Winning The TBI Case

Winning The TBI Case

Download on the App Store

Winning The TBI Case episodes

  • Jury Selection in a Mild TBI Case with Robert Hirschhorn (Part 1)

    “If you can’t get the essence of your case to a jury in 30 minutes, then you have got to go back to the drawing board.” – Robert Hirschhorn

    Welcome to Winning The TBI Case, hosted by trial lawyer Tom Crosley. Listen as Tom provides practical, powerful guidance for litigating traumatic brain injury cases. This podcast is meant for litigation attorneys who are ready to explore the essentials of TBI cases to confidently represent clients who have suffered traumatic brain injuries.

    What’s In This Episode

    Tom is joined by Robert Hirschhorn, attorney and trial consultant from CEB Jury & Trial Consultants to talk about the keys to successful jury selection in a mild TBI case.
    Picking a Jury For Your Case

    Jury selection in a mild TBI case starts with a difficult challenge: your client looks normal. The headaches, the brain fog, the mood changes, the lost enjoyment of life – none of it shows up on imaging. So how do you find jurors who will believe what they can’t see?

    Jury consultant and attorney Robert Hirschhorn has spent more than 40 years helping trial lawyers answer that question. In this conversation, Robert explains how voir dire has changed since COVID, why 45-60 minutes is enough (and more may hurt you), and the one tool he calls “the 11th commandment” of jury selection.

    Key Takeaways

    Robert is direct about the goal: 80% of your voir dire time should be spent identifying jurors who distrust invisible injuries, not building rapport. He covers:

    • Why your client should not be in the courtroom during jury selection
    • The difference between picking a liability jury and a damages jury
    • Why scaled 0-10 questions provide better information about potential jurors
    • If you’ve ever walked out of jury selection worried you talked too much about money, or missed the juror who was never going to buy your case, this conversation will reshape how you plan your next voir dire.

      This is Part 1 of a two-part series. In Part 2, Robert returns to discuss jury selection in a severe TBI case.

      Connect
      • Connect directly with Robert Hirschhorn at https://www.cebjury.com/about-us
      • Subscribe to Winning The TBI Case on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube or wherever you get your podcasts. 
      • Follow on Facebook, LinkedIn, and Instagram.
      • And remember, don’t just listen to the strategies, implement them!
      • 44 min
      • Representing the Incapacitated Client with Price Johnson

        “Most probate lawyers don’t know anything whatsoever about personal injury. They’ve never handled a personal injury case, don’t know how to, and don’t understand why you’re doing what you’re doing at all, and that can be dangerous.” – Price Johnson

        Welcome to Winning The TBI Case, hosted by trial lawyer Tom Crosley. Listen as Tom provides practical, powerful guidance for litigating traumatic brain injury cases. This podcast is meant for litigation attorneys who are ready to explore the essentials of TBI cases to confidently represent clients who have suffered traumatic brain injuries.

        What’s In This Episode
        Tom is joined by Price Johnson, a Dallas probate attorney, and CPA who is the kind of specialist trial lawyers call when a severely injured client may lack the capacity to sign a contract or approve a settlement.

        Protecting Your Client, Your Contract, and Your Fee

        A severely injured TBI client walks through your door with a loved one by their side. The injury is clear. The case is real. But the client cannot sign your contract. What do you do? When do you act? And who is your client?

        Price Johnson walks through the practical realities of representing clients whose capacity is in question. He covers the three paths available to attorneys in these situations. He explains the “incapacity trap” that can turn strong damages proof into a procedural problem. And he reveals the specific reason why calling a probate specialist should happen earlier than most trial lawyers think.

        What’s at Stake

        At stake is more than procedure. In a contingency case, how do you protect your fee when a probate judge later gets a say in whether it was reasonable? Price walks through:

        • The reason why one-third contingencies rarely get challenged
        • Why higher contingencies do get challenged
        • Why getting your engagement fee approved up front protects both your client and your firm
        • If you’ve ever worried about whether your contract will hold up or your fee will survive probate court scrutiny, this conversation is for you.

          Connect
          • Connect directly with Price Johnson: 214-468-9000
          • Subscribe to Winning The TBI Case on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube or wherever you get your podcasts. 
          • Follow on Facebook, LinkedIn, and Instagram.
          • And remember, don’t just listen to the strategies, implement them!
          • Winning the TBI Case — Episode 24: Representing the Incapacitated Client

            Host: Tom Crosley Guest: Price Johnson Runtime: 39:37

            [00:00] Price Johnson (cold open): Most probate lawyers don’t know anything whatsoever about personal injury. They’ve never handled a personal injury case, don’t know how to, and don’t understand why you’re doing what you’re doing at all. And that can be dangerous.

            [00:13] Announcer: TBI cases can feel like navigating uncharted territory. Your client’s injury is real, but proving it — that’s where the real challenge begins. If you’ve ever felt like you’re missing crucial pieces of the puzzle, you’re in the right place. Welcome to Winning the TBI Case, where Tom Crosley shares the insights he’s gained from over 60 injury trials. Not just the victories, but the lessons learned along the way that make all the difference. Winning the TBI Case: strategy, science, and storytelling.

            [00:48] Tom Crosley: Welcome back to Winning the TBI Case. I’m Tom Crosley, and today we are joined by Dallas attorney Price Johnson. Price is a CPA and a lawyer and represents business clients in business litigation. A significant portion of his practice is probate issues and probate litigation. And in particular, he helps personal injury lawyers deal with guardianship and probate issues that arise in their cases.

            What I’ve invited him on the show to talk about today is what we TBI lawyers need to be aware of when representing severely injured clients. In some cases, our client may lack capacity even to sign the original attorney-client contract. What do we do? How do we spot those issues? When do we act? At some point we might need court approval for certain activities in the case, including settlement. And so Price is the kind of lawyer that lawyers like me call when we have these issues in our cases. Price, how are you doing this morning?

            [01:50] Price Johnson: Tom, I’m great this morning. Thanks for having me on. It’s a privilege to be here with you.

            [01:55] Tom Crosley: What I’d like to do — for an audience that extends beyond the borders of the state of Texas — is frame the issue for us. When we have a more serious TBI case, let’s say we’ve just gotten it in to sign it up. What do we need to be aware of to make sure we’re doing it right?

            [02:15] Price Johnson: It’s a can of worms. There are a lot of things to do, and probably the most important thing I think a personal injury lawyer handling TBI cases can do is find out as many facts as possible. The place I would generally start is to try to find out what your client’s capacity is.

            Keep in mind, in my probate world — unlike the personal injury world, where so much of what we rely on is common law, where we go look up court cases and they tell us what the rules are, sometimes even the elements of our causes of action and claims — much of this is codified. It’s an old area, and a lot of it’s codified. So when I use terms like “incapacitated,” those are literally defined terms.

            So the first thing you want to make sure of is: who’s your client? Just as in any case, right? You want to make sure who your client is, because without a client, well, you don’t have a case, right, Tom? You don’t have a client to work for. So the first thing you’re going to do is try to figure out who the client is. And if the injured party that you’re trying to ultimately represent is incapacitated, you’ve got to find somebody with authority to hire you.

            [03:27] Tom Crosley: What is the significance to us TBI lawyers that probate codes exist, and that the law in probate is typically code-based as opposed to stare decisis–based?

            [03:43] Price Johnson: Well, one nice thing about it is some of these things you can look up — they’re actually rules, statutes that exist. For example, we all tend to rely on case law, or in my area, statutes, but also case law that interprets those statutes.

            But where I would tell you to be very, very careful — particularly, for example, you and I are in Texas — is the Rules of Civil Procedure. Lawyers come to me all the time and go, “Well, Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 151 or 152” — which I refer to as the dead plaintiff and dead defendant rules — “say this. They say I can just go file a suggestion of death, a motion for scire facias, serve the heirs, and I’m good.” Well, those are rules. They’re not statutes or case law, and they absolutely conflict with the statutes and case law, and you will walk right into a malpractice claim and no client. So there are pitfalls and traps to be aware of.

            And to go back to a question you were asking me a moment ago — trying to figure out who your client is — obviously in a TBI case, you’re presuming that your client’s not deceased. Not yet, and hopefully won’t be. So you’re not going to end up with, for example, an administrator or an executor of an estate, because that only happens when someone’s dead, right? What you’re going to have is possibly someone with a power of attorney, possibly a guardian of the estate.

            Then there comes the trick: how many of us have powers of attorney right now, while you and I are competent and have capacity? Most don’t. Most lawyers don’t, most people don’t — just like most people don’t have wills. So what are the odds that your fellow TBI lawyers out there are going to have someone walk in and say, “My husband, my son, my daughter, my parent, my whomever was seriously injured. They’re in the hospital with a TBI, or they’re in a coma right now and they can’t communicate because they don’t have capacity. But here, I’ve got this power of attorney.” I’m guessing that doesn’t happen for you a lot, does it, Tom?

            [05:51] Tom Crosley: No, not at all. Probably never.

            [05:53] Price Johnson: And so the trick then becomes: well, if they don’t have capacity right now, they can’t sign a power of attorney. So then you get into whether they qualify for a guardianship or not. And is the guardianship the right move — where you’re at least temporarily, possibly permanently, stripping the rights from that individual that has the TBI and vesting them in someone else? That’s certainly an option, but that takes time. It’s a process.

            And then, of course, in Texas we do have the next friend rule — Rule 44 in Texas. It also depends heavily on what the relationship is between the person coming to you and the injured party that lacks capacity. So there are a lot of different things you look at, but that’s where I would suggest everybody start: what are the facts of the capacity? How long is it expected to last? Are they going to come out of this in a week, hopefully, or is it unknown? How severe is it? Is it potentially permanent? And then what steps should we be taking, and who’s the party coming to you? What is their relationship with this person? That will help us figure out what the avenues are.

            [06:55] Tom Crosley: Let’s use a few case examples. Often I’ll get hired later in the process — maybe a referring attorney gets me involved. And so I had one case where it had already been going for maybe two years by the time I got involved. The wife was severely injured and was in a coma for 30 days. And while she was in a coma, her husband signed the personal injury contract with the lawyer, individually and as next friend of his wife. I was concerned about that, because she lacked capacity. Her recovery was never good enough for her to really ratify. She required round-the-clock care. How should that scenario be addressed, if it’s done right from the outset?

            [07:43] Price Johnson: Tough spot to be in. And I’ll touch briefly on something you said about ratification. If you have someone — depending on the state and nature of their TBI, and you and your audience know better than anybody that these come and go — they can have lucid moments, or they may not. But you also have to watch out for the medications they’re on, namely pain medications and things like that, and the implications of those. If they have a lucid moment, especially when they’re in the hospital, and you can have a doctor or nurse or someone verify that, ratification is a great opportunity, right?

            As you mentioned, in your example, you don’t have that. And so here you have someone coming in who has no legal authority to sign a contract on behalf of his wife. I know that may sound strange to some, but he doesn’t. Had the wife died, he’d have his own wrongful death claim. But again, we’re talking TBI cases. We’re not talking administrators, executors, wrongful death claims, so those don’t come into play. That’s a different animal.

            Here, what you would really have to do is, if the person had any kind of lucid moment, you could go get powers of attorney signed, you could get the contract signed, you could get the contract ratified. But back to your example, where they’re not having that lucid moment — at least not yet — the only true, real option under the law in most states, and certainly in Texas, is a guardianship of the estate.

            Now, there’s guardian of the person and guardian of the estate. Think of a medical power of attorney and a durable power of attorney: medical is healthcare decisions; durable is all the rest of the things, including an engagement agreement with a lawyer. And I emphasize that because I have lawyers come to me all the time, and they think all the powers of attorney are the same. Someone’s got a medical power of attorney — that’s not what you want to sign your engagement agreement. They need to have authority to contract, and that’s the durable power of attorney, or what I like to call the financial power of attorney.

            There is the option of Rule 44 in Texas — the next friend, as you referred to it; most states have something similar. You have him sign it as next friend; you have him sign it individually and on her behalf. And then you start working on trying to fix this problem. What most lawyers do — and obviously it’s got to be a good enough case for you to take and front the expenses — is they call a lawyer like me, and we start working on the guardianship process to get a guardianship, or if nothing else, a temporary guardian appointed for purposes of pursuing the case.

            And you can do that. You can get temporary guardians. There’s not really such a thing as a limited guardian in Texas — it’s a full guardian — but you can get them for a limited period of time, or “temporary,” as we call them. And in a temporary, you can limit the authority — not so on a permanent guardianship, but in a temporary. So there are ways to do that.

            So the first thing you should do is sign them up — number one. And number two, call someone like me who specializes in this — preferably someone who knows probate and guardianship, but also personal injury. And the caveat I will give you here is, I guess I am a bit of a unicorn, because most probate lawyers don’t know anything whatsoever about personal injury. They’ve never handled a personal injury case, don’t know how to, and don’t understand why you’re doing what you’re doing at all. And that can be dangerous.

            On the other hand, most personal injury lawyers don’t have a good grasp on probate. But I will tell you this: when you go hire this probate lawyer, educate them on what you’re doing and why. Do not trust that they’re going to do a probate or a guardianship in the manner that best fits your needs, because they’re not. They are robots. They’re going to do the guardianship and the probate the way they always have in every case, and they’re not going to take into account the needs of you and your client in a personal injury case, which are quite unique.

            [11:40] Tom Crosley: So I have several follow-up questions. Let’s start with the scenario in which the husband signs the contract initially, while the wife is in a coma, and he signs it individually and as next friend of the wife. Now let’s say at some point in the future, the wife comes out of the coma. She’s going through rehab. She’s learning how to walk, talk. She’s got severe impairments. How low is that threshold for a lucid interval that would enable her to sign a durable power of attorney? And is that a viable option?

            [12:12] Price Johnson: It is a viable option. So this is one of the areas where it is not in the codes or the statutes. There is case law out there in almost every state, certainly in Texas, that talks about lucid intervals and lucid moments. I don’t think the case law gives great guidance.

            Here is what my takeaway would be for you from a personal injury lawyer’s standpoint. You know how medical professionals will frequently perform MMSEs on people — you know, “Who’s the president? What time is it? Draw this figure.” They’ll give them three words, wait a few minutes, and have them repeat those three words.

            Tom Crosley: You’re referring to a mini-mental status exam.

            Price Johnson: Okay. And that’s been around in some form for decades. That’s frequently done. At times you can have medical professionals — you can just inquire with them while you’re visiting with the person, and hopefully have them document in the progress notes that, in their opinion, they were with the person that day and the person had the capacity and ability to meet with the lawyer and to engage in a contract. They will use different kinds of language. But frequently, in my opinion: visit with the person, visit with the family, visit with the medical professionals. And if you get a good feel, in discussing with them, that this person has the capacity, then I think you’re probably okay. That’s the easiest way I could say to do it.

            And this is something I would hope any lawyer doing what you’re doing does: stay up to speed with the recovery and status of your client, the patient, and how they’re doing, and go see them when you can.

            [13:53] Tom Crosley: Let’s say we don’t go the durable power of attorney route, but the client improves enough to where they can now ratify that original contract. What, at a minimum, does the client need to be able to do to effectively ratify that contract?

            [14:12] Price Johnson: They have to be able to understand and comprehend the business that they are engaging in and the nature of that business. They have to know who they are. They have to know who you are. They have to understand the business that they’re engaging in — in other words, that they’re hiring a lawyer to help them pursue their claim against the at-fault parties. And I know I’m using sort of legalistic terms, but those are terms your audience will understand, in making sure that they explain this to the person and document that it’s being explained.

            I would love it if you had a witness to it, and then either have them sign a ratification — make sure that the prior agreement is attached — or an entirely new agreement, or both, in an ultimate belt-and-suspenders approach.

            I will also tell you this: if the person has sufficient mental capacity to execute a ratification or a new engagement agreement with you, they also by definition have capacity to execute a power of attorney. And so what you might do at that point in time is go in there with a limited durable power of attorney. Because remember, powers of attorney are shared authority. A guardianship strips authority from Price and vests it in Tom — I can no longer make my own decisions. A power of attorney shares authority: you can make decisions for me, and I can still make decisions for me.

            You might also consider having them execute a durable power of attorney that, if nothing more, at least gives this person — the spouse, in your example — the ability to go in and assist them in the case and the legal aspects of the case, potentially even including settlement and resolution of the case. You could do both.

            [15:59] Tom Crosley: I’m going to describe the process that I’m usually trying to prove in a severe TBI case, and then the sticky wicket that I think we find ourselves in, potentially, in these cases if we haven’t set them up right. And this would be true of the husband signing for the wife in the severe example I gave you.

            Another severe example: a 24-year-old riding a bicycle without a helmet, run over by a UPS truck. He was living independently with his grandparents at the time and working in a convenience store. But after the injury and four months in rehab, and a craniotomy, he was no longer able to take care of himself, feed himself, clothe himself. I mean, he needed to be supervised like a second grader would need to be supervised. And so he moved back in with his dad and stepmom, and they would never leave him alone in the house. There would always be somebody there.

            So what I started doing in both of these cases was proving that the person would never live independently — that they were going to need attendant care, whether it was institutionally provided attendant care, or the type of people that come and let them live in their own home, or some combination of those things. I’m proving all of these things that are supporting what’s ultimately a $20 or $30 million life care plan to take care of this 24-year-old until the end of his life expectancy, 40 or 50 years later — proving it so well that I’m now also proving he lacks capacity.

            And I’m worried about, okay, so what do I need to do in that case? I don’t know that my ratification of an existing contract, or the next friend rule, or any of those things are going to pass muster. I think I need a guardianship in that case. Have I just proven myself into a scenario where I must have a guardianship?

            [17:57] Price Johnson: Possibly. Here are a couple of unique things. And again, obviously you and I practice in Texas, so I’ll refer to Texas law, but I think colleagues in other states that are watching this will know their own statutes and rules and will find it very similar.

            So in Texas — and here’s what I see — first of all, I see lawyers on the defense side come in all the time, and they don’t do anything because they don’t know to. That doesn’t mean you’ve skated and you’re fine, because it’s your problem of not having a client at the end of the day. Let’s say you do win the case or get a big recovery, and someone comes in and goes, “That’s fantastic. But your contract — you don’t have a legitimate contract. You never had it signed by anybody.” Well, okay, maybe you have a quantum meruit case and claim, but that’s not really why you took the case, is it, Tom? Nor did you take it to then fight to recover a fee that you have well earned. So you don’t want to be in that situation.

            So here’s a couple of things. By coming in and putting on all of your evidence that your person lacks capacity and lacks it permanently, you may very well be putting yourself in that position. So what you should be doing is working behind the scenes with someone like myself, who is getting a guardianship, so that you can come in and then substitute that guardian in.

            And I am confident that this works this way in most states; I’d be shocked if it doesn’t. If you have filed suit on behalf of your incapacitated person in their individual capacity, or someone as next friend has done that, timely, before limitations expires, then even after limitations expires, it should relate back to your initial filing. And the reason for that is because it’s a capacity issue. It’s not a standing issue.

            Now, you need to check your state, and check your state carefully. In Texas, we have this very handy case from 2005 from our Texas Supreme Court — Austin Nursing Center, Inc. v. Lovato. We all call the case Lovato. And it dealt with this issue, where — it was a deceased person — they filed as administrator of the estate before limitations, but they actually didn’t get appointed administrator until after limitations. And the defense challenged it and said, “No, no, they lacked standing. They didn’t have standing. Standing is not waivable, and they blew it, and limitations expired.” The Supreme Court came in, in Lovato, and said, “Not so fast. It’s not standing; it’s capacity. Capacity is waivable, and it’s curable.” The cure is getting the guardian, getting the administrator. And that same case talks about the relation-back theory. And the relation-back theory literally means your subsequent filing relates back to the date of the initial filing, and you’re fine.

            [20:41] Tom Crosley: Let me expand a little bit on this guardianship and probate issue. Something comes up in every single case where I have a severe case and, let’s say, it’s time to settle the case. Maybe the trial is a week or two away. Maybe it’s tens of millions of dollars at stake. The question that often comes up is: Who gives me the authority to settle the case on behalf of the client? And then later, who approves my attorney fee, and is my fee subject to review and/or reduction by a probate judge?

            [21:31] Price Johnson: Excellent questions, and ones plaintiff’s lawyers need to be very well aware of. I see this a lot. They know they need to come hire me to either set up a probate when they have a deceased person, or the guardianship when they have a TBI case like we’re here to talk about. And I’ll go file the guardianship, or I will have somebody appointed as the executor or administrator of the estate. And the plaintiff’s lawyers say, “I’m done. I’m done with Price. It’s all over. I’ve got what I need.” And we just move on. Or in a guardianship, I go get the guardian of the estate appointed, and they think, “I’m done. I’m good. I’m golden.” No, no, no, no. Nothing could be further from the truth. And this is exactly where you’re leading me, of course.

            Unless it is a scenario where there’s a deceased person that has a will, or we’re able to get an independent administration — “independent” literally means independent of court oversight — then there’s very little, if anything, you need to go back to the court for or seek approval for. Guardianships are by definition dependent. There is no such thing as an independent guardianship anywhere, to my knowledge. Certainly not in Texas.

            So — dependent on what? Court approval. Of what? Darn near everything. I call it the “mother, may I.” You have to go back to the court every time and say “mother, may I” and seek approval. And mom either says yes or no, and mom calls the shots. That’s how it goes.

            As a personal injury lawyer, what colleagues need to do is keep their probate — in this case, their guardianship — lawyer informed. I tell all my PI lawyers, “Hey, listen, when you guys have a mediation coming up, or you think you’re getting close to settlement or something, call us. Call me.” Don’t tell me, “Hey, we settled this three months ago. It’s all signed. The money’s been disbursed, and we’re good. We’re done with the case.” Because that will cause problems — including you having to refund your fees to the probate court, to be held in suspense until they decide what to do with them. Not a fun position.

            In these scenarios, remember, guardianships are dependent administrations. The guardianship order — if you hire someone like me, for example — is going to give the guardian, whether temporary or permanent, authority to engage counsel and pursue the litigation, and it will also probably give them authority to enter into settlement negotiations. There are still several things that have to be approved. Hopefully we’re thinking ahead, and we will go ahead and simultaneously get your engagement agreement approved and your fee approved.

            Don’t presume your fee is automatically approved. Fees of a third are generally always approved. In fact, in certain situations, by statute in Texas, the judges didn’t have authority to deny a one-third contingent fee. Anything over a third does require court approval. Some of them think one-third fees are outrageous. Thankfully, the legislature has helped us with that, at least in Texas.

            So you need to be prepared, and you need to prepare your guardianship lawyer. Don’t let them go down there unprepared — especially the many that don’t know they need to be prepared — on why your case is unique. For example, a medical malpractice case or a TBI-type case — it’s not your run-of-the-mill fender bender car wreck. It’s not the same thing. You don’t go in there with a police report, put your witness on, and go win your case. You have experts you put on, and you have life care planners, and you have all these other people — psychologists, neuropsychologists — that you put on and deal with.

            It is always critically important to know that you’ve got to continue to go back to the court to get your engagement approved, your engagement fee approved, and your settlement approved when it’s settled. And also keep in mind, if there are other claims by other parties — for example, a spouse with a loss of consortium claim, or whatever the case may be — the court wants to scrutinize that. The probate court’s sole interest is going to be either the ward, in the guardianship, or the estate, in a deceased party’s case.

            Your question is very poignant and prescient: you have to keep all this stuff in mind as a plaintiff’s lawyer. Keep your guardianship or probate lawyer informed of how your case is progressing, so they can do what they need to do to help make sure your client and your firm and your fee are protected — which, at the end of the day, I think is important.

            [26:26] Tom Crosley: Well, I’m gonna share with you two stories. First, the 24-year-old young man that I was telling you about with the bicycle injury. In his case, I sought the guardianship early, while we were still early in the litigation. And I had heard horror stories about probate judges later, in mega cases like that, cutting the fee from 40% to a third. I didn’t want to put myself in a position of having that decision deferred until the case was successfully completed, because there was a lot of risk in the case. There was significant contributory negligence by the bicyclist. It was a case that could be lost outright. I was spending hundreds of thousands of dollars and, I don’t know, more than a thousand hours on the case.

            And so what I really wanted was to have my contract approved in advance as a contingency fee contract. Because, frankly, the difference between one-third and 40%, I think, is to make up for the investment risk we have in the case, because we’re advancing expenses. I tell people all the time that if the client is paying all the expenses necessary to prosecute the case, I’m happy with a one-third fee. If I instead am fronting all the expenses necessary to prosecute the case, and I don’t get that money back if I don’t win, then that’s a 40% fee. To me, that is my distinction between those two things.

            So I didn’t want to be in a situation where I get to the end, and now I’ve successfully navigated the minefield and I have a $20 million settlement, or whatever the number is, and now a judge says, “You know, I’m going to cut your fee by a couple of million dollars, down to a third.” So in that one, rather — quite easily, frankly — it’s quite easy to get that normal contingency fee contract approved at 40% when the work is yet to be done and the risk is yet to be navigated. Any criticism or concerns or comments about what I’ve just laid out?

            [28:29] Price Johnson: No comments or criticisms, other than that what you’re doing is perfect, every single time. Here’s my answer to your first question, and here’s how I’ll rephrase your question: At what stage do I get my engagement agreement approved? Always, 100% of the time, without exception: the beginning. To do anything else is foolish.

            [28:50] Tom Crosley: Often, Price, when we do settle these cases involving severely brain-injured clients, the court appoints an ad litem attorney, whether there is or isn’t a guardianship. Sometimes there’s an ad litem for the guardianship as well, and an ad litem for the settlement of the case, if that was in a different court than the probate court where the guardianship is happening. So can you talk to us about ad litems and the scenarios that we’re likely to face in these kinds of cases?

            [29:19] Price Johnson: Absolutely. And good questions you brought up, because guardianships are unique, and this is another reason not to wait on the guardianship. The fewer people monkeying with your case and your settlement, the better — especially the fewer people that don’t have a clue how to spell TBI or PI. Okay? Because they can’t. And you think I’m being facetious, but not by much.

            In a guardianship case, you get an attorney ad litem appointed and a guardian ad litem appointed — both. Those are not to be confused with the attorney ad litem that’s appointed in the personal injury court, for the personal injury side of it — in your district court, I’ll call it. So in Texas, we have Rule 173. That’s your attorney ad litem that gets appointed in a personal injury case, frequently for a minor, but also for any incapacitated person. And their job is to go in and say, “Is this settlement in the best interest of the [blank] — the child, the proposed ward, the potentially incapacitated person?” And the real job is to go and ask, “Well, is there someone in conflict?” Like if there were parents who have a claim for medical expenses and a minor who’s got the personal injury claim. That’s their job. It’s a very limited role.

            In the guardianship court, the attorney ad litem and guardian ad litem have much, much, much more significant roles, and can stick their noses into a lot of stuff, for good reason. In fact, the first role the attorney ad litem has is to file a general denial when the guardianship is filed. A lot of lawyers don’t realize that — that the court appoints a lawyer for the proposed ward to come in and file a general denial, which puts me to my proof. It’s an adversarial proceeding. Although if the person clearly lacks capacity, usually it’s not that adversarial. Usually my attorney ad litem will come in and go, “Yeah, I went and visited with the person, talked to the doctor, read the medical records. Yeah.” So they’ll go in and they’ll oppose it, but no evidence to oppose it.

            If we get the guardianship done — once the guardianship’s done, the attorney ad litem and guardian ad litem roles are largely gone. Then we’re just dealing with the guardianship court’s investigators, coordinators, clerks, and people like that. So you won’t have to fight that fight with as many people if you get the guardianship done first.

            If you don’t get the guardianship done first — like the scenario you gave me a moment ago, where the case was brought to you and you got it settled, but the guardianship hadn’t been done — and especially if you’re trying to do the guardianship after the fact, you’re going to have the probate judge, you’re going to have the court’s investigator, you’re going to have the attorney ad litem, and you’re going to have the guardian ad litem, all appointed by the probate court, all answerable to the probate judge, all up in your business, second-guessing and Monday-morning quarterbacking you. It’s not going to go well, generally. So that’s another reason to get this stuff done, and done timely. Just keep in mind that the roles are very different.

            But once the court appoints a guardian — particularly a permanent guardian — at that point the guardian of the estate becomes your client, and they’re really solely answerable to the probate judge. And then you get everything approved along the way, like we talked about.

            [32:30] Tom Crosley: One other quick aside. In the proof of the guardianship, we’ve got to put on medical proof of the incapacity — for financial decisions, for medical decisions, et cetera, right? Do you see any pitfalls with using an expert witness retained by the plaintiff attorney to make that proof?

            [32:50] Price Johnson: For the incapacity? I do not at all. In guardianship proceedings — this is not required in a temporary, but it is in a permanent — we have what we call a CME, a Certified Medical Examination. It’s usually a doctor; now a nurse practitioner can also do it. They go through and fill these forms out and say whether or not this person has capacity, medical or financial — the incapacity questions, or standards.

            So we have that, so we don’t really use experts so much in our guardianship proceedings. It’s rare. But in my contested probate proceedings, my will contests, we use them all the time. I use neuropsychologists all the time. Generally, I am doing a post-mortem capacity evaluation, because my person’s dead. You at least have the advantage of being able to do a capacity evaluation on a living person, which I rarely get in my practice.

            But absolutely, there’s no problem with you hiring them. There’s no problem with you using them. And if you have the guardianship, you’ll have the ability to say, “Yeah, and we also have the guardianship CME that the doctor did for the court. We have this court investigator.” And for goodness’ sake, at that point you have a court that has made a judicial determination — a final judicial determination, by the only court on the planet that can make this determination — that this person lacks capacity. Now, it won’t tell you the source of the incapacity, right?

            [34:20] Tom Crosley: Yeah. You bring up another point that we can build into our proof, then: that there’s already been a court determination that this person lacks capacity and needs others to make decisions for them. And that kind of supports my long-term attendant care model.

            [34:32] Price Johnson: You get a permanent guardianship, you have a final judicial determination by the only court on the planet that can do it. Nobody can come in and second-guess them, as long as the plenary periods have passed and everything. If you have a final judicial determination of incapacity and a permanent guardianship, it is permanent. There are mechanisms to go have a permanent guardianship undone, but you’ve got to go prove that, and usually the proof doesn’t exist until later, if ever.

            [34:58] Tom Crosley: Okay. So let’s recap the hierarchy of needs for a TBI lawyer representing a severely injured client.

            [35:06] Price Johnson: Absolutely. Someone walks in your door. The person that walks in your door is presumably not the injured person that has the TBI. If the person with the TBI is there, you do your evaluation, you do what you can. But presuming that person is not, figure out what the relationship is. Obviously, the closer the relationship, the better. Sometimes you may get a call from a cousin, right? The cousin may be the family lawyer, and so they had the cousin make the call. Okay, well, the cousin’s not who you need signing the contract. So get the closest family member you can — parent, spouse, or adult child, as the case may be, in my opinion. Sign that engagement agreement in whatever version of a next friend–type statute you have.

            Also inquire immediately: is there any kind of prior documentation — a power of attorney — that this individual may have ever signed? It’s probably not going to exist. And I would certainly think there’s never going to be a preexisting guardianship; that would likely not be the case.

            And then find out: Okay, where is this person? What’s their capacity? Follow up and find these things out, because as quickly as you can, you want to try to get this contract ratified by the ultimate client. If they have lucid moments, find out. Go visit; see what the scenario and situation is. Are they likely to be recovering, hopefully, and going home in 10 days to two weeks? Or is this a much more permanent scenario, and they’re in a six-month medically induced coma for their brain swelling to reduce? I mean, you’ve got to find these things out.

            And then do not wait if you feel like you need to do a guardianship. Guardianships aren’t fast. The fastest you’re probably going to get a temporary guardianship done in most states is probably 30 days — and that’s temporary. Maybe faster, maybe a couple of weeks; that’s rare. A permanent guardianship in most states is going to take you probably at least 60 days. This stuff takes time.

            And the number one thing I probably should have started with is: call your probate lawyer, call your guardianship lawyer, start getting them up to speed and asking questions right away, because they may be able to help give you guidance on what to do.

            [37:16] Tom Crosley: Yeah. Thank you, Price. I think that’s good advice. I mean, potentially it saves millions of dollars in legal fees and risk. If we don’t do this right, we run the risk of having our entire contract voided, or perhaps our fee limited to something less than the contracted amount. So I don’t think we would knowingly enter into that risk, right, without ameliorating it by getting somebody involved to do it right for us.

            If I left our listeners with one piece of advice, it would be: when you have a severely injured client who may lack capacity — not “do they,” but “they might” — then an early call you make is to somebody who is familiar with probate and guardianship law, so they can make sure you navigate that early in your case and get your contract approved, so that later, when you try or settle your case, your ducks are in a row.

            [38:15] Price Johnson: Absolutely. It will help your client, and it will help you protect your fee, which you well earned.

            [38:22] Tom Crosley: All right, man. Well, thank you so much for spending time with us today and sharing your wisdom. I’d like you to share your contact info, because if somebody were asking me, “Who do I call?” your name is right there at the top of the list. So how do people get in touch with you?

            [38:35] Price Johnson: My name’s kind of unique: Price Johnson. You could pretty much just Google “Price Johnson Dallas lawyer” or “Texas lawyer,” and I’m probably going to pop right up. Our phone number is 214-468-9000 — that’s our main office. Our main office is in Dallas, and we practice all over the state.

            [38:56] Tom Crosley: Price, thank you very much for joining us today and sharing your knowledge with us.

            Announcer: This has been Winning the TBI Case. I’m Tom Crosley. If today’s episode helps you see your current case in a new light, share it with a colleague who’s facing the same challenges in a case. Subscribe wherever you get your podcasts, and join our community of trial lawyers who refuse to settle for average results. This has been Winning the TBI Case: strategy, science, and storytelling, with Tom Crosley.

            40 min
          • Setting Up the TBI Case for Success: The First 6 to 18 Months

             One of the most common mistakes I see is lawyers screening for TBI will simply stop at asking the question, “Were you knocked unconscious?” – Tom Crosley

            Welcome to Winning The TBI Case, hosted by trial lawyer Tom Crosley. Listen as Tom provides practical, powerful guidance for litigating traumatic brain injury cases. This podcast is meant for litigation attorneys who are ready to explore the essentials of TBI cases to confidently represent clients who have suffered traumatic brain injuries.

            What’s In This Episode

            Tom Crosley lays out a practical timeline for developing a TBI case during the critical first 6 to 18 months. He explains how better intake questions, four specific symptom-tracking tools, and consistent symptom documentation can establish an early foundation while helping attorneys avoid gaps that may later create problems with proof.
            Building the Foundation of a TBI Case

            The success of a case often depends on decisions made in the earliest days, long before depositions, expert testimony, or trial. In this episode, Tom explains why the first six months matter enormously and what lawyers need to do during the first 18 months to shape the medical and legal framework of the entire case.

            Using a real case example, Tom demonstrates what can happen when persistent brain injury symptoms are not adequately documented early. He then walks through his approach to identifying potential TBI cases, tracking symptoms, and supporting accurate medical documentation.

            Key Insights for Trial Lawyers

            Go Beyond Loss of Consciousness: Intake forms should explore memory, confusion, altered mental status, acute symptoms, and what others observed immediately before and after the injury.

            Create a Written Symptom Record: Vague descriptions such as feeling “foggy” or “not myself” may not adequately capture what a client is experiencing. Written symptom questionnaires can help clients organize their symptoms and communicate them more accurately to their treating physicians. Tom recommends the following four symptom forms:

            • Philadelphia Head Injury Questionnaire (PHIQ)
            • CDC Acute Concussion Evaluation (ACE)
            • Rivermead Post-Concussion Symptoms Questionnaire (RPQ)
            • Headache Impact Test (HIT-6)
            • Avoid Gaps in Medical Documentation: Persistent symptoms need to reach the treating physician. Long periods without meaningful documentation can make an otherwise legitimate injury significantly more difficult to prove later.

              Know When to Expand the TBI Workup: For clients with persistent symptoms, Tom discusses when to consider advanced neuroimaging and whether a neuropsychological evaluation is warranted.

              Reassess as the Case Develops: As the case progresses into the 12-to-18-month window, repeat neuropsychological testing or neuroimaging may help document whether the client’s condition has improved, remained stable, or changed over time.

              For Trial Lawyers: Build the Foundation Early

              This episode is for trial lawyers who handle serious injury cases but may not regularly litigate TBI cases. Tom’s message is simple:

              • Start early
              • Ask better questions
              • Document symptoms
              • Make sure those symptoms are reaching treating physicians
              • Continually evaluate whether the developing medical evidence supports the TBI case
              • The goal is not to overbuild every potential brain injury claim. It is to recognize legitimate TBI cases early enough to develop the medical and factual record needed to accurately demonstrate the client’s injury when the case reaches trial.

                Connect
                • Subscribe to Winning The TBI Case on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube or wherever you get your podcasts. 
                • Follow on Facebook, LinkedIn, and Instagram
                • And remember, don’t just listen to the strategies, implement them!
                • Winning the TBI Case — Episode 23: Setting Up the TBI Case for Success: The First 6 to 18 Months

                  Crosley Law | Aired: August 13, 2026 | Runtime: 29:37 | Speakers: Narrator, Tom Crosley

                  [0:00] Tom Crosley: One of the most common mistakes I see is lawyers screening for TBI will simply stop at asking the question, “Were you knocked unconscious?”

                  [0:11] Narrator: TBI cases can feel like navigating uncharted territory. Your client’s injury is real, but proving it, that’s where the real challenge begins. If you’ve ever felt like you’re missing crucial pieces of the puzzle, you’re in the right place. Welcome to Winning the TBI Case, where Tom Crosley shares the insights he’s gained from over 60 injury trials, not just the victories, but the lessons learned along the way that make all the difference. Winning the TBI Case: Strategy, Science, and Storytelling.

                  [0:46] Tom Crosley: Welcome back to Winning the TBI Case. I’m your host, Tom Crosley, and today I’d like to talk about how to set your case up for success in the first six months. Because let’s face it, a lot of times a TBI case at trial will only do as well as the foundation that was laid in the early days of that case. Let me tell you what I mean. At trial, we often think about expert witnesses, neuropsychological testing, how well did we prepare for depositions, how well did we pick our jury, but all of that is less important than how well we set our case up for success in the early days. The quality of the intake, the questions we ask our clients at the beginning, the way the client’s symptoms are documented, all those steps taken in the first six months of a case will often determine how successful that case is at trial two or three years later. So I’m speaking now to lawyers that may handle serious injury cases but don’t handle a high volume of TBI cases, and I’m going to provide some tips on how I usually set these cases up for success early. The central point is this: in a TBI case, especially a mild TBI case, the first six months matter enormously, and the first eighteen months or so often define the medical and legal architecture of the entire case.

                  [2:13] Tom Crosley: Let me begin with a case example about the problem with being too late to recognize your case as a TBI case. Several years ago, I was referred a case involving a young college-aged woman who’d been in a serious intersection collision. This was not a minor crash. She had been unconscious for briefly a minute or two. She had some bleeding on the scalp. She had a laceration. She even had a small spot of bleeding within the brain. She was taken to the hospital in an ambulance. In the hospital, the CT scans showed some abnormality, but a few weeks later she had an MRI, and by that time the blood seen on the CT was gone, and the MRI was read as normal. And the doctor told her, “Hey, look, I know you’re having these symptoms, but it’s probably all gonna go away in six weeks or so,” and no follow-up appointment was ever made, and then I get the case two years later. And so I, first thing I do is I meet with the client, and I learn that she’s still got memory trouble. She’s got headaches. Sometimes the headaches are so bad that she has to go into her boss’s office where she works in a copy center at the university, and she has to lay down on the couch and turn off the lights because these are migraine-type headaches.

                  [3:32] Tom Crosley: She didn’t used to have these before the crash, and so this was a life-changing injury for her. The problem is she hadn’t seen a doctor about it in almost two years. And so when I got involved, I certainly encouraged her to go back to the doctor and start reporting these symptoms. The problem with it was the defense took it all as lawyer-generated medicine. “Hey, this client was fine. She didn’t really need to go to the doctor again until Crosley got involved and started representing her on the case.” That wasn’t fair, but that’s what we were dealing with in that case. She had all these post-concussion symptoms. She had classic post-concussion syndrome that, in her case, was unresolved after two years and would likely be permanent, but it wasn’t adequately documented in the medical records. So when there is a long period of time with little or no meaningful documentation about the brain injury symptoms, that creates a problem for our proof. She had seen other doctors in that span of time. She had been to doctors for routine medical care visits, but none of these other symptoms that she was supposedly having were documented, and certainly not documented in a way that supported the full picture of what she was experiencing.

                  [4:48] Tom Crosley: In that case, I had to rely on friends, family members, coworkers to help explain that these symptoms were legitimate, they were real, they persisted all the time. But it sure would have been nice if there had always been a medical doctor checking in with her every ninety days or so and documenting her ongoing symptoms in a medical record. So from a litigation standpoint, the defense argument was very predictable. Hey, if these symptoms were real and they were significant, why was there nearly two years with no documentation of any TBI related symptom? That was a problem in the case. The case ultimately settled, but for less than it would have if we had set it up for success in the first six months. The gap in those records made the case much harder than it needed to be. Had I received that case weeks after the crash instead of more than two years later, the development of the case would have looked very different. As long as she remained symptomatic, she would have had someone encouraging her to follow up with her doctors and tell them what she was experiencing. Someone would have been tracking her symptoms. Someone would have been considering whether advanced imaging or neuropsychological testing was appropriate.

                  [6:05] Tom Crosley: Someone would have made sure the medical record reflected the reality of her condition. That is the lesson. A real injury, especially an invisible injury like a mild TBI, can be undermined by poor early documentation. So how do we avoid that? Step one, let’s ask better intake questions. One of the most common mistakes I see is lawyers screening for TBI will simply stop at asking the question, “Were you knocked unconscious?” Well, that’s a threshold question, but it is not the end all be all of the analysis in a TBI case. Loss of consciousness is not required for concussion or mild TBI. A person can sustain a mild TBI without being knocked out, so the intake has to go far beyond loss of consciousness. It has to focus on brain function. We need to be asking the client what they remember about the crash, whether they remember the minutes immediately before or after the crash, whether they were dazed, confused, disoriented, or slow to respond, whether there are other witnesses who can attest to how they behaved during this timeframe because sometimes the client themselves isn’t the most reliable narrator of those events. You know, was this person still repeating the same question over and over?

                  [7:23] Tom Crosley: Our client probably won’t know that, but they will have heard it from others in their lives. We need to find out whether the client had a headache, dizziness, nausea, light sensitivity, noise sensitivity, blurred vision, balance problems, mental fog, difficulty concentrating, memory problems, irritability, emotional changes. We need to be looking at all of that stuff, and those questions are important because modern mild TBI diagnosis is not built around one single fact. The 2023 ACRM criteria, which I did a previous episode on, begin with this, a biomechanically plausible mechanism of injury, and then they evaluate clinical signs, acute symptoms, and objective findings when available, and neuroimaging when present to lead to that generally accepted diagnosis of TBI. So for lawyers, my practical point is simple: do not reduce the screening for TBI to loss of consciousness. Expand and cover those other things. Ask about memory, ask about confusion, ask about altered mental status, ask about symptoms in the first seventy-two hours. Ask about what other people observed. Those facts may later be important to a treating doctor or an expert witness in the case, and they may ultimately be important to the jury in the case.

                  [8:42] Tom Crosley: Now, this doesn’t mean the lawyer themselves has to conduct every detailed interview. In a well-run law firm, this can be handled by the intake department or a well-trained paralegal. What matters is that the right questions are asked, the answers are recorded, and the lawyer understands those answers. This leads us to step two. Step two is we must help the client create a written symptom record. So one practical thing I recommend in any suspected TBI case is to have the client complete a written symptoms form early in the case. Most lawyers who don’t regularly handle TBI cases probably do not use this kind of process. They may ask the client generally how they’re doing. They may ask whether they lost consciousness. They may ask about headaches, but that’s not enough. So brain injury symptoms can be hard for clients to describe. A client may say, “I don’t feel right,” or, “I’m foggy,” or, “I’m just not myself.” But those statements might be true, but they don’t give the treating doctor, the lawyer, or the later experts enough detail. A written symptom form helps to organize that information. It helps the client to think through the symptoms that started after the crash, trace them to the present day, talk about what’s improved, what continues to be a problem, and it gives the client, here’s the kicker, it gives the client something concrete and tangible to take to the doctor, to their next doctor appointment.

                  [10:09] Tom Crosley: So that’s my key point. The goal is not to create a law firm document that sits in the file. The goal is to help the client communicate accurately with his or her physician. So if the client’s still having headaches, dizziness, memory problems, et cetera, a written form can help the client document and explain those symptoms to a physician. For this purpose, I recommend four forms. The first is called the Philadelphia Head Injury Questionnaire, or the PHIQ. This form, originally created, I believe, in the early nineties, ’cause I’ve used it for a while, just has the client fill out some basic information about the accident, whether they lost consciousness. Did they feel dazed? What did they strike their head on? Did they go to a doctor or hospital? Did they have any imaging? And then it has them describe any persistent symptoms. Do they have recurrent headaches? If yes, describe. Do they have seizures? Do they have dizziness, numbness, clumsiness, loss of balance, changes in vision, hearing, taste, smell, and so on. And they circle yes or no, and sometimes they fill out a brief description. There’s also a cognitive component to the form.

                  [11:25] Tom Crosley: Have you noticed changes in memory, concentration, understanding what you’ve read, understanding instructions? Do you have word-finding difficulties? There’s a personality changes inventory on the form. Are you more irritable or short-tempered? Are you more easily fatigued? Are you having depression or crying spells? And on and on. But the point is that it’s a two-page form with a pertinent medical history. Because it’s a generally accepted form, our client can fill this out. We can keep one copy in the lawyer’s file, but the client can take another copy with them to their next doctor visit. Sometimes the doctor will incorporate that form into the client’s medical record. Sometimes instead, they will use the information on that form to conduct their own screening. The point is, we’re avoiding getting things lost in translation. If the symptom is real, we want the symptom to be documented. If the client hand carries this form to the doctor, it is far more likely to end up being adequately documented in the medical record. The second form that I like to use is the CDC’s Acute Concussion Evaluation form, or the A-C-E.

                  [12:40] Tom Crosley: It’s useful because it’s also a doctor-friendly form. The client can fill out the symptom portions of it and take it to a physician, who can decide whether to review it and to incorporate it in their medical record as part of the clinical history. A third form that I like is called the Rivermead Post-Concussion Symptoms Questionnaire, also the RPQ. Rivermead is helpful because it allows symptoms to be tracked over time. It can be completed early in the case, and then it can be repeated later to show whether symptoms have improved or resolved, whether they persisted, whether they’ve worsened. This one is a list of a few dozen symptoms, and they ask the person filling it out to compare it with before the accident, do you now or over the last twenty-four hours have you suffered from? And then it lists these things like headaches, dizziness, nausea, vomiting, sleep disturbance, fatigue, etc. And the client circles a zero for not experienced at all to a one for no longer a problem, all the way up to a four for this is a severe problem. And so it’s tracking all those typical post-concussion symptoms, and the client is endorsing which ones are currently affecting them.

                  [13:56] Tom Crosley: So that’s a useful one to have the client fill out serially through the life of the case and also to hand-carry with them to their doctor in follow-up visits. There’s a fourth form that I would use if headaches are a significant component of the client’s symptoms, and it’s called the HIT-6. It stands for Headache Impact Test. That one is basically having the client rate their headaches and describe like, how severe is the pain? How do they limit your activities? It’s a two-page form. And the reason that’s important is headaches, I think, according to the literature at least, accompany about ninety percent of TBIs. And in some of our cases, most of the other cognitive symptoms may have resolved, that a client is left with a migraine-type headache syndrome that is attributable to their TBI. In those cases, it’s important that we document the evolution of the headache and whether it responds well to medications. My point is simple. In a suspected TBI case, if you’re the lawyer, do not rely on vague verbal reports. Help the client create a written symptom record that can be shared with the treating physician. If the doctor finds it useful and incorporates it into the medical chart, so much the better.

                  [15:13] Tom Crosley: That’s how you avoid a false gap in the medical records, a situation where the client is having real symptoms but the medical records don’t show them. Step three, make sure these ongoing symptoms reach the doctor. It’s not complicated. It’s the same advice you would give your own spouse, your own child, a good friend of yours, and it’s make sure the doctor understands what you’re going through. We do not want our TBI cases going off the track because the early medical care focuses solely on the orthopedic injuries, and ignores the potential TBI injuries. It is not uncommon in my cases that I’ll get a case where there’s been other body parts injured but, and the TBI symptoms are underreported and no one’s really following them up very well, and then I get involved in the case, usually on a referral, and I start working up the TBI symptoms. Every single time I wish I had gotten the case sooner so that we could work up all aspects of that injury case at the same time. As a lawyer, I am not directing the medical care, but I can make sure the client understands the importance of accurately reporting ongoing symptoms to his or her doctor. This is especially important in the first ninety days. That’s when many concussions improve. A lot of early doctors that see that client may assume the client’s going to get well in that thirty to ninety day period because most people do, and so they won’t even schedule a follow-up appointment.

                  [16:37] Tom Crosley: What happens if that client didn’t get well and there’s no appointment scheduled? Well, if the, if no one’s paying attention, that client might not go to the doctor at all, which creates the classic problem that we often face in these cases. So if we’re in tune with these issues and the client is still having those symptoms, then we could be in their corner encouraging them to follow up with appropriate medical care and have those symptoms documented. Step four is deciding whether advanced imaging is needed. So a normal CT scan that your client may or may not have gotten in the emergency room does not rule out mild traumatic brain injury. CT is excellent in the emergency setting for identifying skull fractures, bleeding, swelling, or surgical emergencies. But CT is not designed to detect many of the microstructural injuries associated with mild TBI. A conventional MRI may also be normal even when the patient has persistent symptoms. So if the client remains symptomatic and the case appears significant enough to warrant a full TBI workup, the lawyer should be thinking about advanced brain imaging within the first six months. Ideally, this would be ordered by a treating physician.

                  [17:54] Tom Crosley: The best practice is for the client’s symptoms to be evaluated by a physician specializing in head injury and for that physician to determine whether advanced imaging is appropriate. In my practice, when advanced imaging is warranted, I generally want a brain MRI with a trauma-sensitive protocol. What does that mean? That means, if available, a three T MRI. Tesla or T is a unit of measurement of magnet strength. The typical MRI is a one point five T machine. A three T machine can give us a better picture. That’s not so important when we’re looking at knees. It’s very important when we’re looking at brains. So I would want a 3T MRI with susceptibility weighted imaging or SWI is useful because it can detect microhemorrhages or hemosiderin deposits, little deposits of dried up blood, which could show evidence of prior bleeding. That picture is worth a thousand words when you’re trying your lawsuit. This trauma-sensitive protocol would also include DTI or diffusion tensor imaging, which I’ve talked about on prior episodes. DTI evaluates white matter integrity by measuring the movement of water molecules along white matter tracts.

                  [19:16] Tom Crosley: It is not a standalone diagnosis of TBI, but it can provide important corroborative evidence. This protocol we would get should also include volumetric analysis when available. Volumetrics can help evaluate whether there are patterns of brain volume loss or asymmetry that may be relevant, especially when interpreted by a qualified expert in the context of the full clinical picture. So this is an area where lawyers need to understand the distinction between clinical medicine and litigation proof. Mild TBI is a clinical diagnosis. A doctor does not need DTI or volumetrics to diagnose a concussion. Some clinical guidelines do not even recommend advanced imaging for routine management of every mild TBI patient. That’s understandable. But litigation is different. In a serious case with persistent symptoms, we’re not just asking whether the client had a concussion. We’re also asking whether there is objective, verifiable evidence that helps corroborate the injury, explain the symptoms, evaluate the prognosis, and respond to predictable defense arguments. We’re looking for proof. And so that’s why in the right case, advanced neuroimaging can be important because timing matters.

                  [20:34] Tom Crosley: If the client is still symptomatic weeks or months after the injury, and the case appears to be having the trajectory of a more significant TBI case, I would not let the first six months pass without deciding whether advanced imaging is warranted. That doesn’t mean every client with a headache needs advanced imaging. It doesn’t mean every concussion case gets a DTI. It’s all dependent on how severe the client’s symptoms are. If they’re still symptomatic ninety days out, I’m starting to think about getting advanced neuroimaging. We certainly don’t want to discover three years into the case that that advanced imaging was never obtained and the client is still symptomatic because that’s a lost opportunity to prove a strong case. So the next step after advanced neuroimaging is neuropsychological evaluation. I like to consider it around the six-month mark. Sometimes it’s ordered clinically. Sometimes it’s not ordered clinically, and I’m getting it as a forensic expert witness. But in any serious case involving persistent, ongoing cognitive, behavioral, or functional symptoms related to TBI, I generally lean toward getting a neuropsych exam at six months. If I haven’t gotten the case in the first six months, then I’m trying to do it at least within the first year.

                  [21:54] Tom Crosley: There are some reasons not to do this comprehensive testing too early. In the first few weeks after a concussion, the symptoms might be fluctuating. Client may still be in pain. There might be other explanations for why they might not perform a certain way on neuropsych testing. But at the six-month mark, if they’re still having problems with memory, attention, processing speed, mental fog, et cetera, then I tend to lean toward getting the neuropsych exam at that point. It will help identify cognitive strengths and weaknesses. It will evaluate validity and effort. It’ll assess functional limitations. It’ll help us sort through the overlap between the TBI symptoms and PTSD or anxiety or other symptoms. Again, this doesn’t mean every TBI case needs a neuropsych test either. If it’s just a headache symptom, and that’s predominantly what I’m building the case around, I don’t need a neuropsych. It depends on the cluster of symptoms the client has. But if they’re cognitive and emotional and they’re significant, I’m probably getting a neuropsych test. And then at the six-month mark, I’m hoping to have classified my case. Was this the type of concussion or mild TBI that largely resolved?

                  [23:09] Tom Crosley: What am I left with? Or is this instead a persistent post-concussion syndrome case? Is it a complicated TBI? Is there more severity to this one with positive neuroimaging? Is there evidence of structural injury? You know, are the symptoms real, but maybe it’s more related to physical pain or depression or PTSD or sleep disruption or medication or other conditions? So I’m really trying to figure out at six months, does this hold together as a TBI case? This prevents potentially two costly mistakes. Number one, missing a real TBI case because nobody developed it early. Or number two, the flip side of that, overbuilding a weak TBI case that doesn’t have the factual or medical foundation to support it. So often I’ll have a case that starts out as a TBI case, but my client has gotten well by ninety days or one hundred and eighty days. I don’t continue to try to pretend it’s a TBI case anymore. I mean, I work up those symptoms for what they were, but I focus on, you know, all my cases. I’m focusing on how has this injury changed my client’s life going forward? Because that’s where the real loss to the client is.

                  [24:26] Tom Crosley: That’s where the real value in a jury argument is, a lifetime of future disability. So now let’s shift beyond the first six months and talk about the first eighteen months. So there are certain things that I’ve done by six months, and there are certain other things I want to do by eighteen months. At eighteen months or at least a year or so after that first neuropsych, I probably want to repeat one so I can see whether they’re more or less the same or whether they’ve changed. Plus I want my experts to have recent information by the time the case is going to court. I will also consider repeat testing with advanced neuroimaging. I might get another MRI, repeat the SWI, the DTI, and the volumetrics. Sometimes we can learn things about the volumetric changes. If there’s been atrophy in an area of the brain that was injured and we look at it again a year later and we see that that part has gotten smaller or atrophied more, that can create powerful evidence when we try the case. So I’m usually doing repeat imaging and repeat neuropsych testing, at least a year after the first time. And then if the case lives long enough, I’m probably doing this repeat testing every twelve to eighteen months during the life of the case, and certainly less than six months before the trial of the case so that my experts can testify based on recent testing results.

                  [25:54] Tom Crosley: So here’s my practical timeline for lawyers. In the first thirty days, screen your case carefully. Don’t stop at loss of consciousness. Ask about memory, confusion, altered mental status, acute symptoms, and what others have observed about the plaintiff. Use these written symptom forms that I’ve mentioned to help the client document their own symptoms and to communicate them to the treating doctors. These forms are the PHIQ, the CDC ACE, the Rivermead, and the HIT-6. Get the emergency room records, EMS records, imaging reports, and discharge instructions, and monitor your client to determine whether the symptoms are resolving or continuing. If they’re continuing, it’s important that the client is still seeing a physician and having these symptoms documented and getting the treatment that they need. At the three to six-month window, I’m usually looking at whether the case requires advanced brain imaging. I’m considering a three T MRI with SWI, DTI, and volumetrics, preferably ordered through a treating physician. Around the six-month mark, I’m considering whether a neuropsych evaluation is warranted, especially if the client’s still symptomatic and depending on what those symptoms are.

                  [27:10] Tom Crosley: And around the twelve to eighteen-month mark, I’m starting to consider repeat testing. So here’s my closing takeaway. I’ll wrap it all up. If you suspect a brain injury in your client, then start early by documenting all those symptoms and have your client make sure they are reporting these symptoms to their physician and that the client’s medical records are documenting those symptoms also. If the client is still symptomatic at ninety days, it’s time to start thinking about ordering advanced neuroimaging. If the client is still symptomatic at one hundred and eighty days, in my practice, it’s time to start thinking about a referral for a neuropsychological evaluation. And then during the life of the case, I want my client to continue to have their symptoms documented and followed over the entire life of the case at least every ninety days. And I probably want repeat neuroimaging and repeat neuropsychological testing at intervals in the life of the case every twelve to eighteen months, and certainly within six months of my trial date. The right fact documented early is often more valuable than a perfect explanation you could come up with years later. So that’s why we lawyers that handle TBI cases need a disciplined early protocol for how to recognize and work up the TBI case.

                  [28:31] Tom Crosley: What’s that saying? An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure. So here we’re doing an ounce of prevention early in the case. The ounce of prevention is preventing there from being a big gap in the medical records that don’t adequately explain what your client is going through. The pound of cure is gonna come later, right? When we have set up the TBI case for success at a trial two or three years down the road. That’s it for today’s episode. This has been Winning the TBI Case: Strategy, Science, and Storytelling. I’m Tom Crosley. See you next time.

                  [29:04] Narrator: If today’s episode helped you see your current case in a new light, share it with a colleague who’s facing the same challenges in a case. Subscribe wherever you get your podcasts and join our community of trial lawyers who refuse to settle for average results. This has been Winning the TBI Case: Strategy, Science, and Storytelling with Tom Crosley.

                  30 min
                • Exposing the Defense Expert Playbook with Dorothy Clay Sims

                  Defense experts often rely on a familiar set of arguments in traumatic brain injury cases. The challenge for plaintiff lawyers is knowing how to identify those themes and effectively challenge them.

                  Welcome to Winning The TBI Case, hosted by trial lawyer Tom Crosley. Listen as Tom provides practical, powerful guidance for litigating traumatic brain injury cases. This podcast is meant for litigation attorneys who are ready to explore the essentials of TBI cases to confidently represent clients who have suffered traumatic brain injuries.

                  This episode is for plaintiff lawyers who want to recognize and dismantle the predictable defense expert playbook in TBI cases. Dorothy Clay Sims reveals the recurring tactics they use and shares the research methods to expose their weaknesses.

                  In this episode, Tom sits down with attorney Dorothy Clay Sims, author of Exposing Deceptive Defense Doctors and a nationally recognized authority on defense medical testimony. Drawing on decades of experience, Dorothy discusses the recurring strategies she sees in TBI litigation and the patterns that appear again and again in defense opinions. She also shares practical steps lawyers can take to identify weaknesses in those opinions and build a stronger case for their clients. Dorothy shares insights on:

                  • Looking beyond the medical record to uncover critical evidence
                  • Challenging imaging and neuropsychological opinions effectively
                  • Researching and evaluating defense experts
                  • Preparing for deposition with a strategic purpose
                  • Avoiding common mistakes that can undermine a TBI case
                  • Whether you’re new to TBI litigation or looking to sharpen your approach, this episode offers practical guidance for recognizing and responding to the defense playbook.

                    Connect
                    • Connect directly with Dorothy Clay Sims: https://dorothyclaysims.com
                    • Mentioned: Exposing Deceptive Defense Doctors
                    • Subscribe to Winning The TBI Case on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube or wherever you get your podcasts. 
                    • Follow on Facebook, LinkedIn, and Instagram.
                    • And remember, don’t just listen to the strategies, implement them!
                    • Winning the TBI Case — Episode 22: Exposing the Defense Expert Playbook 

                      Host: Tom Crosley Guest: Dorothy Clay Sims Runtime: 35:58

                      [00:00] Dorothy Clay Sims (cold open): What we found out recently in a case in California is the defense expert altered the test administration and/or changed our client’s answers 67 times during the examination. 

                      [00:12] Announcer: TBI cases can feel like navigating uncharted territory. Your client’s injury is real, but proving it is where the real challenge begins. If you’ve ever felt like you’re missing crucial pieces of the puzzle, you’re in the right place. Welcome to Winning the TBI Case, where Tom Crosley shares the insights he’s gained from over 60 injury trials. Not just the victories, but the lessons learned along the way that make all the difference. This is practical wisdom from someone who’s been in your shoes and found a path forward. Winning the TBI Case: strategy, science, and storytelling. 

                      When Dorothy Clay Sims discovered that defense experts were systematically lying about her brain injury clients, she made it her life’s work to expose their deceptive tactics. In this eye-opening interview, Dorothy shares the tools every trial lawyer needs to identify and challenge fraudulent medical testimony. 

                      [01:18] Tom Crosley: Welcome back to Winning the TBI Case. I’m Tom Crosley. Today’s guest is Dorothy Clay Sims. She’s a lawyer who has spent decades studying how defense medical experts operate: how they write their reports, how they testify, tactics they use to minimize or deny injury claims. And if you’ve ever read a defense IME report and thought, “Oh, here we go again,” then this episode is for you. 

                      We’re gonna walk through what Dorothy actually does for trial lawyers, when you should consider retaining her, what you can learn from her, and hopefully give a practical framework for researching a defense doctor and building a cross-examination strategy that’s clean, fair, and powerful. All of this without turning the courtroom into a boring medical seminar. So let’s get into it. Dorothy, how are you doing today? 

                      [02:13] Dorothy Clay Sims: I’m good. How are you doing, Tom? 

                      Tom Crosley: I’m doing great. So you and I have known each other for, gosh, a long, long time. Almost 20 years now — more than 15 years for sure. A lot of your background I’m familiar with, but we may have listeners who aren’t. So I wanted to start with: what drew you into studying defense medical testimony in the first place, carving out this niche in your law practice? 

                      [02:42] Dorothy Clay Sims: Well, my motivation, actually, it’s this guy right here. His name was David Hansford Sims. He was my brother. He had a very severe disability. He could not ever speak, communicate. He would sit for hours on end shaking a sock. And I saw how he was treated, and it really bothered me. And I felt like I wanted to represent disabled people. 

                      And then the more I did it, the more defense reports I got, the more I realized these people are lying. And so one day, after 60 cases in a row where the same doctor said my clients were faking based on the MMPI, I went and met the creator of the MMPI, and I showed him the last report, and he started laughing. And I said, “What’s so funny?” And he said, “If this doctor had been my student, I would have failed him. This is not an appropriate interpretation of the test.” 

                      I knew that they were lying — defense experts in general — but I didn’t know how. And so he actually became a friend of mine, and we spent hours together, and he would give me examples, questions to ask, and this is how they manipulated the science. 

                      And I ended up doing a lot of brain injury work because there’s neuropsychological testing, and that is an area where I’ve seen incredible fraud. What we found out recently in a case in California is the defense expert altered the test administration and/or changed our client’s answers 67 times during the examination. It got so bad that during the cross-examination, the judge says, “Okay, you can stop. We know they did it all wrong.” We didn’t want to stop, but it was terrible. So the more I get into this, the angrier I get. 

                      I spent several years taking all these tests myself, having physicals performed on me to understand how those are altered. And then I worked closely with my husband, who’s a physical medicine and rehab doctor, and he ran a brain injury clinic. And he watches the videotapes of the defense medical exams, looks at the report, and then he goes into the body of the report and lists everything they misrepresented based on the video. He’s done probably 700 of these. And when I asked him what percentage of the time the doctor actually accurately reflected what happened in the report — knowing that they were being recorded — the answer is zero. 

                      [05:06] Tom Crosley: Some years ago, you wrote a book called Exposing Deceptive Defense Doctors. I actually bought that book, gosh, 20 years ago maybe. I don’t remember when it was published. But it was one of those three-ring binder books that was multiple volumes, very expensive for a young lawyer at the time. But I recall that book being instrumental in helping me approach defense IMEs. This was not brain injury cases; these were typically spine injury cases. 

                      Dorothy Clay Sims: Right. 

                      Tom Crosley: But since that time, it sounds like you’ve been doing a lot of work on brain injury cases. 

                      [05:39] Dorothy Clay Sims: Yeah, and that book has had significant updates. It’s probably twice as long. I have a lot of references to diffusion tensor imaging — I know you had a piece on that. There’s a lot of politics going into articles that are written saying don’t use it. It’s unbelievable in that field what’s happening. But yeah, the book is longer and there’s a lot more updated information in it. 

                      [05:57] Tom Crosley: I need to get it. So we had as a previous guest Stewart Casper, who you and I both know very well. And he and I talked about the concept of the citation cartel. 

                      Dorothy Clay Sims: Yes. 

                      Tom Crosley: So I’m assuming that’s a little bit of what you’re referring to in your previous comment just now. 

                      [06:14] Dorothy Clay Sims: Well, there is such a thing. And in fact, one of the problems we have is people are afraid to talk about it, especially professionals, because a certain number of defense experts are very litigious. But yeah, when you have a defense expert become the head of a journal, deciding what gets published and what doesn’t, and that individual doesn’t even allow an article published by the creator of a test that is being analyzed and criticized in that journal — they don’t allow the test creator to weigh in. It’s bad. 

                      [06:41] Tom Crosley: I know you speak a lot around the country and even internationally, and I’ve heard you speak several times. You’re always very entertaining. Some of the examples you give are so incredibly outrageous as to defy belief. 

                      Dorothy Clay Sims: Yes. 

                      Tom Crosley: And I haven’t had those examples actually appear in my cases, because I’m usually dealing with pretty known quantities. I mean, I’ve had you do opposition research for experts. You provided packets of information. But what I’d like to hear is the normal — what are you doing for lawyers like me, either by helping us prep for these defense experts, or sometimes, I know, you’ll come in and do them yourself as part of our case? Help us understand what you’re doing when you don’t have this crazy outlier who’s lied on his résumé and put in degrees that he doesn’t have and things like that. 

                      [07:41] Dorothy Clay Sims: I don’t know anybody else that does what I do, and I haven’t had a regular caseload in over 20 years. That’s all I do. But, for example, if I’m looking at a report, I can see there’s something. What I’ll do is I’ll take the report and I’ll take the transcript, and I will analyze what is in the transcript that the doctor misrepresented. Like yesterday, the doctor testified under oath, “Oh, your client has high blood pressure and diabetes, and that’s why there’s cognitive problems. And she told me that.” Well, in the transcript, she said, “I do not have diabetes,” and, you know, et cetera. 

                      So I use some AI proprietary software to help with that, and I get a chart of everything that’s misrepresented. And then I go in — I have material on over 2,000 experts nationwide, and some of it’s 12,000 pages long — and I’ll use software to go in there and tell me what’s in the background that they testified to that’s completely contrary to the report. 

                      And so I’ll analyze that, and then I either will tell the lawyer, “Don’t have me take this deposition, because this expert did so badly you need to save it for trial, because there’s no excuse for what they did” — which, those are my favorite — and then I just tell them what questions to ask and give them the exhibits. Or I just go in and take the deposition myself. 

                      And when I do it, I’m using AI all day now. I have various AI sites open so that when the doctor cites an article, I can go in and say, “What’s the problem with the article?” Even if I don’t know where to find the article, I just describe it. In the middle of the deposition, it’ll come up with something like, “Oh, there were only three people in the normative database. This is not scientific.” And so when the defense experts start citing the literature, it’s clear they haven’t read it, right? And they don’t even really know what it says. I find that happens all the time. And so when you start using AI to go after them, it bothers them. 

                      So I’ll either take the deposition myself or prepare the lawyer to do it. And sometimes I can look at a report and know immediately, over the phone: “Okay, you don’t need me at all. Here’s the problem, and here’s how to fix it.” 

                      I also do private seminars where lawyers will come in and discuss two or three cases. They will come to my home in Oregon. My husband will look at the medical records and will tell them, “These are your weaknesses.” We record the whole thing. “This is what the defense will do. This is how to fight it. This is what you need to do to clean up the case or to prove it.” 

                      [10:06] Tom Crosley: Dorothy, it’s interesting the way you described your practice, and I think it leads to what I’d like to talk about next, which is — in brain injury cases, because this is a TBI-specific podcast — there are recurring themes we see over and over again from defense experts. 

                      Dorothy Clay Sims: Yes. 

                      Tom Crosley: And what they’re trying to get the jury to buy into. And so I’d like to discuss first: what are the recurring themes? I know what I would think, but I’d like to talk to you about it. And then after we identify the recurring themes, I’d like you to talk to us about your strategies for overcoming those. 

                      [10:44] Dorothy Clay Sims: Okay. The recurring things are so predictable that actually my husband and my son, who’s a plaintiff’s lawyer here in Los Angeles, have been tasked by Trial Guides with writing a book on it. And they’ve got the top 30 typical themes that are spewed forth by bad defense experts. And those themes are so predictable, it’s gotten to the point now where, when I find out who the expert is, I can write the report. I know what they’re going to say. 

                      For brain injury, what they’re gonna say is there was no loss of consciousness at the scene and no evidence from a healthcare provider the patient was dazed, okay? That’s ridiculous, because dazed is an experience that the patient — the plaintiff — experiences. It doesn’t mean that they’re telegraphing it to the EMS or to the ER. 

                      And if I could digress on that for a moment: I always get these reports that have a normal neurologic exam from the ER, and the EMS says no loss of consciousness, and there was a witness that saw it — there was a loss. What’s going on? And then I came upon a bad crash, a really bad one, with seven people, and one woman was dying. She had agonal breathing. There was one EMT that was available for seven people, and he was color-coding those that were most severe. 

                      It occurred to me that the EMTs, when they’re working a crash site and there’s more than one person, they’re not going to do a Glasgow Coma Scale. They’re not going to test for awareness. They’re not going to ask the person, “Are you confused?” So they’re not documenting it. Plus, they may not document their records until 24 to 48 hours later, and they don’t remember. 

                      Why does the ER say everything’s normal? And this really bothered me. I had a theory that the ER was making stuff up. So I wrote for my own three ER visits over the last 15 years. All three of them had a tremendous amount of things that the ER doctor did in the report that never happened in reality. About two-thirds of the reports — all three were false. 

                      And so my concern is, how do we prove it? And that’s when I learned you can write for the metadata. In bigger hospitals, they keep track: when the doctor goes in the room, he clicks on an iPad, and that starts the clock running for when he’s with the patient. And if you show that the doctor spent seven minutes with the patient, there’s no way they could have done all the neurologic exam that’s listed in the medical records. And they will admit to that. So we as lawyers need to start automatically writing for that information in those cases where we think that the ER minimized what happened. 

                      [13:21] Tom Crosley: Are you seeing that obtained in discovery in non-medical malpractice cases? Because I haven’t seen that yet. 

                      [13:26] Dorothy Clay Sims: I have been begging lawyers for the last 12 months to start doing this, when I first learned about it, and they’re just now starting to do it. And in one previous malpractice case — and I’m going to talk about that in a minute — I told them, “I guarantee you that radiologist never looked at the brain scan.” And they said, “That couldn’t be. He wrote this long report.” They wrote for the audit trails, and the expert admitted they never looked at it and signed off on the report. 

                      Tom Crosley: Holy moly. That’s crazy. 

                      Dorothy Clay Sims: Problem. My husband and I do live international AI interviews, and we interviewed two radiologists — they’re on my website. And they both said, yes, radiologists believe that AI is better than they are. And so they’re signing their names to the reports but never looking at the scans. And what we’re finding — like in one case, there was a lemon-sized stroke in this guy’s brain, and AI missed it, and the doctor signed off on it. So that is an issue to be aware of for your own personal health and your family. 

                      [14:31] Tom Crosley: I’ve got a friend who’s a neuroradiologist here in San Antonio. He does not want to do any of this legal case work, but I’m going to have to ask him about that. 

                      [14:40] Dorothy Clay Sims: Well, think about this. Another thing you can do is, when they do look at it, the metadata will tell you how long they looked at it. And there was a case in Florida where the doctor looked at the scans for 60 seconds, and there were 5,000 slices. 

                      Tom Crosley: Holy moly. 

                      Dorothy Clay Sims: And so all they did is make a movie of 5,000 slices going — you know, 5,000 in one minute. The jury was furious. 

                      Tom Crosley: Yes. 

                      Dorothy Clay Sims: So you have to be careful. The other problem in a brain injury case is the plaintiff’s radiologists — unless they’re forensically retained, they are missing all kinds of stuff that I’m seeing when I open up the scan. So don’t rely on that if you have a brain injury case. 

                      [15:21] Tom Crosley: I Completely agree with you there. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve had a retained radiologist — somebody I hired to spend the time to do an overread — of preexisting scans that came back as normal. 

                      Dorothy Clay Sims: Exactly, and they can see the damage. 

                      Tom Crosley: That ought to be part of the playbook for every plaintiff lawyer handling these cases. 

                      [15:38] Dorothy Clay Sims: Well, the other thing is the right scan to ask for. If someone wants to email me — [email protected] — I have what you want to ask for. You want susceptibility-weighted imaging at two millimeters. You want everything else at one. The more slices, the more you’re gonna find the damage. If it’s five millimeters apart, you’re gonna miss half of it. 

                      So we talked about the myth that they’re fine at the emergency room. Well, they’re not. And how can you, as the lawyer, prove it? I’ve started asking all the lawyers that I work with: “Hey, I want you to ask your client to send you all text messages sent the day of the crash and the day after, and all emails.” And if you get those, you may very well find — about half the time we see this — stuff’s not making sense. They were clearly dazed, right? 

                      [16:29] Tom Crosley: So I know that when we have other people — family, friends, et cetera — with the plaintiff in the ER, that becomes powerful. But a lot of times we don’t, right? We just have the record. 

                      Dorothy Clay Sims: Right. [unclear] 

                      Tom Crosley: All right, so I started this sequence of questions by saying, “Hey, what are some of the common defense themes?” I’m gonna throw out some of mine. At some point I’d like to shift into what we do, in your opinion, to overcome them. 

                      So the ones I often see are: no objective findings on routine scans — normal imaging. Whatever the issue is must be psychological, or stress, or anxiety, or preexisting depression, or preexisting fill-in-the-blank, right? Inconsistent history — it’s not really the plaintiff’s fault that providers will write down historical information maybe differently, but, you know, they’ll get punished for if, God forbid, a record from Dr. A has a different history than a record from Dr. B. Secondary gain and exaggeration — almost always with defense neuropsychs, not always. And then sometimes we’ll see, with a biomechanical expert, the mechanism of injury was too minor to have caused this TBI. 

                      Those are the ones that I often see. I made a little list before I started. Do you think there are any other big-ticket items that we need to make sure are included in the list of common defenses? 

                      [17:54] Dorothy Clay Sims: Yeah, I think the claim that every mild traumatic brain injury gets better — we know that’s not true. And I think the one thing that I see the plaintiffs’ lawyers miss — and it’s not their fault, it’s the doctor’s fault — is there’s a lot more wrong with the client than you realize. Oftentimes these people have human growth hormone deficiencies and no one ever catches that, or they have a dysautonomia. I always tell the lawyers: make sure somebody measures your client’s heart rate and blood pressure lying down, sitting, and standing, because about a third of the time we’re finding dysautonomia, which means they can’t regulate their blood pressure. It can be fatal. It’s very serious. So we as lawyers need to do a deeper dive into the different kinds of things that a brain injury can cause. 

                      But as to the defenses you talked about — I wrote them down — let’s start with the normal brain scan. Well, here’s how this rolls: the brain scan’s normal except for the areas where it’s not. And what I’ve had defense experts do is write reports calling them normal, but in reality, they’re not describing what’s on the scan, and they’re avoiding it. 

                      For example, if your client has a lot of increased white matter, or little white dots on the MRI, that can be due to ischemic disease or trauma, depending on where it is. The defense expert will see those lesions and not describe them, and just pronounce it normal, because “everybody that age has those lesions.” Well, first of all, that’s not true. And second of all, if there’s a lot of lesions, that’s also not true. And third of all, if the lesions are at or near the gray-white junction, that’s trauma. And so they ignore all that literature and they plead ignorance. 

                      But the other thing that they’re doing — they’re so deceitful. I actually had to get a bite guard from my dentist when I found this out, because I was grinding my teeth so much. I had this case where the doctor writes this long report, and he shows all these images, and he says, “You can see clearly the above images are completely normal.” And this is what lawyers should look out for. Okay, well, wait a minute: what is the series and slice number on that image? I want to find the image in my scan. And that’s when I found out it was someone else’s brain. 

                      Tom Crosley: What? 

                      Dorothy Clay Sims: Yeah. And you know what? This has happened to me once a month in the last six months. Someone else’s brain. 

                      Tom Crosley: Wow. 

                      Dorothy Clay Sims: So the tip is: if there’s no series or slice number, you can’t find it on your own scan. And my subpoena, which I’m glad to share, says the radiologist, when they show up for deposition, shall be prepared to share their screen and show me where the images are — because they always say, “Oh, I don’t have the ability to do that.” Well, that’s ridiculous. So if you don’t see any identifying factor on the scan, then it may not be your client. But if you do see a partial identification, then it’s probably someone else. 

                      Plus, another game they play is, if the lesion’s up here, they’ll show you a slice down here. 

                      [21:07] Tom Crosley: Right.  

                      Dorothy Clay Sims: Or they can dial up the contrast and make it disappear. 

                      Tom Crosley: Yeah.  

                      Dorothy Clay Sims: I mean, there’s all kinds of little games that they play, right? 

                      Tom Crosley: I think you have to have your own radiologist to combat a radiologist. 

                      Dorothy Clay Sims: Yeah. And I always tell my own radiologist that I’m using, “You know, they may serve you a subpoena for your audit trail. You need to make sure you spend sufficient time on this.” And that’s helpful because it’s better for my client, independent of whether the defense asks for it or not. 

                      Yeah, in that particular field, there’s incredible fraud going on. 

                      [21:46] Tom Crosley: Okay, so how do you recommend lawyers build their case files so that the defense doctor can’t get away with this kind of stuff? 

                      [21:58] Dorothy Clay Sims: Well, it depends on the doctor, and it depends on the position that they’re taking. One of the things that’s important is to use artificial intelligence. You’ve got to start using it now. Although I just got a decision where a judge entered an order saying all of the prompts and the research used for the lawyer’s AI research were not protected by any kind of privilege. So it’s kind of a new area that we’re dealing with. 

                      But the reality is this: you can figure out a way to anonymize the medical records and feed them all in and say, “Tell me all the symptoms that could be caused by a brain injury.” You will find stuff in those medical records that you completely ignored — you know, certain blood abnormalities, oxygen saturation. There’s a goldmine of things. 

                      And that’s helpful because I create a before-and-after chart where I list as many as 150 new diagnoses and symptoms. And then I say: Pre-existed? No, no, no, no, no, no. Can trauma cause? Yes, yes, yes, yes, yes. Was it found after the crash? Yes, yes, yes. So I’ve got like 150 different new symptoms, all of which can be explained by the crash. So when they take the position that it’s all in your client’s head, you can show that’s not true. 

                      My client’s depression didn’t cause lesions in the brain, or atrophy of the brain, or an abnormal videonystagmogram, or saccades, or nystagmus. All you do is pick the objective findings and say, “Being sad doesn’t cause this, right?” It doesn’t cause a herniated disc, et cetera. It’s ridiculous. 

                      [23:32] Tom Crosley: So actually, that’s my favorite cross-examination strategy of a defense medical expert: to go through all the medical records of my client and identify everything that is consistent with the claimed injury. Make them — you know, basically make them teach it to the jury — that here it is in the records in black and white, and this is consistent with the injury. 

                      [23:57] Dorothy Clay Sims: Exactly, and then I attach the chart as an exhibit. But here’s another: usually it’s the neuropsychologist or psychologist that’s saying it’s all psychological, right? Oftentimes? 

                      Tom Crosley: Yes. 

                      Dorothy Clay Sims: So when that happens — I love it — I did a deposition yesterday of a neuropsychologist. “Your client has no brain damage.” Okay, did you read all the medical records? “Of course I did.” And here’s the key question: Did you understand them all? And there’s this long pause, and she says, “Of course not.” So, okay, that’s a problem. 

                      And if they say yes, all you do is go into the records and look at a chart, or look at some numbers on a videonystagmogram or EEG, and say, “What do these numbers mean?” They won’t know. And so they don’t know what’s in the medical records. And if you ask them, “Are you an expert on the anatomy of the brain? Because if so, I’m going to ask you questions,” they almost always say no. And so they should not be testifying as to the cause of a brain injury when they can’t interpret the brain scan. They didn’t even look at it, and they don’t understand the medical records. That is ridiculous. They should not have the ability to do that, right? 

                      For example, the Test of Memory Malingering: you look at 50 pictures. Well, if you give the pictures too quickly to the patient, they can’t remember them. The instructions say let the patient look at the images for 199 seconds. The defense expert cuts the time to 70 seconds. And when you say, “Wait a minute, you didn’t follow the manual, you did it too quickly. You caused them to fail this malingering test.” And they did it on purpose, I’m sure. And when we’ve caught them at this, the judges have said, “Why did you do this?” And their response is generally, “I don’t know.” Well, we know, right? 

                      Another thing that happens is they change our client’s answers. They’ll give the MMPI or a test like that, where you fill in a bubble sheet, and then the doctor later goes and inputs the answers in the computer to get an interpretive report. But they change the answers. And so when we get the raw data, we can just check to see if the bubble sheet matches the printout — and it doesn’t, right? I mean, that’s just so stupid. It’s unbelievable. And yet they’re using this to conclude malingering. 

                      In this case I was reviewing earlier for somebody, the doctor writes a report and says, “Oh, there was clear poor effort on an embedded measure.” And then I look at the tape, and what he did was he gave the Reliable Digit Span. You just repeat strings of numbers, right? And if you miss too many, you’re considered to have failed. Well, the doctor didn’t follow the instructions and read the numbers far too quickly. So again, he made my client fail. 

                      But, are any of these tests valid in the first place? No, I do not believe any of these validity tests are valid. The theory is, if you don’t remember the old item that you looked at, and instead you identify the new item, you’re faking. Does that make sense? 

                      Tom Crosley: Yeah, I mean, it doesn’t make sense to me, but I understand the argument that they use. 

                      Dorothy Clay Sims: Yep. Right. Here’s the problem with that: psychological research tells us that when you’re under stress, you have a divided memory, which means you can’t focus as well. If you’re under stress being evaluated by someone that you want to write a good report, that’s a splitting of your attention right there. And most of these malingering tests were not normed under those circumstances, right? So you can get less than chance, and it’d be completely arbitrary and not malingering. So yeah, I mean, that is infuriating, because they’re calling your client a liar, and these tests aren’t valid. 

                      [27:52] Tom Crosley: Dorothy, what do you do with the defense that the forces in the crash were not sufficient enough to cause the brain injury? 

                      [27:58] Dorothy Clay Sims: Okay. If that’s done by a biomech or a doctor, they don’t know the position of the patient’s body in space, typically, when the crash occurred. But more importantly, what we do know is that even in low-impact crashes — the research done by Michael Freeman, an epidemiologist, tells us that even in a very low-impact crash, the probability that the neck injury was caused by the crash versus preexisting arthritis is over one million to one in favor of the crash. Because people have preexisting conditions that can clearly be made worse by even a minor crash, and they should not be allowed to get that to the jury. 

                      [28:40] Tom Crosley: Let’s imagine that we’re talking to a lawyer who does not have a lot of experience in handling TBI cases, and they’re handling a TBI case — let’s call it a mild TBI case. The defense has now designated its experts: perhaps a neurologist, a neuropsychologist, maybe or maybe not a neuroradiologist. What should that lawyer be doing next? 

                      [29:06] Dorothy Clay Sims: All right, a couple things. First of all, make sure you videotape the exam, and make sure that the videographer does not mount the camera on a tripod, but that they’re visualizing the body part the whole time, so the doctor can’t block it. Then you need someone to look at that. It takes about three hours to go through that video and analyze everything they did wrong. 

                      Then you want to get the dirt on the experts. So first of all, email me, because I have stuff on 2,000 of them. I’m glad to share it. 

                      Tom Crosley: Yeah. 

                      Dorothy Clay Sims: You should also go out on your listserv and say, “Who’s had experience with this person?” and volunteer to share what you get. The third thing I do is I have my staff go on Lexis AI, and they put the expert’s name in, and they get all decisions nationally — because I’ve found expert witnesses are less likely to foul their own backyard, do something crazy in their own state, but they’ll take more chances in a different state. 

                      I also will write for the state file of the doctor. Those state files are golden. And if someone works at a university, you want to write for the university file. Then you want to combine it all and use AI to tell you — especially if it’s 10,000 pages — how many times were they limited, stricken, what ethical issues are there, what problems with their conclusions, and let AI analyze that for you. Then you want to get the video analyzed. You also want to get the raw data yourself, so you can see if it’s even in your client’s handwriting. 

                      [30:44] Tom Crosley: All right. I know that you take a lot of depositions. How often are you actually doing the defense witnesses in trial these days? 

                      [30:53] Dorothy Clay Sims: Not that often, because our goal — and our goal really is — to have the witness refuse to testify or have the defense pull him. Like, I was supposed to do a trial two weeks ago on the defense neuropsych, and after we took his deposition, they pulled him. And that’s my goal. So it’s extremely rare. But if we do a really good deposition, then the cross at trial is very easy. You just stay within the four corners of the deposition and make them admit to all of their misdeeds. 

                      [31:27] Tom Crosley: My favorite crosses are short, punchy, in and out — like sticking them with a stiletto in the belly. Forty-five minutes, my five strongest points, that kind of thing. How would you structure that kind of cross, say, of a defense neuropsych? 

                      [31:47] Dorothy Clay Sims: I would do it two ways. One way is, if they really screwed up, you pick the top five things, and you don’t just talk to them verbally — you have a chart, because jurors are not listening. But if they see that chart, even if they can’t read the words, they see check mark, check mark, check mark. And now I’m starting to do the charts in the middle of the deposition and attaching them as an exhibit. 

                      That chart is a cross-examination: You don’t have a degree in it. You don’t have a license in neuropsychology. You don’t have a doctor-patient relationship. You misrepresented the scores. You don’t want them to give you any concessions, because you’re wasting your time — it makes them look legitimate when you do that. You want to show the jury how bad they are. Just go right for the jugular — unless they don’t answer questions directly. 

                      And I had a trial where we got an excess verdict, and I thought it was because of my brilliant cross-examination. And when we polled the jury later, they said, “Well, we didn’t understand what that blonde lady was saying, but we knew one thing: that doctor wasn’t answering her.” And I thought, well, shit, that’s all. All you’ve got to do is let them continue to not answer the question. 

                      Tom Crosley: Right. 

                      Dorothy Clay Sims: I mean, the reality — and I don’t know if lawyers know this — is that jurors make their decision not on what they hear, but on what they see. And if you played that deposition with the sound off, they would get it much quicker. They’re watching the witness. That’s what’s going to result in a favorable verdict: how they behave. 

                      [33:16] Tom Crosley: Yeah. I love summary exhibits in cross-exam, because that’s what a jury will remember. 

                      Dorothy Clay Sims: Exactly. 

                      [33:24] Tom Crosley: Dorothy, if there were just three things that we lawyers took away from today’s interview that would help us better handle TBI cases, what would they be? 

                      [33:35] Dorothy Clay Sims: I think number one: do your due diligence on the doctor’s background. Invariably, they have testified to the exact opposite of what they’re saying in your case. You just have to find that deposition. Invariably, they may have gotten in trouble in various states and left, and you need to find that. Do your due diligence on their background. 

                      And number two: presume everything they’re saying is a lie and make them prove it. When they make a statement, ask them where the science is that supports it. Because the reality is, there isn’t any science that supports their position, but there is one hell of a lot of science that supports yours. And these people, with the right judge and the right set of facts, should not be allowed to testify. So never underestimate the willingness of some of these experts to simply lie. 

                      And the third thing is: timing is important. Take a long time for your deposition. It’s expensive, but that is what settles these cases. If you do a good enough job, you’ll never have to try the case. But if you do have to try the case, you’ve got your roadmap right there, because you’ve done an in-depth analysis. You’ve taken the time, you know what their opinions are, there will be no surprises, and you’ll be ready. 

                      [34:56] Tom Crosley: Well, this has been super helpful. I appreciate you taking the time to share with those of us interested in TBI cases your exceptional knowledge that you’ve gained over the last three or four decades of devoting yourself to taking down deceptive defense doctors. 

                      [35:11] Dorothy Clay Sims: Well, thank you, Tom. It was a pleasure. 

                      [35:15] Tom Crosley: Thank you for joining us on this episode of Winning the TBI Case with Dorothy Clay Sims, to help us learn how to better expose deceptive defense doctors in TBI cases. I’m Tom Crosley.  

                      Announcer: If today’s episode helps you see your current case in a new light, share it with a colleague who’s facing the same challenges in a case. Subscribe wherever you get your podcasts, and join our community of trial lawyers who refuse to settle for average results. This has been Winning the TBI Case: strategy, science, and storytelling, with Tom Crosley. 

                      36 min
                    • Defusing GCS in a Mild TBI Case

                      “GCS is not looking at long-term outcomes. It’s looking at that little slice in time right after the injury happened in the acute phase.” – Tom Crosley

                      Welcome to Winning The TBI Case, hosted by trial lawyer Tom Crosley. Listen as Tom provides practical, powerful guidance for litigating traumatic brain injury cases. This podcast is meant for litigation attorneys who are ready to explore the essentials of TBI cases to confidently represent clients who have suffered traumatic brain injuries.

                      What’s In This Episode:

                      Tom Crosley explains how the Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS) gets weaponized by defense attorneys in mild TBI cases. He breaks down what GCS actually measures, why it was created, and how to defuse defense arguments that use normal GCS scores to discredit legitimate brain injury cases.
                      Defusing the Defense Weapon

                      This is for trial lawyers who need to understand why a normal GCS score doesn’t mean their client wasn’t injured. Tom reveals how defense attorneys take one number from acute medical records and use it to undermine entire cases. He explains the historical context of GCS which was created in 1974 as a bedside tool designed for neurosurgeons to assess coma depth and decide on emergency surgery, not to predict long-term outcomes.

                      GCS measures three basic functions:

                      • Eye opening
                      • Verbal response
                      • Motor commands
                      • All tests that any elementary school student or family dog could pass. Tom provides the analogies and cross-examination techniques to expose how this acute triage tool has zero relevance to how patients function years later in life. By understanding what GCS actually measures (and what it doesn’t), you have the power to educate juries and neutralize one of the defense’s favorite, and often misleading, arguments.

                        Connect

                        • Subscribe to Winning The TBI Case on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube or wherever you get your podcasts. 
                        • Follow on Facebook, LinkedIn, and Instagram
                        • And remember, don’t just listen to the strategies, implement them!
                        • Winning the TBI Case — Episode 21: Defusing GCS in a Mild TBI Case

                          Crosley Law | Aired: May 27, 2026 | Runtime: 20:24 | Speakers: Narrator, Tom Crosley

                          [0:00] Tom Crosley: A GCS is not looking at long-term outcomes. It’s looking at that little slice in time right after the injury happened in the acute phase.

                          [0:09] Narrator: TBI cases can feel like navigating uncharted territory. Your client’s injury is real, but proving it, that’s where the real challenge begins. If you’ve ever felt like you’re missing crucial pieces of the puzzle, you’re in the right place. Welcome to Winning the TBI Case, where Tom Crosley shares the insights he’s gained from over 60 injury trials. Not just the victories, but the lessons learned along the way that make all the difference. Winning the TBI Case: Strategy, Science, and Storytelling.

                          [0:45] Tom Crosley: Welcome back to Winning the TBI Case: Strategy, Science, and Storytelling. I’m Tom Crosley. Today I want to talk about the Glasgow Coma Scale, or GCS, and why it gets misused in mild traumatic brain injury cases. Here’s how this usually shows up in litigation. The defense will point to a normal GCS score in the EMS record or the ER record and say, therefore, ladies and gentlemen of the jury, this was not a significant head injury. There’s no good explanation for the symptoms that allegedly persisted because look, we have this normal GCS score on the day of. And so that’s the defense move. They take one number from the acute medical records and they try to use it to discredit the entire case. If nobody explains what the GCS actually measures, what it was designed for, then that defense argument can sound stronger than it really is. Jurors might hear normal neurological score and assume it means the brain was fine. But that is not what the Glasgow Coma Scale was designed to measure. So let’s talk about a little historical context. It was first introduced in 1974 in Glasgow, Scotland by two neurosurgeons.

                          [2:01] Tom Crosley: They were really looking for a common language for doctors to use as a bedside tool that would help them communicate about a patient’s level of consciousness after acute brain injury. And in particular, when it would become important to call a neurosurgeon. Because maybe the neurosurgeon might have to do some life-saving surgery. That was the original mission. How awake is this person? How responsive are they to simple commands? And are they getting better or worse? So that matters because it tells you the lane that this GCS tool was originally built for. Acute assessment in the minutes or hours following the injury. Bedside communication. Triage. Later, researchers began using GCS scores to correlate severity grading and long-term patient outcomes because GCS became very popular. It’s used worldwide. It’s been cited 37,000 times in the medical literature. So it’s definitely the most common neurological assessment tool in the acute phase. So you’re going to see it in your medical records. You’re going to see it in your cases. So with all that data, researchers who study long-term outcomes for TBI, ranging from severe to moderate to mild, will often look back at what was that early GCS score.

                          [3:22] Tom Crosley: And we learn in the mild category that long-term outcomes are not predicted by GCS score. We learn with moderate and severe injuries, long-term poor outcomes are more predictive based on GCS score. So let’s talk about the name itself because the name matters. If we’re teaching it to a jury, it is the Glasgow Coma Scale. Coma. It’s not the Glasgow Executive Function Scale. It’s not the Glasgow Working Memory Scale. It’s the Coma Scale. It is fundamentally a scale of responsiveness and depth of impaired consciousness. The lower the score a person has, then the more deep their coma. It’s measuring three domains. Eye response. Are the person’s eyes open spontaneously or are they closed? Are they out? And now if they are out, do they open in response to a verbal command? If not, do they open when we give them some noxious stimuli? For example, we rub their sternum. Does that make their eyes open? These are testing levels of depth of coma. Verbal response is the second of the three things they’re looking at. Are they oriented normally? Do they know where, in broad strokes, where they are, what year this is, what city they are in?

                          [4:44] Tom Crosley: Literally, those are the types of questions. Or are they unable to make any sounds because they’re out of it, they’re in a coma? Or are the sounds they’re making guttural and incomprehensible? That’s kind of what they’re looking for on the verbal side. When I see an abnormal GCS in a mild case where they lose a point or two points, it’s almost always on the verbal side. And it’s because the patient is confused. They’re not completely oriented. They might be asking the same question over and over again and not really responding to the examiner’s very basic questions. The third thing that GCS is looking at, remember number one, eyes, number two, verbal, number three is motor response. Can the person obey simple commands? So all the way from no motor response whatsoever, out completely cold, to extension or flexion in response to painful stimuli or trying to withdraw from pain. Again, that sternum rub can be useful there. Or can the person obey simple commands? So I’m typically seeing in the mild case four out of four for eye response, six out of six for motor response, and usually five out of five for a total score of 15 for the verbal response.

                          [6:01] Tom Crosley: Sometimes I’m seeing a four out of five on the verbal response because the person is clearly confused at the scene and keeps repeating themselves. All right. So what is that telling us? When I teach it in CLE, I will often put up a slide showing a doctor talking to a patient on an exam table. And that patient’s sitting there and he’s got his eyes open and the doctor’s holding a clipboard and a stethoscope around his neck wearing a white coat. And I’ll say, “This is what a normal GCS looks like.” And while that slide’s still up, I’ll tell the audience something like this. I’ll say, “You know, I don’t care how much I’m boring you right now. I could be the most boring speaker you’ve ever heard in your entire life. You could be on the verge of falling asleep, but if your eyes are still open, if you’re sitting in this room listening to me, you have a normal GCS.” And then I’ll say, “Do you know what else has a normal GCS?” And then I’ll advance the slide and it’ll be a picture of my dog, a chocolate lab. And that’s the part that gets the laugh. And it works because this point kind of hits home. My dog, his eyes opened spontaneously.

                          [7:16] Tom Crosley: Remember the eyes were category one. The second was verbal response, but it’s really testing is the patient oriented to time, place, and person. And so my dog knows where his food bowl is. He knows where his bed is. He can bark on command. So he’s kind of passing that one too. And then motor response. He can sit. He can shake hands. He can roll over. My dog can pass that one too. So how high is the bar to get a normal GCS? That’s my point. And that’s why this joke kind of hits home. I even got to do it once in a trial. I had a well-known and sneaky defense expert on the stand in trial in Houston. And he was harping on the normal GCS on day one for my patient. And here we are three years later and he’s trying to say this normal GCS somehow means that this patient should be well by now. And so I showed the slide, got the doctor to admit, “Yep, that’s a normal GCS.” Got him to admit that everybody in the courtroom, all the people on the jury, the people in the gallery, those were all normal GCS. And then I said– And we’re about to break for lunch, and so the timing was important here. And then I said, “Doctor, you know what else is a normal GCS?” And then I showed the picture of my dog.

                          [8:35] Tom Crosley: And I said, “That’s my dog. He’s got a normal GCS too.” The jury starts laughing because they’ve immediately kind of clicked how this early acute triage tool that’s just measuring coma is not that relevant in the big picture for the mild TBI case. And the doctor’s response, I still remember it vividly. He said, “Yes,” over the jury’s laughter. “Yes, but he’s not verbal.” And then the judge said, “I think now would be a good time to break for lunch.” So the timing of that worked out well. That is how I’m defusing GCS when the defense wants to make a big deal out of it. I just make it the very low bar that it really is. And if you think about it, any elementary school student can get a normal GCS, but that doesn’t mean if you take Einstein’s brain and damage it, and now in the days, minutes, or hours following the injury, he can only respond as well as an elementary school student. That doesn’t mean he’s normal, does it? So lawsuits, when we try them to juries, we communicate very effectively sometimes with analogies. So use my dog analogy or use this elementary school analogy. A GCS is not looking at long-term outcomes. It’s looking at that little slice in time right after the injury happened in the acute phase.

                          [9:55] Tom Crosley: So let’s now talk about what does a fifteen on GCS really mean. It means the eyes open spontaneously. The person can give a verbal response. They can obey simple commands, touch your nose. It means the person is oriented as to time and place and person. Who are you? What is your name? Where are you? What city are you in? What month and year is it? Those are the very basic kind of questions that they’re being asked. It’s not a subtle evaluation of high brain function. It’s not a test of working memory, of processing speed, executive function, headache, mental fatigue. It’s not testing multitasking. It’s not testing whether they can tolerate noise or light, or handle their emotions, or it’s– it certainly doesn’t test whether they function in the real world the way they used to before their injury. It’s a very blunt but useful tool in the acute setting. Doctors will mostly agree it has very little post-acute value. What do I mean by that? After those days, minutes, or hours, it doesn’t matter that much what their GCS used to be. That’s the point. So I wouldn’t say GCS means nothing. It is certainly in the more severe cases, GCS can be correlated with long-term poor outcomes.

                          [11:15] Tom Crosley: And it certainly has real clinical value in the early stages. It’s important. I understand why they collect that data. I just don’t think you can fairly use that data in a mild TBI case a year, two years, or three years later to say anything about how the patient must not have been hurt. All right. So here is my key point for lawyers handling mild TBI cases. A GCS score tells you very little about the individual patient sitting in your courtroom years later. The defense likes to take a number recorded in the first minutes or hours after trauma, and they like to try to use it as though it somehow meaningfully answers what’s happening three years later. It does not. A normal GCS may tell us something narrow and useful about the acute moment. It may tell us whether the patient was awake enough to answer basic questions. It really is there to help the doctors decide, “Hey, do we need to call the neurosurgeon? Do we need to call him now? Do we need to wake him up in the middle of the night? Do we need him to jump in his Porsche and race down to the hospital to do a life-saving brain surgery?” That’s really what it’s trying to do in the triage setting. So think about how that’s different than what a jury is deciding in our cases.

                          [12:31] Tom Crosley: When we’re in trial a few years later in a mild TBI case, the real questions are completely different. Can this person still process information the way they used to? Can they still work the same way? Can they still tolerate noise, chaos, multitasking? Can they regulate their emotions, or do they fly off the handle? Can they remember what they just read, what they were just told? Do they lose their train of thought? Can they function effectively in work, in family life, in daily life the way they used to? GCS does not and never will answer those questions, and that’s why the defense use of it in mild TBI cases is often so misleading. Many patients with a mild TBI present with a GCS of fifteen. That’s pretty typical. It’s built into that category. We all know from experience and from the literature that a patient can look fairly normal in the ER and still have symptoms and deficits that persist days, weeks, months, or even years, and that’s why the defense can’t take a fifteen from the ER and act like it disproves the case years later. Here is another useful point that I will often make if my client has depression, and I’m often teaching this sometimes to my own experts or the treating physicians and then having them testify to it during the trial.

                          [13:52] Tom Crosley: Some of the long-term things we care about most in these cases do not track neatly with initial GCS scores. Take depression, for example. It would be a mistake to assume that if the, you know, the worse the GCS score, then therefore the worse the depression would later be. There’s lots of studies on this that show that depression post TBI tracks about the same whether it was mild, moderate, or severe TBI. In other words, GCS is completely irrelevant to the question of whether a post TBI victim is likely to have depression. So… and then that’s true with other symptoms as well, especially when you’re talking about the mild class. All right. How would I handle GCS in litigation? Well, if I thought the defense was going to hang their hat on a normal GCS score as a core point that they were going to make in defending the case, then I would jump out in front of it. I would teach GCS early. I would not wait for the defense to turn it into some kind of punchline. Rather, my own expert or treating physician in plain English would talk about what the scale is and what it does and does not do, and I would make the low bar for that scale memorable, my dog example, the elementary student example compared to Einstein, and I would pin any defense expert down on the limits of the scale.

                          [15:13] Tom Crosley: So examples of questions I might ask a defense expert if they are relying on GCS normal scores in the acute setting to somehow prove the defense. I would probably start with asking them what the GCS really is. It’s measuring consciousness, correct? It’s evaluating eye opening, verbal response, and motor response, correct? A fifteen simply means the patient can open his eyes, answer simple questions, obey simple commands. Correct, Doctor? The orientation questions are very basic things, aren’t they, Doctor? Like what is your name? Where are you right now? What city are you in? What is the month and year? And Doctor, you would agree that this test does not test executive function, working memory, processing speed, or any of those items? And then here’s the kicker. Doctor, you would agree a patient can have a GCS of fifteen and still suffer a mild traumatic brain injury with long-term, even lifelong consequences, correct? If they’re being honest, they have to answer correct ’cause there’s no debate in the medical literature on the answer to that question. I might go into the fact that the score was taken in the acute setting. It doesn’t tell us anything by itself about how the patient will do three months later or three years later.

                          [16:30] Tom Crosley: And so ultimately where I’m heading with this is the GCS is not answering the question of is the patient brain damaged? Do they have a mild TBI? The GCS is answering a completely different question. It’s telling us something important about acute responsiveness in the minutes or hours following the head injury. It’s helping doctors decide how worried they need to be right now in terms of the treatment we need to provide this patient right now. It doesn’t tell you whether the plaintiff will likely get back to normal. So where does the real case, especially in a mild TBI case, live? We prove the mechanism of injury. We prove the symptoms, confusion, disorientation, amnesia, dizziness, headache, nausea, sensory sensitivity, altered mental status. We prove those things, none of which have anything to do with GCS in the long-term setting. What did the witnesses see? What changed in the patient? What do the treating doctors say? What do the experts say? What does the imaging show? None of those are really tied to GCS in our mild TBI case. We’re really looking at how is the plaintiff functioning now as compared to before, the study in contrast that I’ve talked about on prior episodes. We’re not talking about whether an injured person in the ER could open his eyes and say what city he was in.

                          [17:50] Tom Crosley: So those are my final takeaways. Number one, GCS was developed as a bedside tool for assessing impaired consciousness or coma following acute brain injury. Number two, it is fundamentally a scale of coma depth, not a test for TBI. Number three, orientation questions are very basic. Any elementary school student could pass them, and even my dog could pass them. Fourth, it has good value in managing acute trauma patients for more severe injuries and also for correlating long-term outcomes for those more severe injuries. Fifth, a normal GCS doesn’t rule out real injury in the mild TBI case, and it certainly does not mean much by itself even if the defense is trying to use it years later at trial to suggest otherwise. Sixth, some important long-term consequences, such as depression, do not map neatly onto the initial GCS score. The initial GCS score doesn’t have any bearing on a patient’s likelihood to develop a lot of the symptoms that are commonly associated with TBI. So the last point I wanna leave you with is a normal GCS is a very low bar that isn’t used in the real world in treating patients for anything outside the first 24, max 72 hours.

                          [19:18] Tom Crosley: So where your case lives is now two years or three years later. It has very little to do in the mild TBI case with what their initial GCS was, and that’s why it’s important for us to teach our juries that the very basic GCS is something that any child could do and has no relevance to what the myriad symptoms your TBI client continues to live with following their injury. That’s it for this episode. This has been Winning the TBI Case: Strategy, Science, and Storytelling. I’m Tom Crosley.

                          [19:56] Narrator: If today’s episode helped you see your current case in a new light, share it with a colleague who’s facing the same challenges in a case. Subscribe wherever you get your podcasts and join our community of trial lawyers who refuse to settle for average results. This has been Winning the TBI Case: Strategy, Science, and Storytelling with Tom Crosley.

                          21 min
                        • A Radiologist’s Approach to TBI Case Evaluation – Dr. David Levey

                          “What I’m looking for is: What is the correct diagnosis? What happened to this patient? Is he or she being treated correctly or properly? And that’s a concern of mine.” – Dr. David Levey

                          Welcome to Winning The TBI Case, hosted by trial lawyer Tom Crosley. Listen as Tom provides practical, powerful guidance for litigating traumatic brain injury cases. This podcast is meant for litigation attorneys who are ready to explore the essentials of TBI cases to confidently represent clients who have suffered traumatic brain injuries.

                          Tom is joined by Dr. David Levey, a diagnostic radiologist and forensic neuroradiology expert who evaluates traumatic brain injury cases for both plaintiffs and the defense. Dr. Levey walks through the detailed process radiologists use to evaluate imaging, medical records, symptoms, and clinical history when analyzing TBI cases in both medical and litigation settings.

                          What’s In This Episode

                          Dr. David Levey explains how radiologists evaluate traumatic brain injury cases and how imaging findings fit within the broader clinical and litigation picture. He also shares practical insight into the role imaging plays in TBI litigation and best practices for trial lawyers working with radiology experts.

                          Key Insights for Trial Lawyers

                          • Radiologists Evaluate More Than Images: Forensic radiology involves an extensive analysis of imaging combined with medical records, symptoms, clinical history, and causation evidence in context.
                          • “Normal” Scans and Imaging Do Not Rule Out TBI: There are times when traumatic brain injuries will not appear on routine CT imaging. MRI studies can reveal subtle abnormalities not visible on CT scans. Advanced imaging such as DTI, tractography, and volumetric imaging can provide additional detail and should always be considered alongside symptoms, testing, and functional changes.
                          • Effective TBI Litigation Requires Collaboration: Radiologists often work closely with attorneys and other experts to help evaluate complex brain injury cases.
                          • Dr. Levey pulls back the curtain on the detailed analytical process radiologists use to evaluate brain injury cases in both medical and forensic settings and shares how he works with both plaintiff and defense teams.

                            Preparation Matters

                            This episode is for trial lawyers who want a clearer understanding of how radiologists evaluate traumatic brain injury cases and how imaging evidence fits into litigation strategy. If you’ve ever struggled with “normal imaging” defenses or wanted insight into how to best leverage your radiology experts in TBI cases, then you’ve come to the right place.

                            Referenced and Mentioned

                            Dr. Levey and Tom reference tractography imaging beginning at time code 22:49 which can be seen on the video version of the podcast. Screenshots below for our audio listeners.

                            Connect

                            • Connect directly with Dr. David Levey by visiting: www.expertradiologist.org
                            • Subscribe to Winning The TBI Case on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube or wherever you get your podcasts. 
                            • Follow on Facebook, LinkedIn, and Instagram
                            • And remember, don’t just listen to the strategies, implement them!
                            • Winning the TBI Case — A Radiologist’s Approach to TBI Case Evaluation 

                              Host: Tom Crosley Guest: Dr. David Levey Runtime: 37:08 

                              [00:00] Dr. David Levey (cold open): Follow-up MRIs can be valuable, particularly in two cases. One, if you have found nothing abnormal on imaging structurally, right? Yet the patient is so abnormal. The family doesn’t recognize them anymore. Work’s not going well. The tasks they used to do, they can’t do them anymore. Well, you know something’s wrong. 

                              [00:20] Announcer: TBI cases can feel like navigating uncharted territory. Your client’s injury is real, but proving it — that’s where the real challenge begins. If you’ve ever felt like you’re missing crucial pieces of the puzzle, you’re in the right place. Welcome to Winning the TBI Case, where Tom Crosley shares the insights he’s gained from over 60 injury trials. Not just the victories, but the lessons learned along the way that make all the difference. Winning the TBI Case: strategy, science, and storytelling. 

                              [00:55] Tom Crosley: Welcome back to Winning the TBI Case. I’m Tom Crosley, and today we’re gonna have an exciting episode. We’re gonna be talking about one of the most misunderstood areas in traumatic brain injury litigation, and that is brain imaging. Our guest today is Dr. David Levey, a diagnostic radiologist with a clinical practice reading brains and spines, and he also happens to serve as an expert witness from time to time in legal cases. About half of his work is on the defense side; about half is on the plaintiff side. So he’s one of those expert witnesses who is exactly what we want: science first, advocacy second. Somebody who does both sides and calls the balls and strikes like he sees them. 

                              I wanted to start with a little bit about you and your background. What led you to go to medical school? How did you pick radiology as your specialty? Kind of bring us current to modern times. 

                              [01:59] Dr. David Levey: Well, when I was 11, I read a book called The Defense Never Rests, and that was it. I was going to be a lawyer. And in the next few years, that evolved. I went to college, got two different bachelor’s degrees, really heading towards the neurosciences, and a master’s degree at UCLA before medical school. Then after medical school: internship, a trauma internship, four years of radiology at USC, and a fellowship. After 17 years coming out of the machine, I finally got my first job doing just that — neuroradiology, musculoskeletal imaging — here in Texas. That was the first job, and here I am. 

                              [02:45] Tom Crosley: Tell us about how forensic neuroradiology — for example, in a brain injury case — differs from day-to-day clinical neuroradiology. 

                              [02:53] Dr. David Levey: It’s extraordinary, the difference. I didn’t know about it until I started this 15 years ago. If you’re reading an MRI of the brain as a radiologist, you get the case; the case comes up. You get some clinical data. You may get some clinical information faxed to you. Some of it’s sketchy, some of it’s from the patient. You may get some nursing notes, from the PA or the doctor, but it’s variable. If you get 10 pages of notes, you’re really doing great. If you get a page or two, that’s acceptable too. Many of the diagnoses are fairly complete, and others may have “headache” or “head pain” or “trauma” — no date, no description, no time. You don’t have any idea. 

                              So you are absolutely starting from the beginning and working your way through the brain MRI and trying to get that diagnosis. So you’re looking for everything under the sun. You can’t focus on trauma or anything. And that takes you X amount of time. You know, a brain MRI may take two minutes or two hours. I’ve had one take two days — spent two days on it, getting through it, it was so complicated. But it’s a finite experience. 

                              But forensic radiology — you get reams of medical records and a number of opinions from everywhere. From the police report at the scene of the accident, all the way through the ER and the ICU and the consultants and surgery or not. Then the patient finally is released from the hospital and has all these follow-up appointments with many other experienced, seasoned experts: pain people, clinical psychology people, PM&R, et cetera. And the vast amount of information I can use to put a story together is what I think attracted me at first to this field. All the imaging available plus all the medical records together allows me to tell a story — not only with the radiology and the imaging, but the medical process and the path the patient took as well. 

                              [04:57] Tom Crosley: Some radiologists that serve as expert witnesses don’t like to look at medical records. They just want to look at the imaging and dictate a report based on what they see. But it sounds like you like to look at the whole picture, including medical records. Why is that? 

                              [05:10] Dr. David Levey: I think it’s important. I do like it, you’re right. But I also think it’s important. I think you’re missing something if you’re not doing that, because, first of all, from the correct diagnosis flows the correct treatment. I want to get involved with any patient — it doesn’t matter, defense, plaintiff, or whatever the situation is. What I’m looking for is: What is the correct diagnosis? What happened to this patient? And is he or she being treated correctly or properly? And that’s a concern of mine. 

                              Because I see that if the radiologist who read the primary studies got it wrong, the whole crowd — medical, surgical, everybody — they’re following down the wrong pathway. And that’s the classic GIGO I see all the time: garbage in, garbage out. You get the wrong diagnosis, and there’s surgery in the wrong place, or no surgery where he needs it, or treatment that is inappropriate because the diagnosis was not made correctly in the beginning. So medical records really help with that. You hardly ever get that when you just get a case, read it, get a case, read it, like in a radiology practice. 

                              [06:15] Tom Crosley: It sounded like your explanation of the difference between clinical radiology and forensic radiology was that sometimes, clinically, you might only spend a few minutes reading a brain scan, but if it’s forensic — meaning it’s going to be used in a court case — then you’re going to spend probably a lot more time. Is that what I’m hearing? 

                              [06:35] Dr. David Levey: I do, and I see them over and over again, because it may take weeks to get the consultative report out. But then if you have a deposition, or are called upon in this case for any other reason, it takes weeks, maybe months, that you’re going over and over these things. I currently have a case that’s in its sixth year. 

                              [06:55] Tom Crosley: Let’s take a step back, Dr. Levey, and have you tell us what radiologists typically do in evaluating brain injury. And I’m not talking about experts; I’m talking about clinical radiologists. What’s their role? 

                              [07:07] Dr. David Levey: You get the scan — you pull it up on your reading station. You have a dictaphone, one you might use such as this one; if you’re on YouTube, you can see my dictaphone. We live and die by it. And you evaluate the case as you go through hundreds of images. 

                              Now, they’re set up in a reading situation where they’re called sequences, and you’ll do different sequences that weight the brain tissue in different ways. And so you can look at them, if you would, from different angles. If you’re doing a CT scan, it’s very simple. Usually it’s axial images. It’s an X-ray study, and it’s black and white. You kind of zip right through the head axially. But now we can reconstruct these in other planes and see a lot more than we used to. So CT is valuable in the acute setting especially. 

                              But then MRI can have hundreds, and in some cases thousands, of images, and we’re no longer looking at pixels. This is one big thing that has changed. It was pixel imaging for decades in radiology. Like X and Y, a box. And these boxes had images, and these images allowed you to look at the brain. But today we’re looking at voxels — a volume pixel. So you have an X, a Y, and a Z: a width, a height, and a depth in these studies. So now we have contiguous imaging, and we don’t miss a thing. We’re right on top and overlapping as you come through the brain parenchyma itself. 

                              And in doing so, you get the base of the brain, you get the orbits, you get the sinuses, the inner ear, the cerebellum, the supratentorial compartment. It’s a fallacy that you’re just looking at the brain only. You look at everything that’s in the field of view. You’re responsible for that. As a diagnostic radiologist, to answer your question, you get that study, you bang through those images, you make your report, you make sure you don’t miss anything, and you’re on to the next one. 

                              [09:10] Tom Crosley: In a clinical setting, what is the typical amount of time that a radiologist will look at a brain scan? 

                              Dr. David Levey: It’s minutes. It’s not hours, that’s for sure. 

                              Tom Crosley: And if it’s minutes in a clinical setting — because of the volume of the practice and the fact that they’ve got to read 50 or 60 or more scans a day — what is the amount of time that you typically spend reading that same MRI scan if it’s a litigation case and you’ve been retained as an expert for the defense or the plaintiff? 

                              [09:37] Dr. David Levey: First off, it has to be a little longer, because I have someone else’s report and I have the images. So I’m going to go through the images, and I’m going to be looking to see what the primary radiologist — I call them the primary radiologist; you can call it the treating radiologist — what they said about the study and what they didn’t. Whatever’s on the image, you must report. We are not of a standing where we can pick and choose. If it’s an abnormality or a finding and it’s on the scan, you need to report it. And I see a lot of things being left out or misinterpreted. 

                              So my first way through is to see what the radiologist said. The next one is to compare it to any of the other prior examinations. And this is very special in my practice: I have a bird’s-eye view into all the other prior scans that many times the radiologists do not. I amass them, right? We download them; we get everything ready. Whereas that radiologist may have one study — reads that study, and he’s on to the next one. He doesn’t have the advantage of having prior studies. And it is so, so nice. So I have an unfair advantage, and now I can see multiple years, sometimes, of brain scans and then see the current one. That’s important. 

                              So yes, it takes longer, because there’s more material there, and I’m kind of doing my due diligence and a little bit of detective work as well to make sure that all the details have been seen. 

                              [11:01] Tom Crosley: Dr. Levey, in my litigation practice over the last few decades, I’ve had cases — certainly very commonly — where there’s a CT scan done in the ER. Very commonly, it’s read as normal unless there was a fracture or bleeding. Does a normal CT scan rule out a brain injury? 

                              Dr. David Levey: It does not. 

                              Tom Crosley: And is that something that every radiologist in the country should agree upon, or is that up for debate? 

                              [11:24] Dr. David Levey: I think it’s really not up for debate. And it doesn’t matter what side you’re on, or even what specialty you are. I mean, if you look at a brain CT and you don’t see an abnormality, you know that there can be something there. And so many of the ones that are read as “no acute process” — you see these, “no specific abnormality” — those are all true statements, but that doesn’t mean there isn’t something present that’s not available to be visualized on the CT scan. 

                              [11:56] Tom Crosley: When a patient comes in with a suspected head injury and a CT is run on them in the ER, is the main thing they’re looking for fracture or bleeding? 

                              [12:06] Dr. David Levey: Those are the two main things they’re looking for as well. You can also have post-traumatic stroke. You can have edema in the brain — so no blood at all, but a real good contusion can give you edema, and that edema should show up quite rapidly and be seen on a CT. But you’re right: fractures and blood are the number one and number two things, because they’re seen so well. They’re radiodense, and they’re gonna be seen as white on your image. 

                              [12:36] Tom Crosley: What I typically see with MRIs is, if a patient is still symptomatic and weeks have passed by, then an MRI scan is ordered. And often in our mild cases, that one will come back as normal. But is that also just a structural test? It’s looking at the structure of the brain and not the function of the brain? 

                              [12:55] Dr. David Levey: It certainly does look at the structure, but the one thing that it has over CT, or much of the other neuro testing you can do, is that we have structural resolution and contrast resolution. Those are the two big things. MRI can look at the contrast between bone and fluid, fluid and fat, cortex and white matter, white matter and ventricles — all the different things. Vessels: flow and no flow. 

                              It’s structural for sure, but it isn’t as good as CT. It will never be as clear as a CT in terms of anatomical, but it’s okay, because it has gotten so good now. But it also has contrast resolution, which is the most valuable thing that an MRI can provide. And because that relates to blood flow as well — tissue viability, or the absence of viable tissue, and tissues that can be injured; blood that’s old, subacute, or acute — all those things can be seen on the MRI. So it’s just a more versatile test than the CT scan. 

                              [13:55] Tom Crosley: In a plaintiff case, if you are retained early enough to where you can make suggestions about what type of imaging plaintiffs should receive, what suggestions do you typically make? 

                              [14:04] Dr. David Levey: If it’s a trauma case, I typically do not need contrast — that’s IV contrast material injected at the time of the examination. So: a non-contrast 3T MRI of the brain. And I have a specific protocol that covers all kinds of disease processes — both the ones we’re looking for that are trauma-related and totally non-trauma-related — because you have to examine the patient’s brain in totality. You get surprised sometimes by what may pop up. 

                              Would I add a DTI to that? Well, you can’t lose in doing that. And what I mean by that is, the patient’s in the magnet, they’re on the scanner, the tech is doing the study, they’re almost done. All they have to add is three or four more sequences. So if the patient can lie still for another 10 to 20 minutes, depending, and you can acquire this data, then I would say do that as well. 

                              And I would say to do that because, thus far in my practice, I never stop with a DTI — get that study, look at it, report it out, and go. I always take the raw images and send them off to be evaluated for quantitative evaluation. You get this one-two punch, and now you have a ton of data on one brain, on one person. And you may or may not need it, but you certainly have it at your disposal to evaluate. 

                              [15:24] Tom Crosley: And is there a separate sequence that’s run for susceptibility-weighted imaging, or SWI? 

                              [15:29] Dr. David Levey: If we’re saying we’re going to do a DTI, then I’d need to be more specific. I’d package it like this: I want a 3T MRI of the brain, non-contrast, with all the typical protocols utilized, and also those that look for trauma-related things, like an SWI or a GRE. I want the planes that I need, and I also add a number of sequences on the back end for DTI. That in and of itself would be one study that could be very useful, because you could then ship the DTI and brain examination off for quantitative study. So what I like to say is what we’ve done here: we’ve done a 3T non-contrast brain, and we’ve done qualitative evaluation of the brain imaging, and quantitative. 

                              [16:23] Tom Crosley: Is it difficult to get patients access to 3T scanners for brain scans? 

                              [16:27] Dr. David Levey: In North America, not really. In a normal setting, a physician is sending a patient for a study, and he wants the very best type of MRI, he should be sent to an MRI center. We’ve already called them and said, “Hey, you guys have a 3T scanner? Will you always have that available? Oh, you haven’t gotten it yet. I see you’re planning. Thank you.” Click. Go to the next guy. 

                              [16:49] Tom Crosley: So I’ve heard of a 7T scanner as well. When is it appropriate to insist upon a 7T machine? 

                              [16:57] Dr. David Levey: Never, unless you’re doing research on animals. We do not yet know that there is a clinically significant difference in image quality or acquisition on a 3T versus a 7T. 

                              [17:08] Tom Crosley: So if it were your family member who had suffered head trauma and needed an MRI, you’d be recommending a 3T machine for the brain MRI? 

                              [17:17] Dr. David Levey: Yes. But if I knew the 1.5 Tesla, and I knew the tech was good and it was a well-kept, good magnet, it would be just as well to get a 1.5. 

                              [17:28] Tom Crosley: So, Doctor, I had a question about when is the best time to get an MRI. And over the life of a case, which can sometimes go two to three years or even longer, how frequently should the plaintiff be imaged to look for changes over time? 

                              [17:42] Dr. David Levey: If the patient in question has had a trauma, and they’ve gone to the ER and gotten their head CT. If they’re stable, there is nothing holding one back in the first week from getting an MRI, because if the head CT is read as normal, the MRI could still be flagrantly abnormal. And you’d want to know that, because then you could track it over time as you reexamine them over the months or years. 

                              If the head CT is read as abnormal, you could further characterize those abnormalities on MRI so much better than on a CT scan. And getting that detail also allows you not only to tell what’s wrong with the patient now, but, importantly, to prognosticate what may be expected in the future to happen to that brain — and therefore what happens to that person and their ability to think, executive functions and the like, memory, emotions, et cetera. So getting an MRI soon or early in the case — I think a lot of lawyers wring their hands over that. I wouldn’t. I would just go ahead and get it if it’s possible. 

                              [18:50] Tom Crosley: And is it appropriate to order a repeat scan at some point? 

                              [18:53] Dr. David Levey: At some point, I think so. Follow-up MRIs can be valuable, particularly in two cases. One, if you have found nothing abnormal on imaging structurally, right? Yet the patient is so abnormal. The family doesn’t recognize them anymore. Work is not going well. Tasks they used to do, they can’t do them anymore. Well, you know something’s wrong. You’ve had normal brain scans; you definitely want a follow-up MRI, and at high field strength at that. 

                              But if you had a prior scan and it’s abnormal — same thing. You want to track that abnormality, because — and this is the most valuable part — once you have established that the brain has been injured (and so many different injuries can occur), then you want to know what the secondary and tertiary effects on the brain are. After the brain bleeds, or has been injured, or has had edema or infarct, it usually walks through a progression — not linear, a nonlinear progression — to either encephalomalacia, or gliosis, or brain atrophy, and any apoptosis of the actual neurons themselves, giving you groups of dead neuronal tissue that will never come back. That’s all part of the process of figuring out how will this patient do in the future. 

                              [20:10] Tom Crosley: I tried a case last year in another state, and the client was still symptomatic. In fact, her symptoms never went away, and it was classic post-concussion syndrome. And one of the important things to the jury in the case was that we had a volumetric study done early, and then about eight or nine months later another volumetric study, and it showed a loss of brain volume in the interim. And that seemed important, certainly, to the doctors in the case, and important in my proof of the case. So my question is: is there an optimal time to do repeat volume studies to look for that type of thing? 

                              [20:53] Dr. David Levey: The literature is all over the place, and there is not an optimal time. But what you’re describing is central to these cases. I would think if you have a T-equals-zero injury in a scan, you need to wait at least six months to get another examination. It’s going to be more valuable the longer you wait, as a general rule. That’s not a hard rule at all — nothing hard and fast. But if it’s at nine months or a year, a year and a half, you’ll really see the effects of the atrophy, if you have it. 

                              [21:24] Tom Crosley: Can you teach us a bit about what is a volumetric study of the brain , and how that is important in litigating a TBI case? 

                              [21:31] Dr. David Levey: An MRI is performed. A neurophysiology lab typically will be able to take those images and feed them into a computer that loks at and measures volumes. They measure volumes of lobes and of sub-lobe regions, and they sub-segment each lobe. They may even take the cerebellum. In my volumetric studies, there’s the lower brain, the cerebellum, and the upper brain, the cerebrum, right? And in my cerebellar sub-segmentation, there are 12 different areas of the cerebellum. Each are looked at for what volume they are and what the normal population volume should be. You also look at what volume segment seven is on the right compared to segment seven on the left and compare them side to side. So you have an internal standard, and then you also have pooled data on what normal should be expected to be. 

                              And so it’s calculated informational data that’s extracted from raw MRI images through computer programs that allow you to calculate those volumes in various areas of the brain. 

                              [22:41] Tom Crosley: Doctor, when you’re examining DTI, what is most persuasive for showing traumatic changes to the brain? 

                              [22:48] Dr. David Levey: Certainly, you must take the whole picture into account, but it is valuable to see if you can identify what should be a normal fiber tract appearance — or if there are less of them, if they’re thinned or attenuated, if they’re blunted or thickened, if they’re shortened, or just simply transected. They should be continuous, but if they’re transected, now they’re in two pieces or multiple pieces. 

                              [23:13] Tom Crosley: Doctor, on the screen now you are showing a tractography of a human brain. What is significant about tractography in traumatic brain injury cases? What are you looking for? 

                              [23:27] Dr. David Levey: To put it in a layman’s way of describing it: every time you look at an MRI and you look at the images, they’re slices, or they’re an image — they’re a part of the brain. And that’s a 2D representation of a three-dimensional thing. Your head is three-dimensional; so is your brain. Tractography at least attempts to get a 3D image of the brain, and you’re able to roll and spin these images so that you can take a look at one side or the other side and do your comparison. 

                              So I will turn this one on. And if you see it rotating here — for those that cannot see it — basically you have, from front to back, color-coded red, green, and blue, these different directional evaluations of the tracts that are there and the tracts that are missing. And if there’s injury or absence — the injuries to the brain — you put it together, of course, with your standard MRI, your DTI, your quantitative studies, and then something like this. Tractography is yet another way of looking at the brain and evaluating for the presence of disease. 

                              [24:36] Tom Crosley: So you’re looking for missing bundles of fiber tracts, from which you can conclude that there’s damage to that area? 

                              [24:43] Dr. David Levey: Yes. If the fiber tracts are shortened or thickened or attenuated, if they’re splayed or absent — anything that takes away from the typical configuration of the brain and the fiber tracts and the actual neuron fibers themselves — that’s a great way to identify whether a brain has been injured. 

                              [25:03] Tom Crosley: Sometimes in my cases, there will be a defense-retained radiologist who says that whatever is visible on the imaging isn’t related to traumatic brain injury. Sometimes they’ll call it preexisting white matter disease, or small vessel ischemic changes, or age-related findings instead of trauma-related findings. Can you teach us a little bit about how radiologists figure out whether it’s trauma or something else? 

                              [25:32] Dr. David Levey: Pattern recognition. And those who are trained and pay attention and spend their lives doing this should know when you have chronic white matter ischemic changes — and only that, that alone — and you have a patient in their 50s, 60s, 70s, 80s, and perhaps they’re a smoker, or have had chronic migraines for 50 years, or have diabetes or some other intercurrent disease, that that pattern should be a microvascular disease, and it’s okay. It’s okay to call it that. 

                              And they could have the worst trauma, and all the stories and hospitalizations and such. If you don’t see trauma or evidence thereof, you can’t call it. And so if a defense guy gets a set of brain MRIs or CT scans, and they know the patient had trauma and they’re evaluating it, and they only see microvascular disease, it’s incumbent upon them to just call it that. 

                              [26:27] Tom Crosley: How do you approach causation analysis as a radiologist, to help us identify whether something was or was not caused by trauma to the brain? 

                              [26:37] Dr. David Levey: I’m certainly not shy, and I’m happy to do it when it’s there. When the elements for being able to connect the dots for causation are there, I am very upfront with that analysis. But it’s infinitely easier on a defense case than it is on a plaintiff case, okay? Because when something’s not there, that’s the easy part. 

                              You can talk about how the patient had trauma, had this, had that. And I’m looking at multiple studies — two or three CTs, multiple MRI examinations, maybe a DTI exam, et cetera. If the data points to the fact that there is nothing there that is trauma-related, I can say the patient may have had a terrible trauma, and there may be pain, disability, connective tissue injury, even long-term effects. But if there is no fracture, then that bone’s intact. If there is no blood, if there’s no brain abnormality — it’s a frankly normal study — then there’s nothing to correlate. And so there’s no causation. 

                              [27:31] Tom Crosley: So what are the types of things that you’re most often called upon, say in a trial, to testify to on behalf of the defense? 

                              [27:38] Dr. David Levey: In a nutshell, it’s the absence of disease. The claims are one thing — what the radiologist said on whatever study, that this is present, and the surgeon or other doctors may be quoting the radiologist and carrying that patient for months, and even treating them in such ways, even with surgery. But if the images show the absence of disease, it’s the thing I can state. It’s the thing I can lay out there for all to see — judge, jury, it doesn’t matter. And then if I need to demonstrate — “Well, let’s see that scan” — I can show that scan and show the absence of disease. It really is quite simple. 

                              [28:20] Tom Crosley: So, Doctor, I find it difficult to cross-examine a radiologist, because I can’t really tell them that the pictures don’t show what they say they show. I can’t get in that debate with them; I’m not really qualified to do that. So what have you seen be effective in cross-examining a radiologist? I mean, clearly we can talk about how much money they’ve been paid, or whether they’re biased, or whether they only report for the plaintiff or only report for the defense. Those things clearly work. But if we get into the merits of the radiology, what else can we lawyers be doing? 

                              [28:55] Dr. David Levey: This is what I don’t see, and I think it would be really helpful for an attorney, would be to consult your favorite radiologist first, before you get up there. I do believe — and you can tell me if it’s true — that plaintiff or defense, you guys practice, you get ready for trial, and there’s a lot of preparation. And in preparation, if I was an attorney and didn’t know radiology, I would have a radiologist in my ear. I’d be pointing out stuff, and at least I’d be able to be conversant. And I’d know which questions to ask. 

                              And I know that I couldn’t compete with him in the weeds. Fine. But I would know already that if he’s going to point to this area, or he’s already said it’s just chronic microvascular disease, then — if my radiologist thought there was an area that was different or didn’t exactly look like microvascular disease — I would have that up. I’d have it circled. “Well, how about that, doctor? Do you think that looks like microvascular disease? How about this one?” And I personally don’t know if you can quote radiologists or have them come on — if you can bring your own radiologist on, right, and cross-examine him on what the other person has said. That would be valuable. 

                              [30:07] Tom Crosley: Sometimes they like to say, “Oh, I didn’t consider the DTI, because that’s not validated in a single-person study. It’s more for research,” or whatever. “So I didn’t look at it.” So I’ll cross-examine them on, you know, FDA approvals and the other uses, et cetera. But it’s very difficult to tell them that you see something different on a scan than what they see, because I can’t credibly argue on that level. 

                              [30:33] Dr. David Levey: Twelve Daubert challenges I’ve had with DTI — they’re zero for 12. I would say that over 90% of the ones that even get taken to task, where they try to limit you and all, they really haven’t been very successful in doing that. And that’s because there’s too much data showing that for the last 30 years this has been used on patients. And the truth is, it was used on patients early for stroke and tumor and seizure — a lot of other disease processes. But we do advance on. We do look at things, and there’s a massive amount of information now to use this for trauma. And I’ve done it long enough, and spent enough time digging through the literature, to see that it’s valid. And you could show it — it would be tough for a jury to sit through going through research paper after research paper to show that. But again, if you’re prepared, you can do the short version, hopefully. 

                              [31:31] Tom Crosley: Doctor, where do you think the science of radiology is headed, specifically in brain radiology? 

                              [31:40] Dr. David Levey: So everyone likes to talk about AI, and AI is great — actually great for hospital radiology, where you’re plowing through tons of studies. Some of the best uses of AI currently are in cardiovascular radiology — without going into too much detail, looking at the coronary arteries in a way that they’ve never been looked at before. And it turns out all of those vessels that are in the heart are in the brain as well. So the vascular function, or the lack thereof, in the brain can now be — and it’s starting to be — looked at. So I think AI of the vascular system may be the first newest technique for the brain. 

                              And past that, I think there are going to be perfusion elements. We use gadolinium as our enhancement now, and I think there are other perfusion elements that are going to allow for looking at different sub-segmental areas of the brain and looking for lesser or greater function. Wouldn’t it be valuable? Wouldn’t it be something, if you could give an injection to a patient and do a brain MRI and see what areas are functioning to a lesser or greater extent, or which are dysfunctioning, or abnormal firing of neurons, et cetera — without having to get a PET scan? Because with the PET scan, you get the radiation, and the spatial resolution of the associated structures will never be as good as MRI. So I’m thinking injectables, and AI using the vascular technique to look at vascular brain anatomy, might be some of the inroads coming up. 

                              [33:03] Tom Crosley: We’ve talked a lot lately at conferences about blood biomarkers. Is there any intersection between blood biomarkers and radiology and brain imaging? 

                              [33:12] Dr. David Levey: I think, like any other blood test or any other test that can dovetail with radiology, it can certainly be valuable. I know that I’m looking into those biomarkers now, because of their value — possible value — in trauma, in acute trauma, and the effects of chronic trauma. But I don’t think they’ll help the radiology per se. We’ll still be doing the job that we do every day. But if we know we have a confirmatory test, that’s always valuable. 

                              [33:43] Tom Crosley: What is one piece of advice you would give to plaintiff lawyers, or that you wish they understood about radiologists in brain injury cases? 

                              [33:54] Dr. David Levey: I think that plaintiff lawyers are subject — and this should not surprise anyone — to bias. And I think it’s their own personal bias, because they want this case to go well, and they want things to go well for their client. I mean, you are working for your clients and their families and for their legacy. I get that. The one piece of advice is: if you can get someone who likes to work with you, do that. The more interaction you have with your experts — sitting down, conversing with them — probably the better. Because you can get creative sometimes, in a positive way, in an honest way. And it makes the case better and more robust. 

                              [34:37] Tom Crosley: When you’re hired by the defense, what is the one thing you wish defense lawyers understood better about radiology? 

                              [34:43] Dr. David Levey: If the case is positive — as badly as you want this to be not an injury, not a brain injury or a body injury — if I’m seeing evidence of injury and it looks acute, you’re done. And so really I help my defense guys two ways. One is by doing their case when they’re right. The other is telling them early, “Hey, get out. Settle this, because you’re wrong.” You could find some other person to say another thing; that would be a bad thing to do. The patient’s been injured. How you’re going to go about settling it, that’s up to you. 

                              And I will point everything out to them. I won’t just say, “Hey, you’ve got a bad case.” I’ll take them through everything — fractures, cord injuries, brain injuries, whatever it is — to let them know the extent of what’s going on. But I think it’s incumbent upon me to get in early and let them know early to get out. You know, this case is not valuable to defend. And it’s really the insurance company’s duty to settle and take care of the patient that’s been injured — doing the right thing. 

                              [35:41] Tom Crosley: Well, Dr. Levey, thank you for your time today. I’ve really enjoyed our interview, and I feel like I’ve learned a lot from this. If any of our listeners wanted to get in touch with you, what is the best way to do that? 

                              [35:52] Dr. David Levey: They can always email me. That’s always a very easy way to do it: [email protected]. In addition, I do have a website, www.expertradiologist.org. There’s a lot of information there as well. There’s a page on DTI. 

                              [36:07] Tom Crosley: Thank you, Dr. Levey, for sharing your expertise on radiology with us. It’s fascinating to me, in a brain injury case, all the various modalities that are available to scan the brain — to look at the brain, to look at function, to look at structure. And the science has just changed so much over the 20 years that I’ve been doing these kinds of cases. And I’m always excited to learn from you on this fascinating subject. So thank you for joining Winning the TBI Case. I’m your host, Tom Crosley.  

                              Announcer: If today’s episode helps you see your current case in a new light, share it with a colleague who’s facing the same challenges in a case. Subscribe wherever you get your podcasts, and join our community of trial lawyers who refuse to settle for average results. This has been Winning the TBI Case: strategy, science, and storytelling, with Tom Crosley.

                              38 min
                            • Inside an $8.1 Million TBI Verdict with Scott Blair

                              “ The TBI alters the organic chemistry, the physical structure of the brain to the point where our personalities then get altered. Our spirit knows who we are. But you can’t get that person back… and I think jurors get that.” – Scott Blair

                              Welcome to Winning The TBI Case, hosted by trial lawyer Tom Crosley. Listen as Tom provides practical, powerful guidance for litigating traumatic brain injury cases. This podcast is meant for litigation attorneys who are ready to explore the essentials of TBI cases to confidently represent clients who have suffered traumatic brain injuries.

                              What’s In This Episode:

                              Scott Blair shares how he built and tried a complex TBI case that resulted in an $8.1 million verdict.
                              He explains the role of advanced neuroimaging, expert strategy, and objective evidence in overcoming common defense arguments. Most importantly, he provides practical guidance on how trial lawyers can strengthen their cases by understanding the medicine, telling the client’s story, and preparing for trial from day one.

                              Winning Complex TBI Cases

                              In this episode, Tom is joined by Scott Blair, founder of Brain Injury Law of Seattle, to break down the strategy behind a recent $8.1 million traumatic brain injury verdict. Scott shares how he approaches complex cases, from digging deep into the medicine to building objective evidence that makes it difficult for the defense to deny brain injury.

                              This conversation goes beyond theory. Scott walks through the real decisions that shaped the case, including expert selection, advanced neuroimaging, trial strategy, and how to handle common defense tactics in high-functioning TBI clients.

                              Key Insights for Trial Lawyers

                              • Dive deep into the medicine: The strongest TBI cases are built by lawyers who understand the underlying medical science and work closely with the right experts.
                              • Objective evidence changes the game: Advanced imaging, sleep studies, and vestibular testing can create converging proof that is difficult for the defense to dismiss.
                              • High-functioning clients require a different strategy: Clients who continue working after injury often face skepticism. Demonstrating how their capacity has changed is critical.
                              • Tell the employer early: Encouraging clients to disclose their brain injury can lead to documentation and accommodations that strengthen their case.
                              • Neutralize defense narratives early: Address issues like travel photos or work performance before the defense raises them to reduce their impact at trial.
                              • Use real-world functioning, not just testing: Speech-language pathology and real-world observations can be more persuasive than traditional neuropsychological testing alone.
                              • Before and after witnesses are critical: Family members, especially spouses, provide powerful testimony about how the client has changed after the injury.
                              • Visual evidence matters: Jurors respond strongly to clear visual representations of brain injury, especially when complex science is involved.
                              • This episode is for trial lawyers who want to take their TBI cases to the next level. If you’re handling complex or high-value cases, Scott Blair’s approach offers a practical roadmap for building stronger evidence, overcoming defense strategies, and presenting a compelling case at trial.

                                Winning the TBI Case — Inside an $8.1 Million TBI Verdict with Scott Blair

                                Crosley Law | Runtime: 50:10 | Speakers: Narrator, Tom Crosley, Scott Blair

                                [0:00] Scott Blair: You know, what I told my client early on, because this is so typical of high-functioning people, they don’t want other people to know that they have a brain injury because it damages their employment reputation. They might lose their job. And it’s really important for us as plaintiffs, TBI lawyers, to tell our clients, no, do the exact opposite.

                                [0:20] Narrator: TBI cases can feel like navigating uncharted territory. Your client’s injury is real, but proving it? That’s where the real challenge begins. If you’ve ever felt like you’re missing crucial pieces of the puzzle, you’re in the right place. Welcome to Winning the TBI Case, where Tom Crosley shares the insights he’s gained from over 60 injury trials. Not just the victories, but the lessons learned along the way that make all the difference. This is practical wisdom from someone who’s been in your shoes and found a path forward. Winning the TBI Case: Strategy, Science, and Storytelling. In this in-depth conversation, Tom Crosley welcomes Scott Blair to explore what it takes to win complex TBI cases that other lawyers won’t touch.

                                [1:12] Tom Crosley: Welcome back to Winning the TBI Case. I’m your host, Tom Crosley. Today we are joined by Scott Blair, founder of Brain Injury Law of Seattle. For Scott, brain injury work is his passion. And for the last 25 years, he has proudly helped folks with brain injuries get the specialized treatment they need, and he has successfully litigated their claims in court cases time and time again. We’re really glad to have Scott here today because he’s going to discuss with us a very significant case he tried that yielded an $8.1 million verdict. I was hoping you could give us your background story. Talk about your life. What led you to law school? Then after law school, how did you end up becoming a brain injury lawyer?

                                [2:01] Scott Blair: I was not a very good student in high school. I kind of failed out and just didn’t really care about it and decided to travel the world. But when I did that and got back and went to college, I wanted to be a doctor and my first semester I took Biology and got a C in it. And the pre-med advisor, I’ll never forget, he came over and put his arm on my shoulder and said, Scott, I don’t think medicine’s for you. And so ended up gravitating to law school instead and off I went. But you know, I was doing PI work early on in my career and did a lot of the musculoskeletal stuff, which is great. It’s just that there’s kind of a ceiling in terms of what you can learn about medicine. What really projected me into getting into some of these oddball you know, esoteric medical issues like brain injury was a case I had where nobody could figure out how my guy became a quad, and I won’t spend a lot of time on it, but he had this rare condition from a post-injury tetanus shot that he got called Chronic Inflammatory Demyelinating Polyradiculoneuropathy. So CIDP for short. And it took me seven years working with a neurologist to establish causation and get that thing up. We ended up getting a very good result for this kid that no one else was going to touch.

                                [3:24] Scott Blair: And that case taught me a valuable lesson that really have to dive deep in the medicine. And so when I started doing TBI cases, I thought, oh my God. This stuff is fascinating as hell because, you know, musculoskeletal, you can only go so far with strains, breaks, and blah. With TBIs though, that stuff was just a total terra incognita, so to speak. And it just really stoked my curiosity. And every time you get into these cases, there’s something new and different, and you get some downright bizarre cases now and then. You know, you just don’t see any place else. They’re a great challenge trying to find how do you get the right experts for these things? You know, and for example, brain injuries, I’ve had two cases where it resulted in a loss of religiosity, for example, which is a really bizarre thing, but I was able to find a guy out of Northwestern University who actually has written papers on this. And so it’s a real thing. Mm-hmm. The challenge was how do you establish damages for a deeply religious family, who one member of the family is suddenly the whole sense of religiosity is gone. And it was. It’s that kind of stuff that is just really bizarre and interesting to me that drew me to TBIs.

                                [4:45] Scott Blair: I’m a geek. I really dig, you know, diving into the other things, the pituitary stuff. I think we got the first pituitary verdict, post-traumatic hypopituitarism verdict in the country. And that just kind of fell in my lap. And we wouldn’t have gotten that without really digging deep into the medicine.

                                [5:05] Tom Crosley: That’s interesting. I’ve not heard of the loss of religiosity. But as you were saying it started to make sense to me because a life-changing injury, especially a brain injury, becomes an existential crisis for the victim. And when you start to question your existence and how you’re going to live the rest of your life, I can see why it might lead one to, claim.

                                [5:28] Scott Blair: You know, actually, Tom, it results from damage to the area of the brain that allows for and facilitates deep beliefs in things. And religion happens to be one of those. And that’s why this neuroscientist from Northwestern basically wrote a paper on it because there is an organic basis for that. So if you see a case like that, there’s, you know. There is a basis for it. They’re rare, but they do pop up.

                                [5:57] Tom Crosley: Yeah. So I think there are three things that separate really great lawyers from good lawyers. One of them is being willing to learn the medicine inside and out. The second one is being willing to learn the client, and their experience inside and out. And a third one to me is having the guts to take the risk of saying no to a really good settlement offer and going to trial.

                                [6:20] Scott Blair: Well, you know, in this case in December that you mentioned, that’s pretty much everything we had to do on that case. And it was a fascinating case because my client you know, he contacted me. He was a senior managing software engineer for Adobe here in Seattle. Incredibly smart guy and making a lot of money, close to half a million a year, and he was still working. You know, he went in to a local medical day surgery facility called Proliance here. Proliance has you know, about 120 DBAs in different medical clinics. So it’s a large medical entity here in the Puget Sound area. And he went in for shoulder surgery just from skiing a lot and that kind of thing. And surgery went fine. There was no problem with that. But they had him in the OR. He was unconscious. He was in what they call a beach chair, where they kinda elevate you up a little bit so the shoulder can you know, the surgeon can get access to the shoulder. And so the surgeon, after getting the surgery, leaves the OR, and there’s four people left in there. There’s an anesthesiologist, a surgical tech, a circulating nurse, and a scrub tech.

                                [7:39] Scott Blair: Somehow, they have three straps on this guy to keep him in his chair. And somehow, all the straps were taken off and everybody turns away and, you know, he kind of lurches forward and falls off and lands on his head. And so he wound up with the TBI from smacking his head.

                                [7:57] Tom Crosley: Is he still under anesthesia at this time? Still under anesthesia. So he knows nothing about what’s happening.

                                [8:04] Scott Blair: No, he knew nothing at all. And in Washington, like most states, there’s a statute that allows for medical organizations to do a quality review, and that’s all privileged. You can’t ever get it. And so, what do these people do? Basically they did no chart notes. The physicians had a couple of chart notes, but none of the nurses did talk about how it happened. And so it was a big void. And so when my client came to me, he just said, you know, they said, well, a mistake happened. And fortunately, my client’s wife, when they called her to say, hey, we got to take your husband to the ER, she had the good sense to turn a recorder on. We ended up getting the director of the facility saying, yeah, we screwed up and all that good stuff. And so it told us a little about what was going on. So fast forward. We wind up filing suit. So the client had a significant TBI. He treated for, oh, gosh, probably two and a half years before we filed. And his neurologist put him on part-time disability who’s only able to work 30 hours a week, where previously he worked 50. He was, you know, still able to do software work, but rather than managing a team of 250, they kept reducing his team and because he just didn’t have the bandwidth or the capacity.

                                [9:30] Scott Blair: You know in the software world, if you aren’t 100%, you know, you’re going to fall behind real quick.

                                [9:36] Tom Crosley: How old was he at the time of the injury, if I may ask?

                                [9:39] Scott Blair: He was 52 at the time of the injury. So at the top of his game, and he would have gone on to become a director or probably a VP, making over a million a year at Adobe. So this really affected him. And you know all the symptoms of TBI. I mean, they’re all he had all of them in spades.

                                [9:59] Tom Crosley: So, how long after his injury were you retained?

                                [10:03] Scott Blair: Well, he had a prior attorney who was not experienced with TBIs, and she had that case for about close to a year, and then he brought us on. And, we had to kind of clean up a little bit of the aftermath because the prior lawyer sent him off for a bad neuropsych that ended up becoming the centerpiece for the defense.

                                [10:23] Tom Crosley: So I was hoping you could, as you approach getting this case to trial, you could tell us what were the things that were most important to you after getting this case a year or so after injury? To make sure they were done, to set yourself up as well as could be for the trial that might be coming down the road.

                                [10:40] Scott Blair: For purposes of the objective evidence, one of the things we do in every case, as you probably do, is send people out for enhanced imaging. And I like to get you know, four or five different types of enhanced imaging so that we’ve got, three or four or five different ways of, or rather convergent validity is, I guess, the term that is used for it. So we sent our guy out for DTI, ASL, arterial spin labeling, of course, the usual volumetric analysis. We also did an MR spectroscopy and we had a fifth one of brain aging, which is really unique. I can show you what that looks like. It’s really cool. We did all of those. They ultimately all came back positive. And the beauty of them is that we were able to take the ASL, for example, and some of the DTI and show that there was a very distinct coup-contrecoup pattern of hypoperfusion in gray matter, from the left side of his head where it hit on the floor, to the occipital lobe in the back. So real nice coup-contrecoup. That kind of sealed the deal. Then we didn’t stop there. He had sleep problems post-fall.

                                [11:57] Scott Blair: And we know that getting a polysomnography can give you really good objective evidence of brain damage, if they can show that the hypothalamus was involved. So we had him do a really involved sleep study and our sleep neurologist, really great guy, he’s very knowledgeable about TBIs and sleep problems, pretty definitively said, yeah, you know, all this stuff shows that he had definitive sleep problems, sleep apnea, which comes from NEC and TBI. And so we were able to do that. And then the other thing we did was vestibular. We sent him to Dr. Gianoli down in New Orleans, who I think is one of the top people in the country for assessing vestibular problems. He did a hell of a job with the hearing and vestibular. Our guy’s vestibular had improved, but Dr. Gianoli was able to definitively show, through an MRI how he had nerve damage to the second cranial nerve. Where it was compressed and it took away hearing in one of his ears and the ability to process conversations in a room which helped explain why our client couldn’t sit in a meeting, listen to multiple voices at once.

                                [13:13] Scott Blair: It was just too much for him. We had all these different objective things we put together that made it incredibly difficult for the defense to do the usual stuff they do, you know, oh, it’s all in your head, or it’s, you know, mommy daddy issues from fifty years ago that are unresolved and other stupid stuff like that.

                                [13:32] Tom Crosley: You’ve got a lot of different experts. You’ve done a lot of different advanced testing. Are these being done as treating physicians in a clinical setting? Or are these retained experts from the outset?

                                [13:44] Scott Blair: Part of them were retained and you know, we had two treating neurologists, one of which requested the DTI. And so in a sense, you know, he requested it, but we had to find the right facility that would do it. So it’s a little bit of a hybrid of both and he also recommended Dr. Gianoli. And so again, we did Gianoli on a forensic basis and the same with the sleep. So kind of a hybrid, I would say.

                                [14:09] Tom Crosley: But the referrals to those forensic experts like Dr. Gianoli and this, were done by clinical physicians. So it gives them a, perhaps an air of more legitimacy, I would imagine.

                                [14:24] Scott Blair: Yeah, you know. I think jurors, when they hear a treating doctor refer out what we had our neuroradiologist do, he offered a very simple explanation for why we have to do this forensically. And he very eloquently said, you know, look, most health insurance will not pay for this stuff. And although we have a ICD nine code for it, it’s still not in the phase of being generally accepted for clinical use. But he said problem with it is that it’s expensive and a lot of health insurance carriers won’t pay. So it’s more of a concierge medicine kind of thing. And that’s why you have to generally get these things on a forensic basis or pay out of pocket for it if you really want to know what’s going on. And it was nice because we were able to kind of tap into that, that people have against the UnitedHealthcare from a year or two ago. I thought that was a national focus group occurring right before our eyes where you could see the anger people had towards organized healthcare organizations. And so we made sure his answer kind of tapped into that.

                                [15:32] Tom Crosley: So, I’ve talked previously on this podcast about diffusion tensor imaging or DTI, talked about various types of MRI scans. I have not yet talked about arterial spin labeling, which is another way to run an MRI scanner. But can you give us the overview of what that is and how it was important to your case?

                                [15:53] Scott Blair: Personally, I like ASL more than DTI or anything else. I’ll tell you why. What ASL does, it’s arterial spin labeling and what it’s doing is measuring blood flow in the brain. Now, there’s all kinds of normative studies that establish what is a normal blood flow in the brain. Now, we all know why blood flow is so important because the brain needs oxygen. Without it, we’re dead in five minutes. Oxygen getting to the brain cells is incredibly important. And what ASL does is it magnetizes the water protons in the blood for about eight or nine seconds. And what it does is it tracks them going through the brain. So in gray matter, it will identify the areas of the gray matter where there’s low blood flow or hypoperfusion. In an ASL scan, what you’ll generally pick up on is asymmetric damage that results in asymmetric areas of hypoperfusion. This is how you can detect, for example, a coup-contrecoup pattern of hypoperfusion in a brain because when you have microscopic damage to the gray matter, it damages the brain cells, blood can’t get through, and so you have these little pockets of hypoperfusion and they show up on an ASL.

                                [17:09] Scott Blair: With ASL, what’s important to remember is there in enhanced imaging, there’s two ways to look at enhanced imaging. There’s a qualitative evaluation, which is what the radiologist does by looking at it with their eyes. And ASL does have both capacities, qualitative and quantitative, which is using post-processing software to evaluate it. Now, a qualitative evaluation. Most MRI centers have ASL, problem is that it’s not favored so far for use in TBIs. It’s mostly used in strokes and tumors and things like that to determine what kind of blood flow is there. However, it is becoming more and more used in TBI. There’s a lot of papers that are saying we need to use this stuff in TBIs. And so I can show you an example of a qualitative ASL scan, and then a quantitative one is detailed, and that’s where you start to see the real patterns that show up.

                                [18:14] Tom Crosley: And is it the same neuroradiologist that’s ordering the MRI, the DTI? It’s doing the ASL as well. And is it all part of the same scanning sequence or is it a separate trip for the patients?

                                [18:27] Scott Blair: Yeah, it’s all the same scanning sequence. It the idea is to get a person into a machine that has all of these post-processing packages. You know, they the radiology facilities don’t always have all of these because they cost money and they have to have licensing. But if they get them all, they can then advertise it. But I’m a big fan of ASL. People intuitively understand blood flow to the brain much more easily than, you know, trying to explain DTI and how that works.

                                [18:58] Tom Crosley: Do you require a 3T machine or can it be run on a 1.5T machine? It can be run on a 1.5. You get a little better detail on a 3T. And then do you ever have a situation where your DTI might come back as abnormal, but the ASL comes back as normal or vice versa?

                                [19:16] Scott Blair: 100% of the time I’ve had positive results with ASL. DTI the only few times we’ve had negative results, it depends on the regions of interest that are being looked at. This was pre-IMECA. And now that we have IMECA, which is, as you know, is the new FDA approved DTI platform. We get pretty much 100% result with IMECA as well. But if you don’t have the old IMECA or the newer IMECA program and you’re using the old regions of interest approach, chances are you’re going to get some negative or, you know, zero findings because they’re not looking at the right spots. And little like. You know, the thinner the slice you go with MRI, the more likely you are to find pathology on an MRI. But if you don’t have thin slices, you’ll miss a lot. It’s kind of the same deal with DTI.

                                [20:10] Tom Crosley: Tell us kind of what happened next in the case.

                                [20:14] Scott Blair: We put all this together in a wonderful settlement opportunity package, sent it to Proliance and the anesthesiologist because he was a contract anesthesiologist. So we had two defendants. The anesthesiologist’s attorney kind of said, Well, you’re going to have to file suit so we can do some more discovery and the Proliance people ignored us. So okay, fine. We filed suit and Tom, it was hilarious because these guys denied liability. And they got into what we call a circular firing squad where the two sides are just pointing fingers at each other. And it was great. They basically had their hands tied because they didn’t keep any chart notes about what happened. And they, you know, just said, well, nothing was done wrong. And we did all kinds of discovery on this. We were, so we wanted to find out what their position was. They hired experts to say, well, Mm-hmm. The facility didn’t do anything and they kind of pointed their finger at the anesthesiologist because he’s the captain of the ship. And they’re right, he was, but he wasn’t in charge of doing the thigh strap or the kidney guard being loosened. So we had both of them, you know, squarely.

                                [21:32] Scott Blair: They continued to deny liability, fought them tooth and nail on that. And what Proliance did, Tom, is really interesting. They only had a million dollar policy limit, believe it or not. Proliance is the surgical facility. And the anesthesiologist was a guy named Dr. Cartier and the National Anesthesiology Group based in your lovely state, they had $4 million in policy limits. Proliance eventually came around and said, Well, all we have is a million, and we’re broke as a joke. And, you know, we just don’t have any more money. You probably ought to take it. It’s like, doesn’t pass the smell test. And so my associate, who’s like a dog with a bone, I said, Richard, go find anything you can on the financial affairs of Proliance. We ended up, my associate, after Mr. Joe said they’re broke, have no further money, you really ought to take this million dollars. Richard did a with our State Department of Health, and he found a you know, 60, 70 page document that they were applying to open up a new surgical facility. And the State Department of Health essentially said, yeah, show us that you’re financially worthy. So they had a CPA validated audit of their financial affairs.

                                [22:52] Scott Blair: They take in five hundred million a year and, you know, they had huge assets. What they did was they just thought if they insured each of their sub-entities, 122 of them, with a singular million-dollar policy each, then, you know, plaintiffs’ lawyers, hey, they’ll take that million dollars and they’ll go away. We’ll be fine, don’t worry about it. And so we got that and we tossed it back. Joast and Proliance said, Nah. You know, you guys are lying to us. And not Joast. Joast, I don’t think, knew. I think that Proliance was not, probably given him the full facts. So we ended up just telling them to pound sand, we’re going to trial. And as we got close to trial, you know, the anesthesiologist finally you know, threw the towel in and said, Hey, here’s our four million. And we made a tactical decision to accept the four and then just go ahead and go against Proliance individually. And that resulted in the 8.1 million verdict.

                                [23:55] Tom Crosley: What should we understand about medical malpractice law in Seattle to better understand your case?

                                [24:01] Scott Blair: There are no caps generally. They tried it back in the 80s with tort reform and our state Supreme Court said, no, it’s unconstitutional to have caps. And so we’ve never had them since then. There’s a few advantages the Med Mal people have. For example, if there’s a big verdict, they can file a motion with the court to have it paid in installments over time as opposed to having to pay it all at once. There’s also a mediation opportunity that can be asserted if both parties agree, you know, before filing. But other than that, there’s not much in the way of limitations.

                                [24:40] Tom Crosley: You’ve now settled with one of two target defendants. You’ve settled with the anesthesiologist. You’ve decided to go to trial against the surgical facility, and pick up the story there. And help us understand also, the lessons we as TBI lawyers can learn from this trial.

                                [25:00] Scott Blair: Well, first off, when you have a high-functioning individual like my client, a guy who’s really smart and is still working, albeit 30 hours as opposed to 50. The defense and the insurance carriers love to say in TBI cases, there’s no brain injury here. I mean, look, the guy’s still working. He’s not sitting in a corner drooling, so he must not have a brain injury. The thing about high-functioning people is that we have found through numerous focus groups that if you have a high functioning individual who is really smart, makes a lot of money, jurors are willing to give big verdicts because they see that this person using their brain and having a brain injury is going to result in bigger damages. You have to overcome all of the noise that the defense generates about how smart they are. So, for example, they will get employment files. And they harp on the employment files and how they’re getting good reviews. They’re not getting penalized or punished. And you know, what I told my client early on, because this is so typical of high-functioning people, they don’t want other people to know that they have a brain injury because it damages their employment reputation. They might lose their job.

                                [26:17] Scott Blair: And it’s really important for us as plaintiffs, TBI lawyers, to tell our clients, no, do the exact opposite. Go tell them. I have a brain injury because now you’re protected under the ADA. They can’t just go ahead and dump you. And then all of a sudden, if they know that you have a brain injury and they start to accommodate you, this all finds its way into the employment file. And how do you think that helps a trial? A lot. And you know. When you have issues like light sensitivity, photo sensitivity or sound sensitivity, and they’re not able to do meetings. You start to talk to some of the co-employees and you learn some really interesting stuff. You know, in our trial, for example, there was a very loquacious fellow from France who was kind of hard to understand, but he worked for Adobe and he loved our client. He came in and said, oh, yes, I can’t even imitate his accent, so I’m not going to try it. The employer knew about Jason. And they really went out of their way to accommodate him, but they started pulling big projects away from him. And that’s all reflected in the file. So this set us up for a really nice, I hired a really good vocational guy who here in Seattle, who’s very used to dealing with high functioning tech people.

                                [27:33] Scott Blair: And he did a masterful job of talking about how he would have progressed on to making a million a year and the economic losses were enormous here because of this brain injury. And you just don’t survive in the high-tech field with a brain injury. There’s always wolves nipping at your heels. You know, if you don’t have game 100%, you’re going down. One thing I really recommend to any of your people listening to this or watching this, is embrace the brain injury and convince your client to go to their employer and just tell them, look, you know, here’s what’s going on. Because otherwise if you don’t tell them, what are they thinking? They start filling the gaps with their own thoughts like this guy’s not very smart, or he’s slacking off, or she’s, you know, blah. They come up with all kinds of internal excuses that damage your client might find their way into their employment file. So be honest about it.

                                [28:30] Tom Crosley: What were some of the other key defense narratives and how did you overcome them?

                                [28:34] Scott Blair: The key defense narrative in this case revolved around the early neuropsych evaluation that was done. Now, here’s another nugget I will pass on to whoever is listening to this. I personally do not like neuropsychology. I will never send a client to a neuropsych if I can help it. Now, if I inherit a case where they have been to one, okay, we can deal with it, prior lawyer who had no real experience in TBIs, sent him to a local outfit that ran him through it was a workers comp rehab place and they had just hired a brand new neuropsychologist with six months of experience. And this guy does an exam on my client, you’re familiar with pre-morbid capabilities and he didn’t properly measure my client’s pre-morbid estimate of intelligence. It looked like my client aced all of these tests and he said, there’s no problem here. You know, this guy must have depression or other problems. And so that became the centerpiece of the defense case, that treating neuropsychologist, you know. We don’t have any, we didn’t hire him, he’s unbiased, look what he said. Well one of the things that I would really encourage people who, if you are stuck with a neuropsychologist.

                                [29:54] Scott Blair: Mm-hmm. Take advantage of the limitations of neuropsychology.

                                [29:58] Tom Crosley: Okay, you mentioned the defense hired a neuropsychologist, a PhD named Summer Rollins. She’s actually based here in San Antonio. I’ve had her on a few of my cases, but I haven’t gone to trial on any of those cases. I’d like you to talk about how you on her opinions in this case, and how you were able to show that her side was wrong and your side was right.

                                [30:19] Scott Blair: What we did with her is: I started out with ecological validity because, with a record review, where she says that, you know, my client was. Doing really well. He tested well, et cetera, et cetera. We wanted to illustrate the difference between, what my client’s work environment was like, working in a busy office versus being tested in a quiet clinical setting. And so we started with this and we just kind of went through and tests are done in ideal conditions. She agreed to that. Tests are done in a structured way, and they don’t reflect real daily life demands. She agreed with all this. And ultimately we came up with this, it’s the ideal versus the real. And that was a moniker that we used for her. And then we, you know. This exhibit here, and I said, So, ideal testing conditions are kind of like what we see on the left. Is that correct? Okay, and here’s a typical high-tech office, you know, on the right. And so one of the questions we asked her was I basically said, so doctor. You know, if you were to give these tests in this real world setting, what would the results be? Well, we can’t because it would invalidate them and they’re not normed for this kind of setting.

                                [31:37] Scott Blair: Okay, so in other words, you can’t tell this jury, how he would have functioned in this environment, only in this one on the left. Is that right? And you know, and the point was made quite clear, I think, for her. And this, you know, he had a problem with meetings and we wanted to highlight this too, to show how there is just a lot of stuff going on in meetings. So she agreed with all this, the ideal versus the real, and it worked out very nice for the jury. We then focused on Lezak’s book a little bit about premorbid intelligence and how a person with, I blew this up. Because our guy was a software engineer. I got her to agree that Lezak was one of the kingpins of neuropsychology. And so for a person who writes software, programs, they’re very superior pre-morbid intelligence. That’s the highest you can get. And in this case, the neuropsych only had him as, you know, above average. And so she had to agree that you know. And then we talked a little about, this is from Bigler’s paper, which I love. You know, he shows the advances of well, the relative lack of advances in neuropsychology.

                                [32:55] Scott Blair: They’re the same after 84 years. And with neuroradiology, he shows how it’s advanced over that timeframe dramatically, but neuropsychology has stayed stagnant, hasn’t budged. And she was trying to weasel her way out of that, but I think the point was made clear to the jury that neuropsychology is a soft science that isn’t going anywhere or isn’t moving really.

                                [33:19] Tom Crosley: So you’ve talked a little bit about your attack of the defense neuropsych. What else do you think was like a watershed moment in this trial?

                                [33:27] Scott Blair: The other thing the defense is really relying upon in this case is my client. You know, he made good money and he and his wife traveled a lot. His wife was in the travel business. She worked for National Geographic and other tours. So they traveled a lot. He had a daughter in college they would travel with. And so the defense quickly picked up on. They subpoenaed all of his vacation photos, of which there were many. And they were in various foreign places around the US and just on and on. And they were trying to say, look at this guy. He doesn’t look brain injured. He’s out traveling. He’s, you know, you see him here in Greece without sunglasses. Has he really got photosensitivity? And we just got right in front of all the travel photographs. And so when the defense started going through it, you know, on cross with our client. It just got the jury’s like, yeah, I’m over it. You know, you could see it on their face. Big deal. And we completely stole their thunder. In addition to that, we also pulled out all the photographs of him laying, you know, in a hotel in the afternoon, exhausted. Or laying at home, you know, with his dog, crashed out late in the day from fatigue.

                                [34:44] Scott Blair: And so it completely diluted their, the power of their photo defense. We spoke to the jury afterwards, and what they told us, they thought the most important witness in the entire case were two. One was our vocational guy. You know, they said he really put everything in perspective from a numbers standpoint how this guy is going to be affected in his career and the other one of two was our speech language pathologist. She was amazing and she’s been doing this for 25 years. Unlike neuropsych testing, you know, as you know, SLP basically, it deals with real-world stuff. They test you in a real-world environment, unlike the neuropsych where it’s the ideal environment. And so, we were able to bookend the SLP with the neuropsych and show how it was so much more valuable in terms of testing real world stuff. And she saw him 20 times versus the one time, with the neuropsyches.

                                [35:47] Tom Crosley: Let’s talk about the closing argument. Tell us about it. How much did you ask for? Did you suggest a dollar amount? Did you come up with various models or mechanisms by which a jury could get to the number you wanted?

                                [35:59] Scott Blair: We had a little bit of a tough jury panel because there were so many medical people on there. And there’s, I don’t know how we ended up with so many, but a lot of them were, you know, a little more tied into actual numbers. And so Courtney basically went through the closing and you know, she talked a lot about the human stuff and then when we got to the numbers, the 30 to 50 million. You know, she talked about the value of a healthy brain and how does that affect a high-functioning person like our client and his wife? One of the things we also harped on very heavily was the future risk of dementia and Alzheimer’s. And our neuroradiologist happened to have a lot of specialty in that area and was able to talk about it. But in Washington we get damages for the fear of you know, a potential thing like Alzheimer’s coming, without having to prove the actuality of it. And so even though our radiologist couldn’t say that our client would more probably than not come down with it, you know, the judge allowed us to go forward with the fear of that, and Courtney harped on that pretty heavily.

                                [37:15] Scott Blair: Because we know from focus groups that is a huge fear factor for jurors. And I would really recommend anybody doing a TBI case to get into that because even a mild TBI, you’re six times more likely to come down with Alzheimer’s. Closing, I think, after they realized just how strong of a case we put on, their number went up to like 800,000. And I could tell they were struggling with on the one hand, 30 to 50, and this is the age-old struggle defense lawyers have. Do you stay really low and try to anchor it down and piss the jury off? Or do you try to appear reasonable and come in somewhere in a mid-range? They were really in a box. And I think that was why they came up with the number they did. And you know, the jury deliberated for about two days. And the number they came up with, they said was largely based upon the vocational experts’ estimates along with general damage stuff. Yeah, we obviously we wanted a bigger verdict, you know, the amount of the verdict the way it turned out.

                                [38:34] Scott Blair: It was pretty much, collectively, everything we collected was essentially what our original demand was. And I thought it was for our client being he essentially told you’re full of crap. You don’t have a brain injury, this and that. Having the validation for him was enormous. He really wanted that. And ironically, my client. You know, just kinda just let go from Adobe because of the TBI and he was able to negotiate a really nice severance package, you know, to them feel free of any kind of pressure from the ADA. But yeah, the moral of the story or the happy ending on this one was he got a nice verdict. He’s set for life now and doesn’t have to worry about trying to compete for a high-tech job when he knows he’s not going to be competitive for it.

                                [39:32] Tom Crosley: What were the biggest lessons you learned from this trial that you think would be important for lawyers around the country to know?

                                [39:39] Scott Blair: So the medical profession now needs to look at a TBI as a disease process. And so do lawyers. We need to look at it and say, this affects everything to some degree within the body. And I think the standard of care in our profession, is we have to look at each and every part that has been affected and talk about that. How is that going to affect this person? By doing that, you know, we show it’s a systemic insult to the body. And if you have a claim for future dementia and that kind of stuff. It just falls, it dovetails very nicely into that disease process for a jury to take a look at. We know from juries, you know, doing focus groups and talking to jurors in these cases that people now are pretty sophisticated with their knowledge of TBIs. You know, the NFL has done us a solid in terms of talking about CTE, even though that’s a different type of brain injury. But they don’t necessarily differentiate the two CTE from a TBI. And in the jurors’ minds, they’re really very similar. So talk about the totality of the TBI.

                                [40:55] Scott Blair: You know, sometimes it’s not possible, but I would say find the top two or three objective measures. And then the other thing is before and after witnesses. You know, you’re well aware of those. And I think any good lawyer knows the value of before and after witnesses. I think they’re probably the most important witnesses in the case because jurors get it. You don’t have to convince them of too much. They’ll subject it to the BS test if you know, if what they’re saying sounds true, then okay, cool. Then all this high-level scientific medical stuff coming in is just backing up everything the witnesses are saying. I think it’s a real beautiful interplay. The last thing I’d say is with all this advanced neuroimaging, I didn’t show you some of these really cool things. Good visual imagery of the brain damage is enormous because the jury afterwards just said it was too complicated. Just show us a visual representation of what you’re talking about. Let me real quickly explain. This is used against a normative database of about 40,000 people, believe it’s volBrain, the database they use.

                                [42:12] Scott Blair: Taking the normative database and then looking at the volumetric findings in my client’s MRI that he had along with everything else. Our neuroradiologist was able to take this, and the areas in red show where you see up on top here. He was 5, at the time this image was done. And so when you see the areas down here in green, some of the areas of his brain were below the normative age for him. Other parts in the deeper red were more closer to 60. So this guy’s parts of this guy’s brain, and this is the contrecoup portion that you see right here. So he whacked his head right here. And on the contrecoup portion, we see significant areas or pockets where his aging is well above what it should have been. Now, this is a normal ASL. Now, you see, for example, I’ll stop it right up here. And on the top, you see this scale of colors. A nice red, that’s robust. That means you got really good blood flow. That’s 100 milliliters of blood flowing per minute. And as it goes down to green and into the purples, those are the areas where there’s low blood flow.

                                [43:28] Scott Blair: Now, this was a sample of what a normal brain probably looks like. Fairly robust with blood flow. And so, all right, let me stop this and here is what our client’s basically looked like. And you see the blue up here in the 20s. Blood flow to the gray matter of his brain was substantially reduced. And you know, this helped kind of fit the bill of why he was having so many cognitive difficulties because there’s lower blood flow to that part of the brain. That’s powerful.

                                [44:06] Tom Crosley: That’s very powerful. Did you do more than one of these ASLs and how far apart were they staggered and did the results change?

                                [44:15] Scott Blair: We only did one of the ASLs in this particular case. However, here’s what I recommend for people thinking about getting imaging. Do what we call a longitudinal study. You’re aware of that. But, you know, if you get a case early on, get your client in right away for at a minimum volumetric evaluations and then 18 months is when I generally look at it, because that’s the point at which most people say it’s chronic if he still has he or she still has symptoms. By getting a second MRI, now you can show the loss of volume between those two points in time, which is always going to be, vastly more rapid than what you see with natural aging. It just kills the defense argument that, oh, maybe this is just due to such, you know, blah. It’s not. Trauma is the only thing that’ll do that. So. That’s my recommendation is get two of them.

                                [45:06] Tom Crosley: Clearly an expert in TBI litigation. There’s a lot that lawyers around the country can learn from you. What advice would you give to young lawyers that are interested in pursuing a career, specializing in TBI litigation.

                                [45:23] Scott Blair: Dive into the medicine. Don’t be afraid of it. When you go talk to the medical experts, if you go in and talk to them where they know you have done your homework and you’ve tried to understand their world as opposed to going in and getting them to deliver everything for you. That makes an enormous difference. And I’ll pass on a little tip which I think it’s worth its weight in gold. When you look at the medicine, before you ever file your case. I like to do what I call oral medical reports. I love these because what it is, you take a little electronic dictaphone kind of thing and you do your phone. There’s all kinds of ways you can do this, but go into the doctor’s office and buy an hour of their time and say, Doc, I want to understand what’s going on here and talk to them first and have them state their opinions. Then you say, you know, Doc, be really helpful for me to if I could just record our conversation, have you tell me everything again. By recording it, what I’ll do is I will have it transcribed and I’ll send it to you to look at, make sure it’s all accurate, sign off on it. It’s like a deposition without the defense lawyer there. And here’s what happens.

                                [46:39] Scott Blair: The magic of one of these things is the minute they see that recorder, you know, sit there between them. They kind of straighten up and you know, they get ready to perform for you. And, you know, they will start saying stuff that you will never get by asking them to write you a narrative report or anything like that. They hate that stuff. The other thing I’d say real quick is go to your client’s house. Meet with your client. Do not sit in the comfort of your office and think you understand your client because that ain’t going to happen, man. Go out and spend a day with your client and watch how they function in their house. Look at all the compensatory strategies they have existing in their house. Are there Post-it notes all over the kitchen in their home office? Listen to what the family members say. Talk to the spouse. I think spouse is the most powerful witness in these cases, but do it without your client being present. And they will say stuff to you that’ll blow your mind. Some of the most poignant moments in any of my TBI trials are always the spouse talking about how the person that left that morning to go to work. They left as one person. They came back, completely different person. And I have a new person in our marriage here. And it’s really hard to adapt to that new person.

                                [47:57] Scott Blair: I still love him or her. Man, I’m not getting used to this new person that’s like a threesome, you know and that stuff is powerful. Brain is the house of our consciousness. It is who we are. And I think in TBI cases, we really have to emphasize how if you are 50 years old and you get a TBI, you spent the first 50 years of your life developing this personality who is essentially you. And the TBI alters the organic chemistry, the physical structure of the brain, the point where our personalities then get altered. Our spirit knows who we are. But you can’t get that person back. And not only does the spouse have to deal with this new person, or the family members. Plaintiff has to. And that is really hard to alter all that, you know? I think jurors get it. So I could go on and on and on. You know, I love this stuff.

                                [48:57] Tom Crosley: Hey, thank you thank you. I’ve gotten so much out of today’s interview and I hope our listeners will as well. If they need to reach you, what’s the best way for our listeners to reach you?

                                [49:08] Scott Blair: They can email me at scott at braininjurylawofseattle dot com and happy to chat with whoever.

                                [49:17] Tom Crosley: That concludes this episode of Winning the TBI Case: Strategy, Science, and Storytelling. I’m your host, Tom Crosley. A special thank you to our guest, Scott Blair of Brain Injury Law of Seattle, for sharing tips from his recent $8.1 million verdict in a TBI case and strategies that he uses in TBI cases.

                                [49:40] Narrator: If today’s episode helps you see your current case in a new light, share it with a colleague who’s facing the same challenges in a case. Subscribe wherever you get your podcasts, and join our community of trial lawyers who refuse to settle for average results. This has been Winning the TBI Case: Strategy, Science, and Storytelling with Tom Crosley.

                                Subscribe and Stay Connected

                                • Connect directly with Scott Blair: [email protected]
                                • Subscribe to Winning The TBI Case on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube or wherever you get your podcasts. 
                                • Follow on Facebook, LinkedIn, and Instagram
                                • And remember, don’t just listen to the strategies, implement them!
                                • 51 min
                                • TBI Defined

                                  “The better you understand the definitions of mild TBI, the better equipped you are to read the records, evaluate the experts, and keep your case grounded in sound medicine.” – Tom Crosley

                                  Welcome to Winning The TBI Case, hosted by trial lawyer Tom Crosley. Listen as Tom provides practical, powerful guidance for litigating traumatic brain injury cases. This podcast is meant for litigation attorneys who are ready to explore the essentials of TBI cases to confidently represent clients who have suffered traumatic brain injuries.

                                  What’s In This Episode:
                                  In this episode, Tom Crosley explains how mild traumatic brain injury is defined using both the ACRM 1993 and updated 2023 frameworks. He breaks down the three primary pathways to diagnosing TBI and how those definitions show up in real cases. And finally, Tom provides the simplified jury presentation that keeps the focus on symptoms, causation, and long-term impact.

                                  Understand the Framework

                                  This is for trial lawyers who want a clearer, more practical understanding of how mild TBI is defined and how those definitions are used in real cases. Tom Crosley breaks down the definitions that form the backbone of every brain injury case. He explains the evolution from the 1993 American Congress of Rehabilitation Medicine (ACRM) definition to the comprehensive 2023 update that created three distinct pathways to diagnosis:

                                  • Clinical signs
                                  • Symptoms with objective findings
                                  • Abnormal imaging (NOTE: most mild TBIs will not appear on routine scans)
                                  • If you’ve ever found yourself caught in a word play battle with the defense over terminology instead of focusing on the injury itself, this episode will help you reframe your approach.

                                    Winning the TBI Case — Episode 18: TBI Defined

                                    Crosley Law | Aired: April 2, 2026 | Runtime: 12:28 | Speakers: Narrator, Tom Crosley

                                    [0:00] Tom Crosley: The case is not about the label. The case is about what the symptoms are and were those symptoms caused by the crash or the event, and what does the future hold?

                                    [0:09] Narrator: TBI cases can feel like navigating uncharted territory. Your client’s injury is real, but proving it, that’s where the real challenge begins. If you’ve ever felt like you’re missing crucial pieces of the puzzle, you’re in the right place. Welcome to Winning the TBI Case, where Tom Crosley shares the insights he’s gained from over 60 injury trials. Not just the victories, but the lessons learned along the way that make all the difference. This is practical wisdom from someone who’s been in your shoes and found a path forward. Winning the TBI Case, strategy, science, and storytelling. Let’s join Tom as he breaks down the fundamental challenges of representing clients with invisible injuries.

                                    [1:00] Tom Crosley: Welcome back to Winning the TBI Case. I’m Tom Crosley, and today I want to talk about how mild traumatic brain injury gets defined, and this can become clunky in a hurry, and I don’t want it to turn into a word game instead of a useful discussion, so I’m gonna try to keep this simple and practical. Here’s the main point. Definitions matter, but they are not the whole case. A case does not rise or fall just because one expert wants to call it a mild TBI and another wants to call it something else. At the end of the day, the real questions are still the same. What happened in the traumatic event? What symptoms and impairments followed to your client as a result of that? Were those problems caused by the event? That’s where the case lives. How do these problems affect that person going forward in life? What does the future hold for this person? It’s not what label we attach to the injury. It was the injury caused by the event. So if a person develops headaches, dizziness, cognitive problems, balance trouble, light sensitivity, fatigue, irritability, an inability to function the way they used to function, those are always going to be real problems regardless of whether a defense expert wants to claim that it’s not a mild TBI.

                                    [2:21] Tom Crosley: So why then do definitions matter? They matter for two reasons. First, the better you understand the definitions of mild TBI, the better equipped you are to read the records, evaluate the experts, and keep your case grounded in sound medicine. The better able you are to avoid getting sidetracked by defense wordplay and semantic games. Second, medical literature is built on definitions. Researchers define who counts as a mild TBI and who does not, and then they study recovery, prognosis, treatment, long-term outcomes based on that defined group. So if you don’t understand the definition that they’re using, you probably don’t fully understand the literature either. So before I go further, let me say one quick word about the American Congress of Rehabilitation Medicine, the ACRM, because we’re studying and relying upon the ACRM definitions here. The ACRM is a major interdisciplinary rehab organization focused on research and evidence-based clinical practice. Its brain injury work has long been considered mainstream for over three decades. When the ACRM publishes something on TBI, lawyers should understand that this is important and widely respected.

                                    [3:43] Tom Crosley: It’s not some fringe view. So let’s talk about the 1993 ACRM definition of mild TBI, which for decades was the classic definition of mild TBI. It said that mild traumatic brain injury is a traumatically induced disruption of brain function shown by one of four things. Loss of consciousness, anywhere from zero minutes all the way up to 30 minutes. Beyond 30, it becomes moderate. Loss of memory around the event, so amnesia, as long as the amnesia resolves within 24 hours. If you have amnesia for more than a day after the event, they’re calling that moderate also. A fourth thing that will fit is focal neurologic deficits. It just means some kinda localized neurologic abnormality. Examples would include weakness or numbness on one side, facial droop, slurred speech, abnormal pupillary response, a visual field cut, impaired coordination in an arm or a leg. Those are pretty unusual, at least in my handling of these cases when I’m looking at medical records and we tend to see altered consciousness. Even if the person is not unconscious, we see altered mental status, dazed, confused, et cetera. Rarely do I see a documentation of a focal neurologic deficit, but it’s important to know what that means.

                                    [5:02] Tom Crosley: So the 1993 definition mattered because it gave medicine kind of a common agreement point. The problem is, over time, that got messy. Different specialties started using different approaches. Sports medicine came up with its own definition. Emergency medicine came up with another. The American Academy of Neurology came up with a different one. The neurosurgeons came up with a different one. So the ACRM got together leading up to 2023 and said, “Hey, we need to fix this and have one universal definition that we can all kinda rely on.” It was an effort to bring more order and consistency to the diagnosis of mild TBI. You probably ought to read it. It’s six criteria. It’s three different pathways, but it’s really easy to get lost there. So I try to boil it down, and if I’m gonna teach it to a jury, I’m gonna try to boil it down as basically as possible. That’s what I’m gonna try to do for you in this episode. I’ll leave it to you to let me know whether I succeeded or not. But here’s how I boil it down. Under the 2023 framework, there first has to be a plausible mechanism of injury, some kind of event capable of transmitting force to the brain. It could be a blow to the head. It could be the head striking an object. It could be acceleration, deceleration from a crash.

                                    [6:19] Tom Crosley: It could be a blast wave concussion type force. But once you have the plausible mechanism, there are basically three ways to get to the diagnosis. The first way is some obvious clinical signs. It’s the easiest one to understand. You have the injury event, and then you have obvious clinical signs of acute brain dysfunction. This route feels similar to the old 1993 definition. The second way of three that we get there without obvious clinical signs, we get there with symptoms plus objective support. So not every legitimate mild TBI comes with a nice clean witness account or a perfect ER note saying that the patient was definitely confused and repetitive at the scene. Real cases are often messier than that. Sometimes the person has the classic early symptoms, headache, dizziness, nausea, light sensitivity, brain fog, trouble concentrating, irritability. And sometimes those symptoms are backed up by objective findings on examination, such as abnormal balance, some kinda abnormal oculomotor testing, some kind of vestibular issue, an abnormal cognitive screen. So if you have some of those symptoms, two or more, and you have some kind of objective medical screen, then that is how you get there.

                                    [7:38] Tom Crosley: The third way you get there is abnormal structural imaging. That means a CT scan usually done in the ER, which as we know in these cases is most often normal. The other way we get there is a structural MRI that shows some kinda intracranial abnormality that’s related to trauma. That’s the imaging route. So let me be very clear here. Positive imaging is not required to diagnose a mild TBI. It has never been. Most mild TBIs do not show up on routine CT or MRI, but when they do show up on CT or structural MRI, that supports the diagnosis directly. And a lot of times, depending on what the abnormality is, it may move it beyond the mild realm into the moderate realm. I’m gonna leave advanced neuroimaging for another episode and keep today’s focus on the core diagnostic framework for the 2023 ACRM definition. That’s the simplified update. Number one, a plausible mechanism of injury and one of three routes, either obvious clinical signs or early symptoms may or may not be documented in the medical record, plus some objective support documented in the medical record, abnormal neurocognitive screen or balance issues or something like that.

                                    [8:57] Tom Crosley: Obviously, some kind of abnormality on CT or structural MRI. That’s the cleanest way I know of to teach this to a jury. Why do lawyers need to know this? It’s not because the entire case turns on the label. The case is not about the label. The case is about what the symptoms are and were those symptoms caused by the crash or the event, and what does the future hold? So when an expert comes in and says, “Oh, this does not meet the definition of mild TBI. This is not a TBI. It’s missing XYZ,” I don’t think that matters that much. Plus, your own experts are probably already laying the groundwork before the defense expert comes in talking about why it is a TBI. The symptoms are still there, the impairments are still there, and you’ve answered the causation question. Why do we need to know what the definitions are? Knowing definitions helps in several ways. First, it helps you read the records with more sophistication. It helps you evaluate experts and see whether they’re applying mainstream medicine or just kinda narrowing the terms. It helps you understand the literature because prognosis studies and outcome studies depend upon how a patient group was defined. And fourth, it helps you from getting dragged into the defense wordplay and semantic games. So when the defense says, “This is not TBI,” you can catch them playing with these definitions in a way to try to move your case out of the realm of injury.

                                    [10:21] Tom Crosley: So the next question, if it’s not TBI, then what is it, right? The defense is usually saying, “Well, it’s made up,” or, “It’s psychological.” And many times I can get defense experts to admit that the impairments are real for the patient, and the impairments were brought about by the event. So regardless of whether we call it a TBI or something else, it’s still a compensable injury. And so that’s where we’re trying to get our case to live. So here’s my final takeaway. In 1993, the ACRM definition gave us the classic framework, loss of consciousness, amnesia, altered mental status. The 2023 update kept in the spirit of that definition, but it made the diagnosis more structured and more realistic for modern practice. So if you wanna teach it to a jury, don’t get bogged down in six criteria and three pathways. Instead, understand those six criteria and three pathways, but teach it this way. Number one, there has to be a plausible injury mechanism. There was in this case, the car crash, whatever the event was. There have to be clinical signs. There were in this case, and list them. There have to be symptoms. There were in this case. What were they? Dazed, confused, disoriented, headache, et cetera. Or there has to be trauma-related abnormality on CT or MRI, which there may or may not be.

                                    [11:41] Tom Crosley: That’s enough for jurors to understand the framework. And that understanding matters not because definitions decide the whole case, but because they help you understand the medical research and understand when the defense is trying to play word games with you. This has been Winning the TBI Case. I’m Tom Crosley.

                                    [12:03] Narrator: If today’s episode helped you see your current case in a new light, share it with a colleague who’s facing the same challenges in a case. Subscribe wherever you get your podcasts, and join our community of trial lawyers who refuse to settle for average results. This has been Winning the TBI Case: Strategy, Science, and Storytelling with Tom Crosley.

                                    Subscribe and Stay Connected

                                    • Subscribe to Winning The TBI Case on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube or wherever you get your podcasts. 
                                    • Follow on Facebook, LinkedIn, and Instagram
                                    • And remember, don’t just listen to the strategies, implement them!
                                    • 13 min
                                    • Neuropsychological Evaluations Demystified with Dr. Janyna Mercado

                                      “Every test you take today is going to tap into how a different part of your brain is working. Some tests will have more emphasis on different lobes of your brain than others. We’re going to be evaluating your memory, your attention, and your concentration ability.” – Dr. Janyna Mercado

                                      Welcome to Winning The TBI Case, hosted by trial lawyer Tom Crosley. Listen as Tom provides practical, powerful guidance for litigating traumatic brain injury cases. This podcast is meant for litigation attorneys who are ready to explore the essentials of TBI cases to confidently represent clients who have suffered traumatic brain injuries.

                                      What’s In This Episode
                                      This episode is essential for TBI attorneys who want to move beyond basic neuropsychology knowledge into advanced tactics. Learn the strategic timing for neuropsychological evaluations, how to interpret validity measures, and why transparency about test limitations strengthens rather than weakens your expert testimony. Dr. Mercado shares insider tips that can transform your approach in the courtroom.

                                      Advanced Testing Strategies and Courtroom Applications

                                      In the second part of this two-part series, Tom Crosley continues his conversation with Dr. Janyna Mercado to reveal strategies for neuropsychological evidence in TBI cases. Dr. Mercado demystifies the evaluation process and explains the critical timing decisions that can make or break your case. This conversation provides expert witness insights to maximize neuropsychological evidence and avoid the common mistakes that undermine TBI cases.

                                      Dr. Mercado’s practical insights reveal why successful neuropsychological evidence requires understanding both the science and the strategy behind telling compelling stories to juries and judges.

                                      Winning the TBI Case — Episode 17: Neuropsychological Evaluation Demystified with Dr. Janyna Mercado

                                      Crosley Law | Runtime: 29:48 | Speakers: Narrator, Tom Crosley, Dr. Janyna Mercado

                                      [0:00] Dr. Janyna Mercado: So I will tell attorneys: these are not lie detector tests. They’re effort measures, they’re validity measures. They let us know a snapshot in that person’s day.

                                      [0:11] Narrator: TBI cases can feel like navigating uncharted territory. Your client’s injury is real, but proving it? That’s where the real challenge begins. If you’ve ever felt like you’re missing crucial pieces of the puzzle, you’re in the right place. Welcome to Winning the TBI Case, where Tom Crosley shares the insights he’s gained from over 60 injury trials, not just the victories, but the lessons learned along the way that make all the difference. This is practical wisdom from someone who’s been in your shoes and found a path forward. Winning the TBI Case, strategy, science, and storytelling. In this conversation, Dr. Mercado breaks down the science behind cognitive testing.

                                      [0:58] Tom Crosley: So my next subject I want to talk to you about is to help us demystify the process of a neuropsychological evaluation. Probably, unlike many of our listeners, I’ve actually done neuropsychological testing. I did it some years ago because I wanted to understand it better, because I figured the better I understood it, the better of an advocate I could be for my clients in court cases. But for those of us that haven’t gone through the process, can you teach us what’s important for us to know about how the evaluation process works?

                                      [1:26] Dr. Janyna Mercado: First part of a neuropsychological evaluation should consist of a comprehensive clinical interview where the client will meet face to face and it’ll be about an hour to an hour and a half long process where we gather substructive information. Now, the assessment itself is the really fun part. And so, this is where we begin by selecting a battery that is very comprehensive. We select tests that will tap into every part of the brain function. And that’s typically what I tell clients: every test you take today is going to tap into how a different portion of your brain is working. Some tests will have more activity in different lobes of your brain than others, but we’re gonna be evaluating your memory, your attention, your concentration abilities. So, to demystify these tests, one of them is typically an IQ test that involves things like verbal comprehension abilities, working memory, processing speed. Then we have memory measures, and these are all standardized tests that are scientifically based. And we purchased them from Pearson from Riverside. There’s a variety of different publishers that you have to be a licensed psychologist to purchase these tests from. And then there is a whole realm of psychological testing that we do in addition to the cognitive testing.

                                      [2:46] Dr. Janyna Mercado: So it’s a full day, it’s anywhere from four to six hours again with breaks. But when you send a client for neuropsychological testing, it is an entire day that they will be in clinic with the neuropsychologist taking a battery of tests.

                                      [3:01] Tom Crosley: And if you’re on the defense side and the plaintiff has already submitted to neuropsychological testing, you know, before your involvement, are you able to do your own neuropsychological testing as a defense expert?

                                      [3:13] Dr. Janyna Mercado: Most of the time I am. And when I do work as a defense expert, I always ask to do my own. I believe there is value in meeting a person face to face, doing my own evaluation to see if we get similar testing. Now, if they had recently been tested by a plaintiff’s attorney, I will ask for the raw data. And I will evaluate that because there’s something called practice effects. You never want to administer test back to back because it will inflate the results because they just recently took it. So I like to wait at least a year between my evaluations. And say, I got a case today and they were tested in 2023, I would definitely ask to retest them. But to answer your question, yes, I always ask to do my own IME when I’m hired by defense.

                                      [4:01] Tom Crosley: Are they typically different tests than were done the first time, or do you sometimes use some of the same tests?

                                      [4:05] Dr. Janyna Mercado: I use my own battery. So if it was a different battery and I see that other tests would be more appropriate, I will use different tests. If I want to mirror the battery to see if there’s any improvement or worsening of symptoms, I will sometimes use the same battery. So it really depends on a case-by-case basis.

                                      [4:25] Tom Crosley: What are you looking for before you ever get into test scores in this clinical interview?

                                      [4:31] Dr. Janyna Mercado: I’m looking for various things. So, number one, I do a full comprehensive from the beginning of life to the event that brought them into the clinic. I am looking for changes. I’m looking for when did symptoms begin. In the field of neuropsychology, onset of symptom presentation is critical for diagnoses. So to understand that from the individual directly. Also, I’d like to see if there’s consistency between what I’m being told and what is in the medical records. What have they been reporting to other providers? And if there’s any inconsistencies, and I have the privilege of having the records before my evaluation, then I get to address those inconsistencies in my interview and ask questions to clarify the matter for me.

                                      [5:18] Tom Crosley: I’m sure there are times when you need to assess whether the patient is putting forth good effort, whether they’re being consistent or truthful or giving you reliable data. How do you do that? And what happens if there’s an allegation of exaggeration or malingering? What do you do in those situations?

                                      [5:42] Dr. Janyna Mercado: Great question. So, every single test battery of these assessments that we administer, anytime I evaluate someone in a forensic setting we always administer at least three to four what we call performance validity measures, and symptom validity measures. One set of tests that is completely unique to the field of neuropsychology. This whole concept of poor effort or malingering comes up in these cases, as we know, are true. And actually, depending on what study you pick up and read, about a third of individuals involved in litigation will overreport symptoms for secondary gain. So it’s something that is very unique and very valuable to the litigation process, in my opinion. Every single battery ICA, you will always see performance and symptom validity measures. What do you do if I suspect that there’s overreporting, intentional over-reporting. There’s something I always do. If I’m hired by a plaintiff’s attorney, I will immediately pick up the phone and schedule a call with the attorney. And tell them we finished the testing.

                                      [6:58] Dr. Janyna Mercado: I can’t tell you much, but I feel that your client is over-reporting symptoms. And this is why. And I just feel that transparency and honesty is best than to sugarcoat. And you know, I’ve had surprisingly, I’ve had some attorneys tell me: you know what, Dr. Mercado, I suspect that I don’t think I’m going to work with this client anymore. And instead of the attorney investing more time and hours and money into trying to prove up a case that, you know, and unfortunately, sometimes these are people with genuine injuries, which is really unfortunate. I think it needs to be addressed. And if they just had a bad day, then let’s reevaluate them in six months or a year.

                                      [7:43] Tom Crosley: If that happens on the defense side, I’m assuming that you write a report that helps the defense prove that you think there’s exaggeration or malingering or that makes sense.

                                      [7:55] Dr. Janyna Mercado: Yeah, defense welcomes those reports, as you can imagine.

                                      [8:00] Tom Crosley: I always tell my clients before they go to their neuropsychological testing to use their best effort. I want the test results to show us what this client is really like on a day-to-day basis. How important do you think it is for our clients to get the message that they need to give best effort, that these tests will catch them if they don’t?

                                      [8:19] Dr. Janyna Mercado: I would tell attorneys that that is a must. If you’re a plaintiff’s attorney and you have a client who’s going to take neuropsychological testing, whether they’re doing the evaluation with the neuropsychologists that the plaintiffs have hired or that the defense has hired. I think both sides should really just engage in a very supportive manner with the testing and let them know about these validity measures. Not show them what they are, do research and coach them on specific measures, but give them clear warning. And I can tell you that at the very end of my interviews, that’s standard for my practice. I will tell the clients in my office: you’re going to take some tests. Some of them are going to be really easy. Some of them are going to be really hard. All that matters is that you try your best because there will be some tests that are measuring whether or not you’re providing good effort. And if you don’t, then my hands are tied and I cannot interpret your tests. It’s almost like using the analogy of you move in an MRI machine or in a CT scan. That image is going to come out blurry. And the same way in testing. If you move during those effort measures and you’re not trying and you’re distracted or purposefully, intentionally not answering in the correct manner when a task is easy.

                                      [9:36] Dr. Janyna Mercado: I’m not going to be able to read your data.

                                      [9:38] Tom Crosley: Yeah, it’s a gift to the defense if the plaintiff tries to exaggerate on their neuropsychological testing. Then it plays right into what I think is the best defense that they’re making this up. For our lawyers who are listening, do try to make sure that your clients put forth best efforts. Don’t try to game the system in any way. I never even asked what tests they’re going to give if the defense is doing the testing. I don’t care. I mean, I certainly don’t want somebody to think that I’m asking to know which tests so that I can prep my client for that test. That’s counterproductive. I just want the test to show how my client really is. I don’t want him to be prepared for it. I mean, that would. Why would I want to do that?

                                      [10:17] Dr. Janyna Mercado: Don’t ask for the lists of tests. You’re rarely going to get them. You’re going to get a caveat, stating what cognitive domains will be assessed. There’s no need, and that’s really something that’s static and really will change depending on the presentation of the client on the day of the testing.

                                      [10:36] Tom Crosley: For the benefit of some of our listeners who may not be familiar with the term raw data, can you tell us what that means?

                                      [10:41] Dr. Janyna Mercado: So raw data is the actual testing protocols that we administer. So it contains all of the standardized test items. And then the responses that is given by the client. That would be true. The raw data includes both cognitive testing and psychological testing.

                                      [11:01] Tom Crosley: I know that in some cases of mine, it’s exchanged only from one psychologist to another psychologist. In other cases, we’ll get court orders that allow the lawyers to get the raw data. What is your typical experience in that regard?

                                      [11:12] Dr. Janyna Mercado: My typical experience has been to send my raw data to other neuropsychologists directly if I get a request from the attorney. I will then forward it to the opposing counsel’s neuropsychologist. And I never have a problem sharing my raw data. I think it’s customary in the field. And if you have an expert who’s not asking for the raw data from the other side, as an attorney, I think you should encourage your neuropsychologist to always ask for the raw data from the other side or any prior testing. So, as an attorney, that would be something I would always be sure that you have your expert ask for.

                                      [11:48] Tom Crosley: When should a plaintiff lawyer ideally have a neuropsychological test done on their brain-injured client?

                                      [11:55] Dr. Janyna Mercado: Ideally, I would say six months for a cognitive screener and one year of full battery.

                                      [12:01] Tom Crosley: And what is a cognitive screener in that context?

                                      [12:03] Dr. Janyna Mercado: A cognitive screener would be a brief assessment to evaluate how that person is functioning, who has persistent cognitive consequences from their traumatic brain injury. That will give us an idea to document the level of impairment that was present. And then at a year, we can determine and do a more comprehensive battery to see if that impairment is still present or if we have any improvement in any cognitive domain.

                                      [12:29] Tom Crosley: And so when do repeat evaluations make sense? Because sometimes these cases can go on for three years.

                                      [12:34] Dr. Janyna Mercado: I would say probably within three months if the case is going to trial. It would be nice to have an updated snapshot, so to speak, of the person’s brain and how it’s functioning. And more than anything, it’ll solidify any permanent injuries that are still present. Way and in trial, you can say with confidence: look, I tested this person three years ago, and this is where they were. I tested them three months ago and this is where they’re still at. And it just kind of solidifies permanency to the court. And to the jury, that the cognitive impairment that still is present.

                                      [13:14] Tom Crosley: It is always awkward if we have an expert, a medical doctor, especially, in any subject, not just neuropsychology, that hasn’t seen the plaintiff for more than a year by the time the trial comes around. Because when you start asking the doctor, hey, how’s Susie doing now? What does the future hold for Susie? You don’t want to get the answer of, I don’t know, I haven’t seen her in two years.

                                      [13:37] Dr. Janyna Mercado: Absolutely.

                                      [13:37] Tom Crosley: What if the case is going on for three years? Do you do the testing every year, or is it enough to do it at the one-year mark and then again months or so before the trial?

                                      [13:47] Dr. Janyna Mercado: Typically, my recommendations are every 12 to 18 months. I would say if you know you do it at the year mark and you’re going to go to trial a year and a half to two years later, just wait the 18 months, 18 plus months. You don’t want too many psych evals back to back. It’s not clinically warranted unless you’re going to trial and you want to prove the permanency of an injury. That would be highly recommended at that.

                                      [14:12] Tom Crosley: From a neuropsychological standpoint, what strengthens or weakens the neuropsych part of the case?

                                      [14:20] Dr. Janyna Mercado: Number one is, I would say, consistent records and treatment records. Ensuring that your client is receiving the treatment needed for the symptoms that are being presented. That may include cognitive rehab, that may include seeing a neurologist for post-concussive symptoms that may be present. That might include being in therapy for the psychological impacts. So I think consistency with treatment, having a good paper trail, documentation of the symptoms is key for plaintiff.

                                      [14:54] Tom Crosley: Let me flip it and ask the same question on the defense side. So, what does a well-supported defense case look like to you as a neuropsychologist?

                                      [15:02] Dr. Janyna Mercado: When I get records that are missing key information or detail, when I see key inconsistencies in the acute medical records where the individual may have had a Glasgow Coma Scale of 15. Neurologically intact at the scene. But then three months later, there’s all these records that begin to appear, brain injury symptoms. And as we know, that’s not the normal trajectory of brain injury. So be wary, whether you’re a plaintiff attorney or defense attorney, if your client claims TBI, but then doesn’t become symptomatic until six months later after they hire you. That’s kind of a red flag. And defense attorneys definitely jump on that.

                                      [15:46] Tom Crosley: Are there any other red flags that you haven’t told us about that would concern you? Regardless of which side you’re on in the case.

                                      [15:53] Dr. Janyna Mercado: You know, my biggest pet peeve is just people trying their best. You know, I, as a neuropsychologist, know what brain injury looks like. And when individuals walk into my office or into an attorney’s office overreporting symptoms that are above and beyond what would be expected for their level of injury, I think that’s a red flag for all of us in the industry.

                                      [16:13] Tom Crosley: When you’re testifying in a legal case at trial in front of a jury, what do you view as your role?

                                      [16:21] Dr. Janyna Mercado: The jury, my role for the jury would be to educate the jury on number one, the type of brain injury that the individual had. And number two, the cognitive and psychological injuries the person may have sustained and how that’s impacted their functioning and their day-to-day activities.

                                      [16:40] Tom Crosley: Do you typically delve into the actual tests that were given that showed deficits and/or how do you explain it?

                                      [16:47] Dr. Janyna Mercado: I feel my experience has been that if I delve into the test scores, I truly lose the jury, and I lose people’s attention. I feel that talking about more big picture concepts is most effective. And so when I’m working with attorneys, I always ask when they present me if they can kind of focus on those strengths and weaknesses in the cognitive profile and the psychological profiles of the individuals. I have seen juries fall asleep and be very bored when an attorney will start asking me questions about, well, the FBS scale on the MMPI was elevated at a 97, and the jury is like, Greek. I like to engage the jury as my audience and speak to them at a level that they understand our field.

                                      [17:38] Tom Crosley: When you work with really strong lawyers, what do you see them doing differently? When it comes to the trial of the case and your role in the case?

                                      [17:46] Dr. Janyna Mercado: Whether it’s plaintiff or defense, I feel that number one, you can tell, I can tell, and I feel that the courtroom can tell. Your knowledge base as an attorney of the subject that you’re trying to question your expert about. Yes, attorneys have their own level of expertise. And I mean, y’all are attorneys, and but I feel that when you’re presenting an expert in a field such as neuropsychology, you should have knowledge, basic knowledge background, what a traumatic brain injury looks like, and what are some of the expected consequences? Be familiar with the literature in that field. I think, as an attorney, that could be your biggest strength: gaining further education in the realm that you’re questioning your expert about, know their field enough that they know you understand what you’re asking about when you’re asking those questions.

                                      [18:36] Tom Crosley: You’re singing my tune now because I think the best cross-examination strategy for an expert, especially a brain injury expert, say it’s a defense expert is for me to find peer-reviewed, well-accepted literature, proves the point I’m trying to make and disputes the point the defense is trying to make. And in most states, not all, but most, we’re allowed to use that literature if it is considered reliable authority, to cross-examine an expert. And so if I can’t get that witness to agree that I’m right and they’re wrong, I can at least force feed them the articles that show I’m right and they’re wrong and make them read them to the jury. Have you seen that done either with you or against you in cases sometimes?

                                      [19:21] Dr. Janyna Mercado: Both. And I think it’s highly effective because you are basically forcing your expert to, one, be genuine and admit to the literature that exists in the fields of traumatic brain injury. I think that’s an excellent strategy that’s used because it’s something that you cannot, it’s what’s been peer-reviewed and scientifically proven.

                                      [19:43] Tom Crosley: So what are some of the most effective cross-examination strategies you’ve seen of neuropsychologists?

                                      [19:50] Dr. Janyna Mercado: I think pulling up prior medical records, prior history. They love to show surveillance cam videos.

                                      [19:56] Tom Crosley: When you’re on the defense side, what have been the most effective cross-examine techniques you’ve seen coming from the plaintiff attorney?

                                      [20:02] Dr. Janyna Mercado: I think, like you said, I think peer-reviewed articles are a really big thing and knowledgeable attorneys don’t happen often enough, I feel like. I feel that when I work as a defense, I think that more plaintiff attorneys need to become savvier and better educated in the realm of traumatic brain injury and take time to research and read the literature in the field.

                                      [20:21] Tom Crosley: There are some that would criticize the field of neuropsychology as too much of a soft science and too subjective. Where do you stand on that issue?

                                      [20:31] Dr. Janyna Mercado: I can definitely understand that when it comes to psychology in isolation. The field of neuropsychology is truly grounded in scientific research for decades. It’s a very well-respected field. Neuropsychology is highly integrated into multidisciplinary teams in clinical settings, hospitals, and rehab facilities. And I would say that the subjective nature of neuropsychology is much less than in psychology by itself, because in neuropsychology we have objective data, which is the result of these standardized measures that are actually providing invaluable information in these cases.

                                      [21:18] Tom Crosley: Plenty of cases that I’ve tried where the plaintiff neuropsychologist and the defense neuropsychologist are looking at the same data. You know, maybe it was the first testing done by the plaintiff. And then maybe the defense did their own testing. Yet one expert says black and the other says white from the same information. So what do we do with that?

                                      [21:38] Dr. Janyna Mercado: That’s where we agree to disagree. And I think we not only see that in litigation, but we see that in a clinical setting as well, which is why we have multidisciplinary teams, all talking about the same case and they can all have different perspectives on it. Much like in the litigation setting, I feel that we really have to work hard remaining unbiased, too. That’s our ethical principle. And if you have a 10-year psychologist and the one hired by the defense or the one hired by the defendant is the outlier. That’s the problem.

                                      [22:10] Tom Crosley: So it seems that I’m typically getting those defense neuropsychologists who do 95 or more percent of their work for the defense. And they’ll usually take outlier type positions such as a person who has a concussion will 100% of the time be well within three months. And if they’re still having symptoms, it’s not related to the concussion, it must be psychological. Something like that. Have you actually seen that or heard of people saying things like that in court cases?

                                      [22:38] Dr. Janyna Mercado: Yes, I do know colleagues in the field who work only defense cases or 99.9 defense cases, and every single mild traumatic brain injury case that I have been opposing them, they consistently say they either didn’t have a concussion, and if they did, they should be fine by now because it’s been more than three months. Everybody. It’s not statistically probable that every single out of the hundred cases they’ve had in their career, a hundred have been fine.

                                      [23:08] Tom Crosley: When a patient fails a performance or symptom validity measure. I know that one explanation is they’re exaggerating or they’re faking. Are there other explanations? That other than intentional deception, can logically be called upon to explain why somebody might fail one of these validity measures.

                                      [23:32] Dr. Janyna Mercado: Thank you for asking that because I feel that attorneys need to know that when these measures are failed. Especially if it’s like one out of three and not consistently across the board that all of these measures are failed. Reasons that these are failed are: one, a person could be having chronic pain that day, they could have a really bad headache. It’s up to the clinician to provide them breaks. They could have not slept well the night before. They may have come in from out of town. They could have had something happen in their immediate family. I mean, there are so many different reasons why an individual will put forth poor effort on testing. And there’s tons of literature about this, that this topic that we’re talking about. That is the first line of what we look at as neuropsychologists and something that could really harm a case. And I feel that defense only experts will always see a failed score and will always say they’re malingering. They’re liars. That’s not true. I think that’s one method in neuropsychology that I would love to teach attorneys and to let them know: look, if you have one failed effort measure, that is not an end-all to your case. There could be a variety of reasons for lower scores. So don’t hang your hat only on one or two isolated tests.

                                      [24:48] Dr. Janyna Mercado: They’re not going to invalidate your entire testing.

                                      [24:52] Tom Crosley: Have you ever heard of that phenomenon, the game show phenomenon, where you know the answer to the question, but now you’re kind of put under the spotlight and they ask you the question, your mind kind of blanks?

                                      [25:00] Dr. Janyna Mercado: Absolutely. And I can tell you, I’ve had clients in here. And that’s why I like to start my days with the interview. And I say, How are you feeling today? Is today kind of a normal day for you? Like, we’ve been so nervous about this evaluation. I’ve been up since three this morning and couldn’t go back to sleep. I didn’t know what today was going to be like. It could be very intimidating to walk into a neuropsychologist’s office and know that you’re gonna be there an entire day, answering questions. We have to take litigation stress into account when interpreting these data profiles that we obtain. And we don’t know that unless we sit with the person and interview them and know if they’re experiencing this concept of litigation stress that can definitely impact testing results.

                                      [25:46] Tom Crosley: From a clinician’s standpoint, Dr. Mercado, what are the limits of what neuropsychological testing can actually tell us?

                                      [25:55] Dr. Janyna Mercado: So I will tell attorneys: these are not lie detector tests, they’re effort measures, they’re validity measures. They let us know a snapshot in that person’s day if that person is engaged with us, if they’re trying or if they’re not.

                                      [26:10] Tom Crosley: And so how would you communicate uncertainty or limitations in your findings, especially in cases where the stakes are high?

                                      [26:18] Dr. Janyna Mercado: I have found it to be best just to be very direct and open and honest. If you’re not honest and transparent, you’re only harming the client. And you’re hurting the case. I wouldn’t want to do that for anybody. There’s people I feel that I’ve tested that have genuine injuries and fail these effort measures. But I still think they are genuinely injured. So I think talking it through and discussing it with the attorneys and re-evaluating when appropriate can be an option.

                                      [26:47] Tom Crosley: Recently, did a case where there was a shoulder injury and a neck injury and a TBI, right? Because it’s polytrauma. You had done some testing on it and you said, this isn’t a TBI. These symptoms probably coming from something else, not TBI related. I was thankful to have that information because I had a very strong shoulder and neck injury case anyway. I would hate to lose my credibility in court by trying to prove something that I’ve got the losing side of.

                                      [27:14] Dr. Janyna Mercado: Thank you so much for bringing that up because not every single case is a TBI case. And you know what? That’s okay. I’d rather you all know than not know and have good information that you could use to strengthen your case.

                                      [27:27] Tom Crosley: What do you see good lawyers doing? What do you wish lawyers would do when it comes to prepping a neuropsych both for deposition and later for trial testimony.

                                      [27:39] Dr. Janyna Mercado: So what I see good lawyers do in prepping for deposition and trial testimony is taking at least an hour a week before the depo, not the morning of the deposition or the day of trial. Give us an opportunity to meet with us 30 minutes to an hour, a week before deposition, a week before trial, to give us time to prepare for the case and to ensure that we have all proper documents. Also, to determine if we need to have any demonstratives that may be helpful to the case.

                                      [28:09] Tom Crosley: What is one thing you wish trial lawyers would do differently when working with neuropsych experts, whether it’s plaintiff or defense?

                                      [28:17] Dr. Janyna Mercado: I wish that trial lawyers would work with us in determining what questions would be the most appropriate to ask us. In a manner that would allow us to convey our opinions in a very simple format to the jury, because ultimately they’re the ones that need understanding the judge. And so I want to be able to convey my findings. And in order to do that, I need to be asked the appropriate questions so that I’m answering a question that is being posed.

                                      [28:47] Tom Crosley: Thank you for generously agreeing to share your time and expertise with us today. If any of our listeners want to reach you, what is the best way for them to do that?

                                      [28:56] Dr. Janyna Mercado: At my office or via email at Janyna Mercado at Texas Neuropsych Institute dot com.

                                      [29:05] Tom Crosley: Thank you very much. So, folks, this wraps up our two-part series with Dr. Janyna Mercado, PhD, a clinical neuropsychologist. I know I learned a lot, and I hope you did too. This has been Winning the TBI Case. I’m your host, Tom Crosley.

                                      [29:19] Narrator: If today’s episode helped you see your current case in a new light, share it with a colleague who’s facing the same challenges in a case. Subscribe wherever you get your podcasts, and join our community of trial lawyers who refuse to settle for average results. This has been Winning the TBI Case. Strategy, Science, and Storytelling with Tom Crosley.

                                      Subscribe and Stay Connected
                                      • Connect directly with Dr. Janyna Mercado at https://texasneuropsychinstitute.com
                                      • Are you ready to take your TBI practice to the next level? Subscribe to Winning The TBI Case newsletter at www.crosleylaw.com/podcast for exclusive case studies, resources, and trial strategies you won’t hear anywhere else. 
                                      • Join our community of trial lawyers who refuse to settle for average results. Subscribe to Winning The TBI Case on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube or wherever you get your podcasts. And remember, don’t just listen to the strategies, implement them!
                                      • 30 min
                                      • Neuropsychology’s Role in TBI Cases with Dr. Janyna Mercado

                                        “Individuals will walk into a courtroom or walk into our offices and they look like you and I. They don’t look like brain injury victims.” – Dr. Janyna Mercado

                                        Welcome to Winning The TBI Case, hosted by trial lawyer Tom Crosley. Listen as Tom provides practical, powerful guidance for litigating traumatic brain injury cases. This podcast is meant for litigation attorneys who are ready to explore the essentials of TBI cases to confidently represent clients who have suffered traumatic brain injuries.

                                        The Critical Role of Neuropsychology in TBI Litigation (Part One)

                                        In the first of a two-part series, Tom is joined by Dr. Janyna Mercado, a clinical neuropsychologist who evaluates and testifies in traumatic brain injury (TBI) cases for both plaintiff and defense cases.

                                        Dr. Mercado defines what neuropsychology is and how it differs from neurology and general psychology. She explains how neuropsychological testing measures cognition, memory, processing speed, and overall brain function. These neuropsychological evaluations often play a critical role in traumatic brain injury litigation. As a neuropsychologist, her role is to translate those complex findings into clear explanations for attorneys, judges, and juries. This helps them better understand what may be happening inside the brain, even when brain imaging appears normal.

                                        In this episode, Tom Crosley sits down with neuropsychologist, Dr. Janyna Mercado to explain the role that neuropsychology plays in traumatic brain injury litigation. They discuss how neuropsychological testing evaluates the “working brain,” why mild TBI cases are often misunderstood, and how expert testimony can help juries understand invisible injuries. This first installment lays the foundation for understanding how neuropsychological evidence can strengthen TBI cases at trial.

                                        Key Takeaways:

                                        • Function Over Structure: Neuropsychology examines how the brain functions, which is critical when imaging scans appear normal but cognitive deficits persist
                                        • Understanding the Full Medical History: Pre-existing conditions should not be ignored or hidden. When properly evaluated, a client’s medical and psychological history can help clarify how a traumatic event aggravated or worsened prior conditions
                                        • Teaching the Jury: Neuropsychologists translate complex brain science into understandable terms that help juries grasp what constitutes a mild traumatic brain injury
                                        • This conversation provides foundational insight for trial lawyers handling TBI cases. If you’ve ever struggled to explain a mild TBI to a jury or wondered when and how to involve a neuropsychologist, this episode is for you.

                                          Stay Tuned…

                                          In the second part of this conversation, Tom Crosley and Dr. Janyna Mercado dive deeper into neuropsychological evaluations, including how testing works, how experts analyze results, and trial strategies attorneys can use based on those results.

                                          Subscribe and Stay Connected
                                          • Connect directly with Dr. Janyna Mercado at https://texasneuropsychinstitute.com
                                          • Are you ready to take your TBI practice to the next level? 
                                          • Subscribe to: Winning The TBI Case newsletter at www.crosleylaw.com/podcast for exclusive case studies, resources, and trial strategies you won’t hear anywhere else. 
                                          • Join our community of trial lawyers who refuse to settle for average results. Subscribe to Winning The TBI Case on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube or wherever you get your podcasts. And remember, don’t just listen to the strategies, implement them!
                                          • 19 min

                                          About Winning The TBI Case

                                          From the publisher's feed

                                          “Winning the TBI Case” with Tom Crosley is a podcast created exclusively for plaintiff attorneys handling traumatic brain injury (TBI) cases. Each week, veteran trial attorney Tom Crosley shares…