A Mason's Work

When Willpower Fails: Rethinking the Virtue of Struggle


Listen Later

We’re taught that if we just try harder, we’ll succeed—and that virtue lies in the trying. But what if that’s not only wrong, but harmful?

In this episode, we examine the myth of willpower as a moral virtue, and the emotional collapse that follows when effort alone doesn’t work. Whether it's in the lodge or in life, perseverance is not always the solution. Sometimes, it’s the trap.

Real growth doesn’t glorify exhaustion. It recognizes that change requires structure, support, compassion—and more than just will.

🔑 Key Takeaways

  • Willpower alone is unreliable and unsustainable over time
  • Struggle isn’t always virtuous—especially when alternatives exist
  • Real transformation honors effort and systems that support change

💬 Featured Quotes

“Willpower is the idea that through determination alone you can overcome the obstacles ahead of you.”  [00:00:09]
“In a lot of settings, there’s no merit in that whatsoever.” [00:00:48]
“The moment you’re low on dopamine or serotonin, you violate your own precepts.” [00:01:24]
“And then you go and consider that a moral failing—which happens to everyone.” [00:01:36]

🔗 Explore Related Episodes

  • “The Gavel and the Gap: When Self-Improvement Gets Real”
    → Explores how effort meets resistance—and why transformation demands more than force.
  • “Fixing the Wrong Thing: The First Trap of Transformation”
    → Looks at the risk of misidentifying struggle as productive when it may be misdirected.
  • “Yin and Yang in the Mortar: What Compassion Teaches the Builder”
    → A reflection on care, support, and knowing when softness—not pressure—is the work.
Thanks to our monthly supporters
  • Tim Dedman
  • Jorge
  • ★ Support this podcast on Patreon ★
    ...more
    View all episodesView all episodes
    Download on the App Store

    A Mason's WorkBy Brian Mattocks


    More shows like A Mason's Work

    View all
    Whence Came You? - Freemasonry discussed and Masonic research for today's Freemason by Robert Johnson

    Whence Came You? - Freemasonry discussed and Masonic research for today's Freemason

    321 Listeners

    The Masonic Roundtable - Freemasonry Today for Today's Freemasons by Jon Ruark, Jason Richards, Nick Johnson, Juan Sepulveda & Robert Johnson

    The Masonic Roundtable - Freemasonry Today for Today's Freemasons

    204 Listeners

    The Art of Manliness by The Art of Manliness

    The Art of Manliness

    14,302 Listeners

    Masonic Lite Podcast by Masonic Lite Podcast

    Masonic Lite Podcast

    47 Listeners

    Short Talk Bulletin by Short Talk Bulletin

    Short Talk Bulletin

    89 Listeners

    Scottish Rite Journal Podcast by The Tyler's Place Podcast

    Scottish Rite Journal Podcast

    34 Listeners

    The Working Tools Podcast by The Working Tools Podcast

    The Working Tools Podcast

    16 Listeners

    The Traveling Man Masonic Podcast by Jim Hall

    The Traveling Man Masonic Podcast

    35 Listeners

    Craftsmen Online Podcast by Craftsmen Online

    Craftsmen Online Podcast

    41 Listeners

    Masonic Muscle by Cesar Rubio

    Masonic Muscle

    27 Listeners

    Further Light Podcast by C Luedke

    Further Light Podcast

    14 Listeners

    Arcanvm Podcast by Ike Baker

    Arcanvm Podcast

    18 Listeners

    Craftcast: The Freemasons Podcast by United Grand Lodge of England

    Craftcast: The Freemasons Podcast

    21 Listeners

    The Third Degree Masonic Podcast by Brothers Samuel , Gabriel,  and Ryan

    The Third Degree Masonic Podcast

    7 Listeners