Breakpoint

Asteroid 2019OK’s Near Miss Rocks Scientism


Listen Later

In the 1998 movie “Armageddon,” the Administrator of NASA, played by Billy Bob Thornton, informs the president that a huge asteroid is on a collision course with Earth. The president then asks, “Why didn’t we see this coming?”

The administrator replies that their budget only “allows us to track about 3% of the sky, and begging your pardon sir, but it's a [really big] sky.”

This scene came to mind after reading about an asteroid designated 2019OK. On July 25th, the 100-meter wide piece of rock passed within 73,000 kilometers of Earth. To put that distance in perspective, the moon is 384,000 kilometers from Earth.

While 2019OK wasn’t big enough to be a “planet killer,” it could have taken out a large city. That’s why one planetary scientist called the pass by “uncomfortably close.”

Even more uncomfortable was that no one noticed this big rock coming our way until it was almost on top of us. It wasn’t being tracked, so it wasn’t on any list of objects that would be passing near Earth.

But, as they say in sports, “no harm, no foul.” Sure, it jangled some nerves, but no one was hurt by our failure to detect 2019OK until it was too late to do anything about it. Still, there’s a lesson to be learned here…

Though no one was hurt physically, our collective scientific egos should be hurt, or at least chastened. The consistent claims of omniscience afforded to science these days has proven, once again, to be false.

Too often what is called science these days is, in fact, “scientism.” Scientism holds that science, as defined by its proponents, is the only “objective means” by which we should judge things, and the only legitimate way we can know in the first place.

Scientism masquerading as science is everywhere. Take a recent Washington Post article entitled “Five Myths About Consciousness.” One “myth” was that “Science will never understand consciousness.” The author, after calling this idea “pernicious,” assured readers that “the argument that difficult science problems are unsolvable has a very poor track record.” After all, “An entire profession, anesthesiology, is devoted to safely turning consciousness off and on again.”

See what he did there? He defined consciousness as, essentially, being awake, as opposed to what is usually means: the awareness of our own existence, thoughts, environment, and “apartness” from others.

Drugging someone until they fall asleep doesn’t bring you any closer to understanding consciousness than putting a person in a coma by hitting them with a blunt object, but claims to scientific omniscience require this kind of reductionism.

Usually, claims of inevitable omniscience like this are, at most, pretentious. The only real harm is us rolling our eyes so far into the back of our heads that they stick. The danger of our arrogance is much more palpable when it comes to other issues, such as playing God with the human genome. As I have said several times on BreakPoint, gene-editing technology such as CRSPR was made widely available with no more ethical guidance than an admonition to “play nice.”

We simply cannot predict the physical and social impact of gene-editing technology. Of course, that won’t stop us. The potentially disastrous process of “trial and error” with this technology won’t cause us to admit we aren’t nearly as smart as we think we are.

Or, we might put it this way: Tracking asteroids, which follows well-known laws of physics, is child’s play compared to manipulating the human genome. And asteroids still manage to sneak up on us. If we don’t learn from incidents like the 2019OK unexpected flyby, our next surprise visitor could find out that there is no one left to destroy.

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

BreakpointBy Colson Center

  • 4.9
  • 4.9
  • 4.9
  • 4.9
  • 4.9

4.9

168 ratings


More shows like Breakpoint

View all
Renewing Your Mind by Ligonier Ministries

Renewing Your Mind

5,191 Listeners

The Briefing with Albert Mohler by R. Albert Mohler, Jr.

The Briefing with Albert Mohler

8,637 Listeners

Stand to Reason Weekly Podcast by Greg Koukl

Stand to Reason Weekly Podcast

1,272 Listeners

Breakpoint by Colson Center

Breakpoint

3,096 Listeners

The World and Everything In It by WORLD Radio

The World and Everything In It

7,124 Listeners

Mama Bear Apologetics by Hillary Morgan Ferrer & Amy Davison

Mama Bear Apologetics

1,249 Listeners

The Alisa Childers Podcast by Alisa Childers

The Alisa Childers Podcast

5,386 Listeners

Conversations That Matter by Jon Harris

Conversations That Matter

1,092 Listeners

The Crossway Podcast by Crossway

The Crossway Podcast

633 Listeners

Life and Books and Everything by Clearly Reformed

Life and Books and Everything

645 Listeners

Upstream by Shane Morris

Upstream

396 Listeners

The Strong Women Podcast by Sarah Stonestreet

The Strong Women Podcast

611 Listeners

The Natasha Crain Podcast by Natasha Crain

The Natasha Crain Podcast

1,316 Listeners

Unshaken Faith by Alisa Childers & Natasha Crain

Unshaken Faith

1,369 Listeners

Transformed with Dr. Greg Gifford by Fortis Institute

Transformed with Dr. Greg Gifford

556 Listeners

The Sean McDowell Show by The Sean McDowell Show

The Sean McDowell Show

281 Listeners