The Minefield

Will weight loss drugs entrench cultural expectations about body size?


Listen Later

Ever since 2023, a class of GPL-1 based drugs — which for two decades were used to treat type 2 diabetes — have been heralded as a “revolution in weight loss” and signalling the “end of obesity”. While these drugs go by different names, they’ve become popularly grouped under the shorthand “Ozempic”.

It’s no exaggeration to say that Ozempic has become a cultural phenomenon. Millions of people in the United States, Australia, South Korea, the UK, the EU take semaglutide injections, not to treat diabetes, but in order to reduce their hunger and eliminate what is sometimes called “food noise”.

Obesity has long been moralised — associated with laziness, ill-disciplined eating, poor diet, a general lack of self-control. But expensive weight loss drugs like Ozempic have, to date, exacerbated the class dimension of obesity. This was nicely captured in a 2024 South Park episode (called “The End of Obesity”), in which Cartman is denied a prescription because the drug isn’t covered by insurance and his mother can’t afford it; as a consolation, the doctor recommends that he listens to more Lizzo. Cartman’s response: “Rich people get Ozempic, poor people get body positivity.”

This begins to point to one of the most troubling aspects of the widespread use of weight loss drugs. It does not have to do with their use per se, or their further applications (to other health conditions or to treat other forms of addiction). Even the question of prohibitive cost may soon be partially resolved with plans underway to make some GPL-1 drugs more affordable.

The more concerning issue is the cultural environment in which drugs like Wegovy or Mounjaro or Ozempic are now being taken up — cultures long preoccupied with dieting and weight loss, and which have elevated the physical aesthetic attributes of thinness, firmness, smoothness and vigour to the level of virtues, even moral demands. Conversely, obesity is stigmatised as ugliness, incontinence, laziness, a sign of servitude to cravings and bad habits.

Such that, even when the sleek physical appearance achieved by means of, say, Ozempic, and has nothing to do with self-control or superior habits, its users continue to accrue the social benefits associated with thinness.

The testimony of women and men, for instance, who have career or social opportunities open up to them after using Ozempic is, frankly, heartbreaking and often contemptible.

If we want to laud the health benefits of weight loss drugs, and explore their application to help address other forms of harmful behaviour, that’s one thing. But to use such drugs to reinforce a kind of cultural aesthetic hierarchy is both troubling and ethically problematic.

If you, or someone you know, is struggling with an eating disorder or with body image, support is available. You can call the Butterfly Foundation on 1800 33 4673.

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

The MinefieldBy ABC

  • 4.6
  • 4.6
  • 4.6
  • 4.6
  • 4.6

4.6

34 ratings


More shows like The Minefield

View all
Philosopher's Zone by ABC

Philosopher's Zone

211 Listeners

Big Ideas by ABC

Big Ideas

114 Listeners

Future Tense by ABC

Future Tense

73 Listeners

Background Briefing by ABC

Background Briefing

71 Listeners

Late Night Live — Full program podcast by ABC

Late Night Live — Full program podcast

95 Listeners

Saturday Extra - Full program podcast by ABC

Saturday Extra - Full program podcast

14 Listeners

Late Night Live - Separate stories podcast by ABC

Late Night Live - Separate stories podcast

46 Listeners

Short & Curly by ABC

Short & Curly

1,726 Listeners

Conversations by ABC

Conversations

848 Listeners

All In The Mind by ABC

All In The Mind

786 Listeners

Health Report by ABC

Health Report

129 Listeners

The Economy, Stupid by ABC

The Economy, Stupid

26 Listeners

Politics Now by ABC News

Politics Now

89 Listeners

Rear Vision — How History Shaped Today by ABC

Rear Vision — How History Shaped Today

68 Listeners

Trace by ABC

Trace

460 Listeners

Imagine This by ABC KIDS listen

Imagine This

157 Listeners

If You're Listening by ABC

If You're Listening

327 Listeners

Unravel by ABC

Unravel

790 Listeners

The World Today by ABC News

The World Today

12 Listeners

ABC KIDS News Time by ABC KIDS listen

ABC KIDS News Time

198 Listeners

No Feeling Is Final by ABC

No Feeling Is Final

111 Listeners

What's That Rash? by ABC

What's That Rash?

247 Listeners

Stuff The British Stole by ABC and CBC

Stuff The British Stole

1,015 Listeners

Global Roaming with Geraldine Doogue and Hamish Macdonald by ABC

Global Roaming with Geraldine Doogue and Hamish Macdonald

46 Listeners