Insight Myanmar

You Down with NUG?


Listen Later

Episode #142: “What must a government do to be worthy of recognition?”  This is a question that Philipp Annawitt poses in a recent The Diplomat article, and discusses with Insight Myanmar Podcast vis-à-vis the NUG and its allies.

The concept of “legitimacy” has evolved in the past couple of centuries century. Considering the various strands of “legitimacy” standards in present-day Myanmar, Annawitt emphatically states that the military junta meets none of them. In contrast, he points out that the NUG (and its allies) carries out many of the commonly accepted, functional duties of a government in those areas of the country not under Tatmadaw control, and has even overseen security for civilians and administered justice in safe areas inside the country.


But not only have few nations recognized the NUG as Myanmar’s legitimate government, it has hardly shown even modicum of support, especially in the face of the junta’s obvious abuses and demonstrable inability to govern well. Annawitt calls this out as indefensible. 


The robust Burmese diaspora communities around the world have been more than doing their part to keep the NUG afloat. This connects to the unique and amazing spirit of collective sacrifice that characterizes the NUG, which includes tens of thousands of civil servants volunteering their time. Moreover, Annawaitt finds that this spirit of sacrifice becomes a political factor in determining future career opportunities, should the Tatmadaw be defeated.


That said, Annawitt also feels that the lack of wages for NUG’s civil servants is a serious issue with major ramifications that urgently needs addressing. Sustainability and the ability to fund all areas of the government are serious concerns. Given this situation, Annawitt envisions a big and urgent role for development partners to come in with financial resources and technical assistance. In fact, if more is not done to build up the government structures of the NUG, Annawitt cautions that there is little hope at any improvement for the country or its people, as the military leadership cares little for infrastructure beyond fattening their own pockets.


Still, the present situation is a long way from being a utopian federal democracy, and Annawitt acknowledges the NUG’s various shortcomings, including a lack consultation with ethnic allies and a convoluted decision-making process. But Annawitt repeatedly reminds us is that this is not a peacetime government or a mature federal system, but a functioning though transitory bureaucracy with limited resources, that at the same time is actively resisting a brutal military. “In the current situation, a pressure is there constantly,” he says. “Pressure for survival, security pressure, and communication is really difficult. And the demands, physically, health, psychologically, on all the actors, are overwhelming.”

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Insight MyanmarBy Insight Myanmar Podcast

  • 4.7
  • 4.7
  • 4.7
  • 4.7
  • 4.7

4.7

51 ratings


More shows like Insight Myanmar

View all
Democracy Now! Audio by Democracy Now!

Democracy Now! Audio

5,640 Listeners

The Interview by BBC World Service

The Interview

368 Listeners

Global Dispatches -- World News That Matters by Global Dispatches

Global Dispatches -- World News That Matters

309 Listeners

Intelligence Squared by Intelligence Squared

Intelligence Squared

782 Listeners

The Inquiry by BBC World Service

The Inquiry

758 Listeners

GZERO World with Ian Bremmer by GZERO Media

GZERO World with Ian Bremmer

763 Listeners

The Take by Al Jazeera

The Take

479 Listeners

Your Undivided Attention by Tristan Harris and Aza Raskin, The Center for Humane Technology

Your Undivided Attention

1,483 Listeners

The Slow Newscast by The Observer

The Slow Newscast

176 Listeners

Hold Your Fire! by International Crisis Group

Hold Your Fire!

58 Listeners

The Inside Story Podcast by Al Jazeera

The Inside Story Podcast

136 Listeners

Ukrainecast by BBC News

Ukrainecast

402 Listeners

Ukraine: The Latest by The Telegraph

Ukraine: The Latest

1,816 Listeners

Myanmar Revolutionary Tales (တော်လှန်ခြင်းများနှင့်ခေတ်သစ်မြန်မာပြည်) by Insight Myanmar

Myanmar Revolutionary Tales (တော်လှန်ခြင်းများနှင့်ခေတ်သစ်မြန်မာပြည်)

4 Listeners

DVB English News by Democratic Voice of Burma

DVB English News

0 Listeners

What's Happening in Myanmar by Frontier Myanmar

What's Happening in Myanmar

2 Listeners