Unsolved Couple

In this bonus episode, Sierra and Ben step away from Unsolved Mysteries to talk about a real-life mystery unfolding in their own backyard. They sit down for an open, honest conversation about the Nancy Guthrie case, sharing what they know, what stands out, and what still doesn’t make sense. From living in Tucson and understanding Pima County’s history with cases like this, to discussing patterns, timelines, and unanswered questions, this episode is about thoughtful exploration.A candid conversation about the mystery, and the questions surrounding Nancy Guthrie.

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/unsolved-couple--6745609/support.

👉 Support the show: coff.ee/unsolvedcouple
📧 Email: [email protected]
📱 Facebook: Unsolved Couple Podcast
📸 Instagram: @unsolvedcouplepod
Original artwork by @evelinejones3
* We’re here to share the stories and spark curiosity, but remember—always do your own digging! Everything we cover is based on public sources, and everyone is considered innocent until proven guilty.

In this episode of Unsolved Couple, we unravel one of the most chilling collections of mysteries ever featured on Unsolved Mysteries. A woman claims memories of dying at Pearl Harbor. A murdered husband’s killer resurfaces years later with terrifying threats. A glamorous Las Vegas con artist vanishes after stealing $150,000. And a young clerk disappears without a trace.
From reincarnation and hypnosis to extortion, fraud, and unsolved disappearances, this episode explores how the past refuses to stay buried.

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/unsolved-couple--6745609/support.

👉 Support the show: coff.ee/unsolvedcouple
📧 Email: [email protected]
📱 Facebook: Unsolved Couple Podcast
📸 Instagram: @unsolvedcouplepod
Original artwork by @evelinejones3
* We’re here to share the stories and spark curiosity, but remember—always do your own digging! Everything we cover is based on public sources, and everyone is considered innocent until proven guilty.

This week, Unsolved Couple is dropping a special bonus episode in our regular feed. After hearing from so many of you asking for our take on the heartbreaking disappearance of Nancy Guthrie in Tucson, Arizona, we felt it was important to talk about this case directly. Nancy Guthrie, 84, the mother of Today Show anchor Savannah Guthrie, vanished from her Catalina Foothills home in January 2026 under deeply concerning circumstances. Blood was found at her residence, security cameras were disconnected, and investigators believe she was taken against her will. With FBI involvement, alleged ransom notes, and no publicly named suspects, this case has shaken both the local community and the nation. In this bonus episode, we break down:
• The final hours before Nancy disappeared
• The overnight timeline and digital clues
• Evidence found at the scene
• The ransom note confusion
• The family’s emotional public plea
• Where the investigation stands now We’re sharing this episode here because so many of you asked us to cover it, and because keeping attention on active cases matters. This bonus episode originally comes from our sister podcast, Bite Me, where we dive into trending true crime and breaking cases. Make sure you’re following Bite Me wherever you get your podcasts so you never miss new episodes. If you have any information about this case, contact the Pima County Sheriff’s Department at 520-351-4900 or call 911. 🖤 Thank you for listening, for caring, and for helping keep Nancy’s story alive.

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/unsolved-couple--6745609/support.

👉 Support the show: coff.ee/unsolvedcouple
📧 Email: [email protected]
📱 Facebook: Unsolved Couple Podcast
📸 Instagram: @unsolvedcouplepod
Original artwork by @evelinejones3
* We’re here to share the stories and spark curiosity, but remember—always do your own digging! Everything we cover is based on public sources, and everyone is considered innocent until proven guilty.

In this episode of Unsolved Couple, we follow four mysteries where nothing truly disappears. At a historic New Mexico hotel, guests and staff report restless spirits tied to the violent past of the Wild West. In Florida, a woman moves into a house she’s dreamed of for years, only to discover it may be haunted by the murdered former owner. Then, the chilling disappearance of Mary Ann Perez, a mother who vanished in 1976, takes a new turn years later with an anonymous phone call claiming she’s still alive and being held captive. Finally, authorities hunt for a clever con man who posed as a doctor, vanished across state lines, and left victims robbed of tens of thousands of dollars. Ghosts that linger. Mothers who vanish. Lies that walk free. Some mysteries refuse to check out.

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/unsolved-couple--6745609/support.

👉 Support the show: coff.ee/unsolvedcouple
📧 Email: [email protected]
📱 Facebook: Unsolved Couple Podcast
📸 Instagram: @unsolvedcouplepod
Original artwork by @evelinejones3
* We’re here to share the stories and spark curiosity, but remember—always do your own digging! Everything we cover is based on public sources, and everyone is considered innocent until proven guilty.

In this episode of Unsolved Couple, we recap Unsolved Mysteries Season 4, Episode 6, exploring three unforgettable true crime and mystery cases involving forced adoption, missing identity, domestic violence, and murder. In 1964 England, a pregnant teenager is sent to a convent and forced to give up her baby for adoption, her daughter taken to America and erased from her life for nearly three decades. In Nevada, a man is found wandering the desert with total amnesia, no identification, and no memory of who he is, until a televised plea leads to a shocking reunion and criminal accusations. And in Florida, a teenage bride trapped in a violently abusive marriage is murdered by her husband after attempting to escape, launching a nationwide manhunt for a fugitive who believed he had disappeared for good. This episode covers true crime stories, cold cases, missing persons, amnesia cases, adoption trauma, domestic abuse, spousal murder, and fugitives captured after Unsolved Mysteries broadcasts. If you’re drawn to true crime podcasts, unsolved cases, and the chilling human stories behind them, this episode pulls back the curtain on how secrets, silence, and fear can shape lives for decades.

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/unsolved-couple--6745609/support.

👉 Support the show: coff.ee/unsolvedcouple
📧 Email: [email protected]
📱 Facebook: Unsolved Couple Podcast
📸 Instagram: @unsolvedcouplepod
Original artwork by @evelinejones3
* We’re here to share the stories and spark curiosity, but remember—always do your own digging! Everything we cover is based on public sources, and everyone is considered innocent until proven guilty.

You’re about to hear something new drop into the Unsolved Couple feed. This week only, consider this a little crossover chaos: Bite Me, Sierra’s brand-new weekly true crime snack, is making its debut right here. Short, sharp, and just a little feral, Bite Me serves up bite-sized updates from the ever-churning world of true crime. Alleged, ongoing, eyebrow-raising, and very much still bleeding into the headlines. Next week, Bite Me will launches with a standalone podcast page. But for now, you get the sneak peek. Press play. Take a bite. Try not to choke

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/unsolved-couple--6745609/support.

👉 Support the show: coff.ee/unsolvedcouple
📧 Email: [email protected]
📱 Facebook: Unsolved Couple Podcast
📸 Instagram: @unsolvedcouplepod
Original artwork by @evelinejones3
* We’re here to share the stories and spark curiosity, but remember—always do your own digging! Everything we cover is based on public sources, and everyone is considered innocent until proven guilty.

In this episode of Unsolved Couple, we revisit one of the most haunting chapters of Unsolved Mysteries:
• The mysterious fate of American airmen declared dead after a covert Vietnam-era mission, despite evidence suggesting capture and possible imprisonment far from Southeast Asia.
• A chilling case of domestic terror, where a violent ex-husband stalks, kidnaps, and nearly kills before escaping from jail, only to be caught after a nationwide broadcast.
• And the story of Josephine White, a master con artist who preyed on elderly victims using the classic pigeon drop scam, vanishing with nearly a million dollars and leaving devastation behind. From secret wars and erased POWs, to obsession-fueled violence and calculated deception, this episode explores what happens when the truth is buried, rewritten, or deliberately ignored. If you believe mysteries don’t end when the cameras stop rolling, this one’s for you.

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/unsolved-couple--6745609/support.

👉 Support the show: coff.ee/unsolvedcouple
📧 Email: [email protected]
📱 Facebook: Unsolved Couple Podcast
📸 Instagram: @unsolvedcouplepod
Original artwork by @evelinejones3
* We’re here to share the stories and spark curiosity, but remember—always do your own digging! Everything we cover is based on public sources, and everyone is considered innocent until proven guilty.

In this episode of Unsolved Couple, we revisit one of the most unsettling collections of cases ever featured on Unsolved Mysteries. Along the New Hampshire–Vermont border, young women vanished after brief, ordinary moments. Their bodies would later be discovered in remote wooded areas, revealing a chilling pattern that investigators believe points to a single, calm, methodical serial killer who selected locations rather than victims. One woman, seven months pregnant, survived a brutal attack and lived to describe her would-be killer, offering investigators a rare glimpse into the mind of a predator who believed he had left no witnesses. We also explore the stunning disappearance of a respected New Hampshire judge accused of stealing more than $10 million from friends and neighbors before vanishing without a trace. And finally, the episode turns toward resolution and reunion, as long-buried family secrets lead to emotional meetings between parents and children separated for decades. From unsolved murders and near-fatal encounters to hidden identities and long-awaited reunions, this episode examines how truth can vanish… and sometimes return when least expected.

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/unsolved-couple--6745609/support.

👉 Support the show: coff.ee/unsolvedcouple
📧 Email: [email protected]
📱 Facebook: Unsolved Couple Podcast
📸 Instagram: @unsolvedcouplepod
Original artwork by @evelinejones3
* We’re here to share the stories and spark curiosity, but remember—always do your own digging! Everything we cover is based on public sources, and everyone is considered innocent until proven guilty.

In this chilling episode of Unsolved Couple, we unravel three unforgettable mysteries that blur the line between truth, deception, and belief. First, we meet a young man found wandering the Nevada desert with no memory, no identification, and no past. Known only as Tyler Doe, he displays astonishing skills—flying planes, rebuilding engines, and recalling military-grade knowledge—yet cannot remember his own name. When a shocking reunion reveals his true identity as Paul Beal, the mystery deepens. Was his amnesia real… or an elaborate escape from a crime he doesn’t remember committing? Next, we follow the disturbing case of Joseph Maloney, a man accused of poisoning his estranged wife with a lethal, untraceable chemical. After escaping custody and vanishing across continents, Maloney lives under an assumed identity for nearly two decades—only to disappear once again, leaving behind unanswered questions and a trail of betrayal. Finally, we turn to one of the most debated relics in human history: the Shroud of Turin. Is it the genuine burial cloth of Jesus Christ, marked by a miraculous image? Or a masterful medieval forgery supported by science, skepticism, and centuries of controversy?

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/unsolved-couple--6745609/support.

👉 Support the show: coff.ee/unsolvedcouple
📧 Email: [email protected]
📱 Facebook: Unsolved Couple Podcast
📸 Instagram: @unsolvedcouplepod
Original artwork by @evelinejones3
* We’re here to share the stories and spark curiosity, but remember—always do your own digging! Everything we cover is based on public sources, and everyone is considered innocent until proven guilty.

In this episode of Unsolved Couple, we examine three stories from season four, episode 2 of Unsolved Mysteries:  involving mistaken identity, secret lives, and people who vanished behind borrowed names. From lingering doubts about the death of John Wilkes Booth, to a man repeatedly mistaken for his own double, to a devoted husband whose disappearance revealed he may never have legally existed, each case raises the same disturbing question: who was he, really? These are true crime and historical mysteries where identity blurs, history fractures, and the truth refuses to stay buried.

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/unsolved-couple--6745609/support.

👉 Support the show: coff.ee/unsolvedcouple
📧 Email: [email protected]
📱 Facebook: Unsolved Couple Podcast
📸 Instagram: @unsolvedcouplepod
Original artwork by @evelinejones3
* We’re here to share the stories and spark curiosity, but remember—always do your own digging! Everything we cover is based on public sources, and everyone is considered innocent until proven guilty.