Plain English with Derek Thompson

What Americans Get Wrong About ADHD


Listen Later

In 1937, a Rhode Island psychiatrist named Charles Bradley ran an experiment on 30 child patients who had complained of headaches. He gave them an amphetamine, that is a stimulant, called Benzedrine, which was popular at the time among jazz musicians and college students. The experiment failed, in one sense. The headaches persisted. But he noted that half of the children responded in what he called spectacular fashion, as teachers said these children seemed instantly transformed by the drug. Rather than being bored by their homework, they were interested in it. Rather than being hyperactive, they became more “placid and easygoing.” Rather than complaining to parents about chores, they would make comments like: “I start to make my bed, and before I know it, it is done.” Bradley published the results in The American Journal of Insanity, and it marks perhaps the origins of our treatment model for ADHD.


Attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder, or ADHD, has always been hard to define. It’s harder still in an age when everybody feels like modern entertainment and the omnipresence of our screens make it hard for anybody to concentrate and sit still. But clearly, some people struggle with concentration and stillness more than others. ADHD has many classic symptoms, but it is typically marked by patterns of inattentiveness—frequently losing items, failing to follow multistep instructions—or by hyperactivity: say, fidgeting, or, for some children, being literally incapable of sitting in one place for more than half a second. In a way, I’ve always disliked the phrase "attention-deficit disorder," because ADHD is not about a deficit of ordinary attention but a surplus of feral attention—an overflowing of raw, uncontrollable noticing.


Last week, the journalist Paul Tough published a long, 9,000-word essay in The New York Times Magazine about ADHD called "Have We Been Thinking About ADHD All Wrong?" Tough asked hard questions about why diagnoses are soaring. Is this evidence of an epidemic? Or is it evidence of overdiagnosis? Paul is today’s guest. We talk about his blockbuster essay, what its loudest critics said about it, what its loudest advocates said about it, and why they both might be wrong.


If you have questions, observations, or ideas for future episodes, email us at [email protected].


Host: Derek Thompson

Guest: Paul Tough

Producer: Devon Baroldi

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Plain English with Derek ThompsonBy The Ringer

  • 4.7
  • 4.7
  • 4.7
  • 4.7
  • 4.7

4.7

1,936 ratings


More shows like Plain English with Derek Thompson

View all
The Bill Simmons Podcast by The Ringer

The Bill Simmons Podcast

29,976 Listeners

The Press Box by The Ringer

The Press Box

3,113 Listeners

Pivot by New York Magazine

Pivot

9,250 Listeners

The Ringer NBA Show by The Ringer

The Ringer NBA Show

9,229 Listeners

The Watch by The Ringer

The Watch

5,320 Listeners

The Rewatchables by The Ringer

The Rewatchables

13,810 Listeners

The Mismatch by The Ringer

The Mismatch

5,441 Listeners

The Ryen Russillo Podcast by The Ringer

The Ryen Russillo Podcast

14,248 Listeners

Interesting Times with Ross Douthat by New York Times Opinion

Interesting Times with Ross Douthat

6,945 Listeners

The Big Picture by The Ringer

The Big Picture

5,513 Listeners

The Prof G Pod with Scott Galloway by Vox Media Podcast Network

The Prof G Pod with Scott Galloway

5,415 Listeners

The Ezra Klein Show by New York Times Opinion

The Ezra Klein Show

15,397 Listeners

The Prestige TV Podcast by The Ringer

The Prestige TV Podcast

1,573 Listeners

The Town with Matthew Belloni by The Ringer

The Town with Matthew Belloni

1,050 Listeners

The Zach Lowe Show by The Ringer

The Zach Lowe Show

2,000 Listeners