Send us a text

On this week’s The Hot Slice Podcast, Executive Editor Denise Greer chats with Peter Falzo, owner of Vinnie’s Pan Pizza in Millburn, New Jersey. Peter created Vinnie’s to honor his uncle who owned a successful pizza restaurant for decades.

Peter shares his story of transforming his Italian restaurant into a high-demand carryout pizzeria. He details how he created Vinnie’s Pan Pizza brand and vital tenants to allow it to thrive.

Vinnie’s has received high marks local and nationally for its unique take on pan/bar pie. The pizza garnered such a reputation that Dave Portnoy gave it 8.3 score out of 10 on his Barstools Pizza Review. The review sparked an infusion of new interest in the pizzeria. Peter reveals what happened at the restaurant after the review and tips for other restaurants who receive a visit from Portnoy.

Learn more about Vinnie’s Pan Pizza at https://www.vinniespanpizza.com/, on Instagram at https://www.instagram.com/vinniespanpizza/ and on TikTok at https://www.tiktok.com/discover/vinnies-pan-pizza-nj.

Thanks to our sound engineer and designer Katie Wilson.