Richard Caroll Jr. thought his Harlem apartment was a great deal when he moved in in 2004.
The artist said the natural light that spilled in through the living room windows made for a perfect painting studio. The rent was technically $2,000 a month, but the landlord let him pay $1,200, according to court records.
Carroll said there were no glaring issues at first. Then the stove stopped working, the windowsills decayed, the ceiling lights broke, the bedroom door fell off its hinges, and rats chewed through the wall under the kitchen sink.
In 2022, a landlord who bought the building after Carroll moved in tried to evict him, saying his lease had expired, even though he wasn’t behind in rent. It was only while fighting the eviction case that he learned his apartment had been rent-stabilized until he moved in. Court records show the prior tenant had been paying less than $500 a month, while Carroll’s rent climbed to $1,425.
“I was robbed for $1,000 a month for 20-something years. That’s how I felt,” Carroll said following the judge’s decision. “My apartment was in total decay. So, I paid an extra $1,000 a month for 20 years, and I didn’t even have a livable space.”