Baskin and Phelps react to the Guardians late win over the Detroit Tigers and discuss Stephen Vogt's Manager of the Year candidacy.

Baskin and Phelps full show for Tuesday, September 16, 2025

Hour 1 of Baskin and Phelps

Hour 2 of Baskin and Phelps

Hour 3 of Baskin and Phelps

Hour 4 of Baskin and Phelps

Dan leads the way as he breaks down all of the latest story lines in the NFL

Joe Posnanski joined Baskin and Phelps to talk about the Guardians' playoff push as the regular season comes to a close and what it will take for Cleveland to have legitimate post season hopes. He talked about how likely it is for the Guardians to take over the Tigers in the division, what their depth looks like from a post-season perspective, and whether he thinks Emmanuel Clase or Luis Ortiz will get a chance to come back to the league. He also shared his thoughts on Kevin Stefanski and the Browns' quarterback situation.

Jeff, Andy, and Dan all discuss their favorite Robert Redford movies following the news of the actor's recent passing.

Paul Hoynes joined Baskin and Phelps to preview the Guardians' upcoming series with the Detroit Tigers, what they need to do to overtake Detroit in the division, and how the Tigers are specifically scheming to ruin Cleveland's season. He talked about the prospects down the pipeline and why the Guardians have been so cautious to call them up and what he expects the rotation to look like when they do. He also discussed where the Guardians' recent success is stemming from and whether or not they have a shot at the post season.