
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


A lot of people believe that before the 17th amendment, state legislatures had the power to recall and replace senators in congress. But that’s nothing more than a myth. Records from the ratification debates show that this power never existed under the Constitution.
Path to Liberty: August 23, 2024
Subscribe: Apple | Spotify | Podbean | Youtube Music | Stitcher | TuneIn | RSS | More Platforms Here
SHOW LINKS:
Show Archives
Articles of Confederation – Article V
Philadelphia Convention (12 June 1787)
Edmund Randolph – Philadelphia Convention (16 June 1787)
Elbridge Gerry – Philadelphia Convention (14 Aug 1787)
Alexander Hamilton – New York Ratifying Convention (24 June 1788)
Theophilus Parsons – Massachusetts Ratifying Convention (23 Jan 1788)
Alexander Hamilton – New York Ratifying Convention (25 June 1788)
Patrick Henry – Virginia Ratifying Convention (12 June 1788)
Federal Farmer X (7 Jan 1788)
Luther Martin – Genuine Information IV (8 Jan 1788)
Dr. Taylor – Massachusetts Ratifying Convention (14 Jan 1788)
Col William Jones – Massachusetts Ratifying Convention (19 Jan 1788)
Major Martin Kingsley – Massachusetts Ratifying Convention (21 Jan 1788)
Gilbert Livingston – New York Ratifying Convention (24 June 1788)
John Lansing – New York Ratifying Convention (24 June 1788)
Ratification of the Constitution by the State of New York (26 July 1788)
Amendments Proposed by Rhode Island (29 May 1790)
James Barbour – Letter to James Madison (11 Dec 1807)
George Mason – Virginia Ratifying Convention (16 June 1788)
Episode – The Imperial Senate: Anti-Federalist Warnings
Episode – 17th Amendment: Did it Destroy the Structure of the Constitution?
MORE VIDEO SOURCES
Watch on Odysee
Watch on X
Watch on Minds
Watch on Facebook
Watch on Bitchute
Watch on Brighteon
Watch on TikTok
Watch on LinkedIn
FOLLOW and SUPPORT TAC:
Become a Member: https://tenthamendmentcenter.com/members/
The post 17th Amendment Myth Busted: There was no Recall Power appeared first on Tenth Amendment Center.
By Tenth Amendment Center4.9
182182 ratings
A lot of people believe that before the 17th amendment, state legislatures had the power to recall and replace senators in congress. But that’s nothing more than a myth. Records from the ratification debates show that this power never existed under the Constitution.
Path to Liberty: August 23, 2024
Subscribe: Apple | Spotify | Podbean | Youtube Music | Stitcher | TuneIn | RSS | More Platforms Here
SHOW LINKS:
Show Archives
Articles of Confederation – Article V
Philadelphia Convention (12 June 1787)
Edmund Randolph – Philadelphia Convention (16 June 1787)
Elbridge Gerry – Philadelphia Convention (14 Aug 1787)
Alexander Hamilton – New York Ratifying Convention (24 June 1788)
Theophilus Parsons – Massachusetts Ratifying Convention (23 Jan 1788)
Alexander Hamilton – New York Ratifying Convention (25 June 1788)
Patrick Henry – Virginia Ratifying Convention (12 June 1788)
Federal Farmer X (7 Jan 1788)
Luther Martin – Genuine Information IV (8 Jan 1788)
Dr. Taylor – Massachusetts Ratifying Convention (14 Jan 1788)
Col William Jones – Massachusetts Ratifying Convention (19 Jan 1788)
Major Martin Kingsley – Massachusetts Ratifying Convention (21 Jan 1788)
Gilbert Livingston – New York Ratifying Convention (24 June 1788)
John Lansing – New York Ratifying Convention (24 June 1788)
Ratification of the Constitution by the State of New York (26 July 1788)
Amendments Proposed by Rhode Island (29 May 1790)
James Barbour – Letter to James Madison (11 Dec 1807)
George Mason – Virginia Ratifying Convention (16 June 1788)
Episode – The Imperial Senate: Anti-Federalist Warnings
Episode – 17th Amendment: Did it Destroy the Structure of the Constitution?
MORE VIDEO SOURCES
Watch on Odysee
Watch on X
Watch on Minds
Watch on Facebook
Watch on Bitchute
Watch on Brighteon
Watch on TikTok
Watch on LinkedIn
FOLLOW and SUPPORT TAC:
Become a Member: https://tenthamendmentcenter.com/members/
The post 17th Amendment Myth Busted: There was no Recall Power appeared first on Tenth Amendment Center.

3,964 Listeners

3,368 Listeners

4,884 Listeners

2,265 Listeners

964 Listeners

1,145 Listeners

757 Listeners

8,203 Listeners

484 Listeners

905 Listeners

1,209 Listeners

5,308 Listeners

2,378 Listeners

670 Listeners

9,007 Listeners