Brand New Day: The Heroic Trio vs. Madame Web

Koji and Andrew host the podcast You Gotta Love It with a “brand new day” theme, pairing spider/superhero films: hidden gem The Heroic Trio (1993, dir. Johnny To) and “Lovett” Madame Web (2024, dir. S.J. Clarkson). They summarize The Heroic Trio’s plot—babies stolen for an underworld master, three heroines (Michelle Yeoh, Anita Mui, Maggie Cheung) ultimately team up—and praise its Hong Kong wire-work action, genre-blending tone, cult history, and wild finale, while noting jarring child deaths and tonal whiplash. They compare origin-story exposition versus being dropped into a world, then discuss Madame Web’s muddled “pre-origin” premise, weak characterization, product placement, and unrealized potential around fate vs. choice and precognition, citing poor reviews but noting some visual moments, Adam Scott’s performance, and Koji’s daughter liking the future-vision and costumes. They end with “love it or leave it” prompts and tease future episodes (Coyote vs. Acme, Space Jam: A New Legacy, Hundreds of Beavers, 65).

00:00 Welcome to the Pod

01:11 Theme and Picks

01:50 Heroic Trio Setup

04:23 First Impressions

06:36 Cast and Context

09:56 Dynamite and Tone

14:59 Origins vs Drop In

18:46 Action Craft Talk

22:23 Cult Status and Finale

25:29 Shelf Respect Segment

28:04 Weekly Recs

30:37 Madame Web Roast

33:12 Plot Breakdown Begins

35:22 Dunking Then Praise

37:26 Fate Versus Choice

39:04 Fixing The Action

40:49 Origin Story Gaps

42:38 Responsibility Gives Power

43:42 Pepsi And Branding

46:28 Spider Verse Nods

48:54 Kid Review Notes

49:32 Style And Soundtrack

52:29 Budget Box Office

54:37 Critic Or Commenter

56:07 Scores And Wrap Up

59:20 Love It Or Leave It

01:01:28 Final Thoughts And Next

In this episode, Kohji and Andrew dive into the cinematic reinterpretation of Homer’s epic, The Odyssey, directed by Christopher Nolan. They explore the artistic choices, casting decisions, and thematic updates Nolan infused to make the story resonate with today’s audience, and debate the authenticity of such adaptations.

• The shift from traditional storytelling to a modernized adaptation with contemporary vernacular and accents

• Casting choices including star-studded cast and their implications for audience immersion

• Nolan’s simplification and reinterpretation of Odysseus’s character—from a tricky antihero to a more straightforward hero archetype

• The use of familiar actors to evoke real-world parallels and elevate the mythological storytelling

• The debate over historical and mythological accuracy versus artistic license in adaptations

• The influence of modern society’s diversity on casting and character portrayal

• The impact of perceived “dumbing down” of complex characters for broader appeal

• Conspiracy theories and controversies regarding box office manipulation and online review tactics

• The enduring power of storytelling, myth, and adaptation in contemporary film

• (00:00) - Introduction and the significance of Nolan's The Odyssey adaptation

• (01:34) - The importance of modern storytelling techniques in the film

• (03:24) - Historical debates surrounding Homer and the origins of The Odyssey

• (05:10) - Audience reactions and overall experience of the film

• (06:09) - Casting choices and their effect on viewer immersion

• (08:34) - Nolan's characterization of Odysseus as an antihero

• (11:03) - Modern vernacular to connect audiences to ancient themes

• (15:02) - The symbolism of Zeus’s Law and its contemporary relevance

• (18:07) - The use of accents and diversity in casting

• (21:08) - The controversy of “woke” casting and representation

• (27:17) - Analysis of star casting and actor choices

• (38:27) - Simplification of Odysseus’s character for narrative clarity

• (44:23) - Nuance and symbolism in mythological storytelling

• (48:32) - Artistic liberties and deviations from the original poem

• (52:35) - Adaptation vs. fidelity in myth and storytelling

• (57:05) - Movie ratings, conspiracy theories, and box office realities

• (65:16) - Hypothetical remakes and future reimaginings

• (69:51) - Final recommendations and closing thoughts

You Gotta Love It: The Fall (Hidden Gem) and Clash of the Titans (2010)

Koji and Andrew Patterson introduce You Gotta Love It while discussing poor Toronto air quality from forest fire runoff, then preview an episode themed around Christopher Nolan’s upcoming The Odyssey, which they have tickets to see in 70mm IMAX. Their hidden gem is Tarsem Singh’s The Fall (festival 2006; wider US 2008), set in the 1920s and starring Lee Pace and Catinca Untaru, about an injured stuntman who tells a six-year-old a fantasy epic to manipulate her into helping him obtain means to end his life, only for her imagination to reshape the story and ultimately push him toward living; they praise its visuals, child performance authenticity, and real-world locations shot across 20+ countries, with Tarsem largely self-financing. Their “you gotta love it” is the 2010 Clash of the Titans remake (Louis Leterrier), criticized for plotting, action, and post-production 3D; they note strong cast/design elements, shaky-cam issues, and score it around 6–7/10, debate remakes and man-vs-gods themes, play “critic or commenter,” and tease a next episode on Madame Web and The Heroic Trio (1993).

00:00 Botched Cold Open

00:28 Toronto Smoke Talk

01:48 Episode Theme Setup

02:44 The Fall Premise

05:17 Storytelling Layers

08:27 Why It Hooks You

10:29 Child Actor Magic

15:03 Meaning of the Falls

17:29 How It Was Made

22:01 Ending and Spoilers

23:36 Why It Was Overlooked

26:19 Shelf Respect Segment

27:54 Book Recommendation

29:40 Clash Intro and Stats

33:08 Plot Breakdown

35:42 What Works Design

38:03 Pacing and Ruthlessness

39:47 Stacked Cast Talk

40:13 Sam Worthington That Guy

43:04 Campy Greek Drama

46:23 Remakes Love Or Leave

50:40 Clash Scores Breakdown

52:56 Final Verdict And Box Office

55:31 Themes Fate And Hubris

57:54 3D Shaky Cam And Wigs

01:01:48 Critic Or Commenter Game

01:03:36 Recommendations And Next Episode

This week's episode is all about dystopian babes with questionable superpowers. Kohji and Andrew dig into two gloriously unhinged '90s/2000s guilty pleasures: the grimy, Heavy Metal-inspired cult classic Barb Wire, starring Pamela Anderson as a mercenary nightclub owner who really doesn't want to be called "babe," and the notoriously maligned Catwoman (2004), starring Halle Berry as a resurrected, catnip-obsessed corporate whistleblower turned superhero. Plus: Tank Girl gets a shelf-respect shoutout, a new "Critic or Commenter" segment puts Roger Ebert head-to-head with internet reviewers, and the guys debate whether sexualized action heroines can ever really have agency.

Show Notes

• Intro & Supergirl chatter — is it this year's Mordecai?

• Barb Wire (1996): a Casablanca remake nobody asked for, its Heavy Metal comic energy, practical '90s effects, and Udo Kier's unhinged Curly

• Shelf Respect segment: Tank Girl and its comic-book roots

• Catwoman (2004): origin story breakdown, the infamous "walk," basketball scene, toxic beauty industry themes, and the movie's tonal whiplash

• Critic or Commenter: guessing game featuring a real Roger Ebert quote

• Love It or Leave It: makeovers, Catwoman movies, dystopian B-movies, screwball tonal shifts, and sexualized leads in action films

• Recommendations: The Death of Robin Hood and Adolescence

• Next episode preview: The Fall and Clash of the Titans (2010)

Disclosure Day Theme: The Vast of Night (Hidden Gem) and Knowing (You Gotta Respect It) Koji and Andrew Patterson return to You Gotta Love It and announce a new themed-episode format tied to Spielberg’s “Disclosure Day,” pairing the hidden gem The Vast of Night with the “you gotta love it” pick Knowing. They catch up on life (Andrew finishing an MFA and moving back from New York; Koji watching movies with his nearly six-year-old and collecting 4K discs), then discuss The Vast of Night as a slow-burn, Twilight Zone–styled 1950s UFO mystery with real-time dialogue, long takes, and themes of ignored voices (teens, Black characters, the elderly). A new “Shelf Respect” segment spotlights Jordan Peele’s Nope on 4K; Andrew recommends Canadian sci-fi horror Cube. They break down Knowing (2009), its disaster set pieces, fate vs. choice, religious symbolism, and divisive ending, rate it “you gotta respect it,” note its box-office success, play “love it or leave it,” invite listener suggestions, tease future episode ideas, and close with thoughts on whether aliens exist or could be imperceptible.

In this episode we talk about Joker: Folie à Deux and Strange Darling

In this episode we talk about Everything Everywhere All at Once and Morbius

The hidden gem for the week is The Suicide Squad (2021) and the You Gotta Love It is Thunder Force

This weeks hidden gem is Vivarium and the You Gotta Love It is Mortal Kombat 2021

In this episode we discuss Bo Burnham's Inside and the pandemic so far