What’s a surefire way make your next podcast episode better than your last? A perfectly crafted prompt. Duh. You might be thinking about your flow, time management, or how the guest shines when you have someone on.
Today, I’m sharing how I use a simple system, including an AI transcript grading tool, to get clear, specific feedback.
There’s a prompt that goes beyond general notes and gives you a real grade,
Why I won’t move forward if my work is below a B,
And how you can use the same approach for your own show or creative work.
Here’s the direct prompt I said I’d share. Copy/paste and implement it into your workflow.
“Please grade the attached transcript on a scale of A to F on the following criteria: relevance to Your Mic's audience of aspiring and new podcasters, preparedness, flow, value for the audience, and time management. Your Mic is Speke Podcasting's educational arm, where I as the founder do solo rants to supplement expert interviews. The goal is to have people hear different POVs. Different takes on some of the stuff I may have covered in previous episodes. It's about building a world for hosts to thrive in.”
Subscribe to Your Mic on YouTube, Apple, Spotify or wherever you get your podcasts.
Shoot Freddy an email: [email protected].
Key Takeaways
1. Freddy emphasizes the importance of getting detailed, actionable feedback—specifically graded evaluations—before moving forward with creating new podcast episodes. This ensures the quality and relevance of each episode, helping hosts continually improve.
2. Freddy advocates using AI tools like Perplexity, ChatGPT, or Claude to grade podcast transcripts. Leveraging AI for this purpose provides objective and structured critiques on specific criteria, aiding podcasters in refining their content.
3. Freddy provides a thorough list of criteria to use when grading transcripts: relevance to the audience, preparedness, flow, rapport (especially with guests), letting guests shine, value for the audience, and time management. Using these focused standards helps ensure episodes consistently meet listeners' needs.
4. Freddy shares his personal threshold: he will not publish solo rants or posts if an episode transcript is graded below a B. He recognizes the importance of maintaining high standards and avoiding mediocrity in both his own work and client work.
5. Freddy offers to share his exact feedback prompt, encouraging listeners to try it themselves and to reach out if they need help. This openness fosters a supportive community and empowers other creators to use precise, actionable feedback in their own creative processes.