What's it like to be a New York Times Bestseller?
It's a momentous time for the 12 x 12 membership and so we bring you a momentous podcast episode!
During the first week of August 2026, not one but TWO 12 x 12 member books were on the New York Times Bestseller List for Children's Picture Books (August 2, 2026). Considering that any book currently in print from Dr. Seuss. Maurice Sendak, and Margaret Wise Brown to award-winners and everything released this year, it's quite an accomplishment to land on the bestseller list.
Congratulations go to 12 x 12 members Kari Lavelle and Michael Benner!
Published by Sourcebooks Explore, Kari's nonfiction picture book BUTT OR FACE landed at number 7 after being in print for 3 years. Illustrated by the incredible Alison Hawkins and published by Orchard/Scholastic, Michael's picture book MAC & CHEESE: THE ORIGIN STORY debuted at #1 the week it came out!!
Two very exciting journeys starting at two very different places. Today, we hear how these bestsellers came to be!
Here's what you'll discover in this episode:
- How Julie & Kelli found out about TWO members being on the NYT Bestseller List
- Who helped BUTT OR FACE land on the list
- What books you're competing with to get on the list
- The role Michael's publisher played in getting MAC AND CHEESE to the #1 spot
- How funny books attract sales
- How YOU can help an author make it on the bestseller list
- The importance of pre-order sales
- How Barnes & Noble supports pre-orders
- What's a frontlist title vs. a backlist title
- The surprising ways Michael and Kari found out the news
- Why BUTT OR FACE doesn't have an illustrator
- Puns for the win!
- The origin story of MAC AND CHEESE: THE ORIGIN STORY
- The different ways a book can find an audience
- What does it mean to be a publisher's "lead book"
- How Kari and Michael stay true to themselves when writing
- What's involved with having a special edition of your book for Barnes & Noble
- What it was like when Michael saw Alison's illustrations
- A look at the fun event kits created for MAC & CHEESE
- What it's like to work on a book that becomes a series and how to balance your creativity between projects
- The fun of read-alouds
- What books Kari and Michael wish they would have written
Books mentioned in this episode:
- BUTT OR FACE by Kari Lavelle
- MAC & CHEESE: THE ORIGIN STORY by Michael Benner and Alison Hawkins
- WE MOVE THE WORLD by Kari Lavelle and Nabi H. Ali
- ODE TO GRAPEFRUIT: HOW JAMES EARL JONES FOUND HIS VOICE by Kari Lavelle and Bryan Collier
- MILK AND COOKES: THE PERFECT PAIR by Michael Benner and Alison Hawkins
- E-MERGENCY by Tom Lichtenheld and Ezra Fields-Meyer
- WHILE WE'RE HERE BY Anne Wynter and Micha Archer
Links mentioned in this episode:
- See the video for this episode on YouTube
- Picture Book Summit's Home Page
If you enjoy the podcast, please like, subscribe, and review so other kidlit writers can find us!
Have questions for us or ideas for future episodes? Leave us a quick voicemail here.
Thank you for listening!