Originally Aired: May 2, 1934
Calling All Cars #23, "Murder at Southgate," presents Chief Eugene Mueller of the Southgate Police Department investigating the first murder in his city's history. When two young visitors from Washington, Marjorie Barr and Rose Hammond, return to their friend Laura Stevens' home in Southgate, they find a group of drunken sailors inside waiting for Laura. The sailors, including Bob, Bill, Pete, and one nicknamed "the snake," have broken into the house and are drinking heavily. Rose becomes frightened by their increasingly aggressive behavior and locks herself in a bedroom, while Marjorie decides to stay and party with the men.
As the evening progresses and the sailors grow more intoxicated, Rose's fears prove justified. Around 10:30 PM, she hears a violent confrontation outside her locked bedroom door, including someone saying "You didn't have to hit her, did you?" followed by the men fleeing the scene. Terrified by what has transpired, Rose escapes through the bedroom window to seek help. Chief Mueller and his small-town force must now solve a brutal crime committed by transient criminals in their quiet residential community.