The episode recounts the chilling true story of the Joe Cool, a fishing charter vessel that set sail from Miami in September 2007 and never returned, leading to a perplexing maritime murder mystery. It details how the boat’s owners, Jake and Kelley Branam, along with crew members Scott Gamble and Samuel Kairy, vanished at sea, while two passengers, Kirby Logan Archer and Guillermo Zarabozo, were found alive in a life raft, claiming to have been attacked by Cuban pirates. The narrative then unravels this fabricated story, presenting the FBI’s investigation that uncovered inconsistencies, the suspects' criminal backgrounds—particularly Archer's fugitive status—and the eventual convictions of Archer and Zarabozo for the murders, despite the victims' bodies never being recovered. The text concludes by placing this tragedy within the broader context of Florida’s maritime dangers and the lingering questions and legacy of the Joe Cool case.