The gang's murder investigation gets even stranger when a second victim turns up, along with a single, mysterious metal cog. Between questionable detective work, overpriced mimic milkshakes, and Ulrich’s highly public bathroom choices, one thing is clear—this case is getting out of hand fast.

Like what you hear and want to support the show? Even $1 goes a long way for us! bit.ly/halfwaytopatreon

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices