X's and Joe's

[23.5] We've Seen This Before: Assessing the Current State of Indiana Basketball


Listen Later

Hosts Bob Moats and Mike Wiemuth provide an emergency analysis of Indiana University basketball's current state following concerning recent losses and program developments.

Segment 1

After briefly discussing their recent trip to Philadelphia and the historic Palestra, they examine the underlying factors contributing to IU's current struggles:

  • The unique nature of Mike Woodson's hiring and the dual expectations he faced
  • Early successes in his first two years followed by concerning regression in year three
  • Recruitment challenges, including going 0-31 on top-100 guard offers and losing key commitments


Segment 2

The hosts provide detailed analysis of ten key indicators that typically signal problems for a coaching tenure, based on Mike Wiemuth's research into coaching transitions:

  1. Lack of winning relative to expectations: Despite a 14-5 record, recent blowout losses and struggles against top competition are concerning
  2. Underperformance against rivals/contemporaries: Particularly notable given Purdue's success and recent losses to programs like Louisville
  3. Erosion of trust with local coaching networks: Limited engagement with high school and AAU coaches, with many lacking direct contact with the staff
  4. Declining attendance: Notable student section departures during games and increasingly visible empty seats
  5. Loss of attraction with high-impact recruits: Going 0-31 on top-100 guard offers and losing key commitments like Liam McNeely
  6. Increased media speculation: Growing national coverage questioning the program's direction
  7. Staff stability concerns: While more stable than previous struggling tenures, signs of stress appearing
  8. Social media sentiment: Reaching concerning 3-to-1 negative to positive ratio thresholds
  9. Negative program leaks: Increasing behind-the-scenes stories emerging
  10. Vocal fan displeasure: Growing audible frustration at home games, which research shows is often a late-stage indicator

The hosts note that these indicators tend to build on each other, creating momentum that becomes increasingly difficult to reverse.


Segment 3 and wrap up

The hosts discuss how to approach the remainder of the season as fans:

  • Acknowledge that events are largely beyond fan control
  • Understand that while turnarounds are possible, they become increasingly improbable
  • Root for the current players while being realistic about the situation
  • Recognize that significant changes may be coming regardless of late-season results

Throughout the episode, they emphasize providing analytical context rather than advocacy, helping fans understand the mechanics and patterns of college basketball programs during challenging transitions.

The episode ends with some lighter discussion of their recent Philadelphia trip, including authentic cheesesteaks and the historic Palestra.

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

X's and Joe'sBy Back Home Network

  • 4.6
  • 4.6
  • 4.6
  • 4.6
  • 4.6

4.6

19 ratings


More shows like X's and Joe's

View all
Podcast on the Brink by Inside the Hall

Podcast on the Brink

400 Listeners

The Peegs Podcast by The Peegs Podcast

The Peegs Podcast

189 Listeners

CrimsonCast by CrimsonCast

CrimsonCast

126 Listeners

The Assembly Call IU Basketball Podcast and Postgame Show by Jerod Morris

The Assembly Call IU Basketball Podcast and Postgame Show

14 Listeners

Hoosier Huddle Podcast by College Huddle

Hoosier Huddle Podcast

45 Listeners

Indiana Sports Beat Radio with Jim Coyle by Jim Coyle

Indiana Sports Beat Radio with Jim Coyle

36 Listeners

Hoosier Morning After by Chad Schwartzkopf

Hoosier Morning After

2 Listeners

Mind Your Banners by Indy Star

Mind Your Banners

12 Listeners

House Of Hoosier: An Indiana Basketball Podcast by The Field of 68, Blue Wire

House Of Hoosier: An Indiana Basketball Podcast

243 Listeners

Locked On Hoosiers - Daily Podcast On Indiana Hoosiers Football & Basketball by Locked On Podcast Network, Jacob Goins

Locked On Hoosiers - Daily Podcast On Indiana Hoosiers Football & Basketball

69 Listeners

The Hoosier Hysterics Podcast by The Varsity Podcast Network

The Hoosier Hysterics Podcast

127 Listeners

Doing The Work by Jeff Marlow and Kathy Amos

Doing The Work

13 Listeners

East 17th Street by Mike Schumann

East 17th Street

5 Listeners

Football Weather by Back Home Network

Football Weather

14 Listeners

The Big Red Carpet by Rhett Lewis

The Big Red Carpet

9 Listeners