Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan

When Indigenous Identity Emerges After Sentencing


Listen Later

A guilty plea, a forgotten past, and a courtroom test of how identity meets justice. We open with a 2011 assault case resolved by a joint submission: an 18‑month conditional sentence after the accused conceded his force exceeded self‑defence. Years later, he discovered his father was Indigenous and obtained status, then sought an out‑of‑time appeal to revisit both plea and sentence. We walk through the legal gatekeeping for late appeals—intention, prejudice, merit, and the interests of justice—and unpack why section 718.2(e) and the Supreme Court’s Gladue jurisprudence require more than ancestry alone. Without a Gladue report or concrete evidence tying personal background to the offence and sentence, the Court of Appeal found no basis to disturb a non‑custodial disposition, underscoring the balance between individualized justice and finality.

Then the floor drops out on a modern confidence game. A Victoria woman was lured by “1% per day” crypto returns, saw early profits, re‑mortgaged her home, and pushed $671,000 through a cryptocurrency exchange to a third‑party wallet. Could the exchange be liable in negligence? We break down duty of care, standard of care, causation, and damages, and why the court concluded the platform did everything a reasonable exchange should: prominent written warnings, live calls from staff and a supervisor urging her to stop, risk scoring on the destination wallet, and documented customer pressure to proceed. The claim failed, and the case now stands as a sharp warning about irreversible blockchain transfers and the psychology of fraud.

If you care about Canadian criminal law, Indigenous sentencing principles, or investor protection in crypto, this story delivers practical takeaways: build a real record for Gladue considerations; treat “guaranteed” returns as a red flag; and know that platforms can warn you, but they can’t always save you. Like what you heard? Follow the show, share it with a friend, and leave a quick review to help others find thoughtful legal analysis that cuts through the noise.


Follow this link for a transcript of the case and links to the cases dismissed.

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Legally Speaking with Michael MulliganBy Michael Mulligan

  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5

5

1 ratings


More shows like Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan

View all
As It Happens by CBC

As It Happens

425 Listeners

Ideas by CBC

Ideas

398 Listeners

CANADALAND by CANADALAND

CANADALAND

219 Listeners

The Current by CBC

The Current

205 Listeners

The House by CBC

The House

64 Listeners

CTV Power Play with Vassy Kapelos Podcast by CTV News

CTV Power Play with Vassy Kapelos Podcast

36 Listeners

Michael Campbell's Money Talks by HPC Inc.

Michael Campbell's Money Talks

73 Listeners

At Issue by CBC

At Issue

110 Listeners

The Big Story by Frequency Podcast Network

The Big Story

87 Listeners

Front Burner by CBC

Front Burner

452 Listeners

The Herle Burly by Air Quotes Media

The Herle Burly

53 Listeners

The Decibel by The Globe and Mail

The Decibel

114 Listeners

Honestly with Bari Weiss by The Free Press

Honestly with Bari Weiss

8,505 Listeners

Hub Podcasts by Hub Media Canada

Hub Podcasts

36 Listeners

The Ben Mulroney Show by Corus Radio

The Ben Mulroney Show

55 Listeners