Rob and Joe return from the bachelor weekend and some may not have recovered yet. Joe has gotten very little sleep since Friday, but it was Rob who was the first of many to learn that you shouldn't gamble when you are tired. There's a lot of money riding on Ohio State, but Katie's father eclipses the game with his own free throw demonstration. Not everyone appreciates the murder mystery troupes cruel way of playing Quiplash. Being influenced by others, Joe makes the first of many gambling errors betting on the Maryland/LSU game. Rob on the other hand finally wins when he decides to ignore a suggested parlay. Joe becomes the talk of the poker room by making two critical errors at the table. Meanwhile someone calls Justin's bluff, but not in a card game. Many legendary stories were repeated over the weekend, Rob highlights one. Former landlord Dave contends with an elevator and a woman with an interesting career. Joe has an awkward moment with one of the hotel staff. Rob's sleep is disturbed by people trying to get into his room. Later he offers a beer to a stranger and immediately realizes this was a mistake. Katie is going to a housewarming party and is on the fence about whether or not she wants Joe to accompany her.

Aired Live Monday, March 25th at 7:45PM