Amy Mihaljevic

TIPS: 440-871-1234

The thing is, that October 27, 1989, was just like any other day in northeast Ohio up until those first reports of a missing girl from Bay Village hit the news around 10 o’clock. The city and the citizens felt like they had been punched in the gut. How could one of their own be taken right out from under the noses of the public, across from the police station nonetheless? As the days progressed, new information was being released regularly, with the most important being that of this phone caller who had potentially lured Amy to the plaza that Friday afternoon. The information about this phone call was given by two of Amy’s friends, who had been told of the plan on the meeting day. In speaking with Chief Spaetzel, these kids were able to provide a few very significant details, one of the most essential being that Amy was told she had $45 to spend and that if there was any money left over, she could also get a gift.

Suppose you would like to help support this podcast. In that case, you can donate via the Venmo app with my username @bill-huffman-3.

If you have any information regarding Amy's murder, please get in touch with the Bay Village Police Department @ 440-871-1234 or the FBI @ 1-800-Call-FBI.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices