
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


Amy keeps it light this week with multiple stories that explore the Third Man Phenomenon. Then, because everyone needs a well-balanced podcast, Monique goes extra dark and hits it out of the park with the deeply traumatizing story of baseball player, Marty Bergen. If you liked this episode, please take a moment to rate, review, and subscribe.
Join OurPatreon!
Check Out OurWebsite!
Follow Us OnInstagram!
Monique gets the party started with Theresa’s nightmare-inducing experiences with “her.” Then, Amy covers the various illegal activities of the head of Missouri Medical College, Dr. Joseph Nash McDowell. Was McDowell just a quirky eccentric, or, as Monique repeatedly speculates, completely coked out? You decide. If you liked this episode, please take a moment to rate, review, and subscribe.
Join OurPatreon!
Check Out OurWebsite!
Follow Us OnInstagram!
Monique starts us off with the first known real life gothic ghost story: the haunting of Hinton Ampner. Then, luckily for all of us, Amy goes rogue this week, with not 1 but 2 stories of man-eating tigers! Fuck. Yes. If you liked this episode, please take a moment to rate, review, and subscribe.Join Our Patreon!
Check Out Our Website!
Follow Us On Instagram!
Monique covers the creepy and unsettling circumstances surrounding the death of Christopher Case. Then, Amy recounts Wayne & Mary Hale’s harrowing and nightmare-inducing experience with the Macdona train accident. If you liked this episode, please take a moment to rate, review, and subscribe.
Join Our Patreon!
Check Out Our Website!
Follow Us On Instagram!
Amy starts us off with the phone call 9-11 dispatcher, Rebecca, will never forget. Then Monique gets into how Cynthia Guy Thomas handles her divorce from her husband, Terry. Spoiler: NOT WELL. If you liked this episode, please take a moment to rate, review, and subscribe.Join Our Patreon!
Check Out Our Website!
Follow Us On Instagram!
Amy continues our journey through the Twilight Zone with the unsettling story of Tanna Leggett’s doppelgänger. Then Monique covers the sweetest and worst counterfeiter in US history, Emerich Juettner. If you liked this episode, please take a moment to rate, review, and subscribe.
Join Our Patreon!
Check Out Our Website!
Follow Us On Instagram!
Happy New Year, kids! Monique starts things off in Appalachia with Chuck’s experiences with the Demon Dog of Valle Crucis. Then, Amy covers the unbridled audacity of Zsuzsanna Fazekas and the Angel Makers. If you liked this episode, please take a moment to rate, review, and subscribe.Join Our Patreon!
Check Out Our Website!
Follow Us On Instagram!
In our last episode of 2024, Amy starts things off with, arguably, the most adorable alien story of all time. Then, Monique dives into the ridiculous antics of Florida Man, Derrick Irving. If you liked this episode, please take a moment to rate, review, and subscribe.
Join Our Patreon!
Check Out Our Website!
Follow Us On Instagram!
Because psychic sisters are gonna psychic sister, Monique & Amy return from their break with an inadvertently themed episode. Monique gets the spookiness started with Myke’s experience with the Burnt Man. Then, Amy covers the audacious story of Nasa intern, Thad Roberts. If you liked this episode, please take a moment to rate, review, and subscribe.
Join Our Patreon!
Check Out Our Website!
Follow Us On Instagram!
Hey, kiddos! Monique and Amy are both still recovering from being sick, but a new episode will be out soon!
From the publisher's feed

51,261 Listeners

171,953 Listeners

35,743 Listeners

8,739 Listeners

9,838 Listeners

99,713 Listeners

6,356 Listeners

14,041 Listeners

12,062 Listeners

10,386 Listeners

2,706 Listeners

1,594 Listeners

4,491 Listeners

1,445 Listeners

465 Listeners