Rebecca Haro told police a stranger attacked her and kidnapped her 7-month-old son, Emmanuel, outside a Big 5 sporting goods store. She and her husband, Jake, even stood before cameras, pleading for his safe return.

But investigators say it was all a lie. Detectives believe Emmanuel was already dead when his parents made that public plea. Jake allegedly confessed to killing his son and dumping his body. Prosecutors also point to a disturbing history of abuse involving both parents. Blood was found in the home, but Emmanuel’s body has never been recovered.

Now Jake and Rebecca both face murder charges, and their surviving children are in the care of relatives. With confessions, lies, and haunting questions still unanswered, one mystery remains: what really happened to baby Emmanuel?

Follow True Crime Recaps for more cases that expose the shocking truths hidden behind family secrets.