.org
🌟💰 Tip Jar: https://ko-fi.com/beachhouse34
In this episode, we continue with John Ertl's testimony as the defense continues to question him. We learn about the handling of the contents of the burn pit outside of Avery's residence, the garaage, and whether or not the evidence was collected and documented properly.
Ertl talks about how the contents of the burn pit was collected and sifted. Not only that, faint luminol reactions in the garage that turned out to be...not blood.
Bottom line is, the crime lab team wasn't allowed to process the scene the way they were trained to do because others stepped in.
Subscribe & join the community:
🔔 YouTube: @BeachHouse34
🎧 Podcast: https://pod.link/1665226558
📸 Instagram: Instagram.com/BeachHouse34Podcast
🚪 Patreon: patreon.com/BeachHouse34
✨Website: https://BeachHouse34.com
00:00 The Avery Trial: Episode 24
01:23 Defense Questioning Continues
13:52 Redirect
26:18 Recross
32:18 Summary
33:07 The Zellner Files
🔔 YouTube: @BeachHouse34
The DNA guy's testimony continues. In this episode, it's the defense who gets to question him. we'll hear about issues with evidence collection, timelines that don't quite add up, and why wasn't the state crime lab team given full control over key searches? They didn't even process Avery's home or garage from start to finish. Something that is done on nearly every other crime case.
It's interesting to say the least...
Subscribe & join the community:
🔔 YouTube: @BeachHouse34
🎧 Podcast: https://pod.link/1665226558
📸 Instagram: Instagram.com/BeachHouse34Podcast
🚪 Patreon: patreon.com/BeachHouse34
✨Website: https://BeachHouse34.com
🌟💰 Tip Jar: https://ko-fi.com/beachhouse34
00:00 The Avery Trial: Episode 23 - Why Block the Crime Lab Team?
01:50 The Defense Questions John Ertl
02:20 Exhibit 159
20:49 Exhibit 143
30:13 Exhibit 91
41:16 Exhibit 135
41:40 Exhibit 29
52:47 Exhibit 160
55:55 Lunch Break Taken
58:21 Wrap Up
Sources: foulplay.site
🔔 YouTube: @BeachHouse34
The DNA guy's testimony continues. In this episode, it's the defense who gets to question him. we'll hear about issues with evidence collection, timelines that don't quite add up, and why wasn't the state crime lab team given full control over key searches? They didn't even process Avery's home or garage from start to finish. Something that is done on nearly every other crime case.
It's interesting to say the least...
Subscribe & join the community:
🔔 YouTube: @BeachHouse34
🎧 Podcast: https://pod.link/1665226558
📸 Instagram: Instagram.com/BeachHouse34Podcast
🚪 Patreon: patreon.com/BeachHouse34
✨Website: https://BeachHouse34.com
🌟💰 Tip Jar: https://ko-fi.com/beachhouse34
00:00 The Avery Trial: Episode 23 - Why Block the Crime Lab Team?
01:50 The Defense Questions John Ertl
02:20 Exhibit 159
20:49 Exhibit 143
30:13 Exhibit 91
41:16 Exhibit 135
41:40 Exhibit 29
52:47 Exhibit 160
55:55 Lunch Break Taken
58:21 Wrap Up
Sources: foulplay.site
DNA doesn’t lie—at least, that’s what we’re told. But in Steven Avery’s trial, the way evidence was collected, handled, and explained leaves you scratching your head.
Today, we hear from the state’s DNA expert, John Ertl. He walks the jury through his role in collecting and documenting key evidence: from Teresa Halbach’s RAV4, to suspicious stains in Steven’s garage, to burn barrels, a golf cart (another distraction?) and even the car crusher that has become weirdly infamous.
But here’s the issue it was Ertl's team, the field response team who was called in to do the professional processing. Yet, when they got to Avery's garage, it had already been done. Not by them. By who then?
Why did investigators raise the car crusher ramp only to be told by Fassbender, “we don’t need that anymore”? Did the field response team really have to investigate there or was it a distraction because at the same time, Teresa's RAV4 was being moved into the trailer.
By the way, it was an enclosed trailer. Who was in the trailer with the car? Do we even know?
This is the first of a couple Episodes where Ertl is on the stand. This is Part 1 - the prosecution questions him. In the next episode, the defense gets a stab at him.
Subscribe & join the community:
🔔 YouTube: @BeachHouse34
🎧 Podcast: https://pod.link/1665226558
📸 Instagram: Instagram.com/BeachHouse34Podcast
🚪 Patreon: patreon.com/BeachHouse34
✨Website: https://BeachHouse34.com
🌟💰 Tip Jar: https://ko-fi.com/beachhouse34
00:00 The Avery Trial - Episode 22
01:59 Prosecution Questions John Ertl
12:41 Exhibit 86
20:53 Exhibit 130
27:19 Exhibit 86
34:04 Exhibit 66
53:45 Exhibit 84
59:52 Exhibit 156
01:06:57 Exhibit 50
01:15:20 Exhibit 107
01:18:53 Wrap Up
Source: Foulplay.site, StevenAveryTrial.org
From the publisher's feed

10,574 Listeners