Sign up to save your podcasts
Or
Share 🏆 Which MTG Set Is BEST for Commander?! 🫵 YOU DECIDE! Tournament Begins! 🔥 - #431
Share to email
Share to Facebook
Share to X
Share to email
Share to Facebook
Share to X
Or
🏆 Which MTG Set Is BEST for Commander?! 🫵 YOU DECIDE! Tournament Begins! 🔥 - #431
Episode 431:
🎙️This Week on the CommanderSmiths Podcast! 🎙️
It's tournament time! 🏆🔥
This week we're putting the greatest Magic: The Gathering sets head-to-head to determine which one has had the biggest impact on Commander.
Which set gave us the most iconic commanders?
Which one introduced the strongest staples?
Which set deserves to be crowned the best Commander set of all time?
We're building a bracket and letting the sets battle it out until only one remains!
In this episode we cover:
🏆 The Commander Set Tournament begins!
🔥 Which sets make the bracket
⚔️ Head-to-head matchups
👑 Which sets advance and why
🤔 What makes a set great for Commander?
Before the tournament begins, we also break down the newest Secret Lair announcement!
✨ Global Fund for Women: Their Magic Is Limitless
This print-to-demand charity Secret Lair will be available July 20 through August 3, and we'll discuss:
💜 The featured cards and artwork
💰 Whether it's worth picking up
❤️ Supporting the charity through Secret Lair
📈 Collector and long-term value
💬 Let us know in the comments:
Which MTG set do YOU think is the greatest Commander set ever?
💰 What Is Break Point (BP)?
Break Point helps figure out how many drops you need to buy before one becomes "free."
Because let's be real — we all want that freebie drop for the shelf! 😎
How It Works:
1️⃣ Add up the lowest Foil + Non-Foil values.
2️⃣ Subtract fees, shipping, and the drop cost to find Net Profit.
3️⃣ Divide total profit by drop cost = your BP.
Example:
If a drop costs $40 and nets $80 → BP 2
If it nets $55 → BP 4
💡 Pro Tip: Prices often dip right after shipping but usually rebound (or climb higher) 10–16 months later. Patience = profit.
🚨Live Cast Here🚨
https://youtube.com/live/FynqvaWMY0g
💸 Donate Live!
Support us during our live streams here:
👉 Streamlabs Donation Link
Whether you’re a Secret Lair collector, Commander player, or just here to see us suffer through Malört… this one’s gonna be a ride. 🤢😂
🔥 Recent Videos from the CommanderSmiths 🔥
🎮 NEW COMMANDER GAMEPLAY VIDEO!
🐉 Elder Dragon “Not-So-Highlander” 🐉
https://youtu.be/Q9SpjVOY4ag
🤫 MAGIC PASSWORD!
https://youtu.be/PqpLA7BvZ_c
🎨 Proxy Time! 🌌
https://youtube.com/shorts/IdYlGlmcaxw?feature=share
🛒 Check Out Our Store!
Get your MTG merch, Kill Him Tokens, playmats, and more!
👉 Adam's eBay Store
📢 Support the Smith Boys!
Join our Patreon and get access to exclusive Discord perks:
👉 Patreon Link
🎉 A FREE Way to Support Us!
Subscribe to our YouTube channel, like, and share our videos!
👉 Subscribe Here
💬 Get in Touch!
📧 [email protected] — send in Stump the Smith Savant cards, questions, or just to chat!
View all episodes
By Podbean
4.6
4141 ratings
Episode 431:
🎙️This Week on the CommanderSmiths Podcast! 🎙️
It's tournament time! 🏆🔥
This week we're putting the greatest Magic: The Gathering sets head-to-head to determine which one has had the biggest impact on Commander.
Which set gave us the most iconic commanders?
Which one introduced the strongest staples?
Which set deserves to be crowned the best Commander set of all time?
We're building a bracket and letting the sets battle it out until only one remains!
In this episode we cover:
🏆 The Commander Set Tournament begins!
🔥 Which sets make the bracket
⚔️ Head-to-head matchups
👑 Which sets advance and why
🤔 What makes a set great for Commander?
Before the tournament begins, we also break down the newest Secret Lair announcement!
✨ Global Fund for Women: Their Magic Is Limitless
This print-to-demand charity Secret Lair will be available July 20 through August 3, and we'll discuss:
💜 The featured cards and artwork
💰 Whether it's worth picking up
❤️ Supporting the charity through Secret Lair
📈 Collector and long-term value
💬 Let us know in the comments:
Which MTG set do YOU think is the greatest Commander set ever?
💰 What Is Break Point (BP)?
Break Point helps figure out how many drops you need to buy before one becomes "free."
Because let's be real — we all want that freebie drop for the shelf! 😎
How It Works:
1️⃣ Add up the lowest Foil + Non-Foil values.
2️⃣ Subtract fees, shipping, and the drop cost to find Net Profit.
3️⃣ Divide total profit by drop cost = your BP.
Example:
If a drop costs $40 and nets $80 → BP 2
If it nets $55 → BP 4
💡 Pro Tip: Prices often dip right after shipping but usually rebound (or climb higher) 10–16 months later. Patience = profit.
🚨Live Cast Here🚨
https://youtube.com/live/FynqvaWMY0g
💸 Donate Live!
Support us during our live streams here:
👉 Streamlabs Donation Link
Whether you’re a Secret Lair collector, Commander player, or just here to see us suffer through Malört… this one’s gonna be a ride. 🤢😂
🔥 Recent Videos from the CommanderSmiths 🔥
🎮 NEW COMMANDER GAMEPLAY VIDEO!
🐉 Elder Dragon “Not-So-Highlander” 🐉
https://youtu.be/Q9SpjVOY4ag
🤫 MAGIC PASSWORD!
https://youtu.be/PqpLA7BvZ_c
🎨 Proxy Time! 🌌
https://youtube.com/shorts/IdYlGlmcaxw?feature=share
🛒 Check Out Our Store!
Get your MTG merch, Kill Him Tokens, playmats, and more!
👉 Adam's eBay Store
📢 Support the Smith Boys!
Join our Patreon and get access to exclusive Discord perks:
👉 Patreon Link
🎉 A FREE Way to Support Us!
Subscribe to our YouTube channel, like, and share our videos!
👉 Subscribe Here
💬 Get in Touch!
📧 [email protected] — send in Stump the Smith Savant cards, questions, or just to chat!
More shows like MTG Commander Smiths Podcast
View all
Limited Resources
1,111 Listeners
MTGGoldfish Podcast
552 Listeners
The Command Zone
2,155 Listeners
MTG Fast Finance
115 Listeners
Magic: The Gathering Drive to Work Podcast
748 Listeners
Commander Cookout Podcast: Magic the Gathering
196 Listeners
Lords of Limited
314 Listeners
Legendary Creature - Podcast
133 Listeners
EDHRECast
523 Listeners
Commander ad Populum
35 Listeners
Into the 99
15 Listeners
Commander's Pod
7 Listeners
The Play to Win Podcast
125 Listeners
EDH Social Contract: A Magic The Gathering Commander Podcast
15 Listeners
MTGGoldfish Commander Clash Podcast
238 Listeners