This week, we turn our focus close to home with a case that has haunted our community of La Grande, Oregon for decades— the Candy Cane Park murder.

 In 1983, Dana Dumars was brutally attacked in a place most locals once associated with safety, laughter, and childhood memories. Until the murder. The arrest and conviction of Bart Cochran brought relief to this small community, but did the police get the right person? 

The case quickly became marked with questionable investigative methods, which led to an appeal, resulting in Barts release after his conviction was overturned. Central to that appeal were concerns about use of hypnosis, mind control, "Projection Transfer  Technique" trickery, and claims that evidence might have been planted. Questions were also raised about the Cochran's vulnerability during the interrogation, and his requests for representation being ignored. 

While the murder of Dana Dumars remains unsolved, we look ahead to the possibility that modern DNA science could finally give justice in a case that has cast a shadow on this community far too long. 

Sources: 

M.J. Smith, N. R. Smith, N. Witten, A. Rasheed, (Personal communication, Nov. 12, 2025)

Goldberg, Emma. "A Twist in the Candy Cane Park Murder Investigation in Oregon" - The New York Times, Oct 28, 2025.

Appellate Brief "State V. Cochran, Court of Appeals of Oregon, June 25, 1984

Sharpe, Franklin, "The Brunette was Bludgeoned in Candy Cane Park", Front Page Detective, Dec. 1983

Findagrave.com

La Grande, (AP) Observer, Feb 14, 1983 and Feb 15, 1983

 

Message us!

Hello spooky crew! Our tote bag drawing is officially closed, and we just want to say a massive thank-you to everyone who entered. We're so grateful for the love and support!

Missed the tote? No worries, we are still sending out high-quality vinyl stickers while supplies last. Just email us proof of your rating and review along with your mailing address to thespookydarlings.gmail.com, and we will get one headed your way. 

And, just to put your mind at ease, we promise you

There's still time to get a Spooky Darlings sticker. Just email us proof of your rating and review to [email protected]. Bummed about missing out on the tote? We've got you! Treat yourself to a perusal of our merch store at thespookydarlings.printful.me. You deserve it! 

Thanks for listening to The Spooky Darlings! If you have a creepy, strange, or cool story you would like to share email us at [email protected].

Follow us on instagram and TikTok @thespookydarlingspodcast for more!

Peruse our merch store at https://thespookydarlings.printful.me/