The castle hunks are playing a risky game with Lisa Rinna… Do we think they’re ready to face her fury?! Did Rob make a smart move at that round table? Is Colton on his last breath?  

Plus, what player are we feeling sorry for, despite the players’ accusations? Is this castle filled with high school bullies or are we missing something?! 

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

From his off-camera chats with Colton to his nightmare castle experience with a housewife, Michael Rapaport is here to break down the good, the bad and the ugly of his Traitors experience. 

He tells Tamra, Dolores and Wells all about his eating style that he dubs “the shoveling technique” and admits whether or not he actually drinks a glass with two hands.

Plus, he openly stated that he wanted to ditch the Traitors season 4 reunion… Were Tamra and Dolores able to change his mind?! 

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Stephen Colletti is still gracing our screens this season, but in reality, he’s preparing to be a first-time dad! He tells us what that experience is like and gives us a deep dive into his “unconventional wedding” last year.

When Stephen first arrived at the castle, which traitor did he sniff out immediately? What was a moment that he’s happy never made it on-screen?

Plus, Stephen talks us through tonight’s episode and why he voted the way he did… Can we anticipate the faithfuls having a big comeback?!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Caroline Stanbury is spilling all of her Scotland secrets… Did she love or hate having no contact with Sergio and the kids? What players got under her skin the most? 
Plus, Caroline says there’s a definite love connection this season... Who could be the new “it” couple?! 

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

These episodes left our jaws dropped… What are our thoughts on Michael’s explosive exit? Do we think Ron is a snake in sheep’s clothing?!

There are sone telltale signs on who could win the entire game. Which traitor has one foot out the door? What faithful is writing their own death wish?

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

MJ’s setting the record straight on her near-win on The Traitors, plus, she’s giving us the inside scoop on “The Valley: Persian Style”.

Is she still holding a grudge against C.T. & Trishelle for that blindside?! Would she consider going back on The Traitors for redemption?

She opens up about her very public divorce and her overly critical mother… How much can we expect to see of it on The Valley: Persian Style? 

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Season 4 of The Traitors has officially begun! We’ve said that we want the traitors’ identities to stay a secret, but now that it’s happening, did it fall flat?!

What are Tamra, Dolores and Wells’ first impressions of each cast member? Are the traitors at a disadvantage with no gamers in the turret?

Plus, we try to imagine what a season of this show would look like with an all housewives cast… Would that result in a REAL murder? 

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Happy New Year all of you faithfuls and traitors! We'd like to thank each and every one of you for supporting the podcast this year. We're looking forward to starting 2026 with The Traitors season 4!

Don't forget to tune into our first recap of the new season next week on January 9th... Until then, have a fun and safe holiday!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Happy holidays from us to you. Thank you for supporting and listening to By Order of the Faithfuls.Catch up on our latest recaps during winter break before we’re back with The Traitors season 4 in the New Year!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

It’s the end of season 3, and we have a winner right here with us! Dolores is telling Wells all about her last day in Scotland (which was her version of a wellness retreat), and what it was like to win alongside her friends.

What was her biggest takeaway from this entire experience? Did she actually cry before having to leave the castle? What is it about Traitors that she’s SO obsessed with?! 

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.