Who’s Shannon and why does she get her own episode? This week is the first time we see a living Shannon Rutherford and learn all about her. This week, we’re asking: What’s the difference between a sextant and a sex tent? When did you stop thinking you’d grow up to be a rockstar? How do… Read more 90: Abandoned

We welcome back author Dan Connell to talk about the tale of the Tailies this episode. This week, we’re asking: Who spends 2 hours pooping? Was Mikhail so angry because they stole his glass eye? Are Brett Cullen, Sean Bean, and David Wenham the same person? Dan’s been getting lost in Succession. Chad’s still getting… Read more 89: The Other 48 Days w/ Dan Connell

What kind of cop was Ana Lucia? We find out this week. This week, we’re asking: How do volcanoes work? Why is Eko your favorite? What is your favorite Bear Grylls moment? Should we make shirts? Chad’s been getting lost in Fallout 4. AJ’s still lost in Watchmen. DKJ’s been getting lost in the Action… Read more 88: Collision

We finally find out what Kate did and to whom! This week, we’re asking: Was Kate born during the Korean War? Were Rose and Bernard TV’s first interracial couple? Who was the bearded guy on Star Trek? Should we do a Watchmen podcast called “Who Listens to the Listenermen?” in which we watch the Watchmen?… Read more 87: What Kate Did

We’ve got real priests, fake priests, heroin. It must be an Eko episode! OR maybe a Charlie episode… This week, we’re asking: What sins are unforgivable? What was Kony 2012? Do you smoke on the toilet? What music will play as you die? Chad’s been getting lost in the “new” fall CW shows. AJ’s been… Read more 86: The 23rd Psalm

IS this the episode that finally proves David is Jack’s actual son? This week, we’re asking: How do you say “Smoke Monster” in Italian? Do you want one of Chad’s old Maxim magazines? Can someone please explain “yiffing” to AJ? Chad’s been getting lost in Magic: The Gathering, Commander format. AJ’s been getting lost in… Read more 85: The Hunting Party

This episode has everything! Fire, water, Charlie in a diaper, Virgin Mary heroin statues. It’s everything we ever wanted. This week, we’re asking: How much are pianos worth? Are air sports a sin? How come Sawyer gets to talk about droppin’ loads? Were you baptized? Chad’s been getting lost in The Boys on Amazon. AJ’s… Read more 84: S2E12, Fire + Water

We’re watching Sawyer teach Cassidy how to con, but is it a con? Yes, it’s a long con! This week, we’re asking: How many times can you say “con”? Do you like bad boys? What CD is in DKJ’s car? Are there haunted horses in your home? Can we see more of Sawyer as a… Read more 83: S2E13, The Long Con

This week we witness the birth of a torturer! This week, we’re asking: Is Sawyer a psychopath? Is there a female version of The Stranger? Does Rousseau recognize Ben? What was Shasta McNasty all about? What is Fred Durst OCD about? Chad’s been getting lost in the new Borderlands 2 DLC. AJ’s been getting lost… Read more 82: S2E14, One of Them

We get to see some of Claire’s fake pregnant belly this week! This week, we’re asking: Which one of the Brothers Karamozov was eaten by a smoke monster? Does Jack only know spine surgeon stuff? Are you a genius or standing in the shadow of a genius? What fun conspiracy theories are left? Chad’s been… Read more 81: S2E15, Maternity Leave