WFAN Daily

Craig Carton and Big Mac discuss the mystery surrounding Mitchell Robinson’s injury and his absence from media availability before Game 1 against the Spurs. Craig argues that the New York Knicks are deep enough to win the championship series even if Robinson is limited or sidelined. They also touch on the Mets' recent struggles and reports of locker room dysfunction involving A.J. Brown and the Eagles.

01:03 - Mitchell Robinson Injury Mystery

03:47 - Knicks Depth Without Robinson

12:51 - San Antonio Fan Base

17:59 - Mets Struggles & Eagles Drama

Odell Beckham Jr. is back with the Giants, but Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber say the signing is less about nostalgia and more about concern over Malik Nabers. With Nabers recovering from major knee issues and not looking close to full speed, the Giants’ sudden wave of veteran wide receiver additions feels like a clear sign that they are preparing for uncertainty.

Evan and Tiki break down what Beckham can realistically be at this stage of his career, why Juju Smith Schuster and Braxton Berrios change the conversation, and how the wide receiver room has become a true roster battle. They also debate when Nabers might actually return and why missing significant time would be a major blow to the Giants’ 2026 season.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the blockbuster news that A.J. Brown is officially heading to the New England Patriots—and it sparks a passionate debate about NFL insiders, breaking news, and Dianna Russini's controversial reporting.

Craig argues that Russini deserves full credit for the story after being the first reporter to connect Brown to New England months ago, while questioning why other insiders are rushing to claim the scoop now that the deal is official.

The New York Giants made headlines by bringing back Odell Beckham Jr. while also signing JuJu Smith-Schuster and Braxton Berrios. But are these moves actually helping the Giants, or are they creating more distractions?

On The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to OBJ's return to Big Blue, discuss Malik Nabers' injury concerns after appearing in a charity softball game, debate whether Jaxson Dart has enough weapons around him, and question if the Giants' offseason has become a complete circus.

Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash react to the Knicks landing a Finals matchup with the San Antonio Spurs and explain why, even as Knicks haters, they see it as great news for New York. The Spurs have earned respect after taking down Oklahoma City, but their lack of postseason scars raises real questions about whether they are ready to finish the job.

The guys compare San Antonio’s emotional win to teams that celebrated too soon, debate whether Victor Wembanyama and the Spurs are playing with house money, and contrast that with a Knicks team that has treated every playoff step like business. They also revisit the NBA Cup matchup and why this Finals rematch may give that tournament new meaning.

We started with the Spurs beating the Thunder to set up Knicks/Spurs in the Finals.

Hoff talks about Game 7 of the Western Conference Finals and says how he doesn't care who wins.

Carton and Big Mac critique the New York Giants for prolonging a controversy involving Abdul Carter and Jaxson Dart by holding an unnecessary press conference. They also discuss the mystery of Mitchell Robinson’s broken pinky, questioning why the Knicks are hiding the cause of the injury. Finally, they contrast this secrecy with Aaron Boone’s historical honesty regarding off-field accidents.

01:16 - Giants Press Conference News

02:46 - Giants PR Strategy Questioned

10:42 - Mitchell Robinson Injury Mystery

17:40 - Aaron Boone Injury Honesty

Mitchell Robinson’s broken right pinky has Knicks fans anxious, and Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber dig into what the injury could mean with the NBA Finals looming. With Robinson expected to play after surgery while wearing a brace, the big question is how much the injury will affect his pain tolerance, rebounding, lob catching, rim protection, and overall confidence.

The conversation also turns to Robinson’s brutal free throw struggles and whether this is the moment to try something drastic, including the underhanded “granny shot.” Evan and Tiki debate Rick Barry, Wilt Chamberlain, Ronnie Lott, and the difference between football and basketball toughness while weighing whether Robinson can remain a true X factor for the Knicks.

We started with the news that came out yesterday that Mitchell Robinson is dealing with a broken pinky - will it affect him? The Spurs & Thunder are heading to a game 7 tomorrow night. Watching these games, Boomer wonders how the Knicks aren’t favored over both of these teams.