In April 1532, Sir William Pennington was cut down on the very edge of Westminster sanctuary—and his killers walked away with a manslaughter verdict, a £1,000 pardon, and glittering careers. In this Tudor true-crime deep dive, I unpack the fight, the politics, and the legal loopholes that made it possible.
What’s inside:
The argument and fight, from Westminster Hall to the sanctuary precinctHow sanctuary should have worked—and how it was bentThe official indictment vs. Carlo Capello’s explosive diplomatic reportCromwell’s intervention and the price of a royal pardonHolbein’s 1537 portrait: the scar carried from the fightWhat this case tells us about power, patronage, and Tudor justiceSources & further reading:
Shannon McSheffrey, “The Slaying of Sir William Pennington: Legal Narrative and the Late Medieval English Archive" - https://journals.lib.unb.ca/index.php/flor/article/view/21566/25053Venetian ambassador Carlo Capello’s report, Calendar of State Papers Relating To English Affairs in the Archives of Venice, Volume 4, 1527-1533, 761 - https://www.british-history.ac.uk/cal-state-papers/venice/vol4/pp331-334Hans Holbein: preparatory sketch & portrait of Richard Southwell (1537) - https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/a/a3/Hans_Holbein_d._J._060.jpg and https://www.rct.uk/collection/912242/sir-richard-southwell-15023-1564If you enjoy Tudor true crime & deep dives into the records, please like, subscribe, and ring the bell.
Tell me in the comments: Was this justice, or a cover for court politics?
#TudorHistory #TrueCrime #HenryVIII #ThomasCromwell #AnneBoleyn #Westminster #Sanctuary #Holbein #RichardSouthwell #SirWilliamPennington