To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
For most of my life, I carried a quiet fear beneath the surface of my faith; a fear of hell. Not just the concept of it, but the unsettling idea that God might actually send people there forever. It didn’t sit right with me. It never had. But I believed it anyway, because I thought I had to. It was what good Christians believed, right? It was “the truth”.
Still, that nagging dissonance followed me everywhere. How could a God who is love create a system where most of His children are doomed from birth? How could an all-powerful, all-loving Creator either fail to save us or choose not to? Why did he hate me so much for being just what he made me to be?
Then, in my mid-30s, I stumbled across Christian Universalism. I wasn’t looking for a new doctrine. I just wanted the truth. I had given up on the Christianity of my youth being right. When I found Christian Universalism, something deep inside me lit up. This is it, I thought. This is the truth I knew in my heart all along.
Two Gospels, Both Incomplete
To understand why Christian Universalism is hopeful and theologically sound, we first need to explore the two dominant views on salvation that have shaped the church for centuries. You’re probably familiar with them even though you might not know their names.
Arminianism: Love Without Power
Arminianism, named after the 16th-century Dutch theologian Jacobus Arminius, teaches that:
* God genuinely loves all people.
* Jesus died for the sins of the whole world.
* Salvation is offered freely to everyone.
* But humans have free will, and many will reject God's offer.
* Eternal separation from God (hell) is the result of human choice, not divine decree.
What Arminians get right: They rightly emphasize God's universal love and the inclusiveness of Christ's atonement. Verses like John 3:16, 1 Timothy 2:4, and 2 Peter 3:9 strongly support the idea that God's desire is for everyone to be saved.
What Arminians get wrong: They render God ultimately powerless in matters of salvation. If human will can override divine will, then God wants to save all, but tragically cannot. That turns salvation into a fragile negotiation. Human stubbornness trumps divine grace. God wants to save all. But since he gave us the “gift” of free will, we are free to reject him. I contend that anyone in their right mind who truly knew God could not resist him forever. This is something the Calvinists got right (keep reading).
It also raises a troubling question: If God knew billions would reject Him and suffer eternally, why create them in the first place? That’s a big risk!
Calvinism: Power Without Universal Love
On the other end of the spectrum is Calvinism, rooted in the teachings of John Calvin. Calvinism insists on God's total sovereignty and uses the acronym TULIP to summarize its core doctrines:
* Total Depravity: Every part of human nature is affected by sin; we are incapable of saving ourselves.
* Unconditional Election: God chooses whom to save, not based on anything we've done, but according to His will.
* Limited Atonement: Christ died only for the elect, not for all humanity.
* Irresistible Grace: When God chooses to save someone, they will respond to His call.
* Perseverance of the Saints: Those whom God saves will endure in faith and never finally fall away.
What Calvinists get right: They affirm God's sovereignty—His will is not frustrated, and His purposes always stand (Isaiah 46:10). They rightly point out that God is irresistible.
What Calvinists get wrong: They drastically narrow the scope of God's love. If Christ died only for some, and the rest are predestined for eternal torment, then God’s character is called into question. Why create billions of people only to damn them? This view makes God the author of a cosmic tragedy. It’s a cruel God who creates beings he knows are bound only for torment. That’s deeply at odds with the picture of a God who is love (1 John 4:8).
The Middle We’ve Missed: What If God Can Save All And Wants to?
Now that we've examined both frameworks, something becomes clear:
* Arminianism affirms God’s love but denies His ultimate power.
* Calvinism affirms God’s power but denies His universal love.
But Scripture tells us both are true:
* God is all-powerful.
* God does desire all to be saved.
So what if the error is not in believing one or the other, but in thinking we have to choose?
Christian Universalism takes both truths seriously. It affirms God's love and His power. It trusts that when Scripture says God wants to save everyone, and that His will is never thwarted, we can believe that means… everyone.
The Absurdity We’ve Accepted
If we take a step back, the picture many of us were taught begins to look less like justice and more like a tragic contradiction.
We’re told that God is love. He is the Good Shepherd who leaves the ninety-nine to rescue the one. He is the Father who runs toward the prodigal while he is still a long way off. And yet, this same God, in most Christian doctrines, creates billions of people knowing they will end up in eternal torment. The Arminian God doesn’t know who wil be lost. The Calvinist God doesn’t care.
Some say hell wasn’t made for us—it was made for Satan and his angels. But that only kicks the can down the road. If God created Satan, knowing what he would become, then God created the conditions for eternal suffering. He built the system. He set the trap. And if God is sovereign, as Arminians and Calvinists believe, He could undo it.
So why doesn’t He?
The common answer is that God’s holiness demands justice. He must punish sin with eternal fire. But this only deepens the absurdity. What kind of justice is eternal conscious torment? What loving Father would allow, let alone decree, infinite suffering for finite failure?
If your theology requires a cosmic torture chamber to satisfy God's character, maybe it's time to reconsider what kind of God you believe in.
What If God's Judgment Isn't the End?
Christian Universalism doesn't deny judgment—it redefines its purpose.
Yes, Scripture speaks of fire. But fire in the Bible often purifies, not punishes. Think of the refiner’s fire in Malachi, or the consuming fire of God’s presence in Hebrews. Judgment then isn’t eternal damnation—it’s the beginning of restoration.
“When I am lifted up from the earth, I will draw all people to myself.” — John 12:32“For as in Adam all die, so in Christ all will be made alive.” — 1 Corinthians 15:22“God has bound everyone over to disobedience so that he may have mercy on them all.” — Romans 11:32
What if judgment is part of the healing process? What if even the hardest hearts are not lost forever, but slowly, surely drawn back to the source of all love? Why would God be limited by time, space, or even human “free will”?
That doesn’t erase human agency. It honors it. It just trusts that in the end, love will win, not by force but by God’s faithfulness patiently wooing us to Godself.
A God Who Actually Gets What He Wants
Let’s return to that original tension.
* If God wants to save all...
* And God’s will cannot be thwarted...
* Then the only logical conclusion is: God will save all.
This is the heart of Christian Universalism.
It doesn’t flatten the Gospel. It fulfills it. It doesn’t ignore sin. It puts it in perspective. It doesn’t erase justice. It completes it in mercy.
Because a God who can save all, and wants to save all… is a God who will.
The Gospel That Finally Made Sense
When I first encountered Christian Universalism, I wasn’t looking to rewrite my faith. I was trying to make sense of a God who claimed to be love, but seemed to act otherwise.
What I found wasn’t just a different doctrine. It was a deeper truth. A Gospel that finally aligned with everything I felt in my spirit, but never knew how to say out loud.
This is the truth I knew in my heart all along.
What If You Let Yourself Hope?
What if God is better than you were told?What if love really does win, not in spite of justice, but through it?What if every soul ultimately finds its way Home?
If this stirred something in you, don’t ignore it. Question what you've inherited. Explore the heart of God with fresh eyes. And most of all—hope.
Because maybe, just maybe, that hope is the Holy Spirit whispering:This is it. This is the truth you’ve known all along.
Thanks for reading. Paid subscribers get access to scriptures for further reflection and additional resources.
Thanks for reading. If this article challenged, encouraged, or comforted you, I invite you to share it with someone who may need to hear it. And I’d love to hear your thoughts in the comments.
🙏 Thank you for being here. Your presence means more than you know. If my words have offered you comfort, insight, or a moment of clarity, consider supporting my work.Your paid subscription or a one-time tip helps keep me sharing stories, tools, and reflections to guide others through grief and growth.
Together, we’re expanding consciousness—one heart at a time. 💛
Scripture References for Further Reflection
These verses offer a glimpse into the fullness of God’s love, will, and redemptive purpose:
* God's desire to save all:
* 1 Timothy 2:4
* 2 Peter 3:9
* Ezekiel 18:23, 32
* God’s sovereignty and the fulfillment of His will:
* Isaiah 46:10
* Job 42:2
* The universal reach of Christ’s work:
* John 12:32
* 1 John 2:2
* 1 Corinthians 15:22
* Romans 11:32
* Philippians 2:10–11
* God’s refining judgment and restorative purpose:
* Malachi 3:2–3
* Hebrews 12:29
* Revelation 21:5
Further Reading & Resources
* Tentmaker.org — Articles, scripture studies, and testimonies from a Christian Universalist perspective.
* Book: The Inescapable Love of God by Thomas Talbott — A philosophical and theological case for Universalism.
* Book: Christianity Without Insanity by Boyd C. Purcell — A pastoral and psychological perspective on letting go of fear-based theology.
Thanks for reading. If this article challenged, encouraged, or comforted you, I invite you to share it with someone who may need to hear it. And I’d love to hear your thoughts in the comments.
🙏 Thank you for being here. Your presence means more than you know. If my words have offered you comfort, insight, or a moment of clarity, consider supporting my work.Your paid subscription or a one-time tip helps keep me sharing stories, tools, and reflections to guide others through grief and growth.
Together, we’re expanding consciousness—one heart at a time. 💛
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit grief2growth.substack.com/subscribe
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit grief2growth.substack.com/subscribe