UNHEARD with Emily Moheb

Kirk Hysell Jr. was a father spending time with his young son when the night took a devastating turn. After giving his son melatonin and putting him to bed, a series of events unfolded that would lead to a shocking homicide investigation.

In this episode of UNHEARD, we break down the timeline, the evidence, the circumstances surrounding the killing, and the disturbing details investigators uncovered afterward.

This episode contains discussion of homicide, violence, and other disturbing subject matter. Listener discretion is advised.

When police arrived at Jessika Garrett’s home, her two young daughters answered the door and told officers their mother was sleeping. But when officers entered the bedroom, they discovered Jessika was dead.

Her husband, Brandon Garrett, would go on to tell investigators several conflicting stories about what happened, including the extraordinary claim that Jessika had asked him to kill her.

In this episode of UNHEARD, we examine the police bodycam footage, Brandon’s interrogations, the history of domestic violence, and the warning signs that preceded Jessika’s murder.

How did two little girls end up alone in a home with their mother’s body? And what did Brandon tell investigators as the truth began to emerge?

Watch the full video episode, including police bodycam footage and interrogation recordings, on YouTube at UNHEARD.

#UNHEARD #TrueCrimePodcast #JessikaGarrett #BrandonGarrett #TrueCrime #DomesticViolenceAwareness

Eighteen-year-old Natalie Martin was on a post-graduation trip with friends in Myrtle Beach when she was killed inside their hotel room — while her friends were just feet away.

In this episode of UNHEARD, we look at the events leading up to Natalie’s death, the relationship between Natalie and her boyfriend, the accounts of the friends who were there that night, and the evidence that ultimately led to a guilty plea.

This case is also a devastating reminder of how quickly relationship violence can escalate, even when other people are nearby.

Content Warning: This episode discusses intimate partner violence, strangulation, and homicide.

On July 12, 2024, 42-year-old Matthew Restelli arrived at his mother-in-law’s home in American Fork, Utah. Moments after entering the house, he was shot seven times by his brother-in-law.

His family claimed it was self-defense. But investigators quickly discovered evidence suggesting something far more sinister.

Matthew had been shot multiple times in the back. A knife was found in his right hand, despite him being left-handed. And a trail of text messages and other evidence pointed toward a carefully planned murder involving his own wife, Kathryn Restelli, her mother, Tracey Grist, and her brother, Kevin Ellis.

In this episode of UNHEARD, we examine the shocking family conspiracy, the evidence that unraveled their story, and the investigation into Matthew’s murder.

Want to watch the evidence unfold? UNHEARD is also on YouTube, where you can watch the full video episode featuring police bodycam footage, 911 calls, courtroom testimony, and evidence from the investigation.

Subscribe to UNHEARD on YouTube, Apple Podcasts, and Spotify for more true crime investigations and the psychology behind violent crime.

#MatthewRestelli #TrueCrime #UNHEARD #TrueCrimePodcast #UtahMurder

In February 2025, authorities discovered the bodies of Donald Mayer and Tatiana Casap inside their home in Waukesha, Wisconsin. Their 17-year-old son, Nikita Casap, was missing.

Investigators believe Nikita murdered his mother and stepfather, then remained inside the home for nearly two weeks before leaving in the family SUV with their money, valuables, and dog.

When a police officer in a small Kansas town pulled him over for running a stop sign, the investigation took a big turn.

In this episode of UNHEARD, we walk through the timeline, the disturbing evidence investigators uncovered, Nikita’s alleged plans beyond the murders, and the psychological questions surrounding a teenager accused of killing the two people raising him.

A case involving alleged premeditation, extremist ideology, and 12 days that are almost impossible to comprehend.

Former American Idol contestant and worship pastor Caleb Flynn told police an intruder had broken into his Ohio home and killed his wife, Ashley, while their two daughters were inside. But investigators quickly began questioning his story.

Behind the marriage was a years-long affair, more than 100,000 text messages, disturbing conversations about Ashley’s death, and evidence prosecutors said showed the supposed home invasion had been staged. In September 2026, a jury found Caleb Flynn guilty of murdering his wife.

In this episode of UNHEARD, we examine the 911 call, the affair, the digital evidence, the prosecution’s case, and the details that ultimately led to Caleb Flynn’s conviction.

When Emily Lambert disappeared during a trip to New Mexico, the man she was with reported her missing. But as investigators questioned him, his story began to unravel—and he ultimately led police to Emily’s body.

In this episode of UNHEARD, Emily Moheb examines the murder of Emily Lambert, the conflicting accounts given to police, the evidence that exposed what happened after she left the Stevens Inn, and the investigation that brought the truth to light.

On June 15, 2021, Alexander Jackson called 911 from his family’s Cedar Rapids, Iowa home and claimed a masked intruder had broken in, murdered his parents and sister, and shot him in the foot. But investigators quickly began questioning whether an intruder had ever existed at all.

In this episode of UNHEARD, Emily Moheb examines the murders of Jan Jackson, Melissa Jackson, and 19-year-old Sabrina Jackson, the evidence prosecutors said showed Alexander staged himself as a fourth victim, his changing account of what happened inside the home, and what ultimately happened at trial.

In Fall City, Washington, five members of one family were killed inside their home. The surviving 11-year-old daughter was wounded, and investigators quickly focused on her 15-year-old brother.

He claimed another brother was responsible. Prosecutors said the evidence told a very different story.

In this episode of UNHEARD, I walk through what happened inside the home, the defendant’s account, the evidence presented in court, the competing arguments about his mental and physical condition, and what ultimately happened in the case.

This episode includes discussion of homicide, violence involving children, and mental health.