This week on See You On The Internet, we’re talking about Taylor Swift’s The Life of a Showgirl — and spoiler alert: it’s fine. Just… fine.

After spending last week unpacking her marketing era, we’re back to give our full review of the album — track by track. From The Fate of Ophelia (and Taylor’s questionable interpretation of Shakespeare) to Eldest Daughter (which deserved better) to Actually Romantic (aka the alleged Charli XCX diss track), we get into all of it.

We also talk about how The Life of a Showgirl feels more like Crescent City 3 than Reputation, why fans might finally be hitting their Taylor fatigue era, and what happens when the queen of Easter eggs becomes her own biggest mystery.

Basically: we love her, we’re disappointed, and we can’t stop talking about it.