In this episode, Beard Laws discuss the tragic events that occurred on April 29th, 1989, in Lakeville, Indiana. The Pellies, a prominent family in the community, were found shot to death in their home. The main focus of the episode is on Jeff Pelly, the 17-year-old son of the family, who became a person of interest in the case. Despite maintaining his innocence, Jeff was eventually arrested and charged with the murders. The episode explores the evidence, the trial, and the controversy surrounding the case.
Episode Highlights
The Pellies, a prominent family in Lakeville, Indiana, were found shot to death in their home on April 29th, 1989.
Jeff Pelly, the 17-year-old son of the family, became a person of interest in the case due to inconsistencies in his alibi and suspicious behavior.
Despite maintaining his innocence, Jeff was arrested and charged with the murders. The prosecution argued that he killed his family in a fit of rage over his father's strict rules and an argument about prom night.
The case went cold for many years until advances in forensic technology led to a breakthrough in 2002. Jeff was found guilty of four counts of murder in 2006 and sentenced to 160 years in prison.
The case remains controversial, with some believing that justice was served and others arguing that the evidence was insufficient to convict Jeff beyond a reasonable doubt.
Episode Quotes
"We're talking about again, something a little bit dark. Prom night murders."
"The prosecution argued that Jeff had killed his family in a fit of rage over his father's strict rules in the argument about prom night."
"Jeff Pelley was found guilty of four counts of murder. He was sentenced to 160 years in prison."
Check out all the podcast on the Beard Laws Studio: https://beardlawsstudio.com
Check out the interactive map at https://yoretown.com
Chapters
00:00 The Tragic Events of April 29th, 1989
14:29 Jeff Pelly: A Person of Interest
25:14 The Legacy of the Case
Yore Town Podcast is a podcast that features your towns dark, wild, unbelievable past that has you thinking no way that really happened here. Matt and Zac dust off the books, hit the streets and an occasional nursing home to unveil Yore Town’s past. From small towns to where we live to big cities before they were what they are today. This is Yore Town, Yore Stories
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.