Wickedly Judged

Hey! I'd love to hear your thoughts, send me a voice note.

In this comprehensive episode, Rebecca delivers the full story of Donald Rogan Simpson Jr.—a man who has spent more than 33 years in a Missouri prison for a crime he has always insisted he did not commit. This episode leaves no detail unexplored: from Donald’s early life and the events that led him to Joplin, to the flawed investigation, coerced witnesses, lost and ignored evidence, and a trial that lasted mere minutes before sealing his fate.

Rebecca guides listeners through every twist and turn: the shifting stories of John Katura, the ignored confession of another suspect, a prosecution built on unreliable testimony, and Donald’s decades-long fight for exoneration. This is a story not just of one man’s struggle, but of a justice system in desperate need of reform.

What You’ll Hear in This Episode:

• Donald’s background and how he ended up in Joplin, Missouri
• The murder of J.D. Masters and the investigation’s immediate focus on Donald
• John Katura’s changing statements and the plea bargain that changed everything
• The missing and mishandled evidence, including lost fingerprints and ignored confessions
• The trial: coerced witnesses, broken promises, and a 13-minute jury deliberation
• Donald’s appeals, new evidence, and the ongoing fight for justice
• The impact of wrongful conviction on Donald’s life and his message to listeners
• How you can get involved and support Donald’s fight for exoneration

Key Resources & Links:

• Review the evidence and case files: wrongfullyconvicted-seekingexoneration.com
• Learn more about justice reform and wrongful convictions: wickedlyjudged.com
• Contact Wickedly Judged: [email protected] | (513) 393-7452

How You Can Help:

• Share this episode and Donald’s story—awareness is the first step to change
• Visit Donald’s website to review the evidence and support his fight for exoneration
• Contact Missouri officials and demand a review of Donald’s case
• Support justice reform and follow Wickedly Judged for more stories, updates, and ways to join the movement

Special Thanks: Thank you to our sponsor, Veteran Alliance, and to JP Verse of Versefire Records for providing the music for this episode.

Remember: Stay vigilant, stay informed, and stay hopeful. Because nobody deserves to be wickedly judged.

Hey! I'd love to hear your thoughts, send me a voice note.

In the second half of this eye-opening interview, Rebecca continues her conversation with Donald Rogan Simpson Jr., who has spent over 33 years in a Missouri prison for a crime he has always maintained he did not commit. Picking up after John Katura’s pivotal plea bargain, Donald recounts the investigation, his trial, decades of relentless appeals, and the daily reality of surviving inside a system that refuses to admit its mistakes.

Donald’s story is one of lost evidence, shifting witness statements, ignored confessions, and a justice system that valued closure over truth. Through his own words, listeners are invited to witness the resilience and hope of a man fighting for exoneration.

What You’ll Hear in This Episode:

• The fallout from Katura’s plea bargain and how it shaped the state’s case
• The investigation: missing evidence, ignored confessions, and unreliable witnesses
• Donald’s trial: broken promises, coerced testimony, and a defense that never materialized
• Decades of appeals, new legal motions, and the ongoing battle for justice
• Life inside prison and Donald’s unwavering hope
• How listeners can support Donald’s fight for exoneration

Key Resources & Links:

• Review the evidence and case files: wrongfullyconvicted-seekingexoneration.com
• Learn more about justice reform and wrongful convictions: wickedlyjudged.com
• Contact Wickedly Judged: [email protected] | (513) 393-7452

How You Can Help:

• Share this episode and Donald’s story—awareness is the first step to change
• Visit Donald’s website to review the evidence and support his fight for exoneration
• Contact Missouri officials and demand a review of Donald’s case
• Support justice reform and follow Wickedly Judged for more stories, updates, and ways to join the movement

Special Thanks: Thank you to our sponsor, Veteran Alliance, and to JP Verse of Versefire Records for providing the music for this episode.

Remember: Stay vigilant, stay informed, and stay hopeful. Because nobody deserves to be wickedly judged.

Hey! I'd love to hear your thoughts, send me a voice note.

In this powerful first installment, Rebecca sits down with Donald Rogan Simpson Jr., who has spent over 33 years behind bars for a crime he insists he didn’t commit. In his own words, Donald shares his background, his arrival in Joplin, Missouri, and the events that led to his arrest and wrongful conviction for the murder of J.D. Masters. This episode covers Donald’s early life, his relationship with John Katura and Angie Kirk-Head, and the pivotal moments leading up to Katura’s plea bargain—the moment that changed everything.

What You’ll Hear in This Episode:

• Donald’s childhood, travels, and how he ended up in Missouri
• How Donald met John Katura and Angie Kirk-Head
• The circumstances leading to the discovery of J.D. Masters’ body
• The shifting stories and threats that set the stage for Donald’s arrest
• The beginning of a nightmare: Donald’s arrest and the buildup to Katura’s plea bargain
• Donald’s reflections on being targeted and his first experiences inside the justice system

Key Resources & Links:

• Review the evidence and case files: wrongfullyconvicted-seekingexoneration.com
• Learn more about justice reform and wrongful convictions: wickedlyjudged.com
• Contact Wickedly Judged: [email protected] | (513) 393-7452

How You Can Help:

• Share this episode and Donald’s story—awareness is the first step to change
• Visit Donald’s website to review the evidence and support his fight for exoneration
• Contact Missouri officials and demand a review of Donald’s case
• Follow Wickedly Judged for more stories, updates, and ways to join the movement for justice reform

Special Thanks: Thank you to our sponsor, Veteran Alliance, and to JP Verse of Versefire Records for providing the music for this episode.

Remember: Stay vigilant, stay informed, and stay hopeful. Because nobody deserves to be wickedly judged.

Hey! I'd love to hear your thoughts, send me a voice note.

In this powerful solo episode, Rebecca unpacks the full timeline of Joshua Brazzel’s case—revealing how a secret custody dispute and hidden personal motives led to a devastating conviction. This episode is a straightforward, fact-driven narrative about how unchecked conflicts of interest and withheld evidence can destroy lives and families.

Key Points Covered

• The Hidden Custody Battle: How the biological father of Joshua’s partner’s 8-year-old son filed for emergency custody—and how this crucial conflict of interest was never disclosed to the judge or jury.
• Unreliable Informants and Evidence: The police’s main “confidential informant” was the 8-year-old at the center of the custody dispute, who couldn’t accurately describe what he allegedly saw. When this fell apart, police shifted the story to claim three informants, using statements from the child’s parents—one of whom stood to gain custody if Joshua was out of the picture.
• The Raid: A 2:47 a.m. flashbang raid on Joshua’s home, traumatizing five children (the youngest just five weeks old). No drugs were found in the house.
• The Trial and Sentencing: Despite no controlled buys, no witnesses, and no direct evidence, Joshua was convicted and sentenced to 50 years in prison. The judge and jury were never told of the biological father’s emergency custody filing or his motive.
• The Aftermath: The emotional and social impact on Joshua’s sons—growing up without their father, facing the stigma of a public conviction, and learning to navigate small-town judgment.
• Systemic Failures: A look at how undisclosed motives, personal vendettas, and prosecutorial shortcuts can lead to wrongful convictions—and why transparency and reform are desperately needed.

Special Thanks

Special thanks to Veteran Alliance for their ongoing support, and to JP Verse of Versefire Records for providing the music that powers our message.

Call to Action

If this episode moved you, please don’t let the conversation stop here:

• Share this episode with friends and on your socials—let’s make sure stories like this are heard.
• Follow Wickedly Judged on your favorite podcast platform and social media for updates and advocacy.
• Support our work by checking out our merchandise at wickedlyjudged.com—every purchase funds investigations and reform efforts.
• Get involved or share your story: Email [email protected] or call (513) 393-7452.

Together, we can demand real justice and accountability.

Contact & Links

• Email: [email protected]
• Website: wickedlyjudged.com
• Merchandise: wickedlyjudged.com/merch

About Wickedly Judged

Wickedly Judged is dedicated to exposing wrongful convictions and advocating for justice reform through active investigations, storytelling, and community action. Join us in the fight for justice.

Hey! I'd love to hear your thoughts, send me a voice note.

In this emotional follow-up episode, Rebecca sits down with three of Joshua Brazzel’s sons to hear firsthand how their lives have been shaped by their father’s incarceration. Growing up in a small town with a well-known last name, they share the challenges, stigma, and personal struggles of life without their dad—and what it truly means to be judged by circumstances beyond their control.

Key Points Covered

• The Hidden Impact of Incarceration: Joshua’s sons open up about the pain and confusion of growing up without their father present, and the ripple effects it’s had on their family.
• Life in a Small Town: The boys discuss the challenges of living in a tight-knit community where everyone knows their story, and how the Brazzel name has followed them everywhere.
• Stigma and Judgment: They share candidly about the social stigma, bullying, and assumptions they’ve faced simply because of their last name and their father’s conviction.
• Resilience and Hope: Despite the hardships, Joshua’s sons reveal the ways they’ve found strength, hope, and their own voices in the face of adversity.

Special Thanks

Special thanks to Veteran Alliance for their ongoing support, and to JP Verse of Versefire Records for providing the music that powers our message.

Call to Action

If this episode moved you, please don’t let the conversation stop here:

• Share this episode with friends and on your socials—let’s make sure stories like this are heard.
• Follow Wickedly Judged on your favorite podcast platform and social media for updates and advocacy.
• Support our work by checking out our merchandise at wickedlyjudged.com—every purchase funds investigations and reform efforts.
• Get involved or share your story: Email [email protected] or call (513) 393-7452.
• Sign up for our newsletter on our website for exclusive updates and action opportunities.

Together, we can demand real justice and accountability.

Contact & Links

• Email: [email protected]
• Website: wickedlyjudged.com
• Merchandise: wickedlyjudged.com/merch

About Wickedly Judged

Wickedly Judged is dedicated to exposing wrongful convictions and advocating for justice reform through active investigations, storytelling, and community action. Join us in the fight for justice.

Hey! I'd love to hear your thoughts, send me a voice note.

Host: Rebecca, President of Wickedly Judged

Episode Overview

In this gripping episode, Rebecca sits down with Joshua Brazzel to uncover the real story behind his conviction—a story of personal vendetta, questionable police tactics, and a justice system that failed to protect the innocent. This case challenges everything we think we know about due process and the dangers of hidden motives.

Key Points Covered

• No Controlled Buys, No Witnesses, No Evidence: The search warrant for Joshua’s home and storage unit was issued without a single controlled buy, no eyewitnesses, and no direct evidence of drug activity.
• The “Confidential Informant”: The primary informant was an 8-year-old child who couldn’t even accurately describe what he claimed to have seen. Police later changed their story, claiming three confidential informants, and relied on statements from the child’s parents.
• No Drugs in the House: Despite the dramatic raid, police found no drugs in Joshua’s home.
• Extreme Police Tactics: At 2:47 a.m., police used flashbang grenades to raid the house, where five children—including a five-week-old infant—were sleeping. There was no clear justification for such dangerous tactics.
• Hidden Motives and Custody Battle: The biological father of the 8-year-old was the ex-partner of Joshua’s significant other and was seeking emergency custody. The only way to get custody was to remove Joshua from the picture—a critical conflict of interest never disclosed to the judge.
• The Cost of Police and Prosecutorial Misconduct: Joshua was sentenced to 50 years in prison, with at least 24 years to serve, as police and prosecutors doubled down to cover their mistakes.

Special Thanks

Huge thanks to Veteran Alliance for their ongoing support, and to JP Verse of Versefire Records for providing the music that powers our message.

Call to Action

If Joshua’s story moved you, don’t let the conversation end here:

• Share this episode with friends and on your socials—let’s make sure stories like this are heard.
• Follow Wickedly Judged on your favorite podcast platform and social media for updates and advocacy.
• Support our work by checking out our merchandise at wickedlyjudged.com—every purchase funds investigations and reform efforts.
• Get involved or share your story: Email [email protected] or call (513) 393-7452.

Together, we can demand real justice and accountability.

Contact & Links

• Email: [email protected]
• Website: wickedlyjudged.com
• Merchandise: wickedlyjudged.com/merch
• Social Media: [Insert social links]

About Wickedly Judged

Wickedly Judged is dedicated to exposing wrongful convictions and advocating for justice reform through active investigations, storytelling, and community action. Join us in the fight for justice.

Hey! I'd love to hear your thoughts, send me a voice note.

Host: Rebecca, President of Wickedly Judged

Episode Overview: In this special episode, Rebecca steps into the interviewee seat to share the deeply personal story behind Wickedly Judged and the ongoing fight for justice in Johnny’s case. Listeners will get an inside look at the mission, motivation, and advocacy efforts that set Wickedly Judged apart from other true crime podcasts.

Key Topics Covered:

• The founding story of Wickedly Judged and what inspired Rebecca to launch the movement
• An overview of Johnny’s wrongful conviction and why his case is at the heart of the podcast
• The unique approach Wickedly Judged takes—combining storytelling with active investigation and legal advocacy
• The challenges faced in fighting for justice reform and overturning wrongful convictions
• How listeners can get involved and support the mission, from spreading awareness to purchasing merchandise

Special Thanks: A heartfelt thank you to Veteran Alliance for their support, and to JP Verse of Versefire Records for providing the music that powers our message.

Call to Action: If this episode moved you, please follow Wickedly Judged on your favorite podcast platform, share this episode with a friend, and join our community on social media. Check out our merchandise to help support ongoing investigations—every purchase makes a difference!

Contact & Links:

• Email: [email protected]
• Website: wickedlyjudged.com
• Phone or Text : 513-393-7452

About Wickedly Judged: Wickedly Judged is dedicated to exposing wrongful convictions and advocating for justice reform through active case investigations, not just storytelling. Our mission is to inspire change and empower others to join the fight for justice.

Hey! I'd love to hear your thoughts, send me a voice note.

This special solo episode marks the 20th anniversary of Johnny Watkins’ wrongful conviction. Rebecca takes listeners through the heartbreaking details of Johnny’s case, from the flawed investigation and ignored confession to the years of appeals and the human cost of injustice. The episode also highlights the renewed hope and advocacy brought by R & R Russell’s Services LLC and Street Groomers, and shares how listeners can take action through the Change.org petition and GiveSendGo fundraiser.

Key Topics Covered

• Case Recap:
  • Johnny’s arrest and prosecution despite no direct evidence
  • The ignored confession by another individual
  • Prosecutorial misconduct and withheld evidence
  • Ineffective defense due to an overwhelmed public defender
  • The human and emotional toll on Johnny and his family
• Systemic Failures:
  • How tunnel vision, lack of resources, and a broken appeals process led to twenty years of injustice
  • The broader impact of wrongful convictions in America
• Advocacy in Action:
  • Partnership with R & R Russell’s Services LLC for new legal motions
  • Street Groomers’ grassroots community support and outreach
  • Ongoing rallies, campaigns, and public awareness efforts
• How to Help:
  • Sign the Change.org petition for Johnny’s release
  • Support the GiveSendGo fundraiser for court expenses
  • Share Johnny’s story and follow Wickedly Judged, R & R Russell’s Services LLC, and Street Groomers on social media
  • Purchase Wickedly Judged merchandise to support advocacy work

Featured Calls to Action

• Sign the petition: Change.org – Justice for Johnny Watkins
• Donate: GiveSendGo – Johnny Watkins Court Expenses
• Learn more: wickedlyjudged.com
• Contact: [email protected] | (513) 393-7452

Closing Message

Rebecca closes the episode with a reminder to stay vigilant, stay hopeful, and stay curious—because nobody deserves to be Wickedly Judged.

For more updates and resources, visit wickedlyjudged.com or follow us on social media.

Hey! I'd love to hear your thoughts, send me a voice note.

In this powerful episode of Wickedly Judged, Rebecca sits down with Mary Wicker to unravel the heartbreaking story of her husband Doug’s wrongful conviction in Michigan. What began as an act of family compassion quickly spiraled into a devastating legal nightmare—one that exposes the dangers of a law allowing conviction based solely on an accusation, with no physical evidence or corroboration required.

Mary shares the emotional and practical toll this ordeal has taken on their family, the details of Doug’s trial, and her relentless fight for justice in the face of systemic failure. Together, we explore why justice reform is urgently needed—not just in Michigan, but across the nation—and how every listener can play a role in demanding change.

Key Topics Covered:

• The Wicker family’s decision to care for a vulnerable child and the events leading up to the accusation
• How Michigan law allows conviction based solely on an accuser’s word
• The trial: judicial bias, prosecutorial misconduct, and a disengaged jury
• The devastating impact of wrongful conviction on families
• Mary’s ongoing advocacy, pursuit of a mistrial, and broader fight for justice reform
• Why laws like Michigan’s are unconstitutional and threaten every American’s rights
• The importance of justice reform and how listeners can help

Calls to Action:

• Learn More: Visit wickedlyjudged.com for case details, advocacy resources, and our blog, “The Reform Advocate.”
• Support the Mission: Shop our advocacy merchandise—every purchase funds investigations and outreach.
• Connect: Share your own story, volunteer, or reach out for support at [email protected] or (513) 393-7452.
• Support Mary & Doug: Visit guiltybyhearsay.com and join the Guilty by Hearsay Facebook group.
• Advocate: Contact your legislators and demand evidence-based justice. Share this episode to raise awareness and spark conversation.

Resources & Links:

• WickedlyJudged.com
• GuiltybyHearsay.com
• Guilty by Hearsay Facebook Group
• Email: [email protected]
• Phone: (513) 393-7452

Thank You: Special thanks to our sponsors and every listener who helps shine a light on wrongful convictions. Your support fuels the fight for justice reform.

Hey! I'd love to hear your thoughts, send me a voice note.

Wickedly Judged Podcast – Episode Notes

Episode Title: Update: Mary Wicker on Doug’s Fight for Justice & the June Court Dates

Release Date: July 10, 2025

Episode Summary: In this follow-up episode, Rebecca reconnects with Mary Wicker for an in-depth conversation about the ongoing battle to overturn the wrongful conviction of her husband, Doug. Mary provides a firsthand account of the pivotal court hearings held on June 2nd and 3rd, sharing new developments, legal arguments, and the emotional impact on their family. This episode offers listeners a behind-the-scenes look at the realities of post-conviction advocacy and the hope that comes with every day in court.

Key Topics Covered:

• Recap of Doug Wicker’s wrongful conviction and case background
• Insights from the June 2nd and 3rd court dates: what happened, key moments, and outcomes
• Mary’s perspective on the legal team’s arguments and the prosecution’s response
• Emotional and practical challenges faced by Doug, Mary, and their supporters during the hearings
• Next steps in Doug’s case and what the court’s decisions could mean for his future
• How listeners can support Doug and the Wicker family as the fight continues

Featured Guest:

• Mary Wicker – Advocate and wife of wrongfully convicted Doug Wicker

Host:

• Rebecca – President, Wickedly Judged

Resources & Links:

• wickedlyjudged.com
• Contact: [email protected] | (513) 393-7452
• Support Doug’s case: guiltybyhearsay.com

How to Get Involved:

• Share this episode to raise awareness about Doug’s case
• Follow Wickedly Judged on social media for real-time updates
• Visit our website for advocacy resources and merchandise
• Reach out if you have legal expertise or want to help directly

Quote from the Episode: "Every day in court is a step closer to the truth. We’re not giving up." – Mary Wicker